Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 15/10/2022 13:11

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:07

Weight Watchers and Slimming World DON’T WORK.

If they did you wouldn’t have people returning time after time when they’ve put the weight back on.

You’re 100% right, OP.

They do work, you've just got to keep on the eating plan, obviously if you go back to your old habits you will gain again.

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 13:10

*Weight Watchers and Slimming World DON’T WORK.

If they did you wouldn’t have people returning time after time when they’ve put the weight back on*

they do. Where people put the weight back on is when they go back to old habits.

same with low carb. If you go back to your old eating patterns you’ll put the weight back on.

same with any “diet”.

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 15/10/2022 13:10

Where is the know it all op anyway??

HumourReplacementTherapy · 15/10/2022 13:08

People aren't weird about it @florengreen
But when the title to the thread is preaching that 'people don't know enough about insulin' and the OP talks about 'lowering insulin levels' then yes, it's annoying as she's the one who doesn't understand it.

Tadpoll · 15/10/2022 13:07

Weight Watchers and Slimming World DON’T WORK.

If they did you wouldn’t have people returning time after time when they’ve put the weight back on.

You’re 100% right, OP.

greenacrylicpaint · 15/10/2022 12:56

posts like the op bring out the evangelical low/no carb people.

that kind of diet is neither healthy, nor sustainable on a personal level, nor sustainable for the planet.

reduce refined carbs. reduce refined fats. if you do that you should be able to sustain yourself very healthily.

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 12:56

ReeseWitherfork · 15/10/2022 12:30

Neither 🙂

Just offering nuance to a conversation that started so black and white (which things rarely are).

That article is so fascinating, thanks for sharing! Really shocking that Fung tried to get that medical academic sacked for disputing his 'science'.

jennakong · 15/10/2022 12:56

Yes - reasonably low carb worked for me in terms of overall weight loss (4 stones in 1 year) and I think trashy carbs and refined sugar can certainly be discarded to great benefit (I still like fruit, legumes and nuts though, and I love porridge). But I am still struggling with weight around my middle! I am 50 and I do think it's got something to do with insulin AND sex hormones. Testosterone hasn't helped either. Any suggestions OP?

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 12:44

florengreen · 15/10/2022 12:27

I love the way any talk of 'carbs' ends up in a carby bun fight! Why are people so weird about it?! I guess we are all desperate to kind 'the magic key' to maintaining a healthy weight.

I can't speak for everyone but for me it was guilt, shame and fear. I would have defended my refined carb, processed food diet to the hilt. An entire lifestyle and mindset change felt impossible.

I think when the original post is almost evangelical in espousing low carb it gets backs up, because for a lot of people weight loss isn't just about what they eat, psychological barriers play a role too. Preachy OPs like this one push buttons. Plus the calorie deficit caused by cutting down/out carbs is of course a factor in weight loss, but LC fans will argue otherwise until they're blue in the face.

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 15/10/2022 12:44

Probably because for the majority of certainly very overweight people, doing that would cause your energy levels to crash, which would likely result in binge eating sugar.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 12:40

I do wonder how many people in countries like Vietnam and Singapore and tens of others are tracking their blood glucose... You know with them having so low obesity rates, they obviously cracked it

ReeseWitherfork · 15/10/2022 12:30

Redterror · 15/10/2022 11:30

Are you debating diets? Or the role of insulin?

Neither 🙂

Just offering nuance to a conversation that started so black and white (which things rarely are).

cosmiccosmos · 15/10/2022 12:29

I agree OP. Just to add that I thought SW also works by using food combining ie you don't eat carbs and protein with the same meal, similar to food combining like the Harcombe diet.

florengreen · 15/10/2022 12:27

I love the way any talk of 'carbs' ends up in a carby bun fight! Why are people so weird about it?! I guess we are all desperate to kind 'the magic key' to maintaining a healthy weight.

I can't speak for everyone but for me it was guilt, shame and fear. I would have defended my refined carb, processed food diet to the hilt. An entire lifestyle and mindset change felt impossible.

MumUndone · 15/10/2022 12:25

I agree, sugar is the enemy.

sashh · 15/10/2022 12:21

ThisIsTrifficult · 15/10/2022 09:42

But different people respond to different carbs with different blood sugar spikes/crashes.
Low carb is not a long term strategy for most as it is a dull diet with little texture (nothing crunches and don't try and tell me celery does!). Low carb can hinder sleep also.

If it works for you, great, do it. But overall calorie is the boss. Eat less that you need. People want to complicate it or answer your prayers with this 'one simple trick' and it's lies

Your gut microbiome plays a HUGE part in the blood sugar response one has to a particular carb. As soon as people can map their gut microbes they may have an indication as to what foods (carbs) affect their blood sugar a lot and those that don't.

Low carb doesn't mean no carb.

I was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes in May. I've been low carb and protein for breakfast since then and my A1C went from 69 to 59 in a month, I'm waiting for a result from the one I had last week.

My fasting glucose is down from 14 to <8 most days with occasional drops to 6 or 6.5.

I have lost 10 kg.

As for no crunch, well I like pork scratchings and crispy parmesan crisps so I get my crunch from there and also from the carbs I do eat eg I can have 3 frozen croquette potatoes.

I do agree though that our bodies are all different.

I used a free trial of a libre 2 glucose monitor and tracked the levels, I found out that bananas spike my blood sugar.

If anyone is trying to lose weight the Libra 2 costs £50 for 2 weeks(no I don't work for them) and is an easy way to track your blood sugar / response to food and exercise.

Exercise lowers blood glucose.

LemonSwan · 15/10/2022 12:21

I actually exponentially put on weight from SW/WW type diet. It was perplexing as have never been so simultaneously fat and starving. It was impressive! Was going up a dress size every 4-6 weeks.

Through no fault of my own I may add. Was staying with the MIL for a year and ate the tiny terrible meals out of politeness. Dropped straight off when we moved out.

lobsterkiller · 15/10/2022 12:15

I agree re carbs. Never had a problem until I got into my mid 40s. I wasn't eating much, calorie wise but I was eating too many carbs.

Cutting bread, rice, potatoes and pasta meant I lost my hunger. It's not boring. even as a veggie. The weight dropped off me and I've maintained.

I do find it harder in the colder months and my carbs go up but I recognise the cravings for what they are now.

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/10/2022 12:14

The purpose of insulin is to convert blood sugar to fat (energy for future use)

that is not the only, or even the main purpose of insulin.

the rest of your post isn’t accurate either.

Jaxhog · 15/10/2022 12:10

I agree Op. Insulin makes you fat. The purpose of insulin is to convert blood sugar to fat (energy for future use). When your blood sugar rises, it triggers insulin to be produced (unless you have T1 Diabetes). Insulin resistance e.g. T2 Diabetes means your body converts less blood sugar to energy, so you are more tired and hungrier, and more blood glucose remains unused, which insulin then converts to fat. (Unfortunately, it is harder to convert fat back into energy.) The only way around this is to have less blood sugar. The only way to have less blood sugar is to eat fewer carbs, especially refined carbs. which create blood sugar faster.

The only reason SW and WW work is that they reduce the number of refined carbs you eat along with reducing overall calories.

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 12:10

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 12:08

Also people with diabetes do not have elevated insulin.

Are you taking a piss or am I massively misreading ehat you are saying?

I think she's muddling Type 1 with Type 2.

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 12:08

Argh, mean causal, not casual! Damn auto correct.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 12:08

Also people with diabetes do not have elevated insulin.

Are you taking a piss or am I massively misreading ehat you are saying?

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 12:07

notputtingtheheatingon · 15/10/2022 12:03

YANBU, however, weight loss and diets are about so much more than what we eat. I've tried every diet out there. I lose a stone or two and then put it back on because the battle is mental/emotional rather than what I actually eat. Low carb does work but when I've had a stressful day, my brain shouts 'Dominoes and wine' not 'low carb omelette and sparkling water'. I often listen to my brain.

I understand the principles on insulin resistance and low carb eating. It's just that weight loss for some is incredibly more complex than that.

Exactly. There may be other hormonal imbalances too that have a casual effect, such as hypothyroidism, excess cortisol.

InCheesusWeTrust · 15/10/2022 12:06

Redterror · 15/10/2022 12:03

It's hard to measure insulin. Probably why we focus on sugar. But we know that people don't go from being non-diabetic to type 2 diabetes overnight. It's a process where over time the pancreas has to secrete more and more insulin. Probably lots of people are pre-diabetic without knowing it. Their blood sugar is controlled but compared to someone without diabetes their insulin is elevated.

Erm what.

Are you coming in with "eating sweets will give you diabetes"?