Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
Againstmachine · 18/10/2022 20:44

no need to be so rude. Some of us have done plenty of reading around the science of the subject, even worked in the field.

It's scary they even are calling me a victim blamer, this cult people are in it's ry bizzare.

Againstmachine · 18/10/2022 20:41

Oh stop with the victim blaming bullshit, it is that simple if you complicated it it's on you.

I can't even believe you are comparing this with victim blaming it's pathetic and disrespectful to people who are victims

Glad to see people on mumsnet hate basic physics.

Reallyreallyborednow · 18/10/2022 20:39

It isn't simple at all - if you would know if you had done any reading around the science of the subject

no need to be so rude. Some of us have done plenty of reading around the science of the subject, even worked in the field.

i have reached a different conclusion to you. I am very aware it’s not simple, which is why I don’t claim I have all the answers.

i believe the bottom line is energy balance.

your research has led you to a different conclusion. As you say, it’s very complicated so different interpretations of the science isn’t unbelievable.

you do your low carb if it works for you. Don’t try and convert me because you arrogantly believe your interpretation of the science of a very complicated subject is the right one.

fwiw, I do believe that for some people low carb helps them control their calorie intake, and they may be able to lose weight on relatively larger calorie loads than a high carb diet. But it still is about energy, it’s about finding a way not to overeat.

BIWI · 18/10/2022 19:39

which you would know....

BIWI · 18/10/2022 19:39

It isn't simple at all - if you would know if you had done any reading around the science of the subject.

And stop with the victim blaming. That helps no-one.

Againstmachine · 18/10/2022 19:21

@BIWI
If it was that bloody simple @Againstmachine then no-one would be overweight Hmm

It is that simple the mathematics of it all for majority of people , these fad diets are rubbish.

People sticking to them is another matter, people either have many reasons why they may not stick to it but, the reality is if you put less in than you expend you will lose weight.

BIWI · 18/10/2022 19:17

If it was that bloody simple @Againstmachine then no-one would be overweight Hmm

Againstmachine · 18/10/2022 19:13

*So pasta isn't the diet demon?

I think reheated pasta has a lower GI than freshly cooked pasta. Same as frozen bread being toasted that a PP referred to. I don't understand the process but I think the Van Tulleken twins did a TV programme about carbs and they explained why it happened.*

Nope it isn't and stop posting this rubbish about toast , pasta etc.

It's what you put in vs what you put out it's that bloody simple.

UglyModernWindows · 18/10/2022 13:42

I agree with you OP. In fact today is my 2nd anniversary on a low carb diet and I'm yet to be bored with it. I will never go back to the old "everything in moderation" crap diet. I'm careful though not to over do the cream, butter etc though, I spend time meal planning each week and make sure to have varied meals with lots of vegetables, berries and some fruit. Eating low carb has infact opened up my eyes for variety foods compared to being in a rut of cooking pasta/rice on most days.

If you have lots of belly fat, eating less and moving more is not going to do much. Realising that was a huge revelation after years jogging and enduring the cross trainer at the gym. Once eating low carb my 39 inch waist just melted away, it was amazing, it's now nice trim 29 inches even though I'm perimenopausal and nearly 50. I don't think many people realise the dangers of a non-fatty liver.

Reallyreallyborednow · 18/10/2022 13:17

So pasta isn't the diet demon?

this is what I lost 3 stone on:

breakfast: cereal bar/granola/porridge- 200-250 cals
lunch: noodle/pasta/bulgar wheat pot noodle thing- 250 cals.
dinner: stir fry veg/cauli rice/roast veg/salad 300 cal portion of ready made chilli/macaroni cheese/tagine or similar.
snack: biscuit/oat cake/chocolate raisins/nuts/crisps/ popcorn- 60-200 cals.

plus a milk allowance of 120ml for tea coffee etc.

not majorly hungry as long as I ate at steady intervals. I’d tried IF previously and got so hungry I binged when I was “allowed” to eat. I’ve tried low carb but just ate my bodyweight in cheese so put on weight, and was still hungry.

it’s more processed than I’d normally eat in some ways, but it did vastly increase my intake of veg and salad. I struggle with portion control so this way meant the portions were done and I couldn’t throw a bit extra in or have seconds. The psychology of knowing what I’m eating and having it all “prepared” works for me.

PBSam · 18/10/2022 13:15

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 18/10/2022 12:49

So pasta isn't the diet demon?

I think reheated pasta has a lower GI than freshly cooked pasta. Same as frozen bread being toasted that a PP referred to. I don't understand the process but I think the Van Tulleken twins did a TV programme about carbs and they explained why it happened.

The GI is only relevant if you're eating pasta alone and nothing else. Once you combine food groups the GI changes anyway.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 18/10/2022 12:49

So pasta isn't the diet demon?

I think reheated pasta has a lower GI than freshly cooked pasta. Same as frozen bread being toasted that a PP referred to. I don't understand the process but I think the Van Tulleken twins did a TV programme about carbs and they explained why it happened.

TightDiamondShoes · 18/10/2022 08:34

You can always tell those parroting stuff they don’t understand. Eg I’ve magically put in a pound overnight. A “nutritionist” friend will tell me that’s impossible because you need to eat 7000 surplus calories or something… or maybe I did negative exercise/BMR.

PeloFondo · 18/10/2022 00:56

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 20:09

If I ate for example 1200 calories a day of purely white bread I would lose weight, but I would feel terrible and experience reactive hypoglycemia and have to eat more calories to correct the low blood sugar

if you are not diabetic and taking exogenous insulin you don’t need to eat calories to “correct blood sugar”.

if your blood sugar drops cells will release glucose to maintain homeostasis.

you may feel like you need to eat, but there won’t be any serious consequences.

prior to the fasting/low carb/insulin theory we had the idea that if you ate little and often your insulin levels remain steady and don’t spike.

it’s just a new twist on an old idea.

See I faint with low blood sugar. My dad does too
Worse in the afternoon especially if I fall asleep, I wake up shaky and faint if I don't eat. But I'm careful to balance carbs/protein so I don't spike and then drop instantly again
Dad carries glucose tablets, I did when I was at school as well. Both tested as "normal" on bloods but we both seem to get low blood sugar fast Confused

Last time I fainted I had porridge and a banana for breakfast. Ate 2 Jaffa cakes at work and then fainted. Took a Mars bar and then 2 lots of glucose from the paramedics to get it up to normal

Getoff · 18/10/2022 00:10

”eat less, move around more” may be more nuanced than that, but it is the basic bottom line.

I bet on a thread about finances this poster would advise "earn more, spend less" and declare a problem of poverty solved.

MapleLeafForever · 17/10/2022 22:00

Justkoko · 17/10/2022 20:14

So pasta isn't the diet demon?

Depends also on what the goal is - if it's purely weight loss, then you can probably find ways to lose weight as well as eat pasta.

I think for those of us who have to lower blood sugar, though, pre-diabetic, then it is kind of a demon at least until the weight is lost and the blood sugar is in the normal range for a good chunk of time. And even then white pasta is probably not going to be great - though I still hope I can eat it sometimes!

Fairislefandango · 17/10/2022 21:55

That's a great post @Eeksteek! I don't think I've ever seen it put quite like that. The point about what your body chooses to do about a calorie deficit, and the fact that it doesn't necessarily choose fat loss , is a bit of a game-changer imo.

I think it's also important to see the drive to eat more food, and more calorific food, as the body's natural reaction to being deprived of nutrients (either due to dieting or due to a poor diet full of processed crap) rather than just 'lack of willpower'. Our hormones are in charge.

Reallyreallyborednow · 17/10/2022 20:50

So pasta isn't the diet demon?

depends who you ask 😂. O/p and the other low carb evangelists will disagree.

if it keeps you full so your overall intake is lowered and you lose weight then there’s no issue.

MagsR2356 · 17/10/2022 20:47

Sounds interesting can you give an example of a daily diet plan? I’m interested in what you would have on the menu if following this?

Justkoko · 17/10/2022 20:14

So pasta isn't the diet demon?

Reallyreallyborednow · 17/10/2022 20:09

*I would really like to understand this more. I had a huge bowl of veg and chicken soup at lunch yet come 4pm I was still absolutely ravenous. It was thick soup too, not a broth.

Yet not so long ago, I had a bowl of leftover pasta at brunch time, it kept me full until dinner*

pasta is bulkier with more fibre. Not a lot, as it’s processed, but more than soup. This will keep you fuller as it takes longer to digest, and will stay in your stomach until it is broken down to a more liquid consistency. Which also means it will be slower release so your blood sugar levels will raise more slowly and for longer.

MapleLeafForever · 17/10/2022 18:37

I think the idea that it's the protein and fat that keeps you feeling full. So you just had mainly carbs (the veg), and soup (mainly water!) with perhaps a small bit of chicken (protein). And the volume of it all might not have been that much either, which doesn't keep you feeling full for that long.

But it's true that pasta is just so much nicer and more comforting, and even when I eat lots of protein with fats, I still constantly crave the carbs. Really frustrating, but they definitely satisfy something else for me, whether it's taste or psychological or feeling filled by volume or whatever. Or just that knowledge that you can't ever really have them again. I could easily have eaten an entire bowl of pasta with nothing else for dinner. Or rice. Or porridge.

Justkoko · 17/10/2022 16:51

I would really like to understand this more. I had a huge bowl of veg and chicken soup at lunch yet come 4pm I was still absolutely ravenous. It was thick soup too, not a broth.

Yet not so long ago, I had a bowl of leftover pasta at brunch time, it kept me full until dinner.

I do know that I love pasta and if I'm told to give it up I'll want it more. I have to find a way to keep it in my plan. And lose weight.

Eeksteek · 16/10/2022 22:24

I have written an absurdly long rely and it wont copy and paste. I’ll keep trying.

MapleLeafForever · 16/10/2022 19:29

i haven't, no, but I"ll add it to my reading list!