Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:41

@MrsTuxedo I don't think I've mentioned steak or rice. Although your point depends on the size of either.

My point is when insulin is raised you will mostly be burning sugar and if you want to lose weight you need to burn fat. To burn fat insulin needs to be lowered.

OP posts:
Mercurial123 · 15/10/2022 10:39

It annoys me, because so many people on here say low carb is the only way to go and all carbs are bad without bothering to differentiate between simple and complex.

I eat a well balanced diet and exercise a lot. I love complex carbs along with the occasional cake. At 51 and 175 cm weighing 65 kg I'm happy with that.

Great low carbs works, hopefully long term but I will never do it.

plasticdragon · 15/10/2022 10:39

YANBU but your posts do ring with the zeal of a recent convert.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 10:38

Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:35

@Adultchildofelderlyparents the easiest thing to do first is cut out snacks and refined sugar. Eating frequently means you will be regularly spiking insulin. The more hours in a day your insulin is elevated the harder it is to lose weight.

How big are your spikes? And do you check around exercise too?

Galaktoboureko · 15/10/2022 10:38

Similarly, booze is high in calories but doesn't fill you up.

Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:38

I use the word presumably in this context because someone is on a weight loss diet, I don't know that particular poster so they may not have lots of fat to burn.

Yes it's based on science. The role of insulin is well understood.

OP posts:
ThatGirlInACountrySong · 15/10/2022 10:37

I inject liraglutide daily

Lost stone so far. That's how I decrease my blood sugar 🤷‍♀️

Monsterpage · 15/10/2022 10:37

Galaktoboureko · 15/10/2022 10:21

I believe this theory has been disproven by science over and over again. To prove his point, a nutrition professor went on a junk food Twinkie diet He ate every three hours sugar loaded snacks but limited his daily calorie. Quite interesting to read.He lost 27 pounds.

It's also been done with donuts.

I can eat 2500 cals and not get fat if I'm training hard. Pro strongmen eat between 10,000 - 20,000 calories a day for comparison, although admittedly are mostly on the juice.

I have a theory (not scientific in any way) I think age and previous eating and dieting history plays a part. As a teen and early twenties I thought I was fat (size 12) and would go on calorie controlled diets on and off to bring it down and take me to a nice size 10.

When I was 26 I went on the depo provera hormone injection and I put on 3 stone in about 8 months. I was prob eating more I can’t remember but after the injection wore off I went on a SW diet - green days eat all the carbs you want. I had never really eaten much pasta before that but I loaded my days heavily with pasta (as it was free on a green day) and dropped the weight in about 6 months. I was delighted.

However my theory is that that sort of diet where you are over stressing the body with carbs damages it. I developed PCOS and later gestational diabetes and then diabetes type 2 - and as I have got older the ability to lose weight has become harder.

it is not simply calories in - I had COVID and barely ate for a week last Christmas - surviving on water and I stayed the same week when with the calories in theory I should prob lost 2 pounds. For the following 3 weeks my food intake was very very limited and I should have lost more weight - I didn’t.

it is so complex and mad diets can totally muck up your body. I wish I knew then what I know now about my body.

Galaktoboureko · 15/10/2022 10:37

AntlerRose · 15/10/2022 10:33

But why do i feel starving if i only eat donuts even though its the same calories?

Because they're calorie dense and it's food not calories that fills you up. An enormous bowl of porridge has at most as many calories as a regular Mars bar but is waaay more filling.

Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:35

@Adultchildofelderlyparents the easiest thing to do first is cut out snacks and refined sugar. Eating frequently means you will be regularly spiking insulin. The more hours in a day your insulin is elevated the harder it is to lose weight.

OP posts:
Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 10:35

Presumably there is plenty of fat to burn because you're overweight so your cells don't need to send out signals to eat more because they have a plentiful supply of energy. That's why you don't feel hungry as much or get cravings

presumably?

so is this your own theories based on presumption and assumption, or is any of it based in science at all.

MrsTuxedo · 15/10/2022 10:34

@Redterror a steak will raise your insulin level more than a bowl of brown rice, so you want to rethink your science !

Soakitup37 · 15/10/2022 10:34

I’ve struggled with weight loss from hormone issues and hypothyroidism since my teens, the only way I ever lose weight is with fasting and keto+ resistance weight/exercise- It’s definitely a life style choice but one I have come to see works for me so I revert back to it when nothing else works.

I had gestational diabetes in my recent pregnancy and I really learnt more about how insulin works and what I need to do to keep weight off. I can’t do my usual fast or keto atm as I’m breast feeding and a diet of any kind makes your milk dry up immediately. My weight is ok atm but I’m keen to get back to losing more once I can.

my friends and family notice just how had I work to keep my weight in check, they will never think of the next thing they eat but I have to actively think about it every meal. It’s so draining when you have to work for a 1lb weight loss in a month when someone else would lose 4lbs in a week - but if you know that’s what needs to be done and commit to it it can be done.

all that said, when your life revolves so hard around losing weight and the struggle it’s understandable why individuals throw in the towel and say f-it, I’m just gonna eat what I want because the alternative isn’t working ; or working to minuscule effect.

AntlerRose · 15/10/2022 10:33

Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:31

@AntlerRose so if you are overweight and choosing to eat low carb your body will be burning fat because your insulin levels are lower. Presumably there is plenty of fat to burn because you're overweight so your cells don't need to send out signals to eat more because they have a plentiful supply of energy. That's why you don't feel hungry as much or get cravings.

But why do i feel starving if i only eat donuts even though its the same calories?

Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:33

@Fairislefandango low fat diets reduce insulin levels too. You will have restricted foods containing a lot of sugar by avoiding things like sweets and chocolates. You probably snacked less too. Both of these will reduce insulin levels.

OP posts:
Adultchildofelderlyparents · 15/10/2022 10:33

So can I ask, as I'm a bit clueless about this, how do I lower my insulin or at least not elevate it?
Asking as I have three stone to lose, and a month into an exercise plan I have lost nothing, which has totally demoralised me.
Any suggestion of what food I should definitely include or cut out?

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 15/10/2022 10:33

When you say 'low carb' which carbs are you restricting?

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 10:31

Fairislefandango · 15/10/2022 10:29

So if reducing your insulin is the only way to lose weight, why did I lose more weight on low-fat than I did on low-carb?

😁

Redterror · 15/10/2022 10:31

@AntlerRose so if you are overweight and choosing to eat low carb your body will be burning fat because your insulin levels are lower. Presumably there is plenty of fat to burn because you're overweight so your cells don't need to send out signals to eat more because they have a plentiful supply of energy. That's why you don't feel hungry as much or get cravings.

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 15/10/2022 10:29

So if reducing your insulin is the only way to lose weight, why did I lose more weight on low-fat than I did on low-carb?

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 10:28

People need to remember that medical conditions make things different.

Normally healthy person shouldn't need to worry about carb or insulin (which I would like to know how many people who don't have diabetes are actually testing their glocose levels...). Someone pre or diabetic may need to.

This is imho basically the glutenfree thing all over. It helps someone with specific medical conditions, someone jumps on it and sells it and et voila. Diet and expensive products.

Fairislefandango · 15/10/2022 10:27

Kind of YANBU. It isn't the only way to lose weight, but it's probably the most sustainable and healthiest (if you don't reduce the carbs by eating processed low-carb stuff).

The thing is though, most people fail to lose weight not because they aren't knowledgeable about insulin or because they've chosen the 'wrong' method. They fail because all diet changes require a level of willpower that's unachievable for most people long-term.

I lost loads of weight eating very low fat (and considerably higher sugar than normal, as I felt so deprived of other nice food) for 8 months through no choice of my own while awaiting gallbladder surgery. Slightly more weight than I lost during a similar length period of low carbing in fact, and felt no less healthy. It probably wouldn't have been good for me long-term though.

AntlerRose · 15/10/2022 10:24

I wish i understood the science.
I eat lowish carb, lost weight and maintained it so far. I did this as i was pre diabetic and the pre diabetes went
It may well be a simple calorie deficit mechanism, but what i found is a low carb calorie deficit is the only one where i dont feel starving, get cravings, and get slumps and crashes or highs. So for me there is something else going on too. Like 1 calorie of protien or fat feels more filling and slower burning than 1 calorie of carb?

Galaktoboureko · 15/10/2022 10:21

I believe this theory has been disproven by science over and over again. To prove his point, a nutrition professor went on a junk food Twinkie diet He ate every three hours sugar loaded snacks but limited his daily calorie. Quite interesting to read.He lost 27 pounds.

It's also been done with donuts.

I can eat 2500 cals and not get fat if I'm training hard. Pro strongmen eat between 10,000 - 20,000 calories a day for comparison, although admittedly are mostly on the juice.

MrsTuxedo · 15/10/2022 10:21

PortiaWithNoBreaks · 15/10/2022 10:15

Ppl eating low carb end up creating a calorie deficit. You could just eat doughnuts and as long as you’re consuming fewer calories than you’re using, weight will be lost.

Losing weight is really simple. Low carb, high carb, one meal a day, fasting, eating windows, whatever. All end up creating calorie deficits if weight is lost.

That's it. plain and simple.