Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
Sago1 · 15/10/2022 12:05

Baaaaaa Proper sourdough only contains flour water and salt, no commercial yeast.
its a fermented food, I have some on the go now that I started yesterday it is a 24-36 hour process.
It’s a fermentation process so the carbs in the flour are broken down, this makes it low GI and easier to digest and break down in the gut.
No bread is ideal but as a weekend treat it’s worth making.
We don’t bloat either after SD bread.

notputtingtheheatingon · 15/10/2022 12:03

YANBU, however, weight loss and diets are about so much more than what we eat. I've tried every diet out there. I lose a stone or two and then put it back on because the battle is mental/emotional rather than what I actually eat. Low carb does work but when I've had a stressful day, my brain shouts 'Dominoes and wine' not 'low carb omelette and sparkling water'. I often listen to my brain.

I understand the principles on insulin resistance and low carb eating. It's just that weight loss for some is incredibly more complex than that.

Redterror · 15/10/2022 12:03

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 11:58

I am just wondering about the black-n-white nature of that claim. Is there ... literally no example ever where people lost weight on a diet but had no change in their insulin levels? This seems like an example where there was lots of weight loss by people who maintained higher blood glucose & insulin levels

has anyone ever measured insulin levels in response to diet?

I’ve had a quick look but all the insulin theories seem to depend on measuring blood glucose, and inferring insulin from that.

It's hard to measure insulin. Probably why we focus on sugar. But we know that people don't go from being non-diabetic to type 2 diabetes overnight. It's a process where over time the pancreas has to secrete more and more insulin. Probably lots of people are pre-diabetic without knowing it. Their blood sugar is controlled but compared to someone without diabetes their insulin is elevated.

OP posts:
Leakingroofagain · 15/10/2022 12:01

I'm all for low GI but low carb is soul destroying and expensive.

LindaEllen · 15/10/2022 12:01

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:35

Both slimming world and weight watchers stop you from eating lots of cake, chocolate, pizza, crisps, bread, sweets, etc. These all elevate insulin.

Pretty much any diet (or any worth following) would stop you eating that crap, though. The best diets are the ones that include non-processed foods such as fruit, veg, meat, milk, rice etc and then lightly processed like pasta, cheese etc. Food with artificial ingredients is not what our bodies evolved to deal with.

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 12:01

Redterror · 15/10/2022 11:59

I thought this was about your level to be honest.

Miaow! I suppose a playground insult is to be expected from someone who uses BBC Bitesize to back up their argument. I'm a nurse, actually. What's your medical qualification?

MarshaBradyo · 15/10/2022 11:59

Yeh I’m not getting the sneering from just pp before you

Why get so bent out of shape by it. Odd

Baaaaaa · 15/10/2022 11:59

Sago1 · 15/10/2022 09:46

I put on weight in my early 40’s after a year of illness, I did slimming world and it dropped off!
I was back down to a comfortable 12 in 3 months.

Now in my 50’s I tried it again to drop a dress size………nothing!

I have now been low carb for some time and it works ,it’s also easy and very healthy, we eat loads of vegetables and the only bread we ever have is homemade sourdough.

I cannot go no carb, I think the “Atkin’s” type diets are dangerous but low carb with a Mediterranean slant is very doable.

Could i ask about sourdough? I've heard this before but how can it be low carb, when it's made of flour?

Redterror · 15/10/2022 11:59

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 11:51

Ah, now you get it, because you've just looked it up on a kids' website. 😂But your previous comment that your cells remove sugar from the blood was plain wrong. Insulin removes the glucose and converts it into energy for your cells. The cells aren't stripping it out themselves, which is what you were saying.

If you're going to be so preachy about something that is medically related, get your facts right!

I thought this was about your level to be honest.

OP posts:
Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 11:58

I am just wondering about the black-n-white nature of that claim. Is there ... literally no example ever where people lost weight on a diet but had no change in their insulin levels? This seems like an example where there was lots of weight loss by people who maintained higher blood glucose & insulin levels

has anyone ever measured insulin levels in response to diet?

I’ve had a quick look but all the insulin theories seem to depend on measuring blood glucose, and inferring insulin from that.

Smilelesstalkmore · 15/10/2022 11:57

I love the way any talk of 'carbs' ends up in a carby bun fight! Why are people so weird about it?! I guess we are all desperate to kind 'the magic key' to maintaining a healthy weight.

MrsTuxedo · 15/10/2022 11:55

Low carb warriors have no interest in science. There is no point in arguing and presenting facts. If it is on Youtube , it must true for them.
That was fun for a while.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 11:55

When bbc bitesize enters discussion it's the end😂

Smilelesstalkmore · 15/10/2022 11:54

Whynobreadpudding · 15/10/2022 10:53

Eating white bread that’s been frozen and then toasted reduces the carbs by about 30 %, and eating leftover pasta the next day at least 24 hours, reduces carbs, it changes the composition, but still tastes great.

What a load of bollocks! 😂

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 11:51

Redterror · 15/10/2022 11:49

What do you think happens to it? Insulin is a hormone that facilitates the entry of sugar into body cells.

www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zt49gdm/revision/2

Ah, now you get it, because you've just looked it up on a kids' website. 😂But your previous comment that your cells remove sugar from the blood was plain wrong. Insulin removes the glucose and converts it into energy for your cells. The cells aren't stripping it out themselves, which is what you were saying.

If you're going to be so preachy about something that is medically related, get your facts right!

Beancounter1 · 15/10/2022 11:51

Confrontayshunme · 15/10/2022 11:38

I agree with this. I have been on a high carb low fat diet for a couple of years and I am never hungry and have easily kept off my initial weight loss with no issues and lots of energies. I only eat whole un processed starches so no issues either with my blood sugar.

Just to re-emphasise what a couple of posters have already said:
'Carbs' are not just one thing, not all carbs are equal.
Carbs are either 'sugars' or 'starches'. The body eventually breaks down starches into sugars, but it takes time to digest so doesn't cause the insulin spike.

Cut out 'sugars', including fructose in fruit juice. (i.e. don't drink fruit juice - either eat whole fruit or take a vit-c tablet). Also read labels - sugar is sneaked into all sorts of processed things like ready-made lasagne or tomato soup.

Don't cut out complex carbs, otherwise known as starches. These include brown rice, brown pasta, potatoes, wholegrain bread, etc. I say brown as you get more roughage and again it takes longer to digest.

Protein and fat sit in the stomach for longer so make you feel fuller, so you eat less overall.

Redterror · 15/10/2022 11:49

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 11:44

Your cells don't remove glucose from your blood, insulin does, which is a hormone produced by the pancreas. Please stop posting OP, you're getting it so wrong.

What do you think happens to it? Insulin is a hormone that facilitates the entry of sugar into body cells.

www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zt49gdm/revision/2

OP posts:
lljkk · 15/10/2022 11:46

"all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it."

I am just wondering about the black-n-white nature of that claim. Is there ... literally no example ever where people lost weight on a diet but had no change in their insulin levels? This seems like an example where there was lots of weight loss by people who maintained higher blood glucose & insulin levels.

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 11:44

Redterror · 15/10/2022 11:33

What do you think happens to the food you eat?

Your cells don't remove glucose from your blood, insulin does, which is a hormone produced by the pancreas. Please stop posting OP, you're getting it so wrong.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 15/10/2022 11:42

Wasnt this in the news a couple of days ago, i'm sure I read about the success of an NHS app aimed at diabetics in also reducing weight

Is that something similar?

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 11:41

HumourReplacementTherapy · 15/10/2022 11:29

It's not your insulin you're trying to lower!
It's your blood glucose. You can't 'lower your insulin' as you have stated in your op.
Insulin is used to lower BG.
Insulin is a hormone.
You are spreading a lot of misinformation

This is what I was coming on to say! It's your blood glucose that spikes and your pancreas produces insulin to convert it into energy. OP doesn't understand the basics.

NoDairyNoProblem · 15/10/2022 11:40

Simonjt · 15/10/2022 11:30

As a type 1 diabetic I can confirm that this is not true.

This kind of misinformation is both frightening and dangerous in equal measure.

Confrontayshunme · 15/10/2022 11:38

NumptiesIncorporated · 15/10/2022 10:08

I was told by my doctor, who used to specialist in diabetes, that fat is a bigger issue than carbs when it comes to insulin resistance.

Too much fat in the system blocks the insulin from working properly. Carbs are only an issue because of the amount of fat stopping the insulin from doing it's job.

It's hard to know what to believe when there are so many people saying different things

I agree with this. I have been on a high carb low fat diet for a couple of years and I am never hungry and have easily kept off my initial weight loss with no issues and lots of energies. I only eat whole un processed starches so no issues either with my blood sugar.

MrsTuxedo · 15/10/2022 11:36

Are you really asking me to explain microcellular biology?

LCopp89 · 15/10/2022 11:34

I did Slimming World and found it really good for steady weight loss that I kept off for years. Whilst I was doing it and after I stopped going to the groups, I also trained for half marathons, triathlons and all sorts, as I had so much energy which I didn't get from any other diets.

It didn't feel very restricted and I was (and still am) eating loads of carbs - big plates of pasta, rice, couscous, fruit etc. I did consciously make the choice of not touching bread and ate things like Weetabix/Ryvita instead, as you get one 'fiber' choice.

I think it works as although you are eating carbs, you really have to make most meals from scratch to stand a chance of keeping within your syns for the day - which means no added or artificial sugars or fats.

I think convenience food is the biggest contributor to how unhealthy society is right now, rather than simply blaming carbs or fats. The best diets incorporate all types of food, in moderation - and homemade/fresh is always best.

And for me, SW is one of the easiest diets to keep up forever - even if you're only following 80/90% of the time, you will keep the weight off.