Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
Baaaaaa · 15/10/2022 14:51

Sago1 · 15/10/2022 12:05

Baaaaaa Proper sourdough only contains flour water and salt, no commercial yeast.
its a fermented food, I have some on the go now that I started yesterday it is a 24-36 hour process.
It’s a fermentation process so the carbs in the flour are broken down, this makes it low GI and easier to digest and break down in the gut.
No bread is ideal but as a weekend treat it’s worth making.
We don’t bloat either after SD bread.

Thanks Sago!

Primroseprimula · 15/10/2022 14:49

From my own anectodal experience you are right OP.

I recently had a blood test which showed my average blood glucose level was way too high. It was a surprise because I wouldn't have said my diet was particular sugar heavy in the sense of sweets, cakes desserts etc. I was however eating a lot of refined carbs - Cereal for breakfast l. Sandwich for lunch, pasta for tea - and had been gradually gaining weight.

Testing my blood sugar, it seems a lot of white & refined carbs give me an enormous sugar spike and then reactive hypoglycemia. I've cut out all sugar and white carbs now and am eating brown rice/bread in very limited quantities, and am eating a lot more protein.

I'm actually shocked at the effect its had. For the first time for about a decade I no longer get ravenously hungry before meals, (I would get home from work and have to have a snack to have enough energy to make dinner) my appetite has decreased, my IBS has disappeared, I feel generally better and my spots have cleared up. I'm craving things I wasn't keen on before - oily fish, certain vegetables, eggs. It feels like with a veil of constantly fluctuating blood sugar lifted i can actually listen to my body and what it wants without the interference of the "give me easily accessible glucose now" klaxon going off every few hours.

I'm losing weight slowly but steadily, but even if i plateaued tomorrow I would carry on with this way of eating. I genuinely think for whatever reason my body cannot process refined carbs effectively. When I have tried classic calorie counting diets in the past I've simply gone mad with hunger and fallen off the wagon when my body's need for sugar gets louder than my willpower.

I think a carby diet is fine for some people, and I don't think everyone needs to go lower carb. I think it's worth a try though if other methods are not working well for you.

VioletInsolence · 15/10/2022 14:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 14:27

I think we can just look at countries with low level of obesity and sew that carb isn't the issue.

I agree with pps talking about activity. While when losing weight, it's essentially impossible to lose purely by being active, it has masive benefits when keeping weight off and how we process the food. Activity also affects blood sugar levels as said. And many other things like digestive. We have lost lots of that here.

Also, things like nicotine, for example, change how we process sugars.

Then you look at gut. We have everything sterilised and dead with no or very little gut bacteria in. If you look at countries where fermented food is popular it shows quite a few benefits as well.

It's not carbs. It's us

VladmirsPoutine · 15/10/2022 14:27

Tbh I think a lot of this is down to lifestyle - it's often just impractical to hold down a 9-5, raise young kids and find all the time in the world to go to the gym and eat veg sticks for dinner. Most people don't live the lifestyle that allows for a lot of these things.

SallyWD · 15/10/2022 14:21

This is why I do fasting (16/8). It works brilliantly for me! People say fasting only works because you eat less calories but that's simply not the only reason - it's a lot to do with insulin as you say.
I personally can't do low carb. I've tried it and both times I felt miserable and was horribly constipated (that's despite me eating loads of veg and chia seeds etc.). I have the type of digestive system that needs lots of wholegrain carbs to keep regular.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 15/10/2022 14:19

Bacibaci yes I agree that it is more complicated. And exercise is known to be an important factor in blood sugar level control hence people with T2 diabetes are advised to exercise. Plus there are genetic factors to consider, I remember in the Michael Mosley fasting book that there is a tribe of people who never get cancer because of their genes. However it has meant that the people take no care of their health, smoke drink, bad diet etc. because they consider themselves immune to illness and so live no longer than other populations because they die from other conditions!

LCopp89 · 15/10/2022 14:17

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:07

Weight Watchers and Slimming World DON’T WORK.

If they did you wouldn’t have people returning time after time when they’ve put the weight back on.

You’re 100% right, OP.

They DO work (well, SW works).

But you can't think it's a temporary fix like a fasting or juice diet - you have to stick at it forever (or at least most of the time, as I said in my post) for you to keep the weight off. It is designed to be sustainable.

And as I said, it's not really restrictive and relies heavily on common sense plus lots of homemade cooking. Eat loads of lean protein and vegetables = brilliant. Make your own pasta sauce/stew/soup = no added refined sugar. Limit your everyday intake of processed sugary, fatty food = duh. No food is off-limits, just some in moderation = no-brainer.

Bacibaci · 15/10/2022 14:06

I am not a scientist but my brief reading suggests the science is not settled that only low carb diets work. There are tribes that eat a high sugar diet, in the form of fruit and honey, that don’t have obesity, heart disease etc. Steve Guyenet a neuro scientist and someone interested in the science of body weight and health. He writes about the tribe that has a high sugar diet in the below link. He thinks physical activity helps regulate insulin and he is also interested in the role of food reward in the brain and overeating. Also once a person is obese insulin then can be affected.

www.stephanguyenet.com/bad-sugar-or-bad-journalism-an-expert-review-of-the-case-against-sugar/

CarefreeMe · 15/10/2022 13:56

I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

Because every few years someone comes out with a new fad to make money.

How long were fats the bad guys and now all of a sudden some diets promote high fat foods.

Literally all food groups have been labelled as bad at some point.

If you look at all of the diets they all increase veg and cut out refined sugar and junk food.

I do think insulin is important and I think we eat way too many sugars/carbs in the western diet due mainly to snacking and portion size but I don’t think carbs should be demonised as things like potatoes are so good for you.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 15/10/2022 13:54

I don't understand why the OP's posts are considered so controversial. I thought the science about sugar levels/obesity/ fasting was pretty well accepted nowadays. Obviously everyone's biochemistry is slightly different and other hormones will interact but in general isn't it now thought that keeping a relatively low stable blood sugar level is better for your health and obviously insulin plays a major role in that.

My understanding is that if you eat a lot of sugar you'll get a large sugar spike and (in a healthy person) a consequent large release of insulin. This will make the cells take up the sugar quickly meaning that the cells won't need to burn fat plus your blood sugar levels will drop suddenly leading to an energy slump which will make you want to eat more. Plus your cells may become resistant to insulin meaning that the sugar will stay in your blood wreaking all the havoc associated with diabetes.

And low carb is different to no carb. No carb would cut out fruit and veg and a complete lack of fibre would be pretty bad for most people. I try to cut out simple carbs and stick to complex carbs like brown rice/bread etc and combine them with proteins and fats to reduce blood sugar spikes and don't snack or eat late evening. I find it makes me less hungry and it's easy for me to keep to a healthy weight.

mauveskies · 15/10/2022 13:51

Blinded with bro science.

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:40

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 13:37

It is low carb - it’s reducing refined carbs and sugar right down 🤔

but I can eat unrefined carbs, so it isn’t low carb.

Grains, oats, brown rice. Not all carbs are refined.

🙄

It’s still low carb compared to the standard diet of pasta/rice/bread/potatoes with every meal.

I believe that if everyone in the developed world just cut out wheat we wouldn’t have an obesity epidemic.

Meili04 · 15/10/2022 13:40

I think your theory is rubbish I think already being fat increases risk of insulin resistance. I've never cut carbs or sugar I eat all food groups my fasting glucose at 18 stone was 6.5 my fasting glucose at 10 stone is 4.

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:37

Gwenhwyfar · 15/10/2022 13:30

I just don't want to cut out an entire food group. It's really not practical.
I do avoid eating between meals during the week so I avoid having constant spikes and drops in blood sugar I suppose.

But low carb isn’t cutting out a whole food group.

There are plenty of carbs in root vegetables, pulses, fruit, seeds and nuts, for example.

I think people mistake ‘carbs’ with ‘refined carbs’ and think low carb means you don’t get any carbohydrate in your body.

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 13:37

It is low carb - it’s reducing refined carbs and sugar right down 🤔

but I can eat unrefined carbs, so it isn’t low carb.

Grains, oats, brown rice. Not all carbs are refined.

Playthegamebwah · 15/10/2022 13:33

People say “move more eat less” because people can massively over complicated weight loss when really weight loss is 99% common sense.

Does anyone really think foods like: sugar, white carbs, high saturated fat foods and stereotypical “junk” food like cakes and chips fall into the : eat as much as you like categories? We all know what should be treats and what we should eat more of to feel full.

you can start naming diets and saying what mechanism it works by, low carb, high protein reduce appetite for example which makes it easier to eat less calories but it’s not some secret mumbo jumbo. If you ate your daily allocated calories of white bread and spoonfuls of sugar you’d feel like shit and be healthy but you’d still lose weight.

Gwenhwyfar · 15/10/2022 13:32

"avoid UPFs, excess sugar and refine carbs is the only thing that works. It’s not that restrictive so it works."

I'd find that much more restrictive than simply cutting or maintaining calories.

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:30

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 13:17

Changing your way of eating permanently to avoid UPFs, excess sugar and refine carbs is the only thing that works. It’s not that restrictive so it works

that’s not low carb though. So how does o/p’s insulin theory fit in to that?

It is low carb - it’s reducing refined carbs and sugar right down 🤔

Gwenhwyfar · 15/10/2022 13:30

I just don't want to cut out an entire food group. It's really not practical.
I do avoid eating between meals during the week so I avoid having constant spikes and drops in blood sugar I suppose.

Meili04 · 15/10/2022 13:29

I think it's bullshit I've gone from 18 stone 1lb to 10 stone. I don't naturally have a sweet tooth anyway but I have sugar in my coffee , full sugar fruit juices. I just don't eat as much.

Abei · 15/10/2022 13:17

Interesting post op. Following.

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 13:17

Changing your way of eating permanently to avoid UPFs, excess sugar and refine carbs is the only thing that works. It’s not that restrictive so it works

that’s not low carb though. So how does o/p’s insulin theory fit in to that?

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:14

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 13:10

*Weight Watchers and Slimming World DON’T WORK.

If they did you wouldn’t have people returning time after time when they’ve put the weight back on*

they do. Where people put the weight back on is when they go back to old habits.

same with low carb. If you go back to your old eating patterns you’ll put the weight back on.

same with any “diet”.

That’s what I mean. They’re not sustainable.

Changing your way of eating permanently to avoid UPFs, excess sugar and refine carbs is the only thing that works. It’s not that restrictive so it works.

MapleLeafForever · 15/10/2022 13:12

Definitely find low carb boring here. I am doing it, but hating it. I'm not cutting out all carbs, but restricting them to a small treat, as well as also regularly having dairy, some startchier veg like squash, and berries. But pretty much no bread, rice, pasta, cereals, potatoes, cakes, biscuits, crisps, most fruit, juice. I dislike eggs and lentils. So just have veg, cheese, yoghurt, meat, nuts, and it's boring, expensive, and never gives me satisfying feel of having something nice.

I'm doing it for blood sugar reasons, having had a too high reading on blood tests a few times. I did it before, pretty strictly for many months, and got the blood sugar down, but never stopped cravings, and then gradually relapsed. I've lost a bit of weight this time, but it makes me miserable, always missing the stuff I've cut out, and it's so depressing to think that I'll have to do it permanently!

So I expect it's true for me, that keeping insulin resistance at bay is the only way I will avoid type 2 diabetes in the end, and the only way to lose weight, but god I hate it. I'd rather cut out all other calories and have a tiny amount of what I liked! Might work for weight loss for me, but won't help the blood sugar.

I wonder if doing low-carb for a while, enough to lose some weight, will actually reset the insulin response so that I could have more carbs without elevating the blood glucose levels, or whether low carb is just avoiding causing the issue rather than actually treating/resetting the insulin response in any way.