Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think too few people understand the role of insulin with regards to weight loss?

366 replies

Redterror · 15/10/2022 09:24

So I am an advocate of low carb but I know plenty of people who have used slimming world, or weight watchers or any other diet to lose weight. I have seen though people being really negative regards low carb diets and I don't get it.

When you understand how your body deals with different nutrients it because clear that all diets need to lower insulin. How you do this is up to you but ultimately all weight loss diets do it.

When insulin is elevated then you can't burn much fat and instead rely on mostly burning sugar from your diet. If you want to burn mostly fat from your fat cells your insulin needs to be lowered.

People say eat less move more without understanding that for someone who is insulin resistant this is really hard. The body cells stop responding to insulin so stop taking up sugar from the blood. This effectively means the cells feel like they are 'starving' as they can't get enough sugar and this drives hunger signals. It also makes the person feel lethargic and lacking in energy, so exercise is harder.

You can reduce insulin levels by fasting, reducing carbs in the diet, reducing consumption of refined carbohydrates, cutting calories etc but the key is your insulin.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aria999 · 12/11/2022 13:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Reallyreallyborednow · 25/10/2022 19:11

You can't manage type 1 through diet and exercise. You know that, right?

to start, she doesn’t say she’s type 1.

second, while you can’t manage type 1 though diet and exercise, you can manage your weight through diet and exercise, even if you’re T1. And you can make a difference to how well you control your T1 with diet.

PBSam · 25/10/2022 17:33

Givenuptotally · 25/10/2022 16:43

You unfortunately have a genetic predisposition to having diabetes but that doesn't mean you can't manage it better through diet and exercise

You can't manage type 1 through diet and exercise. You know that, right?

Where does it say she's type one?

BIWI · 25/10/2022 16:59

I have loads of cookery books! But most of what I cook is now from low carb recipe books (or my own head Smile.

Because I am a low carber, I'm pretty used to adapting recipes so they suit my way of eating.

If you want more (low carb) inspiration, go and check out the Low Carb Bootcamp topic here - there are several recipe threads there, organised by food type. (i.e. meat/chicken/veg etc)

FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco · 25/10/2022 16:57

Also your meal options sound delicious @BIWI! Very helpful recipe inspiration, thank you 😊 are there any particular recipe books, sites or places you go to for new recipe/meal ideas?

FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco · 25/10/2022 16:45

BIWI · 25/10/2022 16:42

But what are you trying to achieve there @FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco? What you're eating isn't especially low carb, which is where the insulin 'control' will come from.

A typical day for me would be something like this:

Breakfast - sometimes nothing, if I'm not hungry. If I am, then some full fat Greek yoghurt (10% fat). Occasionally scrambled eggs.

Lunch - usually leftovers from the previous day's supper, or a cheese omelette, or a sandwich made with very low carb bread.

Dinner - here are some of my favourites:

  • salmon fillet marinated in sesame or olive oil, with lemon juice and garlic
  • Spanish chicken, made with chicken thighs, chorizo, black olives, onion, garlic, chilli and tinned tomatoes
  • chilli (no beans), with extra mushrooms, with grated cheese and yoghurt on top
  • cauliflower cheese (sauce made with cream and cheese - not a roux/flour-based sauce)
  • aubergine and courgettes, layered with a tomato and garlic sauce, with fresh basil, mozzarella and Parmesan
  • high meat content/low carb sausages, baked with peppers, cauliflower, shallots, courgette (and sometimes halloumi)
  • meatballs (home-made, no breadcrumbs or any other filler), with a chilli and garlic tomato sauce

I use konjac/shirataki noodles if I'm having a stir-fry, or cauliflower rice.

Other vegetable sides:

  • leeks, pan-fried with a sliced red pepper
  • fennel, par-boiled, then slowly caramelised in a frying pan with lots of butter, and a squeeze of lemon juice at the end
  • roasted cauliflower, lots of olive oil, and ground cumin
  • roasted tenderstem broccoli and shallots, lots of olive oil and well-seasoned with Maldon sea salt
  • griddled Hispi/sweetheart cabbage
  • braised white cabbage, with onion and lemon
  • braised red cabbage, with onion and apple cider vinegar
  • butterhead lettuce salad, with a red or white wine vinegar vinaigrette
  • celeriac and leek mash (a great topping for fish pie or shepherd's pie)
  • swede or celeriac 'chips'

is that enough to go on?!

I’m not aiming to eat low carb@BIWI, but am just trying to make sure I have a varied and healthy diet, and was looking for some inspiration, so thought I’d ask here.

FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco · 25/10/2022 16:43

Well done for your weight loss and lowering your blood pressure @Worldgonecrazy, that’s amazing!! Most of my relatives (parents, aunts, uncles) all have high blood pressure, and I’m really worried about getting it. It’s so positive to hear you can actually reverse it (or maybe avoid it) through eating well and exercising.

Givenuptotally · 25/10/2022 16:43

You unfortunately have a genetic predisposition to having diabetes but that doesn't mean you can't manage it better through diet and exercise

You can't manage type 1 through diet and exercise. You know that, right?

BIWI · 25/10/2022 16:42

But what are you trying to achieve there @FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco? What you're eating isn't especially low carb, which is where the insulin 'control' will come from.

A typical day for me would be something like this:

Breakfast - sometimes nothing, if I'm not hungry. If I am, then some full fat Greek yoghurt (10% fat). Occasionally scrambled eggs.

Lunch - usually leftovers from the previous day's supper, or a cheese omelette, or a sandwich made with very low carb bread.

Dinner - here are some of my favourites:

  • salmon fillet marinated in sesame or olive oil, with lemon juice and garlic
  • Spanish chicken, made with chicken thighs, chorizo, black olives, onion, garlic, chilli and tinned tomatoes
  • chilli (no beans), with extra mushrooms, with grated cheese and yoghurt on top
  • cauliflower cheese (sauce made with cream and cheese - not a roux/flour-based sauce)
  • aubergine and courgettes, layered with a tomato and garlic sauce, with fresh basil, mozzarella and Parmesan
  • high meat content/low carb sausages, baked with peppers, cauliflower, shallots, courgette (and sometimes halloumi)
  • meatballs (home-made, no breadcrumbs or any other filler), with a chilli and garlic tomato sauce

I use konjac/shirataki noodles if I'm having a stir-fry, or cauliflower rice.

Other vegetable sides:

  • leeks, pan-fried with a sliced red pepper
  • fennel, par-boiled, then slowly caramelised in a frying pan with lots of butter, and a squeeze of lemon juice at the end
  • roasted cauliflower, lots of olive oil, and ground cumin
  • roasted tenderstem broccoli and shallots, lots of olive oil and well-seasoned with Maldon sea salt
  • griddled Hispi/sweetheart cabbage
  • braised white cabbage, with onion and lemon
  • braised red cabbage, with onion and apple cider vinegar
  • butterhead lettuce salad, with a red or white wine vinegar vinaigrette
  • celeriac and leek mash (a great topping for fish pie or shepherd's pie)
  • swede or celeriac 'chips'

is that enough to go on?!

Worldgonecrazy · 25/10/2022 16:40

Me - Hot water with lemon juice and lemon zest.
OH - full fat Greek yoghurt with berries and nuts

Lunch - one thick slice of granary sourdough, avocado, feta
OH - scrambled eggs made with butter and full fat milk, feta, half an avocado, tomatoes

Mid afternoon snack
Me - thin slice of sourdough with peanut butter
OH - half an apple with peanut butter

Dinner - vegetable curry with paneer or lentils, served with crème fraiche

I am low glycaemic, OH is low carb

At weekend’s I will have a pastry and some red wine.

we also do at least half an hour of intensive exercise six days a week, usually it’s closer to an hour.

I was a size 16-18 with high blood pressure, now I’m an 8-10 with normal blood pressure.

FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco · 25/10/2022 16:27

Would people on here mind popping a quick summary of what they generally eat in a day? Sort of inspired by your latest post ProudBoomer (hope you don’t mind!) I’m trying to eat much more fruit and veg daily, to boost my fibre intake, and trying to cut out gluten, as it doesn’t make me feel great.

I can kick off - atm I’m trying to eat something like the below:
breakfast: yoghurt with berries, porridge oats, nuts or seeds and maybe an apple or banana, or poached/scrambled eggs with spinach or a bit of cheese

lunch: normally leftovers from dinner (e.g. sweet potato, chickpea and spinach curry with quinoa, roast chicken and veg tray bake); rice box with beans or chicken from somewhere like Leon

dinner: roast chicken with roast veg; fish with veg and quinoa; veggie shepherds pie. Yoghurt, sometimes frozen, with berries and dark chocolate for dessert; or a bit of chocolate for dessert.

Proudboomer · 25/10/2022 14:24

Dalaidramailama · 24/10/2022 16:10

@Proudboomer

Sounds impressive. May I ask how do you “spend” your 50-100 grams of carbs a day. For example, would it still work if you had a small slice of brown bread within the carb allowance of course? Or does the 50/100 need to come from fruit and veg etc?

I take most of my carbs from fruit and veg. My treat food is a pepper sauce with a steak. The steak is carb free and high protein but if I add the sauce it will be just over 6 gms of carb which I would count in my daily allowance so maybe skip the raspberries for pudding or have a boiled egg for lunch which again is carb free. I rarely eat bread now but if I do I opt for a low GI one and will again skip something else that day so I don’t go over my carb total. I always eat a no sugar probiotic yogurt each day which is just under 9 gms of carb as they are good for gut health plus a small plum which are packed with antioxidants which is around 4 gms of carb and these are easy things to drop if I have had bread or a couple of spoonfuls of brown rice.

PBSam · 25/10/2022 14:24

ThreeblackCats · 25/10/2022 14:15

As a diabetic, I’m pretty pissed at the amount of imbeciles that think telling me “eat less, move more” is what I need to hear.

My parent, my uncle (parents sibling) my grandparent and grandparents siblings all being diabetic really didn’t help.

would you tell someone missing a limb it’s their fault!

If they did something stupid that lost them the limb then yes, if they were born with it obviously not. You unfortunately have a genetic predisposition to having diabetes but that doesn't mean you can't manage it better through diet and exercise.

ThreeblackCats · 25/10/2022 14:15

As a diabetic, I’m pretty pissed at the amount of imbeciles that think telling me “eat less, move more” is what I need to hear.

My parent, my uncle (parents sibling) my grandparent and grandparents siblings all being diabetic really didn’t help.

would you tell someone missing a limb it’s their fault!

Aria999 · 25/10/2022 14:09

@Mad1988 slightly afraid to ask this but have you read the book 'Why We Eat too much' by Andrew jenkinson? You are clearly very well informed and I would welcome your opinion.

What he says about insulin is different from the model discussed in the article and would (I think) need a longer time frame to test. He suggests that insulin prevents the body knowing how much leptin it has, so it doesn't know how fat it is and can't adjust metabolism accordingly.

Is that plausible or is it crazy?

Aria999 · 24/10/2022 23:50

Looks like chicken is ok. Yay!

Aria999 · 24/10/2022 23:42

@Mad1988 thank you! That is all very interesting.

In fact I have been past the end of my weight loss journey for a while, it's a way of eating not a diet. I will check out your book recommendations.

That is bad news about animal protein and cancer. How big an effect are we talking? DH is a confirmed carnivore so whatever it is we are probably stuck with it...

Mad1988 · 24/10/2022 22:17

Aria999 · 24/10/2022 17:07

@MatchaTea is there a meta-analysis somewhere?

I am not a scientist so I rely on people I trust feed me potted data. I browsed a bit but got nowhere. It seems possible to find other articles that suggest differently e.g.

academic.oup.com/jcem/article/90/9/5175/2838683

Body weight and fat free mass
The 1-wk LC/HP did not affect fat free mass, which was 50.3 ± 3.6 kg before and 49.9 ± 3.6 after the diet. Percent body fat (28.7 ± 4.7% and 28.3 ± 4.9%) and total fat mass (20.2 ± 3.0 kg and 19.7 ± 3.2 kg) were also not different before vs. after the LC/HP. However, the diet slightly, yet significantly, reduced total body weight from 70.5 ± 3.7 kg to 69.5 ± 3.6 kg (P = 0.01).

I am clearly out of my depth here and I certainly don't want to be culty! but something is going on because having struggled to control my weight my whole life I am now effortlessly slim without counting calories.

@Aria999 , we are not talking about the same thing"
I talk about insulin, you talk about protein.

So this discussion is about the carbohydrate insulin model of obesity which puts ALL the blame on insulin and states that by restricting carbs, insulin is low, and you lose weight independently of proteins. As you might recall, the full name of the low carb diet is Low Carb High Fat or LCHF
This insulin model has been tested and they also tested what weight was lost, was is fat or lean mass.

This study indicates that the restriction of dietary carbohydrate does contribute to body weight loss but not to body fat loss.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6224925/

The insulin model does not pass the test.

Then we go on to talk about protein. And High Proteins diet. The body has no trouble using fat and glucose. Proteins on the other hand, have to go to a transformation process. Think of it as the difference between going into Tesco and grabbing a packet of pre-sliced coconut from the fridge and having to walk to a beach, climb on a coconut tree, cut a coconut down, whack it open, and scoop some flesh. That's more or less the steps the body has to go through to be able to utilise the protein, and as result 25-30% of the calories are wasted in processing it. This is known as thermogenesis. If you eat 100 calories of chicken, in reality you are eating 70 calories. In addition to that there is more satiety from eating proteins.

Nobody has ever said that high protein diets do not make you lose weight. Every time you eat protein , your body has to go through a lot of trouble to use them.

The paper you linked is about high protein diet, not LCHF.

You also have to consider that anytime you remove a big chunk of something, carb, fat, meat, you not only reduce the category of you food you can eat, but you are also forced to cook from scratch because most ultra-processed foods have a bit of everything. And there have been plenty of studies on hunger on UPF. This one is really interesting, again by Kevin Hall who locks people for a living. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31105044/ with equal calories, fat, salt, sugar, on UPF you overeat.

Then let’s talk about palatability. Take a potato. The poor potato that receives so much hate, Boil it but don’t put anything on it. No butter, no cream , no oil. Plain pure carb. Or pasta, cook it, no butter, no oil, no cream, no cheese. Pure carbs, How much are you going to eat of them? One could argue that it is as much the fat that makes us overeat. I love avocado. But avocado with a spoon or avocado on a sourdough bread are two very different things. Add salt on top, my brain goes banana.

What I am trying to say, is that there is less appeal to overeat when a big macro is out,

One thing that is important to clarify is that there is the assumption that anyone who challenges the insulin model is labelled as a low fat advocate. This is not the case for me. I argue that the ideal diet is a normal diet. Normal carb, normal fat and more than everything else, normal protein.

Proteins accelerate several growth pathways and they are not void of risk for health.

Unless you are over the age of 65, you should be mindful of the quantity and origin of you protein . Animal proteins raise your risk of cancer. This study www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8755536/ looked at animals in a zoo. It is almost impossible to determine the natural cause of death of animals in the wild. But the zoo represents the perfect setting. And carnivore animals die of cancer more than herbivore A high-fat, low-fibre diet, a known risk factor for carcinogenesis, has also been suggested to explain the elevated cancer risk in Carnivora.

There is a difference between plant proteins and animal proteins, When eating low carb, you cut a big family of very beneficial protein. The pulses. Lentils, chickpeas, beans, … The ideal package: fibre and protein in one food.

You are on a weightloss journey. Great. Once you have reached your weight, focus on your next goal : health span and lifespan. You might want to read Luigi Fontana’s Path to Longevity. Very factual and science-based book on the human life and diet. I believe you will also enjoy “Burn” by Herman Pontzer. A mix of science and anthropology, fascinating page turning book. The author spent quite a fair time with the Hazda.

Both books will help you understand why you are losing weight now and once you understand it , you will be able to maintain without having to cut a big group of food.

Good on you, for looking at the science, and please anytime you have questions, or doubt , reach out. The human body is hugely complex and reductionism is absurd. Our biochemistry works in synergy, you can't isolate an enzyme, a protein, a gene, an hormone.

Aria999 · 24/10/2022 19:09

@MatchaTea apologies I have just re-read the article you shared and it doesn't say that low carb doesn't cause weight loss, it's specifically looking at falsifying a particular version of the insulin model.

I think my main conclusion is I don't really understand it!

My secondary conclusion is that the book I have been relying on actually proposes a different reason for insulin affecting weight loss than the one examined in the article, which could still be true.

I have nonetheless slightly lost faith in the book as I would like it to have talked about some of the studies you have highlighted. But the reason I was compelled by it in the first place was that it was working for me, which remains true.

Anyway thanks for your help and I have taken on board what you have said.

Aria999 · 24/10/2022 17:07

@MatchaTea is there a meta-analysis somewhere?

I am not a scientist so I rely on people I trust feed me potted data. I browsed a bit but got nowhere. It seems possible to find other articles that suggest differently e.g.

academic.oup.com/jcem/article/90/9/5175/2838683

Body weight and fat free mass
The 1-wk LC/HP did not affect fat free mass, which was 50.3 ± 3.6 kg before and 49.9 ± 3.6 after the diet. Percent body fat (28.7 ± 4.7% and 28.3 ± 4.9%) and total fat mass (20.2 ± 3.0 kg and 19.7 ± 3.2 kg) were also not different before vs. after the LC/HP. However, the diet slightly, yet significantly, reduced total body weight from 70.5 ± 3.7 kg to 69.5 ± 3.6 kg (P = 0.01).

I am clearly out of my depth here and I certainly don't want to be culty! but something is going on because having struggled to control my weight my whole life I am now effortlessly slim without counting calories.

Dalaidramailama · 24/10/2022 16:10

@Proudboomer

Sounds impressive. May I ask how do you “spend” your 50-100 grams of carbs a day. For example, would it still work if you had a small slice of brown bread within the carb allowance of course? Or does the 50/100 need to come from fruit and veg etc?

FinallyHere · 24/10/2022 14:22

Congratulations @Proudboomer

Proudboomer · 24/10/2022 07:16

I went low carb, high protein when I was diagnosed a type 2 diabetic just over a year ago. I was a size 18 with most of the weight around my belly. 6 months of extremely low car of no more than 50 a day and I had lost all the extra weight and was a size 10 bottom and 12 top and still losing. When I got now to a size 8/10 I had to actually increase my carb to sablise my weight so I upped to 100 gms of carb a day. My weight is now sable at a size 8 bottoms and 10/12 top. My blood sugar is under control and I have no symptoms of diabetes.But I know should I go back to eating pasta, rice, and bread that will all change as once you become diabetic you will always be diabetic so I am just a diabetic with my blood sugar under control due to diet.

Tadpoll · 24/10/2022 04:02

Sorry, that quote was from the study - first paragraph.

Tadpoll · 24/10/2022 04:02

gordonpym · 23/10/2022 21:34

Just posted on another thread but I think it is relevant here as well :

Unless one has diabetes , low carb diets can actually increase risk of diabetes.

Conclusions: A score representing a low-carbohydrate diet high in animal protein and fat was positively associated with the risk of T2D in men. Low-carbohydrate diets should obtain protein and fat from foods other than red and processed meat
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21310828/

Conclusion: Our findings suggest that a higher adherence to LCD, mostly with higher intakes of protein and fat from animal-source foods, can increase the incidence of diabetes; however, a plant-based low-carbohydrate dietary pattern is not significantly associated with risk of type 2 diabetes.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33042230/

Conclusions: Diets high in animal protein are associated with an increased diabetes risk. Our findings also suggest a similar association for total protein itself instead of only animal sources. Consumption of energy from protein at the expense of energy from either carbohydrates or fat may similarly increase diabetes risk. This finding indicates that accounting for protein content in dietary recommendations for diabetes prevention may be useful
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19825820/

And worse, if you eat high animal protein you increase your risk of gestational diabetes.

Diets aimed to lose weight that encourage restriction of carbohydrates and elevated consumption of animal protein intensify insulin resistance increasing the risk of developing type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
Accordingly, pre-pregnancy intake of meat (processed and unprocessed) has been strongly associated with a higher risk of gestational diabetes whereas greater pre-pregnancy vegetable protein consumption is associated with a lower risk of gestational diabetes.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2405457719303146

so this something that needs to be said, because gestational diabetes raises not only risk of pre-eclampsia but if left untreated also premature birth and stillbirth .

As @MadelineUsher said, low carb is not a superior way of dieting . It carries health risk which most are not aware of or worse dismiss attacking the science.

Isn’t this about increasing animal protein while reducing plant foods though? That’s not the case in the low-carb way of eating most are talking about here. In fact, since I reduced carbs I eat way more vegetable foods.

dietary patterns with elevated amount of animal products and low quantity of vegetable food items raise the risk of these diseases.