Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to move to London as soon as DC go to uni

508 replies

GoutFine · 14/10/2022 22:16

DH is from London and we moved to the Home Counties when DC were small for schools/ quality of life. I have always loved it and he has loved it but always missed London. We met in London but I was from another area of the UK originally so don't have the same emotional ties.

Now the DC are older and youngest l due to start uni next year DH has said very strongly he is desperate to move back to central London. He wants to sell our lovely family home and buy a "lovely" flat in zone 1, with spare rooms for the children.

We have lived where we are for 18 years and built up a great network of friends and I'm so emotionally attached to this area as this is all our children have ever known. If it were up to me I'd stay here and the DC would still have their family home to return to. In all likelihood they'd be living with us for a while after uni and we are within easy commuting distance to London (25 minutes into Marylebone and we are a short walk from the station).

He says I'm being unfair as he has lived here for so long and he belongs in London and wants to live back there. I feel my life is here end don't see why he must live in London when we are so close anyway. I mainly feel sad for the children I don't want them to lose their family home and the friendships and connections they have here.

WIBU to refuse to move? He is desperate to.

OP posts:
FlamencoDance · 15/10/2022 12:32

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster’s request.

sevenbyseven · 15/10/2022 12:23

It's a difficult one and hard to know what the right answer is, particularly as there's no obvious compromise.

Could you try renting a small flat in London for a while (or even an Air BnB at weekends) to see if the lifestyle he's remembering is really still available? I miss our old life in London pre-kids sometimes but realistically most of the people we knew then have also moved away, plus we're 20 years older, so it would be very different moving back now.

ambermorning · 15/10/2022 11:46

I'm sure when he says 'Central London' he doesn't literally mean Piccadilly Circus, does he OP? What area/s does he have in mind? That would help people comment on whether he is BU or not.

Sausagenbacon · 15/10/2022 11:39

my mum, in her 90s, still lives in the 'family home', which none of her children see as anything but a major pain in the bum, as it constantly needs work on it.
My children love to visit us in the city.
The responses only show how various we all are, and that you won't get an answer, unless you would like to prefer the cherry pick the ones that fit with your view.
It would be my idea of a nightmare to have stayed in our country house. It needed constant maintenance, including gardening.
You only ever met exactly the same people all the time - we keep in touch with some people, but have made new friends. And you had to get in the car to do anything, apart from walk.
I suppose it depends on how open you are to new experiences. I remember being horrified, when I went to a school reunion, to find that some of them had never moved away and were still in the same friendship group.
And as for nature! In dreary weather you can always find new parks in the city, and new ways to walk to them. In the country, although it looks lovely, you're stuck with the same old muddy footpaths.
Good luck with whatever you decide to do.

WendyWagon · 15/10/2022 11:39

@GoutFine
How often does your husband see these London friends? We moved to be closer to family after my father died. It didn’t work. No one came to see us anymore frequently and the imagined nights out didn’t happen. We sold up and moved 18 months ago to rent a friends flat in our tweedy market town whilst we looked around. Good property has been hard to find as we needed a train station, shops and parking. I wouldn’t go back to living rurally but be careful about the imagined full on social life with old friends. They will have their own plans. I bet after the initial pub night , dinner party etc things will quiten down. We were wondering about missing our friends until we found out they were in the main planning a Bath move or overseas!

GoutFine · 15/10/2022 11:23

@BatteryPoweredMammy that's me - I too find it all so superficial and also very money focussed. It's all about going out to this that and the other which is lovely to me once in a while but not what I want every single day. I crave nature and value our friendships.

I'm not dismissing his feelings but do think this is a huge issue we can't really compromise on. One of us is going to be unhappy. I (probably selfishly) can't see how he hadn't got the best of both worlds where we are, he can easily be in London in no time at all, less than if he lived in zone 3 to theatres etc. I just don't see how it warrants giving up everything we have now for that change but maybe we will have to 😞

OP posts:
washingbasketqueen · 15/10/2022 11:18

It sounds so exciting! I'd love to do it- if I could afford it.

Humobean · 15/10/2022 11:17

I don’t think he’s being unreasonable, he’s compromised for the kids and you for the best part of 2 decades, time for you to compromise now. How much longer can he be held hostage to you and your dc needs!

This was my father's view 🙄. He's now not happy in Australia.

You need to reach a compromise for both parties. A transactional approach 'But I did that then so now you need to do this now' is, to my mind, not healthy for a marriage.

If he feels like a hostage then he should just b*gger off and leave the poor OP in peace 😁

BatteryPoweredMammy · 15/10/2022 11:01

I agree with others that maybe you could try renting a flat for 6/12 months to see if it’s really what he wants or just an itch he has to scratch? That might be a better compromise than a flat out NO. Hopefully, he’ll realise it’s just a mid-life crisis that will pass.

For myself, I can’t imagine anything worse than living in central London and in your shoes, if he still wants to live in London after this trial period, then you’ll have to think seriously about splitting up.

My two adult DC. live in London because of work and they seem settled and happy for now but every time I visit, I’m desperate to go home to my rural idyll by about day 5. I can’t stand the crowds, noise and have no interest in going out in the evenings to dinner or the theatre or similar more than once or twice a year. I find it all a bit superficial.

I much prefer to spend time on my hobbies and being with my friends.

PeekAtYou · 15/10/2022 10:58

Trains go both ways. You are currently 25 mins into Marylebone so your kids can travel 25 mins to see their friends. Plus it's not a given that they will spend all holidays with you anyway. They could have partners in other areas of the country, want to travel or work elsewhere. What you and your h want should be the priority as you're living there every day.
Do your kids care about the family home? My kids are a similar age and won't care that I plan to move when my youngest finishes A-levels. They'd love it if I lived somewhere new and in the city. They had a lovely childhood in the suburbs but they find it dull after all these years.

Sisisimone · 15/10/2022 10:56

What would you have to sacrifice in terms of living standards if you were to buy a flat in a decent area with enough bedrooms for your children to stay? I imagine you would have much less space? No garden? I guess my answer would largely be dependent on your financial circumstances. For instance a multi million property in London and a smaller place you can keep in the home counties is a very different situation to having to sell a big family home with garden and end up in a poky flat in a shitty part of London

Macaroni1924 · 15/10/2022 10:51

Summerfun54321 · 14/10/2022 22:51

I must say I see your DH’s view. I really miss London and find the quieter life pretty dull. Can you at least not compromise by booking in a few regular weekend London trips and talking about where you would live and trying it out. He mind find the reality isn’t quite what he remembered.

This is a good idea. It may make him want it more and you even less. However chances are that it’s not what he remembers plus you are both older now and so used to a different style of living. Maybe even when you see what kind/size of properties you can reasonably afford it might be off putting too.

Sisisimone · 15/10/2022 10:50

CentralLondonLife · 15/10/2022 09:36

Oh and GP care is much better where I am in central London than it was in the affluent town I lived in before

I wanted a flu jab today, booked it yesterday with massive central London choice. 1st date sister in large (naice) Yorkshire town can get in late November.

She can literally walk into any chemist and get one. I was offered one whilst I was waiting for a prescription for my mum.

thecatsthecats · 15/10/2022 10:50

I don't think it's quite fair to say that the journey to friends argument is equal, because I think the status quo is the default, all things being equal.

He THINKS it will be better. She THINKS it will be worse. But neither know.

I don't think that buying a bolt hole is even necessary. You can always take short term lets, month long Airbnb stays etc. You could pick the three months of the year he least likes the countryside and spend them in the city.

I'd love to emigrate to NZ, but realistically we're both unwilling to. So we have a deal where we're going to go for a few months every few years, and work our lives around that.

Boshi · 15/10/2022 10:44

OP this is me and my DH in reverse, I grew up in central london and we lived centrally when we got married - I desperately miss the hustle and bustle, everything interesting being a walk away and have also said to my DH we will retire in the same flat we lived in when we first married. I feel like I’ll have done my time living in quiet suburbia, and it’s not a midlife crisis either.

I don’t think he’s being unreasonable, he’s compromised for the kids and you for the best part of 2 decades, time for you to compromise now. How much longer can he be held hostage to you and your dc needs!

The dc will make their own lives so I wouldn’t worry about that. It’s time for them to grow up and realise their parents have needs/desires that aren’t centred around them too.

MsRosley · 15/10/2022 10:26

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 15/10/2022 10:23

It will be great to live in central london! I cant afford it but I am not far anyway. Think of lovely breakfasts outside, loads of museums on your doorstep. Youll be out all night everynight!

Sounds exhausting.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 15/10/2022 10:23

It will be great to live in central london! I cant afford it but I am not far anyway. Think of lovely breakfasts outside, loads of museums on your doorstep. Youll be out all night everynight!

Rubyupbeat · 15/10/2022 10:21

Cripes , its usually moving out when kids have left home.
I am London born and bred, I live on the outskirts now and will be happy to eventually move well away. I love London and have had the best life growing up in the east end, spending holidays in Hampstead and Golders green with aunts and cousins, but that London has gone, the violent crime is off the roof, and it is so bloody crowded, awful.
I bet its a different London to which your Husband remembers. Yes there are nice areas, I have family in lovely areas, but bad crime still happens there and once you are out of the conclaves of the tree lined streets, it's open season.
I would stand my ground if I were you, he must be very selfish if he can't respect your happiness.

MsRosley · 15/10/2022 10:20

I don't think you're DH has thought this through. First of all kids often return home during the holidays, and then commonly back for some time after graduation. Secondly, unless you're absolutely loaded, how on earth will you afford a flat big enough in London for your kids, and then their partners and children, to come to stay? Your current house will be a hub for your burgeoning family to come and visit, but London will make that very difficult.

dollyblack · 15/10/2022 10:19

We recently moved back to a city centre after 18yrs of raising kids in suburbia.

it did feel a bit mid life crisis-y in a fabulous way! We love it- it does make me feel younger and the kids are very happy to have a central base.

its fab living in a flat and so fun and easy being in the middle of it all.

OP you’ll meet new people and be able to easily visit your town/friends. I’d give it a go if i were you.

lovescats3 · 15/10/2022 10:15

London is very different now to 18 years ago especially post Brexit and pandemic.you need to Airbnb for a month or two in it to see the changes

oviraptor21 · 15/10/2022 10:09

I love Central London and luckily live close enough that I can also get there in 30 minutes. But there's no way that I would choose to live there for all the reasons that the OP and others state.

The only room for compromise that I can see is if you can sell your current home and buy two equal value small homes. Easier said than done but if it's possible that's what I'd do. You may end up living apart but that will give you an idea of whether you'd prefer to be together in a place you don't want to be or apart in a place you do want to be.

Another option would be to rent a place in London for a fixed term. Try before you buy as it were.

Bestcatmum · 15/10/2022 10:07

Id sooner get divorced and buy a smaller home where I am than move to London.

PoundShopPrincess · 15/10/2022 10:03

Moving house is such a big decision. I don't think it's enough that he wants to go back when you so obviously don't. You didn't pull him out of the city. You all moved for the family. That doesn't mean his needs now trump everyone else's.

You don't need to hide behind the DCs. It's enough that you don't want to move to London. Your desire not to move is just as important as his desire to move.

However you both need to discuss what you want out of this next stage of your life and where you both want to be. Maybe a smaller town would be a better compromise?

Benjispruce4 · 15/10/2022 10:00

I’m not patronising by saying try it out by renting. Things change. London has changed. He has changed. She may change her mind. Surely it’s sensible to try before making such a massive change?