Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
Primroseprimula · 15/10/2022 20:54

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 20:36

I am arguing against "it's not calories, it's carvs" because for healthy average person that's simply not helpful.
It is calories. Some people will need different diet to it because of medical issues. Even the famous diet people peddle everywhere is about calories at the end of the day.

Claiming calories are not it, is simply wrong.

What is obesity if not a medical issue?

I think there is still a huge amount that isn't understood about obesity. A lot I have read on the subject recently is quite clear that simple calorie counting statistically is unlikely to be effective long term if someone is obese, as opposed to someone who is just a little overweight.

Obesity has such a huge detrimental effect on pretty much every organ and function of the body, it makes no sense that how the metabolism functions would remain unnafected.

I'm not saying that reducing carbs is a panacea, but it can have a huge positive impact on a lot of people who have failed at simply restricting calories.

Abei · 15/10/2022 20:45

🤨 weird.

PBSam · 15/10/2022 20:41

Abei · 15/10/2022 20:35

Lol.

No.

You're wrong. Admit it and move on.

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 20:40

Eeksteek · 15/10/2022 20:24

It’s an astonishingly stubborn concept. The actual specialist medics are most definitely developing theories about obesity being a hormonal and metabolic disorder. (Common or garden medics don’t have any real diet or obesity training all, by the way).

Bodies are unbelievably, staggeringly, amazingly complex and sensitive. The idea that a calorie is just an undifferentiated unit of energy to them and that you just keep packing on fat with no system for regulating weight seems insane if you think about (I have a biology degree and a physio degree, so I’m not exactly approaching this as a layman). Literally NO OTHER biological system works like that. None. It’s a hormonally controlled negative feed back system. Just like all the others. And processed food and refined carbs (which don’t occur in nature, so we haven’t evolved a way of dealing with them) disrupt it.

Also, the idea that we know everything about how this system works? Staggeringly arrogant! We have so much to learn. And that it’s as simple as ‘eat less move more’? Just naive. No body system is that simple. Ever.

Most sensible post all day.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 20:38

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 20:36

Well it’s not working is it?!

It is in countries where carb is actually heavily in a diet.
Look at list of countries with lowest obesity levels.

It's us, not carbs (unless medical issues)

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 20:36

Primroseprimula · 15/10/2022 19:49

How you feel on a diet is going to have an effect on the sustainability of it though, hence why in the majority of cases simple calorie deficit diets do not work in the long term, or you fall off the wagon and binge.

Reducing refined carbs & sugar is simply a way of adjusting what you eat to help control insulin and appetite. Even someone with no metabolic issues will have a bigger sugar spike after eating for example a bowl of honey nut cornflakes vs wholemeal toast with some eggs.

I don't know why you seem to be arguing against advice that can help people successfully lose weight?

I am arguing against "it's not calories, it's carvs" because for healthy average person that's simply not helpful.
It is calories. Some people will need different diet to it because of medical issues. Even the famous diet people peddle everywhere is about calories at the end of the day.

Claiming calories are not it, is simply wrong.

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 20:36

Also, the idea that we know everything about how this system works? Staggeringly arrogant! We have so much to learn. And that it’s as simple as ‘eat less move more’? Just naive. No body system is that simple. Ever

yep. It’s also not as simple as “lower carbs lower insulin”.

however generally speaking, a calorie deficit does work. Whether that’s via Atkins, low fat, low carb. When people successfully lose weight, it’s usually because they have dropped the high fat high sugar refined foods because the calorie load isn’t worth it so they make better choices. Fruit and yoghurt instead of ice cream.

interesting that you should say about common or garden medics as well. Many of these writing books on diet and claiming to have the answer to weight loss aren’t obesity or even endocrinology/nutrition trained.

atkins was a cardiologist. Fung is a nephrologist.

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 20:36

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 19:09

Calories in vs calories out without controlling insulin, through food choices are useless

It's not useless to majority of the world....

Well it’s not working is it?!

Abei · 15/10/2022 20:35

Lol.

No.

PBSam · 15/10/2022 20:34

Abei · 15/10/2022 20:26

Being vegan is a diet.

No it isn't. It's an ethical worldview that also effects what you want to eat. Plant based is the diet without the ethics attached with being vegan.

Mad1988 · 15/10/2022 20:34

I love how @Redterror started the discussion with So I am an advocate of low carb followed by a big post which can be summarise as you lot are ignorant and I am going to educate you on insulin, but struggles to regurgitate whatever she read on a blog or Insta.
Reminds me of the religious zealots that come in pair at the front door to tell me they want to talk to me about Jesus. 😆

PortiaWithNoBreaks · 15/10/2022 20:31

Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:41

@MrsTuxedo I don't think I've mentioned steak or rice. Although your point depends on the size of either.

My point is when insulin is raised you will mostly be burning sugar and if you want to lose weight you need to burn fat. To burn fat insulin needs to be lowered.

You are confusing burning fat as fuel with losing fat. Energy can’t just disappear. You can use fat as fuel but if you’re not in a calorie deficit you won’t lose fat.

Whilst it is move more eat less and the thermodynamics of weight loss is simple, for lots of ppl it is not easy.

It’s the behaviour around weight loss that’s difficult. It’s a behaviour issue. Over restriction leads to over indulgence blah blah. There are lots of easily available highly palatable (calorie dense) foods. All these varying ways of eating are really behaviour mechanisms that may result in weight/fat loss.

Abei · 15/10/2022 20:26

Being vegan is a diet.

Eeksteek · 15/10/2022 20:24

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 18:19

Especially on Mumsnet.

There’s a strong ‘calorie deficit whatever you eat will make you lose weight’ here.

It’s an astonishingly stubborn concept. The actual specialist medics are most definitely developing theories about obesity being a hormonal and metabolic disorder. (Common or garden medics don’t have any real diet or obesity training all, by the way).

Bodies are unbelievably, staggeringly, amazingly complex and sensitive. The idea that a calorie is just an undifferentiated unit of energy to them and that you just keep packing on fat with no system for regulating weight seems insane if you think about (I have a biology degree and a physio degree, so I’m not exactly approaching this as a layman). Literally NO OTHER biological system works like that. None. It’s a hormonally controlled negative feed back system. Just like all the others. And processed food and refined carbs (which don’t occur in nature, so we haven’t evolved a way of dealing with them) disrupt it.

Also, the idea that we know everything about how this system works? Staggeringly arrogant! We have so much to learn. And that it’s as simple as ‘eat less move more’? Just naive. No body system is that simple. Ever.

PBSam · 15/10/2022 20:23

lljkk · 15/10/2022 16:32

Cousin said the worst thing about being vegan is the hours of chopping & preparing food. She isn't a British vegan, she doesn't eat that way to protect animals. She wanted vegan lifestyle for political reasons, in a fury about Trump. Also hoped it might help her husband's T2Diabetes, but eating vegan didn't seem to do that, either. So I think she is (was) pretty committed to less processed, whole grains & lots of veg as the food lifestyle.

tbf since Biden got in WhiteHouse cousin has probably stopped being vegan. 4 long years, though.

She was never vegan then. It's not a diet... best you could call her is plant based.

WiddlinDiddlin · 15/10/2022 20:10

I wish I had a simple solution..

I am:

insulin resistant
insulin dependent T2
gallstones (inoperable due to my heart condition and weight combination)
suffer gastropareisis regularly
ARFID

I tried low carb - great but miserable for me due to the stuff allowed on that plan thats not allowed by the gallstones or my brain, and to keep my BG down to within the 'normal for diabetic' levels I was really struggling, a diet of 600 cal just about achieved it, with tiny meals spaced out during the day to avoid the glucose dumping..

I tried fasting - that causes my liver to dump even more and my BG to shoot up

A lot of the high protein and also the low carb high fibre 'health' stuff triggers a bout of gastropareisis - this fucks up BG and insulin calculations because what i eat now may not affect my BG now but in 8 hours time.. or 6 hours.. or 12 hours or... who knows?!
It means I might eat and dose for that meal correctly, but have a hypo because my BG didn't rise because I am not digesting the food i actually ate.

The net result of all this is I am just getting fatter and fatter until almost certainly, I'll burst. MY gp just shakes her head, my diabetic nurse thinks i am mainlining cake all day long and tells me to follow the NHS guidelines which involves so much carb I'd be using even MORE insulin than I am now!

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 20:09

If I ate for example 1200 calories a day of purely white bread I would lose weight, but I would feel terrible and experience reactive hypoglycemia and have to eat more calories to correct the low blood sugar

if you are not diabetic and taking exogenous insulin you don’t need to eat calories to “correct blood sugar”.

if your blood sugar drops cells will release glucose to maintain homeostasis.

you may feel like you need to eat, but there won’t be any serious consequences.

prior to the fasting/low carb/insulin theory we had the idea that if you ate little and often your insulin levels remain steady and don’t spike.

it’s just a new twist on an old idea.

Primroseprimula · 15/10/2022 19:49

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 19:36

We are talking weightloss not feeling here though.

As discussed before you can lose eating maccies. Will you feel great though? No.
For weightloss it is calories for people without medical issues. If I eat 800 cal, as in that diet, I would bet my trousers I would lose same like on low carb 800. Because it's the calories which cause weightloss in ordinary person.

How you feel on a diet is going to have an effect on the sustainability of it though, hence why in the majority of cases simple calorie deficit diets do not work in the long term, or you fall off the wagon and binge.

Reducing refined carbs & sugar is simply a way of adjusting what you eat to help control insulin and appetite. Even someone with no metabolic issues will have a bigger sugar spike after eating for example a bowl of honey nut cornflakes vs wholemeal toast with some eggs.

I don't know why you seem to be arguing against advice that can help people successfully lose weight?

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 19:36

Primroseprimula · 15/10/2022 19:32

If I ate for example 1200 calories a day of purely white bread I would lose weight, but I would feel terrible and experience reactive hypoglycemia and have to eat more calories to correct the low blood sugar.

Would my body react the same if I had been born elsewhere in the world and not grown up on a diet of ultra processed carbs and hidden sugars? Perhaps not. Its actually irrelevant to my current reality and that of a huge percentage of people in this country struggling to control their weight.

We are talking weightloss not feeling here though.

As discussed before you can lose eating maccies. Will you feel great though? No.
For weightloss it is calories for people without medical issues. If I eat 800 cal, as in that diet, I would bet my trousers I would lose same like on low carb 800. Because it's the calories which cause weightloss in ordinary person.

FinallyHere · 15/10/2022 19:34

@Eeksteek

  • "Your gut microbiome plays a HUGE part in the blood sugar response one has to a particular carb. As soon as people can map their gut microbes they may have an indication as to what foods (carbs) affect their blood sugar a lot and those that don't."

I’d be really interested in finding out more about that. Do you have links

I was very interested in finding out more about my gut microbes so did the Zoe Project Heath Study, wore a continuous glucose monitor for a fortnight, plus a fecal and blood sample.

Surprise, surprise, my results indicate that sugar and starchy carbs spike my blood sugar. So low carb it is for me.

I knew that from observation, but it was reassuring to have the independent, objective confirmation.

joinzoe.com/learn

Primroseprimula · 15/10/2022 19:32

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 19:09

Calories in vs calories out without controlling insulin, through food choices are useless

It's not useless to majority of the world....

If I ate for example 1200 calories a day of purely white bread I would lose weight, but I would feel terrible and experience reactive hypoglycemia and have to eat more calories to correct the low blood sugar.

Would my body react the same if I had been born elsewhere in the world and not grown up on a diet of ultra processed carbs and hidden sugars? Perhaps not. Its actually irrelevant to my current reality and that of a huge percentage of people in this country struggling to control their weight.

Primroseprimula · 15/10/2022 19:26

SimonaRazowska · 15/10/2022 17:16

I think that the way you talk about insulin and low carb makes you sound like a convert to a cult, rather than medical advice

Am never super impressed when people preach medical advice without being an actual trained medic

Everyone can read stuff on the internet

My religion, cult, whatever (am not pretending to be a doctor) is that carbs are fine, just cut back on sugar.

To say your way is THE way is very cult-ish

Me and my family are slim on high carb diets

No insulin issues, no diabetes

Personally I think the demonisation of foods like rice, brown bread and potatoes is unwarranted

You and your family being slim on a high carb diet isn't proof that high carbs is good for everyone, you are giving out dietary advice that would be damaging for anyone with insulin resistance or diabetes.

Most dietary advice I've come across doesn't demonise rice, brown bread and potato's, it just recommends limiting their amounts so they only make up a small proportion of the overall diet.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 19:09

Calories in vs calories out without controlling insulin, through food choices are useless

It's not useless to majority of the world....

TheHumanExperience · 15/10/2022 19:00

ipreferthecat · 15/10/2022 09:31

@Redterror is this something you have studied ?

I highly recommend you read The Obesity Code by Dr Jason Fung who will break this down so any fool (me) can fully understand it. You will then have all the peer-reviewed studies to back up the information and the data. The OP is right. She doesn't have to be an expert but she, as we all can, learn from the experts in this field.

We should be taught this in school. The government have been so fixated on 'eat less, move more', when historical studies, show this is a flawed failed model. Calories in vs calories out without controlling insulin, through food choices are useless. That's why so many people fail on their diets, as much as they try.

AlmostSummer21 · 15/10/2022 18:25

sashh · 15/10/2022 12:21

Low carb doesn't mean no carb.

I was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes in May. I've been low carb and protein for breakfast since then and my A1C went from 69 to 59 in a month, I'm waiting for a result from the one I had last week.

My fasting glucose is down from 14 to <8 most days with occasional drops to 6 or 6.5.

I have lost 10 kg.

As for no crunch, well I like pork scratchings and crispy parmesan crisps so I get my crunch from there and also from the carbs I do eat eg I can have 3 frozen croquette potatoes.

I do agree though that our bodies are all different.

I used a free trial of a libre 2 glucose monitor and tracked the levels, I found out that bananas spike my blood sugar.

If anyone is trying to lose weight the Libra 2 costs £50 for 2 weeks(no I don't work for them) and is an easy way to track your blood sugar / response to food and exercise.

Exercise lowers blood glucose.

@sashh

& a new phone!!

I looked Into getting a libre, but my iphone6 is 'too old' apparently.

Anyone else as well

I've had T2 for years. I had a virus that attacked my liver, fucked my metabolism & I ended up with T2. I was 7stone wet at the time. Because my liver was bad, I was young, they/we/I tried a variety of things to fix it. A good while after I was diagnosed with T2. I then put on a lot of weight. T2 diagnosis FIRST, weight gain AFTER.

I don't take any medication, I control it with diet & exercise. Diet being low carb, but I'm also vegetarian & don't eat eggs (& hate cooking). Low carb is the only thing that keeps my blood sugars controlled without medication.

HOWEVER, it's very very limiting in regards to socialising & I'm fed up with the same food week in, week out.and NOT losing weight.

Add in carbs and my blood sugar zooms up.

Bernstein, Taub & Fung really helped me get my diabetes under control.

However, I'm SO desperate to have a way of eating that doesn't make me a pain in the arse to socialise Leith, I'm open to suggestions.

T2
vegetarian
no eggs
over 50
over weight

unable to weight train, HIT, etc due to consequences of life changing accident (2 years ago) knees that are fucked & age/weight/physical limitations.

,

Swipe left for the next trending thread