Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to accept the money

64 replies

Gruzzpuzz · 15/10/2022 11:13

MIL is moving in with her BF who she has been with for 7 years. She is a pensioner in sheltered council accommodation and he is a widow with his own home. A large flat has suddenly become available in their building and so he is moving in (with very low rent) and selling his house so they can have a lovely retirement.

We have heard from MIL that his children (both married with their own children) are upset at their inheritance being spent so he is giving them some money (I don’t know how much). I don’t know much about them but from other non money-related stories (heard second-hand) at least one of them is selfish and entitled.

MIL has just’ confessed’ to DH that she has a little money saved and in the interests of honesty and equity she’d like to give DH and his sister £2,000 each.

We are very comfortable but not ‘well off’ - we have just agreed a sale on a house with a huge mortgage and the ‘mini budget’ has cost us about 6k a year from the expired mortgage in principle we got at the beginning of sept and are facing 2 years of tight purse strings. SIL is greedy, entitled and tight and will definitely accept the money. Her and her DH have good jobs and a nice house and summer holidays to Florida but they are slightly obsessed with how much we earn and think we are loaded - it’s mostly a north/south thing but it’s also because we are generous with MIL (they never so much as buy her a cup of tea because they are always ‘broke’ saving for eg a new car).

AIBU to accept the money given that 3 other children are accepting money? We have already said no but MIL is insisting; she wants us to buy something big for the house with it. I have to say it will be very welcome but I feel really uncomfortable at the prospect. We have already suggested giving it to DD into a savings account but she said she would rather buy something - she suggests a piano for DD but I will get huge benefit from this and we would probably buy one anyway.

OP posts:
JRHartly · 15/10/2022 18:34

@Ekátn she’s like on this every thread I’ve seen her on.

Ekátn · 15/10/2022 18:32

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 18:16

@Ekátn

Emotion - yes
Expectation - No

@Ekátn your words previously

"Can’t say I would be excited at the thought of my dad selling the home he shared with my mum to move in with someone else. I get no one is entitled to inheritance. But not many people would be happy with their remaining parent potentially spending the money that should have been their inheritance on their partner"

you said it yourself - you would rather your dad be alone than your expected inheritance be spent by him enjoying himself if he found love again.

I speak as I find. And I find grabby in you.

@pocketvenuss

It's a common thing on here to expect inheritance and to be cross if a parent wants to remarry. I know no one that vile in real life (thankfully)

Oh and if my other half's adult kids plan on an inheritance they'll be sorely sorely disappointed- him and I will be spending every damm penny enjoying ourselves.
But I know them well enough to know they're not grabby. Thank god.

Hmmm no I didn’t. Notice how you left the very relevant last sentence off the bit you quoted.

I said I would not be happy with him selling the house he shared with my mother to spend on a new woman. Didn’t say I would try and stop him. And a lot of that emotional. Not even financial.

However, in our family both my parents talked to us openly about what happens if one dies and what they want and both parents were in agreement. That nothing would pass to a new spouse or their children. Just like I won’t be passing on my assets to my new partner His children.

and, weirdly, both me and dad can afford to enjoy life with a partner without draining our assets. He has a partner and we have discussed it at length. His girlfriend also wants her assets for her kids.

And where did I say I would rather he be alone? Again, not being happy about it doesn’t mean I would rather he be alone.

You read a load of crap into my post that wasn’t there. Then tried to pretend you were some paragon of virtue. You, apparently, think in black and white. The world is many shade of grey.

You don’t speak as you find. You find, add a load of bits, take bits out in that you think you can attack because it makes you feel better. it’s a bit odd really

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 18:16

@Ekátn

Emotion - yes
Expectation - No

@Ekátn your words previously

"Can’t say I would be excited at the thought of my dad selling the home he shared with my mum to move in with someone else. I get no one is entitled to inheritance. But not many people would be happy with their remaining parent potentially spending the money that should have been their inheritance on their partner"

you said it yourself - you would rather your dad be alone than your expected inheritance be spent by him enjoying himself if he found love again.

I speak as I find. And I find grabby in you.

@pocketvenuss

It's a common thing on here to expect inheritance and to be cross if a parent wants to remarry. I know no one that vile in real life (thankfully)

Oh and if my other half's adult kids plan on an inheritance they'll be sorely sorely disappointed- him and I will be spending every damm penny enjoying ourselves.
But I know them well enough to know they're not grabby. Thank god.

pocketvenuss · 15/10/2022 16:29

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 13:53

@Ekátn

In NO part of my post did I say a child should be disinherited. That's horrid.

I DO think that the person who made the money is entitled to spend it, every last penny of it.

Having a wonderful retirement on themselves & their partner. Enjoy every minute of their remaining life in comfort and luxury and enjoyment if possible. Turn that heating up, book the cruise etc

If there is money left it should go to children, but no parent is under any obligation to do
So unless making arrangements for a minor)

So so so so many people rubbing their hands in glee waiting till their parents pop off or begrudging their every holiday they have or nice car they buy waiting for "their inheritance"

Disinheriting either to a new wife/their kids or a sibling etc is an altogether and emotionally damaging issue.

Which I didn't mention & neither did OP.

Don't know who these ghastly people are that you know who are gleefully waiting for their parents to die. Maybe you ought to go find some nicer friends.

Ekátn · 15/10/2022 14:09

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 13:53

@Ekátn

In NO part of my post did I say a child should be disinherited. That's horrid.

I DO think that the person who made the money is entitled to spend it, every last penny of it.

Having a wonderful retirement on themselves & their partner. Enjoy every minute of their remaining life in comfort and luxury and enjoyment if possible. Turn that heating up, book the cruise etc

If there is money left it should go to children, but no parent is under any obligation to do
So unless making arrangements for a minor)

So so so so many people rubbing their hands in glee waiting till their parents pop off or begrudging their every holiday they have or nice car they buy waiting for "their inheritance"

Disinheriting either to a new wife/their kids or a sibling etc is an altogether and emotionally damaging issue.

Which I didn't mention & neither did OP.

Then you entire, ridiculous, first reply to me was pointless then and you didn’t read what I actually posted.

I didn’t say op talked about people being disinherited. I was talking about her assumption that one of his kids is grabby and the second hand stories that don’t make them seem money orientates and their concern over their inheritance.

It’s a common concern. And understandable.

You have no idea how many people are rubbing their hands over inheritance at all. Unless you know people personally, You have no idea of peoples motivation in these situations.

Again, I didn’t say anyone CAN’T spend their money how they wish. And I never said anyone can’t enjoy their life. However, to pretend no one should have an emotion attached to it is unrealistic.

pocketvenuss · 15/10/2022 14:04

He is selling a house so has money to give his dc. In what possible universe does this mean your MIL should give her dc any money. She hasn't got much to start with. He is financing their entire future. If she really wants to be fair she would keep her money and use it to contribute to their living. Sheesh. She's the complete opposite of being fair. She's being a complete leech

Fundays12 · 15/10/2022 13:59

Tell her thanks and do something nice with DD. Go on holiday with her so MIL can see her granddaughters enjoying the gift in photos. She wants you to have it. As a mum of 3 I wouldn't be comfortable giving one adult DC and not the rest as it's unfair unless it was got something like IVF the others didn't need or medical treatment but I would hope my kids would understand that.

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 13:53

@Ekátn

In NO part of my post did I say a child should be disinherited. That's horrid.

I DO think that the person who made the money is entitled to spend it, every last penny of it.

Having a wonderful retirement on themselves & their partner. Enjoy every minute of their remaining life in comfort and luxury and enjoyment if possible. Turn that heating up, book the cruise etc

If there is money left it should go to children, but no parent is under any obligation to do
So unless making arrangements for a minor)

So so so so many people rubbing their hands in glee waiting till their parents pop off or begrudging their every holiday they have or nice car they buy waiting for "their inheritance"

Disinheriting either to a new wife/their kids or a sibling etc is an altogether and emotionally damaging issue.

Which I didn't mention & neither did OP.

Fenella123 · 15/10/2022 13:10

Another one here saying take an "if you insist" attitude to the money from MiL but then pop it in the best savings account you can and keep it in case either you're so desperate you unequivocally need it or she needs it.
Pianos need regular tuning and are a bugger to move so think carefully about that! There's a reason used ones can be got starting at "please just take it!"...

NoSquirrels · 15/10/2022 13:05

You could accept it but make it clear to MIL that at any point in the future that she needs £2,000, you will repay her. I’d be concerned by her giving up her secure accommodation, I must admit.

She can’t give you a gift and tell you what to spend it on, though. So if you don’t want to buy a piano, don’t.

Aishah231 · 15/10/2022 13:04

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 12:27

You come
Over SO horrifically grabby. Why on earth should any parent save money so their children can inherit? Why shouldn't they spend it on themselves and their partner.
It's their money.

Not enough vomit in the world for this type of entitlement.

OP take the money and put it in a savings account for mil in case she needs it back. Don't try & judge her or rain on her happiness. Her and her new partner have found love & happiness in their old age.

What a joy!

I'm sorry but I think in a case where one parent has died it is acceptable to expect, unless clearly told otherwise by the deceased parent in the will etc, that the surviving spouse will try to pass on that section of the inheritance - if it's left after care fees etc. If I die first I would expect my husband to pass on my half of he's able to do so. I'd be pissed in the extreme if he married again and my children saw nothing of my own money, The money is generally left to the surviving spouse so they are not kicked out of the house etc.

Ekátn · 15/10/2022 13:00

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 12:27

You come
Over SO horrifically grabby. Why on earth should any parent save money so their children can inherit? Why shouldn't they spend it on themselves and their partner.
It's their money.

Not enough vomit in the world for this type of entitlement.

OP take the money and put it in a savings account for mil in case she needs it back. Don't try & judge her or rain on her happiness. Her and her new partner have found love & happiness in their old age.

What a joy!

Oh no! Someone on MN, who I don’t know and doesn’t like my opinion thinks I am grabby.

Not enough vomit in world for this type of ridiculousness.

I get that in MN everyone like to pretend that inheritance has no emotions attached to it. And everyone should just smile and be happy about whatever someone decides. But it absolutely does have emotion attached to it. Disinheriting someone always has a big fallout. Like it or not, lots of people would feel bad if their parent disinherited them. It’s silly pretend that it doesn’t. There’s a reason that abusive parents disinherit the child or children that they are as the black sheep. Because they know there would be emotion attached to it.

I didn’t say someone could NOT spend their money how they wished. But no I wouldn’t be impressed if everything my parents built during their life time, went to dads girlfriends adult children instead. Which is what happens a lot. You can accept someone’s decision (you don’t have much choice) but also be unhappy about it. Why pretend you can’t?

Thankfully, my dad agrees with me. He also agrees with the complication of emotion being tied to inheritance. He wouldn’t disinherit my brother, even though he has been a shit and I wouldn’t go along with it, even though I would gain. I would give my brother half anyway. That’s not grabby, is it?

It applies in my own life. My kids get everything (bar some sizeable charity donations) upon my death. Dp is aware. If I die, he could leave everything I built before I met him to someone else’s kids. Not happening. Again, dp agrees with this.

We can all pretend there’s no emotion attached to money. But there is. Like the threads where we have where a parent financially helps out one adult child more than other. Either with time or money. We all know people can spend their time or money how they want. It doesn’t mean other people wouldn’t be hurt by it.

I think suggesting the Op takes the money and looks after it for the mil, like the mil is a child is also vomit inducing. But there you go.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 15/10/2022 12:57

Just because he is giving his own kids money doesn't mean that she should feel obliged to.

I wouldn't accept it.

RewildingAmbridge · 15/10/2022 12:46

Is it a rental or is he buying the flat? My gran had a flat in a semi sheltered accommodation complex, some were owned some were council

hellcatspangle · 15/10/2022 12:43

Most areas don't have a shortage of sheltered accommodation.

They may not, but here you have to have less than 16k in savings to qualify for the low rent, so I'm not sure whether the OP's "FIL" has looked into it properly. Why should he sit on the proceeds of a house sale and get a subsidised rent?

Bryterlayter1 · 15/10/2022 12:42

It does make me sad that people feel they need to make life decisions based on leaving an inheritance. I sincerely hope my parents (who are retired) make their life decisions based on maximising their happiness and comfort in retirement, not on how much they will leave me and my siblings.

cutthelawn · 15/10/2022 12:34

*You come
Over SO horrifically grabby. Why on earth should any parent save money so their children can inherit? Why shouldn't they spend it on themselves and their partner.
It's their money.

Not enough vomit in the world for this type of entitlement*

I see what you are saying but at the same time I do see the other poster's view. How many threads on mn have we seen where the ops parent remarries, died soon after and the widow/widower inherits the whole estate and it goes to their children?

It hardly seems fair now especially in this day and age when so many relay on inheritance to get on the elusive housing ladder.

JRHartly · 15/10/2022 12:28

And yes, take the money but keep it aside in case MIL needs money down the line. Don’t tell anyone it’s being saved.

beachcitygirl · 15/10/2022 12:27

Ekátn · 15/10/2022 11:52

No I absolutely wouldn’t accept it and point out to mil how vulnerable she will be should they split.

She doesn’t need to give anyone money, because he is giving his own kids some. And your dh should be deciding.

I would refrain from judging his kids. The stories are second hand. and it’s amazing that you imply (or sometimes say outright) that everyone is grabby. And yet you want to money just because. But that’s ok.

Can’t say I would be excited at the thought of my dad selling the home he shared with my mum to move in with someone else. I get no one is entitled to inheritance. But not many people would be happy with their remaining parent potentially spending the money that should have been their inheritance on their partner. Or often that happens is the new partner inherits it and give it to their own kids.

Inheritance planning should always be part of these decisions

You come
Over SO horrifically grabby. Why on earth should any parent save money so their children can inherit? Why shouldn't they spend it on themselves and their partner.
It's their money.

Not enough vomit in the world for this type of entitlement.

OP take the money and put it in a savings account for mil in case she needs it back. Don't try & judge her or rain on her happiness. Her and her new partner have found love & happiness in their old age.

What a joy!

JRHartly · 15/10/2022 12:27

What happens if MIL and her BF break up and he has to move out?

In his shoes i would get married first.

Shinyhappyperson22 · 15/10/2022 12:23

crowsfeet57 · 15/10/2022 12:11

I'm amazed that the partner can move into sheltered Council accommodation when he is a home owner. This seems wrong when there is such a shortage of social housing

Most areas don't have a shortage of sheltered accommodation.

They do! My dads been waiting ages.

cutthelawn · 15/10/2022 12:20

Why doesn't he buy a smaller property, sell his existing house

this a much safer and sensible option.

Mariposista · 15/10/2022 12:19

Invest it in an ISA for your daughter and give it to her when she has her own home.

Gruzzpuzz · 15/10/2022 12:19

Thanks for these replies. Lots of food for thought.Two important details that I really shouldn’t have left out:

They are getting married next year

She is registered disabled hence being in sheltered accommodation and he has a recent disability that has given him
huge mobility issues and is applying for a blue badge. I am also fairly sure he has a very good occupational pension (but she has nothing).

Sorry for the drip feed.

OP posts:
cutthelawn · 15/10/2022 12:16

Why, let him enjoy the money from the house sale

because he's giving up home security into entering the rental market, at any age this is risky but at an older age it is so much riskier. He could live for another 30 years, the sale from the house isn't going to last forever.