Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to move to London as soon as DC go to uni

508 replies

GoutFine · 14/10/2022 22:16

DH is from London and we moved to the Home Counties when DC were small for schools/ quality of life. I have always loved it and he has loved it but always missed London. We met in London but I was from another area of the UK originally so don't have the same emotional ties.

Now the DC are older and youngest l due to start uni next year DH has said very strongly he is desperate to move back to central London. He wants to sell our lovely family home and buy a "lovely" flat in zone 1, with spare rooms for the children.

We have lived where we are for 18 years and built up a great network of friends and I'm so emotionally attached to this area as this is all our children have ever known. If it were up to me I'd stay here and the DC would still have their family home to return to. In all likelihood they'd be living with us for a while after uni and we are within easy commuting distance to London (25 minutes into Marylebone and we are a short walk from the station).

He says I'm being unfair as he has lived here for so long and he belongs in London and wants to live back there. I feel my life is here end don't see why he must live in London when we are so close anyway. I mainly feel sad for the children I don't want them to lose their family home and the friendships and connections they have here.

WIBU to refuse to move? He is desperate to.

OP posts:
BackOnTheBandWagon · 15/10/2022 08:54

SD1978 · 14/10/2022 22:21

If your main objection is the kids, then that's not enough. They may have connections around there, but they will be off like shits and on with their own lives- as will any friends they have in the area with the right opportunity. If the main objection is your life and friends, then that's a valid one. Your kids don't care about the family home, you do. Instead of framing it about your adult children, tell him why you don't want to.

That's not necessarily true. My parents moved when I went to uni, and it meant I hardly ever went to their house. I did go "home" lots though and crashed with friends because I wanted to see them, as well as staying in my uni town. It also meant I didn't take my planned gap year because they decided to move, and I didn't want to spend a year in a place where I knew no-one.

Benjispruce4 · 15/10/2022 08:53

This is such a refreshing thread. I had no idea so many midlife+ couples aim to or have moved back into London. My family are Londoners and most have emigrated or moved out bar one now who’s as lucky enough to buy a council flat in WC1 a couple of decades ago. DD has recent moved to London for work and we love visiting her(1hr in train) but am happy to leave purely because I love open spaces, sky and a slower pace. However I totally get the pull of having so much on your doorstep at any time.
If you can afford a lovely flat in Zone 1 then maybe agree to try it. Could you rent your house out and rent in London for a year and see how it goes?

CentralLondonLife · 15/10/2022 08:52

Having a small London flat means almost no housework, no maintenance, no gardening. Living costs can be cheaper, travel certainly is, food is the same, lots of entertainment is free.

You end up with so much more time it seems.

If you live in a small place you need fewer possessions. Getting rid of stuff is liberating. Small collection of wonderful clothes and items. Everything that I have in my flat was carefully selected and I love them.

It is 3 minutes walk from my flat to the nearest national museum/gallery

Zone 1 can be cheaper than zone 2. Somewhere such as Chiswick, Putney or Barnes is not going to give you a London lifestyle.

WendyWagon · 15/10/2022 08:51

My husband would like to move back to Birmingham when we retire. Not on your Nelly. We know no one there bar his siblings. I have worked in London for 35 years , mainly commuting. He has worked locally. In hindsight it would have been prudent to buy in London but I didn’t want the crime for my dc. I truly love London but I think you need plenty of money. I have friends in Mayfair and SW and that is a very different ball game. Our DS lives in Putney. He has a very active social life and a great GP practice. However he is planning his escape, too dirty, too costly. He is a country boy at heart. We are less than a hour from London but are in the process of buying nearer to a large town. Better shops, more activities and we have checked the healthcare. Our local friends can visit but tbh they are all planning moves to Bath (cultural, good shops, good hospitals). I would rent in London op for a year. The service charges on flats can be huge. Where will you hang your washing?( we have lived in a flat for 18 months after moving from a 5 bed family home, this has driven us potty). Ditto the lack of a garden for the dog.
Talk to your husband it might just be nostalgia. We got rid of some ‘country cars’ when we moved to the flat and my husband bombs around in a mini (he had one when I met him). Seems to have made him happy.

drkpl · 15/10/2022 08:51

A work colleague of mine moved from London back to my area after falling down an escalator at a tube station. No one helped him or even asked if he was ok. They just stepped over him.

It would be a no thanks from me.

pocketvenuss · 15/10/2022 08:49

@Kissingfrogs25 amazing how different people see things. You seem to judge the commenters parents very harshly. I don't. Who knows why people may move country but support is not always about keeping the old house for the kids to return to. I'd have loved my parents to have been more dynamic and lived their life a bit more. Personally, I would have loved to have a small space in London when I returned from uni rather than being stuck in the 'burbs. Doesn't mean no support. It means changing what support looks like as dc grow. Live a little. You aren't supposed to become martyr once you are a parent. Everyone does things differently. Different doesn't equal bad.

ambermorning · 15/10/2022 08:47

urgen - what do you mean, Barnes and Chiswick are "shocking?"

Ergonomicallydesigned · 15/10/2022 08:47

I think this is such a tricky one. You’re quite happy but your husband isn’t. It’s finding a way I suppose so that both your needs are met. We live in a small market town about an hour from London, husband is quite happy here but when the kids are gone I’d like to move back up north. Could you compromise and move nearer into London?

RootinandTootin · 15/10/2022 08:47

lllllllllll · 15/10/2022 07:35

And I would rather saw my own leg off than live in the “Home Counties” (shudder). We’re all different.

I do find it tiresome when people say Londoners are rude though. I’ve lived here a long time and the vast majority of people are very helpful and pleasant.

I don’t live in the Home Counties either. Been to London once a week and yes some are pleasant but a vast majority are rude. I suppose because it’s tightly packed with people so more likely to have more of both types.

CentralLondonLife · 15/10/2022 08:45

Tomorrowisalatterday · 15/10/2022 06:56

We plan to move to central London for retirement too so I am instinctively on his side - I suspect your kids would love it and you would probably see a lot more of them if they end up working in London.

I think giving it a trial run by renting out your house is a good idea. There are a couple of compromise options which also might be worth talking about:

Quieter/greener area of London

Moving somewhere in the home counties better connected - e.g. if you're currently a drive to a large town with a train station, moving to the town

Flat on a side of London which makes it quick to get to where you currently live

Second home in London which you Airbnb much of the year

I think it's worth talking through what specifically you both want. Is it being able to see your friends that's important to you? Or green space? Or an activity you do? Is it not driving everywhere that's important to him? Is it more cultural things? Etc

Most London airbnb is limited to 90 days and lots of flats it is banned altogether

urgen · 15/10/2022 08:40

My children early 20’s would LOVE us to move to London. We would see them far more than we do.

Iwishmynamewassheilah · 15/10/2022 08:39

Watching with interest. Our DC both moved to London after Uni and they are desperate that we sell up and join them!

Did the OP disclose if they can afford the "nice flat" in central London? We can’t, sadly, so that’s our answer to the kids.

urgen · 15/10/2022 08:38

I know Barnes and Chiswick very well. They are shocking. Have you got a £1 million and say £1.3 million for perhaps a very small 2 bed house? It might be the time to do it with the market being as it is. I presume you will need to sell your current house. Stamp duty on £1m is circa £45k.

If you have you can probably do it. So many people in support of London. I am feeling a little wistful about a life in London…..

Kissingfrogs25 · 15/10/2022 08:37

YukoandHiro · 15/10/2022 08:31

The whole thing about coming back to the family home is oversold. DCs coming back form uni/early independence tend to regress when they walk through the door and that causes extreme conflict.
My parents moved abroad when I was in the third year of uni and it was the best thing They could have done. Forced me onto my own two feet (with some guidance and support from them of course) and also meant I was an adult visiting my adult parents when I stayed with them and the dynamic was much improved. I've had an excellent close relationship with them ever since (in 40s now)

I think that is quite sad to pack up and move away and so far when your children are still in university. In my view students can need a lot of support, emotional and otherwise and having a family home to come back to in the holidays to decompress, see old friends and feel 'at home' is not much to ask for.

It feels very selfish to leave your children and move to another country thousands of miles away, and personally I would never do this to my children whilst they were still fledglings. Being forced to cope is not ideal. Perhaps you have always had to try hard with your parents because it is not a given they will automatically be there for you? They have already proven otherwise. Not exactly unconditional support many of us aim for.

houseargh · 15/10/2022 08:37

My parents moved (country) as soon as my younger brother was off to uni. At that age, especially if you were only in the home counties, they will keep seeing any friends from home that matter to them. And as a Londoner born and bred, I can confirm that living in it is completely different to living in the home counties, however short the journey - he wants to go home, I don't see that he needs more justification than that (not saying that his needs automatically trump yours but sometimes a heart reason is as good as a head reason)

urgen · 15/10/2022 08:33

I suspect you live in Gerard’s X, Chalfont, Amersham area. I used to live there but was brought up in London as a child. Didn’t have a car and walked everywhere (it was rather a long time ago!).

I now live in a very desirable tourist/resential area about 100 mins drive from London. I miss London almost every day although it’s lovely around here. We can still do London theatres but it is a pain to travel too now. Sitting at trendy counter Italian restaurants after a theatre visit sipping a glass of cava. There is nothing like it. We have nice gastro pub restaurants around here but there is a definite recipe to them. There is nothing like London. Could you afford a small house in say Kew or Chiswick. Don’t underestimate losing outdoor space completely - even a small court yard garden would I think be useful.

Personally I could downsize but wouldn’t get a flat. It’s a step too far. Could I ask your budget?

ambermorning · 15/10/2022 08:32

Hi OP,

What I would do if I were you I think, I'd just start having a look around at flats in London. When he says "Central London" what does he actually mean?

London flats don't have to mean noise and congestion. Maybe get something in a gorgeous white stucco building in a garden square in Chelsea? Or there are loads of apartments on the river. Imagine yourself sitting out in the terrace looking at the lights in the evening, or the sparkles in the morning. Swanning round the V&A. Endless supply of coffee shops and restaurants and always something new to discontent every day.,...

You will find you are very popular with your kids and their friends! Chances are, they will be working in London anyway soon enough, so you would have your kids more local in the long term.

What about (as a potential compromise) somewhere like Putney / Barnes where there are river walks and loads of greenery? Still a quick drive into town? Has he mentioned actual locations? What is your budget?

Another option could be renting out your house for a while and renting in London to see if you like it?

He may find, once you start looking, that the reality of what you can afford doesn't quite match up to the image he has in his head. I'd indulge it for now and agree to look at least. You are not committed to anything. Also, see what's happening with the property market as god knows who will be PM next week.

Cleopatra67 · 15/10/2022 08:32

I totally get this. My youngest has just turned 18 and I’m desperate to move back to city life. DH would happily stay put but acknowledges it’s probably time for a reset anyway. He is entitled to his feelings too.

BuryingAcorns · 15/10/2022 08:31

Kissingfrogs25 · 15/10/2022 08:07

I can't help but think he is trying to get his 'young carefree' life back, he remembers the golden years of youth and the excitement and thrill of central London. This is a mid life crisis in the making. He wants to be 'young' again but hasn't factored in the reality.

Hire an air bnb in January when they will be a fraction of the cost at other times of the year and test run a month if you can of life in the city. And see how get on. I am willing to bet for the first week he will love it, and after that it will become increasingly obvious to him the drawbacks.

Just for the record, nothing would get me back to London.
No friends, hectic, stressful, polluted and lonely for you.
I wouldn't do it under any circumstances, but you can do the trial if you think it will give him something to think about.

Honestly, I don't think it is that. (I'm like OP's husbvand. Long to return to London but never going to happen as DH can't stand it. We too live in the Home Counties and now DC are both at uni are looking for the next stage.

What I love about London is its vibrancy and variety whatever your age. If you go to adult ed classes there, you get world class writers and artists and musicians teaching you. DH loves singing in a choir but complains bitterly all the time that local choirs are rock choirs (he won;t do that) and the one classical choir has an average age of 90. If we lived in London he;d have the pick of classical choirs and would end up singing with great professional conductors.

But I also just love the general variety - the pink and blue hair, the people of all races, the quirky behaviour, the buskers and high fashion flaneurs, the fabulous galleries and museums on your doorstep. I love that going to theatre isn't a panic to run back for the train or you have to wait an hour for the next one.

My ideal life in retirement is theatre shows, concerts, rock and comedy gigs, exhibitions, long walks, adult ed creative classes and helping out at a food bank. All on my doorstep in London. None on my doorstep in Home Counties except the long walks. The local theatres just show mainstream musicals, the local area has no need for a food bank, the local adult ed classes are few and far between and the same two teachers teach the same 10 sessions on repeat. The choirs are as DH describes.

pocketvenuss · 15/10/2022 08:31

Worriedaboutethics · 15/10/2022 02:30

@GoutFine

kids like to go back to where they grew up when at UnI.

the wanes after 5/7 years of going to uni.

your husband of course knows this.

why not wait five years

That doesn't change the fact that OP still will refuse to consider his wants

YukoandHiro · 15/10/2022 08:31

The whole thing about coming back to the family home is oversold. DCs coming back form uni/early independence tend to regress when they walk through the door and that causes extreme conflict.
My parents moved abroad when I was in the third year of uni and it was the best thing They could have done. Forced me onto my own two feet (with some guidance and support from them of course) and also meant I was an adult visiting my adult parents when I stayed with them and the dynamic was much improved. I've had an excellent close relationship with them ever since (in 40s now)

whiteroseredrose · 15/10/2022 08:30

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 15/10/2022 03:18

You've had your way for a long time. It's his turn now.

It was a joint decision to move out of London. The DH is making a unilateral decision to move back.

I think you have a problem OP. One of you is going to be unhappy at the end of this.

I like a short trip to London but can't wait to leave after a couple of days. All the people everywhere do my head in. I love getting back to my quiet suburban street.

Humobean · 15/10/2022 08:29

My husband's fantasy cities to move to in retirement would be Chicago or Madrid.
I'd quite like Madrid but would be happy with a move down the road to Edinburgh 😁

Knowing us we'll stay where we are in the suburbia of a tiny city 😂

AdelaideRo · 15/10/2022 08:27

I live in central london and I love it.

I can walk to most places. I have good public transport for when I can’t.

I truly live the city - it’s a rare week when I’m not at the theatre or an art gallery /museum (I still work more than full time).

I feel like I’m suffocating when I visit friends out of town who talk about going to the cinema or panto once a year as an adventure.

give it a try. I have previously lived in the Barbican. It’s FULL of downsizing older couples!

Beautifultrees · 15/10/2022 08:27

As a native Londoner who hasn’t lived there for a long time, what bothers me the most when visiting is the pollution. When you blow your nose in London the mucus isn’t clear but grey or even black! Living there I didn’t realise the “fuzzy brain” feeling was due to air pollution until I moved away and it completely lifted. When you drive around the M25 you can literally see the grey haze over London.

Swipe left for the next trending thread