Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 23/10/2022 23:34

From those quotes you have posted @gordonpym , clearly red meat is the issue, not the absence of carbs.

Plus there's low carb and there's low carb.

For most sensible people, 'low carb' really means 'low GI'. In practice, avoiding starchy white carbohydrate (e.g. pasta, bread) as the main 'filler' in their meal and replacing it with other vegetables. Perfectly healthy, more healthy in most cases as it forces you eat more veg and less junk.

Of course you get your idiots who live on bacon, eggs and cheese, I'm sure they are already well aware that's not good for them in the long term.

gordonpym · 23/10/2022 21:34

Just posted on another thread but I think it is relevant here as well :

Unless one has diabetes , low carb diets can actually increase risk of diabetes.

Conclusions: A score representing a low-carbohydrate diet high in animal protein and fat was positively associated with the risk of T2D in men. Low-carbohydrate diets should obtain protein and fat from foods other than red and processed meat
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21310828/

Conclusion: Our findings suggest that a higher adherence to LCD, mostly with higher intakes of protein and fat from animal-source foods, can increase the incidence of diabetes; however, a plant-based low-carbohydrate dietary pattern is not significantly associated with risk of type 2 diabetes.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33042230/

Conclusions: Diets high in animal protein are associated with an increased diabetes risk. Our findings also suggest a similar association for total protein itself instead of only animal sources. Consumption of energy from protein at the expense of energy from either carbohydrates or fat may similarly increase diabetes risk. This finding indicates that accounting for protein content in dietary recommendations for diabetes prevention may be useful
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19825820/

And worse, if you eat high animal protein you increase your risk of gestational diabetes.

Diets aimed to lose weight that encourage restriction of carbohydrates and elevated consumption of animal protein intensify insulin resistance increasing the risk of developing type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
Accordingly, pre-pregnancy intake of meat (processed and unprocessed) has been strongly associated with a higher risk of gestational diabetes whereas greater pre-pregnancy vegetable protein consumption is associated with a lower risk of gestational diabetes.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2405457719303146

so this something that needs to be said, because gestational diabetes raises not only risk of pre-eclampsia but if left untreated also premature birth and stillbirth .

As @MadelineUsher said, low carb is not a superior way of dieting . It carries health risk which most are not aware of or worse dismiss attacking the science.

AutumnCrow · 23/10/2022 08:49

I have had to be on a personal version of 'low FODMAP and watch the sugars' plan for over a year now (auto immune stuff, very tedious).

Anyway I got into new habits, which I'm hoping will be of long term benefit, like really increasing the protein I eat and always eating some salad or pickles with a carb.

I eat a lot of beetroot ... and tomatoes.

Anyway, it's been about replacing bad habits with good habits for me.

FinallyHere · 23/10/2022 08:40

@lljkk

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/lowcarbbootcamp/4656980-pre-christmas-bootcamp-2022-week-1?reply=1209490522*

The first post always contains a link to the Spreadsheet of Fabulousness which includes the ten key 'Bootcamp Rules'

There is usually a new thread each week started late Sunday / early Monday. The link above it the the current weeks thread, due to change later today or early tomorrow.

The older threads all provide useful background, any posts on the current thread are most likely to be answered.

Hope you enjoy low carbing as much as I do.

FinallyHere · 23/10/2022 08:32

@lljkk

The Low Carb Boot Camp threads are full of low carb knowledge and experience. The founder BIWI haas a programme which does not require counting carbs but does require sticking to ten simple rules.

The first two weeks are particularly strict, to break the connection with sugar and stretch. Thereafter there can be some flexibility depending on my much weight is to be lost

You would be very welcome. I'll try a link but with post this meanwhile.

Tadpoll · 23/10/2022 07:52

Babies here learn to snack before they can talk or walk.

THIS! The obesity crisis is only going to get worse.

Tadpoll · 23/10/2022 07:45

SimonaRazowska · 20/10/2022 13:45

@Dalaidramailama

a diet that is not for you, because you can’t sustain it, is no way “superior” to anything! As it’s not sustainable, and therefore it’s a rubbish diet.

sounds like you are on the right track

if low carb was sustainable and easy, everyone would be slim

i sometimes find the low carb advocates almost cult like in their zeal, leaving normal people like you feel sad (as you say)

half my office low/no carbs, have been, for years and years. They are not slimmer than those who don’t. They just get a bit shaky and dodgy breath from around 2pm

they always cave in at some point and then blame themselves (“the diet is good, I am just weak”)

It doesn’t sound like they’re doing it very well.

What many people don’t realise is that if you eat low-carb (I don’t think anyone would agree that no-carb is good for you) then you absolutely have to increase your protein.

Otherwise you will be shaky and hungry.

I had a friend who went low-carb when I did 8 years ago, except she didn’t increase her protein and ate hardly anything. Needless to say she is now overweight again.

sashh · 23/10/2022 04:25

MavisChunch29 · 23/10/2022 03:11

You are so right @Dalaidramailama The humble potato has had some bad PR from nutrition "experts" recently. I remember 15 years ago or so first hearing about high GI when someone told me I shouldn't have a jacket potato for lunch as it's high GI and won't keep you going/cause a blood sugar dip later. I've always found potatoes satisfying and have never noticed an energy dip or more sweet cravings after eating them. In fact quite the reverse.

But I bet you don't have just a potato. Most people put something on the potato or have something with it like salad, that brings the GI of the meal down.

MavisChunch29 · 23/10/2022 03:15

Plus all the fibre in the skin. Great for me as I don't eat much bread and don't eat cereals at all.

MavisChunch29 · 23/10/2022 03:11

You are so right @Dalaidramailama The humble potato has had some bad PR from nutrition "experts" recently. I remember 15 years ago or so first hearing about high GI when someone told me I shouldn't have a jacket potato for lunch as it's high GI and won't keep you going/cause a blood sugar dip later. I've always found potatoes satisfying and have never noticed an energy dip or more sweet cravings after eating them. In fact quite the reverse.

Buzzinwithbez · 22/10/2022 16:08

There are low carb bootcamp threads past and current running on Mumsnet.
I started by reading some of those those last autumn and just going for it. The first part gives the general idea. There are recipes and ideas throughout.

I would think tofu would be fine, tempeh is lovely.

lljkk · 22/10/2022 13:36

I am thinking low carb is really a cat food diet. The cat sleeps all day so maybe I aspire to have his lifestyle after all.

lljkk · 22/10/2022 13:35

ah come on, this is like Gina Ford She Who Must Not Be Named. Puritanical religion a bit? Anyway, I'm up for being a guinea pig in a 10 day experiment, but only if there are a few other volunteers. The keen folk can extend it to 1 month. I'm having a lazy sofa day right now so being honest with myself, I won't find self-discipline without a group atmosphere of chivvying ourselves along.

BIWI · 22/10/2022 13:29

If you wanted to do a genuine experiment you'd have to do it for longer than 10 days, as it can take a while to become fat-adapted. I'd have thought at least 2 weeks, if not a month.

lljkk · 22/10/2022 11:59

@Buzzinwithbez, I am well up for the LCHF experiment. But I don't want to be billy no mates. Anyone else?
Would I have to roughly count carbs? How low is low enough?

Except I'm not a huge fan of lots of animal flesh. I like tofu. Is that low carb enough? How low carb are we talking?

Buzzinwithbez · 22/10/2022 10:51

We could do an experiment. For anyone considering low carb, it would mean committing to about 10 days lchf -

While eating normally, try noting down how often you feel hungry through the day over 3 days and what times you eat.
-on day 3 try not eating breakfast until hungry and see how long the gap was between last food on an evening.

Then try the same thing after 5-7 days on lchf - it takes me about 3 days to adjust.
No counting calories for either one.

Then after another 3 days, go back to eating as before and note any differences

For the experiment it may be necessary to notice when it's emotional eating vs snacking because of hunger.

Try not to worry about weight loss with each one, it's simply about noticing the differences in how you feel.

Dalaidramailama · 22/10/2022 09:08

@PBSam

I have an obese friend who is addicted to the full sugar stuff and can lose a stone by swapping to Diet Coke so I agree it’s really not making people fat.

Dalaidramailama · 22/10/2022 09:06

@MavisChunch29

No one on this Earth would ever convince me to fall out with the potatoe. My grandmother lived through the Irish famine thanks to potatoes. Her and her sisters lived well into their 90s eating potatoes every day of their lives, even after the famine was over. Their diets were wholesome and home cooked. They did eat cake every day, also bacon with cabbage/potatoes and had a whisky at night.

Worldgonecrazy · 21/10/2022 14:08

Artificial sweeteners increase food cravings in a large percentage of people. Far better to see fizzy drinks as a treat than consume one or two cans a day and think “it’s zero calories therefore it’s okay’.

As food cravings are common in obese people surely avoiding sweeteners should be recommended to that cohort.

Aria999 · 21/10/2022 13:42

I do wish people would stop assuming that overweight people eat too many donuts.

www.nytimes.com/2022/10/18/magazine/anorexia-obesity-eating-disorder.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare

PBSam · 21/10/2022 11:49

Worldgonecrazy · 21/10/2022 08:14

The only people I know who drink sugared fizzy drinks are a healthy weight. The ones who drink lots of sugar free are all obese to morbidly obese. It is known that for a percentage of people, artificial sweeteners increase the number of calories consumed and have a negative effect on blood sugar /insulin levels.

That may very well be the case in your circle but they're not fat because of diet Coke, they're probably chasing down a few doughnuts with it. No one is obese from consuming artifical sweetners which contain little to no calories.

Worldgonecrazy · 21/10/2022 08:14

The only people I know who drink sugared fizzy drinks are a healthy weight. The ones who drink lots of sugar free are all obese to morbidly obese. It is known that for a percentage of people, artificial sweeteners increase the number of calories consumed and have a negative effect on blood sugar /insulin levels.

PBSam · 21/10/2022 07:34

Jacopo · 21/10/2022 02:07

People never used to be so fat. Things that have changed in the last fifty years during which I’ve been an adult:
portion sizes are three times as big
people snack constantly instead of having 3 meals a day plus elevenses which would be one or two biscuits and a cup of tea
fizzy drinks everywhere, sugary or sugar-free are equally bad
Buying massive cups of milky coffee with added syrup flavours
people thinking a whole pizza per person is normal
Buying frequent takeaways

Sugar free fizzy drinks contain like 4 calories they're not causing obesity. If every morbidly obese person who drinks full fat pop swapped to the diet versions they may well start to lose some weight from that alone.

Cormoran · 21/10/2022 04:07

I think it is an Anglo-Saxon issue (UK, Australia, USA) , other cultures have no problem with carbs and don't give a shit about them. Insulin is something diabetics inject themselves with, and of no concern for non-diabetic for most of the world .

This post on French women is quite accurate leoncechenal.com/what-french-women-eat-in-a-day/ , the difference is that I eat a chocolate eclair from a French patisserie, instead of the Godzilla-sized industrial croissant sold in Australia. My lovely DH drives 25 minutes every Sunday to buy me one.

The more people talk , or better said, obsess about carbs, the fatter they are.
Babies here learn to snack before they can talk or walk. Weaning babies on baby crisps, melty puffs, flavoured rice cakes. Pure junk food for babies. And I believe it is the same in UK.

MrsMorrisey · 21/10/2022 02:41

It's not entirely what people eat, most people just eat too much and are not aware that they are eating.

Constantly snacking is not necessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread