Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 18:19

FistFullOfRegrets · 15/10/2022 16:50

@AntlerRose all calories are not created equally. That's often overlooked.

Especially on Mumsnet.

There’s a strong ‘calorie deficit whatever you eat will make you lose weight’ here.

Eeksteek · 15/10/2022 17:41

ThisIsTrifficult · 15/10/2022 09:42

But different people respond to different carbs with different blood sugar spikes/crashes.
Low carb is not a long term strategy for most as it is a dull diet with little texture (nothing crunches and don't try and tell me celery does!). Low carb can hinder sleep also.

If it works for you, great, do it. But overall calorie is the boss. Eat less that you need. People want to complicate it or answer your prayers with this 'one simple trick' and it's lies

Your gut microbiome plays a HUGE part in the blood sugar response one has to a particular carb. As soon as people can map their gut microbes they may have an indication as to what foods (carbs) affect their blood sugar a lot and those that don't.

I’d be really interested in finding out more about that. Do you have links to any resources?

SimonaRazowska · 15/10/2022 17:16

I think that the way you talk about insulin and low carb makes you sound like a convert to a cult, rather than medical advice

Am never super impressed when people preach medical advice without being an actual trained medic

Everyone can read stuff on the internet

My religion, cult, whatever (am not pretending to be a doctor) is that carbs are fine, just cut back on sugar.

To say your way is THE way is very cult-ish

Me and my family are slim on high carb diets

No insulin issues, no diabetes

Personally I think the demonisation of foods like rice, brown bread and potatoes is unwarranted

fleurdelee · 15/10/2022 17:02

Placemarking

FistFullOfRegrets · 15/10/2022 16:50

AntlerRose · 15/10/2022 10:24

I wish i understood the science.
I eat lowish carb, lost weight and maintained it so far. I did this as i was pre diabetic and the pre diabetes went
It may well be a simple calorie deficit mechanism, but what i found is a low carb calorie deficit is the only one where i dont feel starving, get cravings, and get slumps and crashes or highs. So for me there is something else going on too. Like 1 calorie of protien or fat feels more filling and slower burning than 1 calorie of carb?

@AntlerRose all calories are not created equally. That's often overlooked.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 15/10/2022 16:45

@FistFullOfRegrets I tried it. Went from a 1.22 half marathon to about 1.40. It might work for them but not for me. I guess everyone is different

Oblomov22 · 15/10/2022 16:37

OP who are are you referring to? Normal people? Insulin resistant Type 2's? Type 1's?

Most of the Type 1's I know find it hard to keep their BG's stable. Some struggle to keep their weight stable too.

FistFullOfRegrets · 15/10/2022 16:36

Chesneyhawkes1 · 15/10/2022 10:01

I think low carb does work and I've lost weight using it when I was unable to exercise.

However when I'm exercising carbs are important to me, without them performance suffers.

Look up low carb long distance runners & weight lifters. Footballers & climbers. There are plenty of them

lljkk · 15/10/2022 16:32

Cousin said the worst thing about being vegan is the hours of chopping & preparing food. She isn't a British vegan, she doesn't eat that way to protect animals. She wanted vegan lifestyle for political reasons, in a fury about Trump. Also hoped it might help her husband's T2Diabetes, but eating vegan didn't seem to do that, either. So I think she is (was) pretty committed to less processed, whole grains & lots of veg as the food lifestyle.

tbf since Biden got in WhiteHouse cousin has probably stopped being vegan. 4 long years, though.

jennakong · 15/10/2022 16:26

lljkk · 15/10/2022 16:06

My cousin is super pissed off she hasn't lost weight as a result of going vegan. It's amazing to me how much people believe in "magic" foods.

Depends what kind of vegan food she's eating.

A lot of it tends to be highly processed and high fat, inc. palm oil, high carb and a bit nutritionally void.

Old style vegan, ie cooking your own wholefood meals from scratch because there's FA in the supermarket to suit you, is healthy and probably will lead to weight loss in the long term, because you'll be jettisoning so much junk. No cakes, biscuits, desserts, cheese, chocolate., replacing them with wholegrains, vegetables, fruit, nuts. The problem nowadays is that the food industry has developed vegan alternatives to all those things and is flogging them aggressively, often to young people.

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 16:21

And yes to the constant grazing.

Why do people feel the need to eat All. The. Time?

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 16:20

jennakong · 15/10/2022 15:57

Though look at people years ago - like looking at a different race.

The daily diet wasn't low carb by any means, though people certainly seemed to eat more meat, eggs, milk etc.

Portion sizes were smaller, there was less grazing, and certainly no adult snacking culture. Less wine about, far fewer takeaways. And more common to eat more during the day, and less in the evening. And probably more walking, I'd say.

I think people did eat less wheat years ago, and it wasn’t so processed.

Yes, people ate quite a bit of bread, but there weren’t breakfast cereals, for example, and people didn’t eat the copious quantities of pasta they do now. Meals were generally meat, veg and potatoes.

Crucially, wheat-containing foods weren’t ultra processed like they are now, including 90% of bread (seriously, go to a supermarket and try to by sliced bread that’s not UP). If we cut those and breakfast cereals out I think we’d see a huge difference.

Fairislefandango · 15/10/2022 16:15

My cousin is super pissed off she hasn't lost weight as a result of going vegan. It's amazing to me how much people believe in "magic" foods.

I didn't go gluten and dairy free for weight-loss purposes, but because I was having awful gastro symptoms (which gradually improved and eventually totally stopped when I quit gluten and dairy). The reason I'm surprised I haven't lost more weight is not because I think gluten and dairy themselves make you fat, but because most of the more indulgent and less healthy things I loved to eat contained dairy, gluten or both. I've found some substitutes but I eat them far less because they aren't as nice!

FruitToast · 15/10/2022 16:14

I'm just here to watch the bun fight.

But also just want to respond to a comment ages ago. Measuring insulin IS easy. I can order an insulin Elisa kit from most science companies and run one in the lab. Just as I have on studies in diabetics in the past. Along with a whole host of other hormones that are vital in glucose regulation. Have you ever given though to DPP4 or your incretins? Anyway most doctors are interested in glucose because it doesn't really matter how much insulin you are producing as long as it's in control of your glucose levels and your pancreas is coping. Glucose is what causes the damage.

Fairislefandango · 15/10/2022 16:09

This is why I do fasting (16/8). It works brilliantly for me! People say fasting only works because you eat less calories but that's simply not the only reason - it's a lot to do with insulin as you say.
I personally can't do low carb. I've tried it and both times I felt miserable and was horribly constipated (that's despite me eating loads of veg and chia seeds etc.). I have the type of digestive system that needs lots of wholegrain carbs to keep regular.

That's interesting. I guess we're all different, because the one thing that virtually put the brakes on my digestive system and bunged me up massively was 16/8 fasting. Never again! Whereas low-carbing didn't have that effect at all.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 16:07

The wheat is a different matter. Imho it's just indigestible nowadays! I had to cut it out for bit to get my gut ok, now I can eat it in smaller amounts. I think it's the process and bleaching. I know quite a few people who had to limit it. Not for weight purposes

lljkk · 15/10/2022 16:06

My cousin is super pissed off she hasn't lost weight as a result of going vegan. It's amazing to me how much people believe in "magic" foods.

Fairislefandango · 15/10/2022 16:03

I believe that if everyone in the developed world just cut out wheat we wouldn’t have an obesity epidemic.

I'm not so sure. I think cutting out highly processed foods would be better (many of which obviously do contain wheat).

I've been dairy and gluten free for 6 months now. I've maybe lost a tiny bit of weight, but I'd have thought I'd lose quite a lot. If people don't eat wheat, they tend to replace it with other carby things. For a while I didn't do that, but then I gradually discovered acceptable substitutes for gluteny things.

AntlerRose · 15/10/2022 15:57

I dont think i understand anything any better from this thread.

My only take is people do seem to hear low carb and think no carb.

The diabetes uk low carb diet is eating less than 130g of carbs a day so a slice of bread is about 20g and a jacket potato 90g but obviously all your apples and veg can be carby too. They actually have a few different eating plans this one is suggested for type 2s struggling to control blood sugar.

Its not good for children.

jennakong · 15/10/2022 15:57

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:40

🙄

It’s still low carb compared to the standard diet of pasta/rice/bread/potatoes with every meal.

I believe that if everyone in the developed world just cut out wheat we wouldn’t have an obesity epidemic.

Though look at people years ago - like looking at a different race.

The daily diet wasn't low carb by any means, though people certainly seemed to eat more meat, eggs, milk etc.

Portion sizes were smaller, there was less grazing, and certainly no adult snacking culture. Less wine about, far fewer takeaways. And more common to eat more during the day, and less in the evening. And probably more walking, I'd say.

AutumnCrow · 15/10/2022 15:32

I got so hungry reading this thread I went and made myself an omelette.

figtrees · 15/10/2022 15:29

I'm very athletic since I stopped carbs. I also never crave them now and actually feel a bit grossed out by bread. This is from somebody who thought they could never do keto etc.

I found fibre is what my body wanted, so to stick to low carb I had to add in a lot of dietary fibre. Without that I found it unmanageable.

I can get fat just looking at a bowl of oats. A lot if cereals (I don't even mean the processed sugary boxed kind) are absolutely awful. Anything that can be used to put weight on cattle and horses doesn't really belong in a human diet! The exception being if you are a runner etc with huge energy expenditure.

During my 20s I was very slim and ate an almighty amount of pasta and potato every day, I have no idea how I didn't gain weight, if I ate like that now I'd be very overweight. I think as we age and amd our metabolism changes its often hard to let go of old eating habits.

PBSam · 15/10/2022 15:24

purfectpuss · 15/10/2022 15:00

I genuinely think for whatever reason my body cannot process refined carbs effectively

I actually think the problem with refined carbs is exactly the opposite- our bodies can process and digest them too easily- so they are quickly digested and turned into fat leaving your stomach empty and you hungry!

They're only turned into fat if you over eat them. You could eat 1200 calories of biscuits and lose weight.

purfectpuss · 15/10/2022 15:00

I genuinely think for whatever reason my body cannot process refined carbs effectively

I actually think the problem with refined carbs is exactly the opposite- our bodies can process and digest them too easily- so they are quickly digested and turned into fat leaving your stomach empty and you hungry!

purfectpuss · 15/10/2022 14:54

I honestly don't think low carb is the long-term answer. Neither is low fat.

For me, just restricting highly processed carbohydrates like cakes, biscuits, crisps and sweets keeps my weight stable. If I eat sugary items I notice my weight creeping up and I feel lethargic.

I never eat traditional cereals like cornflakes, rice-crispier etc.- instead breakfast is either porridge, wholegrain toast and peanut butter, or egg, or cheese spread, and fruit and/or yoghurt. Lunch is usually leftovers of pasta, curry etc. or salt and some kind of meat, , or soup with seeded bread, or sandwich with cheese, ham or chicken and some more fruit. To snack I might have cheese and oatcakes, nuts, rye crisp breads with butter or cheese spread, humous and bread-sticks, or yoghurt. Meals are just normal things like pasta and sauces, meat or fish with veg and potatoes, curry and rice, casseroles, fish and chips and peas, etc. I always include a protein source in every meal as otherwise I find I get hungry soon after, and always some form of carb- but I always serve a relatively small portion of rice, potatoes or pasta compared to other items in the meal- probably around 1/3 of the plate.