Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think current home sellers are living in a fantasy world?

293 replies

CanStopWillStop · 14/10/2022 20:51

We are looking for a new home (out of necessity unfortunately!) so I am now deeply buried in Rightmove.

The most significant pattern I'm noticing is that dozens of sellers, who according to Land Registry bought their properties in 2019/2020, are listing their homes at £100-200k more than they paid two years ago.

Considering the current dire outlook for mortgages &cost of living etc, AIBU to think that this is absolutely ludicrous money they are chasing?

I understand some people may have remortgaged or are looking to upgrade but a £100,000 mark up on a 3-bed bungalow you've lived in for a couple of years is mind-blowing to me. What's happening here? Greed? Desperation? Do they really think people can actually get mortgages on overvalued properties? AIBU?

OP posts:
aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 15:34

earsup · 16/10/2022 15:19

here in gentfried east london, prices holding up....sales going thro....no reductions as little for sale....bank of mum and dad are sloshing the cash to the young couples around here.....skips within days of purchase....!!

Salubrious east London. Who'd have thunk it.

earsup · 16/10/2022 15:19

here in gentfried east london, prices holding up....sales going thro....no reductions as little for sale....bank of mum and dad are sloshing the cash to the young couples around here.....skips within days of purchase....!!

CentralLondonLife · 16/10/2022 15:06

happinessischocolate · 16/10/2022 15:02

And why haven't those cash buyers bought anything yet?

Waiting for the market to drop perhaps?

If it starts dropping at what point would they decide to buy? At the beginning of the drop or at the bottom?

Cash buyers for buy to let here
give a price as soon as property becomes available and leave it on the table

it is why non cash buyers never get the cheapest flats

happinessischocolate · 16/10/2022 15:02

Jessiesthedog · 16/10/2022 10:16

@Redqueenheart I think you fail to realise just how many cash buyers there are out there.

And why haven't those cash buyers bought anything yet?

Waiting for the market to drop perhaps?

If it starts dropping at what point would they decide to buy? At the beginning of the drop or at the bottom?

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 13:47

If you're not into reading lengthy documents, this was from 2003 in Ireland again cited during the inquiry.

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 13:23

CanStopWillStop · 15/10/2022 15:01

Perhaps the way I framed my original question wasn't clear or maybe even too provocative, to the extent that people are missing my point.

I am questioning why there is a sharp increase in price valuations, and it seems the answers I've heard is "well that's the going rate now" or" everyone else is selling for that price" which of course is something I understand BUT my question is... WHY?

Why does everyone (home sellers, estate agents, buyers) believe their homes are all worth £100k more than they paid two years ago... and as an additional question, how long before the bubble pops?

But in a housing boom something odd happens: when the price rises the demand actually increases. This is because people worry that prices will go yet higher

That's a quote from that document I linked to from David McWilliams.

vera99 · 16/10/2022 13:16

DoubleDinnurs · 16/10/2022 12:53

Are LDIs the new CDOs aboutanidiot?

They come from the same algo universe dreamt up by whizz kids PhD maths wonks gaming the financial system and at the same time making it unstable. Parasites anyways.

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 13:10

David McWilliams used to work for the equivalent of the BofE and as an investment bank economist. He was also a columnist.

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 13:08

This is an interesting testimony by a notable Economist to a parliamentary inquiry into the banking crisis in Ireland in 2008.

inquiries.oireachtas.ie/banking/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Opening-Statement-David-McWilliams.pdf

He was saying what the old-school estate agents were saying. Properties are being overpriced and people were over-exposed financially, but if you didn't play the game, you were going to go under yourself. They're one of the few estate agents still standing as their reputation was crucial to them.

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 12:57

DoubleDinnurs · 16/10/2022 12:53

Are LDIs the new CDOs aboutanidiot?

Not my area of expertise. In Finance I worked with the US market. It depends on what the underlying assets are.

DoubleDinnurs · 16/10/2022 12:53

Are LDIs the new CDOs aboutanidiot?

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 12:52

woff45 · 16/10/2022 12:50

@aboutanidiot do you own a house?

I do.

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 12:52

We had a client in 2009/2010 who had been a 'multi-millionaire' property developer. When the crash hit that country (EU country), he couldn't even receive job-seekers allowance as he had assets (severely depreciated assets, but considered assets nonetheless) but as he couldn't sell those assets, he had NO INCOME WHATSOVER. He couldn't rent them, nobody would buy them and the bank seized them in repayment of the debts he owed. Seizing them took time, but for the purposes of obtaining even the basic jobseekers allowance, he was a couple of years with no income whatsoever. He went from hero to zero in 2 years. His mental health deteriorated and the man became very ill. The stress was killing him. I've left that company so I don't know whether he ever got back on his feet.

woff45 · 16/10/2022 12:50

@aboutanidiot do you own a house?

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 12:44

rainingsnoring · 16/10/2022 11:47

The irony!

The market only picked up after the 2008 crash due to 'temporary', QE and ZIRP. Cheap credit. That is not an option now.
People may wish to buy now for their own personal reasons but that does not detract from the fact that asset prices will fall.

Yes. Agreed. Some people do not understand the nature of banking and mortgages!

aboutanidiot · 16/10/2022 12:44

sst1234 · 16/10/2022 10:39

You really think you did something there.

Look, you don’t understand how house ownership works. Just bow out instead of making a fool out of yourself.

Oh I understand alright. If your house is collateral for your mortgage, while on paper you might technically own it, the bank has a lien on it as you've used your house as collateral. For all intents and purposes, the bank "owns" whatever amount of the value of the property you still owe them.

rainingsnoring · 16/10/2022 11:47

sst1234 · 16/10/2022 10:39

You really think you did something there.

Look, you don’t understand how house ownership works. Just bow out instead of making a fool out of yourself.

The irony!

The market only picked up after the 2008 crash due to 'temporary', QE and ZIRP. Cheap credit. That is not an option now.
People may wish to buy now for their own personal reasons but that does not detract from the fact that asset prices will fall.

sst1234 · 16/10/2022 10:39

aboutanidiot · 15/10/2022 13:05

They bought at peak prices. The global economy crashed. People paid 1 mill for houses worth peanuts when they tried to sell.

If you cannot see that UK bonds are at risk of becoming junk bonds, that the market will crash, that the housing market is inflated, that we're headed into a recession with almost no more borrowing power, you're deluded!

It's like a perfect storm.

Are you 2 years old or something?

You really think you did something there.

Look, you don’t understand how house ownership works. Just bow out instead of making a fool out of yourself.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 16/10/2022 10:20

This country is weird about house prices.

It’s the same in many other countries, inc. the US (parts of it) Canada* and Australia, and part of Europe. A Swedish friend who returned to Stockholm and bought a flat there about 4 years ago told me recently how shocked she was at the price of an identical one in the same block now.

*A Canadian relative who visited recently told me how crazy prices have become in Toronto - she wonders how her dcs will ever be able to afford to buy. I gather that in Vancouver it’s considerably worse.

My sister’s area of Massachusetts has always been expensive, but even she was astonished when selling her house only a couple of years ago - two well over-asking price offers on the very first day of viewings. And she’d been startled at the EA’s valuation anyway.

You can still buy a house (relatively) very cheaply in various parts of France - we visit at least once a year so have seen many ‘A Vendre’ signs, but the cheap ones are in areas with very few jobs, and where (in many small town cases that I’ve seen) there are many boarded up shops, also for sale or to rent. French people we know in one attractive small town in Bourgogne have told us sadly that the town is dying.

Jessiesthedog · 16/10/2022 10:16

@Redqueenheart I think you fail to realise just how many cash buyers there are out there.

Redqueenheart · 16/10/2022 09:54

''@Mezmer
This is free market. Your house is worth as much as anyone is willing to pay for it. Prices are dictated purely by supply and demand. It’s the same for everything. 🙄''

This simplistic analysis is only correct if you assume that everyone is a cash buyer.

In reality if someone needs a mortgage then your house is going to be worth what the bank surveyor says it is worth and all will depend what buyers are able to borrow/what the bank will lend them which is based on practical things like deposit and wages.

So of course if mortgage interests are going up and the cost of living means people have less and less disposable income it will have an effect on the property market.

If people don't have enough money/can't save enough for a deposit and can't borrow from the banks they won't buy houses.

That's also how demand works...

vera99 · 16/10/2022 09:12

Taxation is never retrospective so the quick answer is no. But they will be looking to tax BTL more aggressively.

The Labour Party will look at raising the tax on rent from buy-to-let properties if elected, an MP has said.
In a speech on Friday (May 20), Tulip Siddiq, shadow economic secretary to the Treasury, said the party was committed to “unlocking capital”.
"Unearned income [such as rent on buy-to-let property] is taxed at a much lower rate than earned income,” she said.

Xenia · 16/10/2022 08:59

Some people pulling out because they are worried about much higher interest rates once any mortgage offer fix is over. I don't think in my bit of outer London London there is ashortage of buyers, so far just a massive shortgage of the kinds of properties people want to buy - either very cheap family houses with a garden or larger family houses for those with more money. We are still getting on our road glossy post cards from local estate agents encouraging us all to sell our houses. However anything over priced where the seller will not back down will not be selling now.

I certainly remember the 1990s. We bought our third home (i.e. 3rd move having gone from terraced to semi and then the 1990 detached one) and had only been able to afford it with an interest only loan where some of the interest was not paid now and was added to the loan - known as a deferred interest mortgage and it was based on 4x my salary. Interest rates were about 10% in 1990. I remember the day base rate rose 2% and then 3% in one day - Black wednesday. We also had bought 2 small flats which I now call buy to lose flats as they made losses all the time and when we sold them in about 1996 we sold them at about 50% less than we paid for them. I sitll have never been able to use those income and capital losses. We also then sold our family house in 1997 at a loss too over the 1990 price and bought then where I currently live.

I wonder if Labour bring in big property taxes on London houses they will compensate those of us who have made big losses on our homes in the past?

vera99 · 16/10/2022 08:57

Notjustanymum · 16/10/2022 07:33

Where we live, homes are being put out at a high price to bid, and generally make £150,000+ over the asking price. That’s because our area is being somewhat colonised by people from neighbouring areas that are now so expensive that even the high earners that previously lived there can’t afford to move to larger houses there.
When these buyers move in, they typically extend sideways, into the loft and back into the generous gardens, turning the housing stock from typically 3-bed into 4-6 bed properties, and generally “gentrifying “ the area, making it out of reach for young people to purchase to be near their own parents and the place they grew up in.
It’s terrifying to think that in the 25 years we’ve lived here, house price average has risen to TEN times more than it was in the late 1990’s, especially since wages/salaries haven’t - and it means that the demographic is also very different now, too…
If that’s not the case in your area, OP, try making offers under the asking price, but be prepared for these to be unaccepted - at least until the houses have been on the market for some time with no offers at asking price, that is…

Sounds like East Dulwich where I used to live the housing stock is mostly small victorian terraced 3 bedders so these maxed-out houses have a bit of Emperor's new clothes about them as the tiny land footprints aspire to be Notting Hill or Hamstead but never will be. Posh and very yummy mummy though and I did very well out of it having bought in 1987 when it was more than a tad rough. But back then London was cheap and that's what made it so good - everybody could find their price point, buying, renting and even squatting.

user1471538283 · 16/10/2022 08:17

I'm looking and noticed this. One home had nothing done to it in 2 years and yet the vendor expects £90k profit to "enjoy the money". I saw a home yesterday that is up for the same as a well fitted out one that sold last year. It's like they think that's the ceiling price so I'll have that.

When I last spoke to an EA she said that there are so many homes coming to market but so few buyers.

I'm all ready to go but I will not and cannot buy at these prices.