Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect to be able to stay in a job I am not qualified for

33 replies

Runningmouse · 14/10/2022 21:52

I applied for a job I was (and am) not fully qualified for in the spring of 2021. Basically I really wanted the job, and I thought I could do it despite not having all the required diplomas (I'm smart, and I have held a similar position in an adjacent field).

Because of staff shortages and a lack of qualified applicants, I was hired on a temporary contract, which makes sense. Anyway, it turns out I was right and I've been doing well according to feedback from colleagues and clients. My colleagues now really want me to stay because we get along, work well together, and it is quite a complex role so it would be months before any new person (however qualified they may be) would feel comfortable and settled.

Unfortunately all this time my manager has been kind of holding out for a fully qualified person to come along. No one has so far, but he keeps indicating my time there is limited and he does not expect I'll be there longterm, bla bla. Meanwhile, I've invested lots of extra unpaid hours to learn about the field, master new skills etc, and I am starting to feel like an idiot for doing so. I'd definitely be willing to go back to school & take the required courses in order to become fully qualified, but I'd have to actually follow a programme which would mean I'd need time off during the day. And I'm not getting that because of staff shortages - they need me all day, every day. I think my employer thinks the shortages will just magically disappear soon and he won't have to invest in me at all, and meanwhile I'll do the work and keep the company afloat.

AIBU to think that by now I deserve better, and my manager should let me take the course?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AndSoFinally · 15/10/2022 15:57

I think if youve been there 2 years (which you nearly have) you get some employment rights even if only on a temp contract.

I know our NHS locums get rights after 2 years and theirs are just rolling temporary contracts.

I would check this discretely somewhere

Floweryflora · 15/10/2022 11:53

I think it depends on what it is, if it’s something lie accountancy or something which really should require a formal qualification then I think it’s fine they have been honest with you. It really isn’t hugely relevant you’ve mates there and you like it, it really is about what they wish for the job and where they see it going.

Ariela · 15/10/2022 11:49

As previously suggested, set out the business case for your gaining the qualification and taking the time out.
Also research as to whether there is any funding for the company to pay for your qualification.

Crazykefir · 15/10/2022 11:41

Hmmmm. I'd never go to hr without speaking to my manager as I'd need their backing to do any additional training.
If you really want to peruse this career you need to go ahed and do the training with or without the support of this company.

AlisonDonut · 15/10/2022 11:07

How temporary is 18 months when after years they'd have to make you redundant rather than let you just go?

Surely there comes a point where temporary is actually permanent?

howshouldibehave · 15/10/2022 11:06

You can’t force the manager to send you on the course/let you go on the course. Is it expensive/lengthy?

What leverage do you have-could you go and work unqualified in another company?

itsgettingweird · 15/10/2022 10:50

I agree with a chat with HR.

They can't and aren't getting someone with the qualifications.

They can and do have you.

So either they accept a non qualified person who can do the role or they want qualified and the only way they appear to be able to secure that is to get you qualified.

I'd make it sound like you aren't willing to hang around and wait until they get someone else and you're putting the ball in their court.

Dependent on that outcome of that chat I'd then put it clearer - you aren't prepared to be a next best whilst doing a job and meeting the requirements and will be looking to move elsewhere where you're valued for your contribution.

custardbear · 15/10/2022 10:45

Honestly, I'd just do the course and tell him and more senior people of your interest and commitment. I've got lots of staff and those with higher qualifications aren't always the best for the jobs - you'd be snapped up in my teams (depending on your field lol 😆)

Shinyandnew1 · 15/10/2022 10:16

it’s quite hard to give advice based on just your opinion of what’s going on

Exactly. Are you actually coming back, @Runningmouse ?!

CurlyhairedAssassin · 15/10/2022 09:26

Sounds like accountancy or something?

It could be just that your manager hasn’t taken to you like your colleagues have? You sound like a very confident and self-assured person and I think some managers are put off by that, thinking you’ll demand all sorts. I bet they think that once you’re qualified you’ll demand higher pay (which would be entirely reasonable), and while you’re doing the job well now without the qualification why should they pay you more?

are you really “keeping the company afloat” though? In my experience, if a company needs you that much they don’t fob you off. It’s the opposite, they would do anything to keep you.

it’s quite hard to give advice based on just your opinion of what’s going on.

Heartsofstone · 15/10/2022 09:16

What’s the job! Is the qualification a legal requirement?

Ricardothesnowman · 15/10/2022 09:11

I'd suggest you look into other ways to get the qualification.
From what you behave said I'm guessing the course you want to do is an apprenticeship, but how about looking at evening classes?
This is similar in my industry, we can have unqualified staff, but need a certain number of qualified to operate legally, and training full time unqualified people to get thier qualifications is tricky as the need 20% time out for college work.
We have someone get round this by studying at evening classes, we let him leave early once a week to get to the lesson on time.

Shinyandnew1 · 15/10/2022 09:10

Can’t you ‘follow the program’ and do the diploma in the evenings/weekends and find it yourself?

LickThis · 15/10/2022 09:01

Is it a legal qualification or a desired one ? If its the later I'd join a union pronto

PuppyMonkey · 15/10/2022 08:52

Yes I’m struggling without knowing more detail about the role. You could be an unqualified brain surgeon for all we know.Grin

Shinyandnew1 · 15/10/2022 08:46

What are the qualifications?

CrochetIsCool · 15/10/2022 00:42

It is difficult to give a definitive answer without knowing your role and type of organisation and whether the qualifications are 'required' for the role or 'desirable'. Does your company have a Workforce/Learning and Development strategy that sets training opportunities? If so, this might be helpful.
In the organisation I worked for we would not have been able to offer funding to undertake a qualification to someone on a temporary contract. However in shortage areas developmental roles were created and successful applicants were funded to undertake specific qualifications within agreed timescales and also required a commitment to remain for a minimum of two years post qualification or repay course fees.
As suggested by previous posters, setting out a business case with costed options may help progress the discussion with your manager as an alternative to waiting for a suitably qualified person to turn up. Otherwise you will need to explore self funding the required qualifications which I appreciate is not easy.

Lunar270 · 15/10/2022 00:13

Yes YABU to expect anything. Possibly an unpopular opinion but as difficult as it is, you shouldn't be expecting them to commit to you.

It sounds like you've done brilliantly but you accepted a temporary contract, due to your lack of qualifications. It's possible that you don't need them (qualifications), given you've been doing the job, but your hiring manager is the one that gave you a chance, based on your CV etc. and sees you as a stop gap. Whether anyone actually comes along (and is better than you) is another thing and it doesn't sound like it. But sadly you were aware of the circumstances under which you were contracted and it doesn't sound like it's going to change.

You're definitely not unreasonable to push and try to keep your job but expecting to keep it is another thing.

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 14/10/2022 23:44

How important is the qualification? It sounds as though it's more than just being able to do the job. Is there a legal requirement that someone has that qualification?

Shinyandnew1 · 14/10/2022 23:39

It’s very hard to advise without knowing more detail. Are there ‘clients’ who are paying for your expertise? Do they know you are unqualified? How long would it take you to gain these qualifications whilst working part time for the company-and what would they cost?

MarmiteCoriander · 14/10/2022 23:35

Without knowing the vague industry/field, its hard to advise?

A lot of jobs allow EITHER a certain course/diploma or work experience. Unless of course the requirement is say to be a qualified Dr, registered nurse, lawyer etc. Again, without know the job or sector, its hard to know how hard lined this is for your own job?

Your boss sounds like a twat though! I confused why the boss wants a fully qualified person? Can they do/provide more than yourself? Sorry, its hard to work it out without knowing more details?

You have clearly demonstrated you have prior experience in the role, and demonstrated it since starting there! Would having the 'diploma' mean the role would earn you more than you are on now?

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 14/10/2022 23:34

Yanbu. Any company worth its salt should be investing in good staff, upskilling and training them and yes - financing and allowing paid time off to do courses and qualifications (albeit with reasonable tie in agreements). Our company does this and they make more money as a result as well as having a talented and loyal team. It should be a win-win.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 14/10/2022 23:01

Can you do all the research into the options and put together three possible scenarios to present to him. Say scenario 1 is they fund you and release you one day a week or whatever in return for three years service, option 2 etc. Factor in the costs of recruitment etc. Show him that you are serious about this. Another option would be to put in a flexible working request and reduce your hours, self fund then consider whether you want to stay there. Have you looked into distance learning which may be more flexible and self-paced?

LauraIAm · 14/10/2022 22:56

Would it be possible to offer to do the course and make up the work hours in the evening etc?

do you want them to pay for the course? What’s the cost?

is it a big or small company? Is there a formal appraisal / development process?

Runningmouse · 14/10/2022 22:44

gogohmm · 14/10/2022 22:17

Negotiate, study leave in return promise you'll stay 2 further years post qualification?

Yes, I've tried something like that, but got a rather halfhearted response (as in: ah yes, let's look into that, we'll maybe arrange that in the future some time).

Thing is, I love this job. I love this team. I want to stay. I've had a few bad fits in the past, and being happy at work is just so much better than being unhappy. It is making me really hesitant to make any demands, or give any kind of ultimatum, and I think they know that.

Thanks for the replies and votes so far. I was starting to think I was being ridiculous for having any expectations really.

OP posts: