Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
Janeaustensquill · 19/10/2022 10:42

This is a fascinating thread with very useful links. I’ve been overweight for 40 years and have tried every diet going. Low carb with lots of veg and some fruit suits me best in that I enjoy the food and generally am less likely to binge, but despite that I am now 5 stone overweight because I can’t sustain it. What I’ve noticed from recent reading is that once you’re obese it’s very hard for you to lose weight - all sorts of factors kick in to create a feedback loop where your metabolism goes down and your appetite, desire to eat goes up.
Eating shouldn’t be about willpower but modern lifestyles and UPF make it very difficult for many of us.
I am currently reading the obesity code by Joel Greene. On his Insta fame realjoelgreen he has lots of information. I have no idea whether scientifically his work stacks up but it’s interesting - there are various suggestions that sound worth a punt, such as eating apple skins to start each day to boost healthy gut bacteria. all the benefits are in the skin. He has a very big focus on gut health.
has anyone come across him?

FinallyHere · 19/10/2022 10:35

Low carb and low calorie diets show the same benefit long term.

This is a good news story as far as I can see.

Low carb for me means a full load of green veg plus whatever fat and protein I need to make the food palatable. And all the water.

That way of eating is very different to a highly processed diet of protein powder and supplements, which could also be low carb but would absolutely not be for me.

MadelineUsher · 19/10/2022 10:25

lljkk · 19/10/2022 07:08

6 lbs?
Wait, if I ate 300 g carbs daily (I think that might be typical), that's 300 x 4g = 1.2 kg/day. In "water & glycogen" Or about 3 lbs Previous poster didn't explain if the carbs x 4g gets expelled again, and if that's a once a day or constant process of elimination.

Is previous poster saying they eat 600g carbs / day to get to 6 lb fluctuation? That would be 3000 kcal/day. In carbs alone. Not many weight loss diets would recommend 3000 kcal/day.

A woman could carry an extra 3-4 pounds premenstrually, as part of her natural cycle, then eat a pizza, or takeaway fish and chips, and easily be up 6 pounds that night, c/- salt alone. A load of soy sauce on green veg could cause a few pounds of water weight c/- the salt content, without the carbs.

The water weight is temporary and is excreted over the following 24 hours or so.

Reallyreallyborednow · 19/10/2022 10:17

the report you quote states that fibre is a carb that does not raise blood sugar levels so actually the OP is right to focus on insulin levels rather than carb levels

that makes no sense. How does fibre not raising blood glucose mean the o/p is right? can you explain please.

did you read the whole report, or just focus on that one thing that backs up your theory?

the report conclusion is that low carb is not better long term for the management of type 2 diabetes. Low carb and low calorie diets show the same benefit long term.

FinallyHere · 19/10/2022 10:16

https://gillianriley.com

No idea where that extra 'm' came from.

FinallyHere · 19/10/2022 10:15

@MapleLeafForever

It is interesting for me to know that some people genuinely prefer my mother's low fat approach 😀 and that it really does work better for them. I just rebelled anytime she suggested I consider eating less and proved it by 'eating all the pies .. and sweets and everything else'.

If you could do with some support on your approach to restricting food, you might find something of interest in Gillian Riley's work on taking control of overeating, originally based on her work helping people conquer an addition to smoking. It applies anything I do for my self, where the rewards require a short term 'pain' restrict food or get up out of bed to exercise in return for longer term gain ( or loss of weight).

https://gillianriley.comm*

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 19/10/2022 10:07

they also note that low carb diets that consequentially reduce intake of dietary fibre and other nutritional sources, which can increase other health risk (low fibre is linked to bowel cancer increase, for example.

Reallyreallyborednow the report you quote states that fibre is a carb that does not raise blood sugar levels so actually the OP is right to focus on insulin levels rather than carb levels.

The Van Tulleken programme I mentioned earlier is reviewed here (don't know if it's still available on iplayer) and the conclusion is that not all carbs are equal.

www.diabetes.co.uk/in-depth/truth-about-carbs-bbc-1-review/

And reducing the argument down to calories in/calories out ignores all the psychological and hormonal issues around weight loss.

MapleLeafForever · 19/10/2022 09:35

Thank you.

That is sort of good news I guess! If I could lose weight by eating less, even if it's really hard, but still occasionally having the things I like, then maybe that would bring down the blood sugar levels so that I don't get worse.

I think the low-carb probably does work for me in terms of weight loss, but it's just so miserable that I don't think it will be sustainable. I was persisting because I thought it would be good for glucose levels even if it didn't cause that much weight loss. Of course I know that I also need to work on attitude and try to find it less miserable, but that is hard!!

I would rather eat a single mince pie for dinner than a full place of chicken and veg, for example...!! Not something I'd do often, but being able to have occasional nice things with other reductions in calories would be a lot more pleasant.

FinallyHere · 19/10/2022 09:34

@MatchaTea

Thank you for that text, it's really interesting to read the methodology alongside the conclusions.

The carbohydrate–insulin model of obesity theorizes that diets high in carbohydrate are particularly fattening due to their propensity to elevate insulin secretion.

For example, I completely disagree with this premise. I eat low carb because the food is very palatable and because I feel so much better eating in this way. My whole relationship not because I think starchy carbs are particularly fattening.

As a bonus, the excess weight I have put on by being 'tempted' by highly palatable, even addictive manufactured foods which tend to combine fat and starchy carbs, has very slowly melted.

I know it's equally possible to control low weight using a low fat high carb approach. My mother did it all her life. It required constant vigilance and seems to me to be a miserable existence.

I much prefer eating good food which avoids the padding of starchy carbs and which seems to need no effort for me to sustain. I'm so much more peaceful and calm around food without that voice in my head which screams 'eat, now' which I associate with the blood sugar rollercoaster of eating starchy carbs.

I'm so find myself evangelising about low carb exactly because I feel so much better eating in this way. I'd love everyone to try it, to see whether it works for them, too. My relationship with good has never been better, it's quite a load off my mind to be comfortable eating.

Reallyreallyborednow · 19/10/2022 09:29

@mapleleafforever

diabetes-resources-production.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/resources-s3/public/2021-05/low-carb-diets-for-people-with-diabetes-position-statement-may-2021.pdf

diabetes UK position statement on low carb diets.

  • no benefit in type 1
  • type 2 may be beneficial for up to 6 months, but no difference in the long term. Low carb should not be regarded as superior or better
  • low carb may have serious affects in children so should not be used.
  • the evidence supporting low calorie diets for diabetes remission is more robust.

basically again if a low carb plan works for you great, if another plan does, that’s great too. The overall goal is weight loss- by reducing energy intake.

they also note that low carb diets that consequentially reduce intake of dietary fibre and other nutritional sources, which can increase other health risk (low fibre is linked to bowel cancer increase, for example.

overall recommendation is people should be supported in their choice but weight control is what makes a diet effective wrt diabetes.

PeloFondo · 19/10/2022 09:03

Againstmachine · 19/10/2022 08:55

It isn't victim blaming it really isnt.

Majority people are fat because they eat too much, if you want to make them out to be victims that's rather pathetic.

It's an eating disorder a lot of the time
But people see it differently. Eat too little - disorder. Eat too much - pathetic

MapleLeafForever · 19/10/2022 08:57

Do any of those studies distinguish between people who are pre-diabetic, and those who are not? I think pre-diabetic people are also wanting to lower blood sugar, rather than just lose weight, although I know losing weight will help with the blood sugar problem. But if they've already got insulin resistance, then perhaps they are the ones who particularly need low-carb to lose weight (and possibly to maintain it later?). The books recommending Atkins and other diets at the time often talked about "carb addicts" and things like that, people who really felt cravings for carbs, got symptoms from too many carbs, loved carbs more than other foods, etc., and I suspect were trying to identify those who might be at risk of metabolic disorders or who already had them, because those were the people for whom the diet might work best. The diet then became popular with everyone as a fast means of losing weight, whether or not they particularly needed to keep blood sugar low.

But so many of these studies don't really seem to distinguish between the groups. So if they say low-carb isn't any better than other diets, then I would wonder if all this 'sacrifice' as actually worth it because I miss carbs so much - but on the other hand, if it's really important for lowering pre-diabetes glucose levels and preventing full blown type 2 diabetes and other associated conditions, then I'd try to keep on with it, at least in a moderate form, longer tem - whether or not it was the only/best way to lose weight. But if losing weight by other means had the same ultimate effect on reducing diabetes risk, there would be much more pleasant ways (for me) to do it than low carb. I'm sure some people enjoy the food on low-carb and don't miss the stuff that's cut out as a result, but I don't think I'm one of them!!

Againstmachine · 19/10/2022 08:55

It isn't victim blaming it really isnt.

Majority people are fat because they eat too much, if you want to make them out to be victims that's rather pathetic.

BIWI · 19/10/2022 08:43

@Reallyreallyborednow

Don’t try and convert me because you arrogantly believe your interpretation of the science of a very complicated subject is the right one

And you called me rude?!

I haven't said my interpretation is the right one - I merely pointed out, as have you that this is a very complicated subject.

Where, on this thread, do you believe I'm trying to convert anyone?

@Againstmachine

This ...

it is that simple if you complicated it it's on you

... is victim blaming.

Weight loss isn't simple - there are many factors that impact on weight loss, scientific as well as emotional. As I said, if it was simple, no-one who wants to lose weight would fail.

lljkk · 19/10/2022 07:08

6 lbs?
Wait, if I ate 300 g carbs daily (I think that might be typical), that's 300 x 4g = 1.2 kg/day. In "water & glycogen" Or about 3 lbs Previous poster didn't explain if the carbs x 4g gets expelled again, and if that's a once a day or constant process of elimination.

Is previous poster saying they eat 600g carbs / day to get to 6 lb fluctuation? That would be 3000 kcal/day. In carbs alone. Not many weight loss diets would recommend 3000 kcal/day.

PBSam · 19/10/2022 06:34

MadelineUsher · 19/10/2022 06:02

But that's so silly! Anyone can put a pound or three on overnight, by eating salty food - teporary water retention. It's not magic. Carbs also cause temporary water retention in the process of digestion. So a load of pasta and parmesan, high salt, or chips, and you can "magically put on a pound overnight" and lose it again the following day or night, via urination.

I'm pretty sure every gram of carbs eaten cause cause 4 grams in water retention and glycogen. Anybody who thinks a 1 pound fluctuation in daily weight is fat gain/loss really doesn't understand anything. I can vary by 6 pounds through different points of the day for god sake. 😂

MadelineUsher · 19/10/2022 06:02

TightDiamondShoes · 18/10/2022 08:34

You can always tell those parroting stuff they don’t understand. Eg I’ve magically put in a pound overnight. A “nutritionist” friend will tell me that’s impossible because you need to eat 7000 surplus calories or something… or maybe I did negative exercise/BMR.

But that's so silly! Anyone can put a pound or three on overnight, by eating salty food - teporary water retention. It's not magic. Carbs also cause temporary water retention in the process of digestion. So a load of pasta and parmesan, high salt, or chips, and you can "magically put on a pound overnight" and lose it again the following day or night, via urination.

MatchaTea · 19/10/2022 05:56

@Aria999 when you make a google search, google will not offer links to content that has an intellectual property, therefor the prestigious medical journals (science, nature, cell, ...) who have a paywall on their medical papers will not come up. However, if you go on the medical library called pubmed pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov you will find them there.

There is also the effect called echo chamber , in which content that relates to your beliefs is offered by search algorithm . This has been clearly demonstrated during the antivax movement, Trump and so on. We are also more likely to dismiss whatever proof that disagrees with us. That's human and this is why trying to convince someone, an antivaxxer, a trumpist, or whatever ideology, religion, diet is pointless and a waste of time.

There is plenty of science that has tested the insulin model, and it was disproven again and again and again. An again.

Of course, if you do a study of junk food vs low carb, low carb is better, but when you test low carb vs low fat, with equal calories and equal protein, there is nothing to be gained by controlling insulin. All the feeding tests in which you control the food given to participants failed.

Kevin Hall locks people up for a living. He puts a group of people in a clinic with no access to outside food, every single morsel is monitored , and he alternates groups between low carb and low fat with equal calories and equal proteins. And before you scream "conflict of interest", I have to tell you, there was a big conflict of interest because the main blow to the insulin theory was done in a study paid by the low carb, and despite that , despite paying millions and having enrolled one of the highly regarded nutrition researcher , despite all that, they failed the insulin model.

A review paid by the low carb www.nature.com/articles/ejcn2016260 this has a paywall, but I have access through work and here is the review:

START

REVIEW
A review of the carbohydrate–insulin model of obesity KD Hall
European Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2017) 71, 323–326
© 2017 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved 0954-3007/17
www.nature.com/ejcn

The carbohydrate–insulin model of obesity theorizes that diets high in carbohydrate are particularly fattening due to their propensity to elevate insulin secretion. Insulin directs the partitioning of energy toward storage as fat in adipose tissue and away from oxidation by metabolically active tissues and purportedly results in a perceived state of cellular internal starvation. In response, hunger and appetite increases and metabolism is suppressed, thereby promoting the positive energy balance associated with the development of obesity. Several logical consequences of this carbohydrate–insulin model of obesity were recently investigated in a pair of carefully controlled inpatient feeding studies whose results failed to support key model predictions. Therefore, important aspects of carbohydrate–insulin model have been experimentally falsified suggesting that the model is too simplistic. This review
describes the current state of the carbohydrate–insulin model and the implications of its recent experimental tests.
European Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2017) 71, 323–326; doi:10.1038/ejcn.2016.260; published online 11 January 2017

INTRODUCTION
Obesity is defined as an excess accumulation of body fat, and understanding obesity at the most basic level requires knowledge of how adipose tissue fat storage and mobilization are regulated. Insulin has a major role in modulating the activity of several enzymes whose net effect is to promote the uptake, retention and net storage of fat in adipose tissue.1 These basic facts of adipose tissue physiology, along with the observation that dietary carbohydrates are the primary driver of insulin secretion, have led to the hypothesis that high carbohydrate diets are particularly fattening.
In particular, the ‘carbohydrate–insulin model’ of obesity posits that diets with a high proportion of carbohydrate elevate insulin secretion and thereby suppress the release of fatty acids from adipose tissue into the circulation and direct circulating fat toward adipose storage and away from oxidation by metabolically active tissues such as heart, muscle and liver.2–5 This altered fuel availability is theorized to lead to a state of cellular ‘internal starvation’ leading to adaptive decreases in energy expenditure and increased hunger.2,5–7 Therefore, the positive energy balance associated with development of obesity is purported to be a consequence of the insulin-driven shift in fat partitioning toward storage in adipocytes, which decreases energy expenditure and increases food intake in an attempt to remediate the cellular internal starvation of metabolically active tissues. Rather than being a passive accumulator of fat as a result of overeating, the carbohydrate–insulin model suggests that endocrine dysregula- tion of adipose tissue is the primary driver of positive energy balance.
The carbohydrate–insulin model provides a plausible explana- tion of why insulin therapy tends to cause weight gain in people with diabetes8 and why outpatient diet trials comparing low carbohydrate diets to others tend to show greater short-term weight loss despite low carbohydrate diets being unrestricted in calories.9–11 Several popular books have promoted the carbohy- drate–insulin model to the public as the reason why they have
gained excess weight in the past and why they should follow a low carbohydrate, high fat diet for weight loss.12–14 However, despite the apparent explanatory power of the carbohydrate– insulin model, its scientific basis is questionable and recent studies have challenged key predictions of the model.

SCIENTIFIC MODELS AND THE PRINCIPLE OF EXPERIMENTAL FALSIFICATION
Scientific models seek to integrate a variety of data and explain a set of observations about a system within an overarching theoretical and mechanistic framework. Experimental confirma- tion of a model’s predictions provides support for the validity of the model and repeated confirmations may eventually lead to widespread acceptance of the model as the scientific standard. However, scientific models cannot be proven to be true. Rather, models represent provisional representations of our understand- ing, and countering evidence may require substantial model corrections or possibly outright rejection of the model. Impor- tantly, scientific models go beyond providing putative explana- tions and make experimentally testable predictions that are capable of falsifying the models.15
As model falsification is relatively rare in the field of nutrition, I will use a well-known example from physics to illustrate the process.16 In the late nineteenth century, physicists postulated that light propagated as a wave through a medium called the ‘luminiferous ether’. Like the carbohydrate–insulin model, the ether model seemed highly plausible as the wave-like nature of light was well-known and all other waves propagated through a medium. It was difficult to conceive how a wave could propagate through a vacuum without a medium and scientists readily accumulated evidence in favor of the ether model. (For example, comet tails were thought to be caused by ‘ether drag’ as they moved through the medium.) The ether model explained a lot and it made sense. Unfortunately, it was also wrong.
As with all scientific models that attempt to explain certain phenomena, the ether model made predictions that were experimentally testable. More specifically, experiments can be designed that are capable of falsifying the model meaning that failure of any necessary model prediction requires that the model be abandoned as either too simple or simply incorrect. It does not matter how many model predictions are successfully confirmed by the experiment, failure of any single prediction means that the model is falsified.

For the ether model of light propagation, falsification came with the classic Michelson–Morley experiment in 1887 that failed to detect a significant difference in the speed of light moving in different directions through the hypothesized ether. Since then, several more definitive experiments were conducted that confirmed these results. The experimental falsifications of the ether model did not imply that light does not have wave-like properties, but the simple ether model of light propagation was untenable.
EXPERIMENTAL FALSIFICATION OF THE CARBOHYDRATE–
INSULIN MODEL

Whereas some models of obesity are so complex that it is difficult to know where to begin when assessing their validity,17 the carbohydrate–insulin model provides clear experimentally testa- ble predictions. For example, the carbohydrate–insulin model predicts that diets with decreased proportion of carbohydrate to fat, but identical protein and calories, will reduce insulin secretion, increase fat mobilization from adipose tissue and elevate fat oxidation. The altered metabolic and hormonal milieu associated with reduced dietary carbohydrate will therefore relieve the state of cellular internal starvation resulting in decreased hunger, increased body fat loss and increased energy expenditure compared with an isocaloric diet with higher carbohydrates and higher insulin secretion.2 If any of these predictions fail, then the carbohydrate–insulin model is falsified and a more commensurate model must be sought.
Testing the model predictions requires inpatient feeding studies as diet adherence cannot be guaranteed in outpatient studies.18 Recently, two metabolic ward studies directly tested the logical consequences of the carbohydrate–insulin model in humans.19,20 Both studies were conducted while subjects were continuously residing in metabolic wards where they consumed carefully controlled diets. Both studies found the expected rapid and sustained decrease in insulin secretion when dietary carbohy- drates were restricted. Therefore, the experimental conditions required to test the predictions of the carbohydrate–insulin model were fully satisfied.
In concordance with the model predictions, carbohydrate restriction led to increased fat oxidation reaching a maximum within a few days and remaining constant thereafter. However, neither study found the predicted augmentation of body fat loss with carbohydrate restriction. Rather, despite the reduction in insulin secretion, both studies found slightly less body fat loss during the carbohydrate restricted diets compared with isocaloric higher carbohydrate diets with identical protein.13,14
In one study, the reduced carbohydrate diet led to a significant decrease in energy expenditure, both during sleep and through- out the day, a result counter to the carbohydrate-insulin model.19 In the other study, a very low carbohydrate ketogenic diet led to increased daily energy expenditure of only 57 kcal/day, and the effect waned over time.20 Although this small energy expenditure increase during the ketogenic diet was in the direction predicted by the carbohydrate–insulin model, it was quantitatively much less than what was expected. Specifically, the effect size of the pre-specified primary energy expenditure outcome was substan- tially smaller than the 150kcal/day threshold determined in advance to be the smallest change that would be considered physiologically important. Furthermore, the observed energy expenditure effect was several-fold lower than the 400–600 kcal day effect previously estimated to be the ‘sizable metabolic advantage’ of a very low carbohydrate diet21 and incompatible with the popular claim of Dr Robert Atkins that such diets increase energy expenditure to an extent that they offer a ‘high calorie way to stay thin forever’.12
CONCORDANCE WITH PREVIOUS INPATIENT FEEDING STUDIES
Despite achieving the desired differences in insulin secretion via isocaloric manipulation of dietary carbohydrate and fat, the recent studies19,20 clearly demonstrated that the energy expenditure and body fat predictions of the carbohydrate–insulin model failed experimental interrogation. These results are in accord with previous inpatient controlled feeding studies that have either found small decreases in energy expenditure with lower carbohydrate diets22–25 or reported no statistically significant differences26–35 when comparing diets with equal calories and protein, but varying carbohydrates from 20 to 75% of total calories. Furthermore, the small effects on body fat loss were similar to those of previous inpatient feeding studies finding no significant differences in body fat resulting from isocaloric variations in carbohydrate and fat.30,36–39
There has never been an inpatient controlled feeding study testing the effects of isocaloric diets with equal protein that has reported significantly increased energy expenditure or greater loss of body fat with lower carbohydrate diets.

THE END

www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-01209-1

Christopher Gardner is another university professor and he made the famous DIETFIT study which followed hundreds of people doing either low fat or low carb ,and at the end, people lost weight on both studies and people gained weight on both studies. Again millions spent on several studies and there is no superiority to the LCHF. Again, that study was paid by a low carb foundation and nope, low carb is not superior.

Taubes' foundation that was going to prove to the world how bad carbs and insulin were , Nutrition Science Initiative , lost credibility and funds, and you can read a bit about the rise and fall here. www.wired.com/story/how-a-dollar40-million-nutrition-science-crusade-fell-apart/. The theory couldn't pass the test.

The science has been there for years. Done, dusted, move on. Once a fact is scientifically established, science moves to other topics

People can lose weight in many ways. You need to find the way that suits you and fits with your life. It is low carb, go for it, but don't preach a superiority or patronise people on something you have watched on YouTube or because of the influencer-du-jour, an osteopath (for some reason, osteopaths love low carb), a journalist, a MNetter, a podcast, and the list goes on and on .

Have a look around pubmed @Aria999 if there is a paper you want to read that has a paywall, send me a PM, and I will see if I have access and send you a PM with the unlocked paper.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 19/10/2022 03:47

TightDiamondShoes · 18/10/2022 08:34

You can always tell those parroting stuff they don’t understand. Eg I’ve magically put in a pound overnight. A “nutritionist” friend will tell me that’s impossible because you need to eat 7000 surplus calories or something… or maybe I did negative exercise/BMR.

The vast majority of that was probably the difference between what you consumed in food/drink and what you haven't yet lost through going to the toilet/water retention. Not an actual increase in your bodyweight.

freckles20 · 19/10/2022 03:38

TightDiamondShoes · 18/10/2022 08:34

You can always tell those parroting stuff they don’t understand. Eg I’ve magically put in a pound overnight. A “nutritionist” friend will tell me that’s impossible because you need to eat 7000 surplus calories or something… or maybe I did negative exercise/BMR.

I can quite easily eat 7000 calories more than o whoops in a day unfortunately.

Aria999 · 19/10/2022 03:21

@Reallyreallyborednow thanks

Can't reciprocate immediately as my sources are in a paper book which I would need to find, but that is interesting.

Reallyreallyborednow · 19/10/2022 02:05

There is a pretty compelling scientific argument and data set behind the low carb idea. I have never seen anyone who doesn't agree with it actually engage with the argument and show why it isn't right

this whole thread no low carb advocate has backed up their theory with evidence. So goes both ways.

www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/low-fat-diet-compared-low-carb-diet

www.cochrane.org/news/featured-review-low-carbohydrate-versus-balanced-carbohydrate-diets-reducing-weight-and

like this study published in Nature Medicine and a Cochrane review?

Most studies show at one year plus there is little difference between low carb and low fat.

note in the nature medicine study fat loss was greater in the low fat group.

Aria999 · 19/10/2022 00:19

The idea is that your body controls its own energy in / out if the mechanisms it uses for doing so are not confused by too much sugar.

By reducing appetite and / or increasing metabolism.

I don't think anyone is denying basic physics.

Aria999 · 19/10/2022 00:15

I don't think it's fair to call it a cult.

There is a pretty compelling scientific argument and data set behind the low carb idea. I have never seen anyone who doesn't agree with it actually engage with the argument and show why it isn't right.

MrsTuxedo · 18/10/2022 20:46

@UglyModernWindows
Once eating low carb my 39 inch waist just melted away ...whilst you were doing Fast800... anyone eating 800 calories would lose inches.

@BIWI
read the science,
Reminds me of the anti-vaxxers screaming " read the science", look it up, google it... and like the anti-vax , the low carb advocates are mostly present in social media

Everyone is entitled to their convictions but don't go on a crusade to promote THE one and only truth.