Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish we had a different national anthem

136 replies

katmeouws · 14/10/2022 21:29

Just listening to The Marseillaise, which I much prefer to "God Save the King". Cant we have something more appropriate to a 21st century democracy.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DownNative · 16/10/2022 10:48

jetadore · 16/10/2022 10:36

I’m pretty sure there’s actually more than 2 verses though usually two are sung (thank fuck, can you imagine that droning on for 5 verses?)

This is the Scottish thing, which never was official you are right but I have heard it sung by some utter twats:

Lord, grant that Marshal Wade,
May by thy mighty aid,
Victory bring.
May he sedition hush,
and like a torrent rush,
Rebellious Scots to crush,
God save the King.

Regardless, it’s still a shite tune.

No, the UK National Anthem only has TWO verses as posted above. We heard it for the first time for King Charles III - this just has two verses.

You're thinking of God Save The Queen which had FIVE verses. None of which refer to "rebellious Scots". Only enemies in general. See attachment.

The Scottish verse is not and never was part of the national anthem itself. That verse actually makes a distinction between rebellious Scots and loyal Scots - context was the Jacobite war. Scots fought on both sides, so the Scots on the Jacobite side were literally the rebellious Scots. The ones on the other British side weren't.

But as I said it was never part of the UK National Anthem at ANY time.

To wish we had a different national anthem
DownNative · 16/10/2022 10:39

PaperDoves · 15/10/2022 09:17

I'm not British, so maybe that's why I like yours. But then Americans liked yours so much that we took it, changed the lyrics and made it one of our own songs. 😂

In general national anthems are all a bit dull though.

Liechtenstein also use the tune for GSTK/Q for their "High On The Young Rhine" anthem. Switzerland also used it until the 1960s.

jetadore · 16/10/2022 10:36

DownNative · 16/10/2022 10:17

Absolute rubbish - the UK National Anthem has never had lyrics like that. We first had an anthem decades after 1745!

You can see the current lyrics of GSTK only has TWO verses and neither mention the Scottish, let alone killing any! 🤦‍♂️

I’m pretty sure there’s actually more than 2 verses though usually two are sung (thank fuck, can you imagine that droning on for 5 verses?)

This is the Scottish thing, which never was official you are right but I have heard it sung by some utter twats:

Lord, grant that Marshal Wade,
May by thy mighty aid,
Victory bring.
May he sedition hush,
and like a torrent rush,
Rebellious Scots to crush,
God save the King.

Regardless, it’s still a shite tune.

DownNative · 16/10/2022 10:17

jetadore · 15/10/2022 10:19

Could easily change England for Britain. The current one has something on about killing rebellious Scots!

Absolute rubbish - the UK National Anthem has never had lyrics like that. We first had an anthem decades after 1745!

You can see the current lyrics of GSTK only has TWO verses and neither mention the Scottish, let alone killing any! 🤦‍♂️

DownNative · 16/10/2022 10:09

FourChimneys · 14/10/2022 21:34

Ours is wrong. It focuses on the current monarch, regardless of their merit or lack of it. It also assumes a belief in the Christian god.

It is only applicable to royalist Christians, is anti Scots, and has an outstandingly dull tune.

We need one which is about the country and its people, with an uplifting tune.

Anti-Scottish?

No, it isn't! At the time a few sung the "rebellious Scots" line which was during the Jacobite war, the UK didn't even have a national anthem.

That verse has never been part of the UK National Anthem.

The words of the National Anthem are as follows:

"God save our gracious King!
Long live our noble King!
God save the King!
Send him victorious,
Happy and glorious,
Long to reign over us,
God save the King.

Thy choicest gifts in store
On him be pleased to pour,
Long may he reign.
May he defend our laws,
And ever give us cause,
To sing with heart and voice,
God save the King."

That's it - no other verses! 🤔

Malfi · 16/10/2022 08:38

It’s the stirring music that makes Jerusalem
particularly evocative. The poem by anti-monarchist, anti-establishment, radical Blake isn’t really suitable for a national anthem. I’d think Blake would be appalled at how his poem has been corralled into support of nationalism and monarchy.

Sn0tnose · 16/10/2022 08:17

Christ no. Because we all know it wouldn’t be a straight swap to something a bit more rousing. The Culture Secretary would get involved, it would be seen as the perfect opportunity to try and distract us from the general shower of shit going on and it would end up being like choosing our Eurovision entry song, with X Factor contestants doing their best Mariah Carey impressions over a disco beat with choreographed dance moves and a video with shots of the White Cliffs of Dover

GSTK may well be a bit dreary. But we’re already a laughing stock. Can we please try and maintain a tiny bit of decorum?

DozyFox · 16/10/2022 07:57

I think the great thing about the religiousness of Jerusalem is that it's pretty easy to just see it as a metaphor.

Did Jesus visit England? In other words (to me anyway), is there something special about our country or not? It almost feels like clinging to an idea. And the desire to build 'Jerusalem', to me that's just very "we will make our country great". I like it because it's much more humble and inspiring than other "wow our country is already so great" options. Jerusalem has a sense of yearning, uncertainty, and determination which I think makes it special and a great option for an official English national anthem.

I think it's fine for an anthem to point to Christianity a little given the history of our country tbh.

That's just my interpretation anyway 😁

Wheredoallthepensgo · 15/10/2022 23:35

Nowt like Flower of Scotland being belted out by 80,000 fans at Murrayfield before a match. It's cracking.

Also love the Welsh anthem too, and the Welsh rugby fans sound amazing! It's like their team travels with the world's largest choir as backup Smile

GSTK is a very "tame" anthem isn't it. Not very rousing, spirited or inspiring. It drags. And yes it's awful the way it's used interchangeably for England and GB/U.K as if there's no problem with this. Hmm They are not the same and add to the frustrations of the other nations about how we are viewed.

purplecheesecat · 15/10/2022 22:33

As a republican, I too wish we had a different anthem! Obviously there are a lot of problems with classics like Jerusalem, I Vow to Thee my Country etc.
Yet despite its obvious faults I can’t help but to love La Marseillaise and I also find the Russian national anthem very stirring (without supporting any of the horrors in Ukraine being committed under that flag and anthem at the moment)
I think this indicates that what I hate most is the dreary and boring tune of our anthem and want something more rousing!

Stationsofthecross · 15/10/2022 21:58

I quite like our anthem 🤷🏻‍♀️

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 15/10/2022 21:55

NoodleSnow · 15/10/2022 10:36

The 5 Live Sports Report theme tune would make a brilliant national anthem. I think we should be like Spain and not have lyrics, because it’s always going to be too divisive.

Which is why Barwick Green (The Archers) is the only correct choice.

Jolly, up beat and so totally British as well

SerendipityJane · 15/10/2022 20:43

All we need is for King Charles to say he wants a different one. There really is nothing else that needs to be done.

I was hoping he'd ask for Jerusalem, as he's a Parry fan (and his BBC4 documentary on Parry was quite watchable). It's aspirational and written by a mystic. Britain doesn't have too many of them ...

FourChimneys · 15/10/2022 20:24

miceonabranch I hadn't really listened to the Ukranian one before. It's great, isn't it?

FuzzyPuffling · 15/10/2022 15:45

EmotionalSupportLynel · 15/10/2022 10:09

Danny Boy is a great tune and would sound brilliant as a belted out anthem, with some new words. That's my choice.

Danny Boy is a lament. Great tune, but shouldn't be sung "con belto".

FuzzyPuffling · 15/10/2022 15:44

LikeTearsInRain · 15/10/2022 08:13

What about Come On Eileen or The Proclaimers?

The Proclaimers are Scottish Nationalists.
Not sure that would work for a UK anthem.

miceonabranch · 15/10/2022 15:39

I love the Ukranian one 😃

girlfriend44 · 15/10/2022 15:21

yes agree.

DozyFox · 15/10/2022 13:24

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 14/10/2022 21:58

Definitely, ours is boring and completely irrelevant.
It does nothing to inspire feelings of pride.
I like Jerusalem.

I adore Jerusalem and wish it would be adopted more officially as England's national anthem - obviously it can't really be the U.K. anthem as it's quite specifically about England.

I don't know what we should have as the U.K. national anthem to be honest, but God save the King is spectacularly dull

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 15/10/2022 11:31

For me, winners of the thread are

  1. Italy. Fabulous tune, lyrics a bit combative but there are worse. Talking of which ...
  2. France. Tune one of the best, but very bloodthirsty lyrics
  3. Russia. Rousing music, non-combative lyrics representing pride in the country rather than fighting others (ironic, I know).
  4. USA. Great lyrics representing the birth of their nation, uplifting tune. Given the native American history though, I can see why even that would be problematic.
  5. Welsh. Absolutely great.

But in sum, nearly everybody's is better than ours.

BashfulClam · 15/10/2022 11:17

@MaChienEstUnDick Flower of Scotland isn’t about Culloden considering the Jacobites were defeated there. The Jacobites were made up of Scots and English just as the British Army was comprised of many Scots too. Culloden was never Scots V English it was Jacobites v the British Army. It’s not Ant-English if you listen to it in full ‘those days are past now, and in the past they must remain..’ so it’s saying we have to leave the past behind.

Malfi · 15/10/2022 11:04

jetadore · 15/10/2022 10:19

Could easily change England for Britain. The current one has something on about killing rebellious Scots!

No, that doesn’t work. Britain isn’t the right term either - because it doesn’t include Northern Ireland, for example.

NoodleSnow · 15/10/2022 10:36

The 5 Live Sports Report theme tune would make a brilliant national anthem. I think we should be like Spain and not have lyrics, because it’s always going to be too divisive.

SnoozyLucy7 · 15/10/2022 10:29

It’s archaic, medieval and outdated. We should be singing about our nation and the people in it etc, and not about one man with a crown and how utterly amazing he is. What nonsense. We need to move with the times.

jetadore · 15/10/2022 10:19

Malfi · 15/10/2022 07:18

Jerusalem as an alternative wouldn’t work at all - it’s all about England.

Could easily change England for Britain. The current one has something on about killing rebellious Scots!