Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to accept the money

64 replies

Gruzzpuzz · 15/10/2022 11:13

MIL is moving in with her BF who she has been with for 7 years. She is a pensioner in sheltered council accommodation and he is a widow with his own home. A large flat has suddenly become available in their building and so he is moving in (with very low rent) and selling his house so they can have a lovely retirement.

We have heard from MIL that his children (both married with their own children) are upset at their inheritance being spent so he is giving them some money (I don’t know how much). I don’t know much about them but from other non money-related stories (heard second-hand) at least one of them is selfish and entitled.

MIL has just’ confessed’ to DH that she has a little money saved and in the interests of honesty and equity she’d like to give DH and his sister £2,000 each.

We are very comfortable but not ‘well off’ - we have just agreed a sale on a house with a huge mortgage and the ‘mini budget’ has cost us about 6k a year from the expired mortgage in principle we got at the beginning of sept and are facing 2 years of tight purse strings. SIL is greedy, entitled and tight and will definitely accept the money. Her and her DH have good jobs and a nice house and summer holidays to Florida but they are slightly obsessed with how much we earn and think we are loaded - it’s mostly a north/south thing but it’s also because we are generous with MIL (they never so much as buy her a cup of tea because they are always ‘broke’ saving for eg a new car).

AIBU to accept the money given that 3 other children are accepting money? We have already said no but MIL is insisting; she wants us to buy something big for the house with it. I have to say it will be very welcome but I feel really uncomfortable at the prospect. We have already suggested giving it to DD into a savings account but she said she would rather buy something - she suggests a piano for DD but I will get huge benefit from this and we would probably buy one anyway.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Flopsythebunny · 15/05/2023 20:26

JRHartly · 15/05/2023 18:39

@Flopsythebunny I hope the son knows this now?

And who will inherit from you? Not him I hope.

My 3 adult children will get 30% each.. Once we are both gone the house is to be sold and the funds distributed. If I go first husband will live in the house until he dies, or if he needs to go into a home the house will be sold so that his 10% can go towards his care. We have built up joint savings and he has a good pension.
Son was very disappointed when his father told him the situation and hasn't spoken to me since. It's no skin off my nose.
If he hadn't reacted like he did when me and his father got married the split would have been 4 equal shares

JRHartly · 15/05/2023 18:43

gogogoji · 15/05/2023 13:00

He's the one with money. If they marry I would want him to make sure it's ring fenced so money goes to his dc upon death and not ultimately to the OP and family.

Oh, true. But if leaves, she would have given up sheltered council accommodation, so she will be vulnerable.

Tinkerbyebye · 15/05/2023 18:42

Just accept the money and tell her what you have spent it on

JRHartly · 15/05/2023 18:39

@Flopsythebunny I hope the son knows this now?

And who will inherit from you? Not him I hope.

Flopsythebunny · 15/05/2023 13:38

When I moved into my husbands home just before we married, his adult son took him to one side to remind him that the house was his inheritance and that my husband should make a new will to make sure the house went to him and not me as his new wife. What the son didn't take into account was that his father had remortgaged the house, interest only to fund the son's 3 years at university and a year travelling the world afterwards.
I paid this mortgage off and spent a fortune on a new roof, windows, doors, kitchen and bathroom and decorated throughout . The house hadn't had any money spent on it for 20 years.
We are now tenants in common, with me owning 90% to reflect the money I've put in. The son, who visits once per year will get his father's 10% when my husband of 18 years dies. I'll get the house valued and give it to him in cash.
The son thought I was a gold digger, when in reality I was the one with money after selling my previous home where I'd already paid off the mortgage

gogogoji · 15/05/2023 13:00

JRHartly · 15/10/2022 12:27

What happens if MIL and her BF break up and he has to move out?

In his shoes i would get married first.

He's the one with money. If they marry I would want him to make sure it's ring fenced so money goes to his dc upon death and not ultimately to the OP and family.

gogogoji · 15/05/2023 12:57

So because he is giving his dc money, your MIL feels she can do the same? That's ridiculous. She doesn't have the same money as he does. If I was him and his dc I'd be pissed off that she is making herself even poorer and contributing even LESS to their pot and relying even more on his money. Sounds like she is either hopelessly clueless or grabby

Ilovecleaning · 15/05/2023 12:52

It irks me that some people see other people’s money (relatives) as theirs. They call it inheritance to make it sound like a right. They expect older parents to not spend or enjoy their own property or money but to sit on it until they die so it can be passed on.

deathofthesnark · 17/10/2022 07:33

We are very comfortable but not ‘well off’ - we have just agreed a sale on a house with a huge mortgage and the ‘mini budget’ has cost us about 6k a year from the expired mortgage in principle we got at the beginning of sept and are facing 2 years of tight purse strings.

Why on earth would you spend £2k on a sodding piano when you have posted this in your op??

Get one off Facebook, people are getting rid of them left right and centre. I did, cost £150? Ish for a free one to transport and tune

Icequeen01 · 17/10/2022 07:19

I'm also surprised that the BF can just sell his house and go into sheltered accommodation when it sounds as though he could fund a smaller home. I'm not sure but could deprivation of assets come into play here?

YilingMatriarch · 17/10/2022 07:03

Before they do anything they should see a certified Financial Planner specialising in Retirement/Pensions. They should shore up their own futures before even thinking of DC's. They should know what the paths are as BF/GF Cohabiting and as a future Married Couple.

dailyfup · 16/10/2022 17:23

I see you have accepted it for the piano. That is a lovely way to spend it.
MIL had saved the money and can choose what she would like to do with it. OP and family did not go begging for piano money.
Perhaps MIL thought better to give you the money for something now which will help your family and bring you some joy, rather than the money ending up going on care home fees.

As for the man - don't see anything wrong with him selling his home and moving into a rental (which is very low rent). My Dad did this when the family home became too large for him - rented a small flat and loved it. He had no worries with it whatsoever as the landlord was responsible for all repairs - and was a good landlord. Yes, it obviously cost more than if he'd sold the family home and bought a small property but it was worry and hassle free and that's what he wanted in his later years.

MaybeIshouldnt · 16/10/2022 16:53

Regardless of whether people think its a bad decision to sell home to rent, its a decision he has made. As to the inheritance angle, he is obviously giving his DC either the entirety or part of their inheritance before his death. There are many reasons why people do this. But who's to say he hasn't also made provision for his DC in his will too? Why has everyone jumped to the conclusion that DM is a wicked woman who is going yo steal all his money and leave it to ger own DC?

Regardless of whether he has or not, he is entitled to free up his own money to enjoy in his twilight years and spend it exactly how he wants and on who he wants. he worked hard to buy that home and build up any nest egg he has. Any children who are eagerly awaiting to inherit should maybe concentrate on working hard to get themselves into the same position so they can also enjoy their own retirement, spending their hard earned money how they like and who they like.

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 16:39

no I absolutely wouldn’t be taking 2k from a pensioner, I’m surprised you’re even considering it

some pensioners I know are taking in about 500 quid a week in their pension, pensioner doesn't equate to low income by any means. Many on the old pensions here in Ireland are living a very comfortable life on it.

Pemba · 16/10/2022 16:26

Leave the OP alone, she has done nothing wrong. The MIL insisted on them having the money, and to see them buying a piano will give her enormous pleasure.

Meanwhile the OP I am certain will quietly be setting aside that much and more to assist the MIL if and when she needs it in the future.

I think you are just one of those posters who likes to have a go at people. Did you enjoy it?

neverhaveiDEVI · 16/10/2022 13:33

We also wouldn’t be here if SIL had done the right thing and said no but that’s a different matter

are you kidding?! the cheek of saying SIL is wrong for taking the money when you were going to take it to buy a piano anyway! Even if she took it, you don’t have to!

neverhaveiDEVI · 16/10/2022 13:31

no I absolutely wouldn’t be taking 2k from a pensioner, I’m surprised you’re even considering it

Gruzzpuzz · 16/10/2022 13:21

Update:
DH spoke to MIL last night and said she should keep the money because we didn’t need it. But things have moved on - she has already transferred the money to SIL and has told DH that whatever we say she now has to give us our money otherwise it’s not fair. She has DH’s bank account and is sending the money over.

She is transfixed with the idea of the piano so we said we would buy this.

She is a lovely, lovely woman and would literally give her last fiver away; this incident is one in a long history of her spending too much on us and our DD which we have to manage carefully because she adores buying presents and we don’t want to be ungrateful.

We are going to treat them both to a big night out this Christmas and will absolutely look after either / both of them if and when the time comes.

Thanks for your opinions; I had a feeling we would end up here and it’s good to know for the most part we aren’t being unreasonable. We also wouldn’t be here if SIL had done the right thing and said no but that’s a different matter.

OP posts:
Seymour5 · 15/10/2022 20:24

Lots of older people in this part of the country own homes that wouldn't raise enough to buy a retirement apartment and certainly not a bungalow. I feel if they have a need to move to sheltered housing they should be given the opportunity. They may never have earned much, not all owner occupiers are wealthy.

cutthelawn · 15/10/2022 19:43

I’m not sure why pp are commenting on his decision to sell up and move into sheltered accommodation. He is an adult. Just because he is old doesn’t mean he can’t decide what he wants to do with his finances. He can make his own decision and it sounds like it will be a good idea if he is already struggling with mobility

because renting in old age can put one in a perilous and vulnerable position, the fact he is disabled even more so. You are much more stable in your own property always especially in old age or in bad health than be at at the mercy of landlord or other authority who could toss you to the streets at any time really. People are pointing it out to the op because so many people are completely oblivious to this and are bad at making safe financial decisions.

Just read other threads here and you will see how oblivious people are when making decisions like this. Another thread has an op's husband wanting to rent the family homer out as he thinks it's an easy way to make money and a free pension when many others pointed out how it wasn't and pointed out the financial realities and pitfalls of it that even the op seemed to be oblivious of.

siestaingsnake · 15/10/2022 19:15

Take the money buy the piano or something else she suggested/ helped pick and let her enjoy seeing you and your family enjoy her gift.

I always refuse money from my mother until she pointed this out to me ( I still feel bad taking it though)

girlmom21 · 15/10/2022 19:12

I wouldn't accept it. She needs it more than you do.

Babyroobs · 15/10/2022 19:08

pocketvenuss · 15/10/2022 14:04

He is selling a house so has money to give his dc. In what possible universe does this mean your MIL should give her dc any money. She hasn't got much to start with. He is financing their entire future. If she really wants to be fair she would keep her money and use it to contribute to their living. Sheesh. She's the complete opposite of being fair. She's being a complete leech

I'd be worried what happens if they split? One of them has no home to go to and no savings left ? what happens if they need to pay for care and all the money has been given away. Health can change very quickly.

Babyroobs · 15/10/2022 19:05

Pemba · 15/10/2022 12:12

I am also amazed at your MIL's partner selling his house to move into council accommodation. It seems crazy, and I would be surprised if its even within the rules. This sheltered accommodation is supposed to be for people in housing need, not someone who already owns a home outright (I presume).

Why doesn't he buy a smaller property, sell his existing house? Then he would raise some cash (some of which could maybe go to his kids if they're in current need). Your MIL and him could stay over at each others more frequently, and each have their own base in case the relationship goes pear shaped. When he dies his kids would still inherit his place.

As for the £2000 gift from MIL, I don't know. Sounds like she has very little if this is such a big deal to her, but also sounds like she is influenced by what her DP is doing WRT his own DCs. Situation is not the same though. But if you think it will make her happy why not take it and buy the piano as you were going to anyway, but be prepared you might very well need to help her out financially in the future. I am sure you would be happy to do so, and it sounds like you'd manage that OK.

I was under the impression that lots of council won't let people move into these places if they have in excess of a certain amount of money ! Maybe that's why he is giving it away. I remember one of my clients wanting to do this and the council wouldn't let her as she had more than 50k from the sale of her home. My great aunt did this years ago though, sold her terrace house to my brother at well below market value, moved to a council bungalow then used the equity on numerous trips to Canada.

Zuma76 · 15/10/2022 18:59

I’m not sure why pp are commenting on his decision to sell up and move into sheltered accommodation. He is an adult. Just because he is old doesn’t mean he can’t decide what he wants to do with his finances. He can make his own decision and it sounds like it will be a good idea if he is already struggling with mobility. I would accept the money. She wants you to have it and it will make her happy to see you buy something special.

Swipe left for the next trending thread