Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Underinsurance - insurers trying it on?

41 replies

Aleaiactaest · 14/10/2022 17:10

OK I admit to name changing for this and I might be being unreasonable but here goes…

Just had a classic leak situation in my house. A leaky pipe behind a kitchen cabinet leaking for months causing some damage into a utility room below, some flooring etc. Have quite expensive home insurance, renewed annually etc. - it is like ÂŁ1000 a year.

When I bought the house 10 years ago the building surveyor stated rebuild cost would be max 500,000k. Every year since the building sum insurance has been adjusted upwards slightly. It is now at around 750,000k which seems loads. Especially because a similar house next door was built from scratch 5 years who for about 450k and all shiny new etc.

Anyway, the loss adjuster shows up and states we are massively underinsured because apparently in the last two years according to RICS March 2020 to 2021 build cost went up 8 per cent and March 2021 to March 20212 a whopping 18.3%. He has plucked the March figure although the loss was in August and the claim is only being addressed now.
So they are not going to cover the whole leak and will only cover around 70 per cent and they want us to pay to have the house revalued properly etc etc.

Thankfully we don’t have a big fire etc. and all destroyed. But just a word of warning to others out there that rebuild costs have gone up massively.
Or are they trying this on?
Are they really going to do similar to some poor family who have lost their house in a fire etc?

OP posts:
Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 19:03

I wonder if it works the other way so that if you overestimate the reinstatement cost of your home you get more than the cost of your repair...

Crispynoodle · 14/10/2022 19:02

I have had a leak in the floor and remarkably my insurance is paying for us to move out, refloor 5 rooms at ÂŁ35 per m squared, wall tiles at the same cost, new skirting and architraves and,unbelievably, a whole new kitchen. We can't believe it! Our kitchen was 40 years old....

AbsolutelyNebulous · 14/10/2022 18:58

It’s called the condition of average and it’s standard in insurance policies. Can you speak to your Broker given that’s who increased the sum insured each year ie you were depending on their knowledge?

Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 18:57

It is not reasonable for insurers to expect the general public to know the reinstatement cost of the their home. The onus should be on them to estimate it not their customer. As for them then trying to wriggle out of a claim because the customer underestimated the total build cost is utterly ridiculous regardless of what it says in the small print.

Aleaiactaest · 14/10/2022 18:57

The thing is at SunneRising I did kind of know this is how it works but I just did a standard yearly renewal not realising rebuild costs have gone up 8, 8, and then 18 per cent in the last 3 years alone, those are huge increases because they are compounded!

OP posts:
SunneRising · 14/10/2022 18:54

It's not a scam or a way to reduce what they pay out - it's how insurance works! I wish schools taught this sort of thing because it's basic and affects us all.

Plexie · 14/10/2022 18:49

Bottomofthepileasusual · 14/10/2022 18:38

Why has the rebuild value got anything to do with your repairs though? You aren't claiming for a rebuild.
I'd threaten them with the FSA and lodge a complaint

It's a way for them to reduce they amount they pay out. Even if you don't need a total rebuild, they argue that any building repairs are proportional to the cost of rebuilding the whole property. If your insurance cover is less than what would be needed to rebuild the property, they call that being under-insured and will use it to justify paying only a proportion of any repair costs.

It's not the case that if your cover is, say ÂŁ500k, and you need extensive repairs but not total rebuild, that they will pay up to ÂŁ500k for the repairs. They would say, your house would actually cost ÂŁ750k to rebuild, therefore you're whatever-percentage under-insured and we'll only cover a proportion of the cost of (eg) repairing your bathroom and kitchen after a water leak, not the full amount.

2bazookas · 14/10/2022 18:40

"Members of the public can't be expected to know how much it will cost to rebuild their homes,"

Every insurer I've ever had, has always told me in writing, how and where to work out the rebuild cost. Every policy I've ever had, has warned that underinsuring risks only partial compensation in a claim.

Bottomofthepileasusual · 14/10/2022 18:38

Why has the rebuild value got anything to do with your repairs though? You aren't claiming for a rebuild.
I'd threaten them with the FSA and lodge a complaint

Aleaiactaest · 14/10/2022 18:12

Thanks for all the input.

The RICS calculator does suggest a higher rebuild cost then 750,000k but that was always adjusted upwards yearly by the broker. In March 21 it would have been 750k, this March it would be almost 900k. I had no idea nor did the broker who sold me the policy adjust it to that level.

So yes, they are saying I am underinsured and so they will only pay a proportion of the claim. So let’s say I get quotes and the claim works out 4000 they will say I am underinsured by X percentage and adjust the 4000 down by that percentage. Then they will also take off the excess of a few hundred pounds.

Anyone reading this check your property’s rebuild value on the RICS calculator to be on the safe side!!!

My house actually has a big garden too - if the property would cost 900k to rebuild plus the property value in Outer London I should really be sitting on a 1.5million property… Sadly that is not the case.

So have these rebuild costs got anything to do with the property crash everyone is talking about? Because how does that make sense if it is so expensive to build a property in the first place.

OP posts:
Plexie · 14/10/2022 17:51

Yes, I'd say they are trying it on. I know someone who had a fire in a rental property they owned (the property was partially damaged, not totally destroyed) and his insurance company said the same thing - it was underinsured and they'd only pay a proportion of the repair costs. He argued it and they changed their minds and covered the whole lot.

I think the industry standard used to be ÂŁ500k and that was based on a cost to rebuild the property, not it's market value (which might actually be higher). I have no idea of rebuild costs and was relieved when our insurers increased it to ÂŁ1m a few years ago (with no change to our premiums - which are considerably less than ÂŁ1k a year BTW).

Members of the public can't be expected to know how much it will cost to rebuild their homes, and absolutely no one commissions an estimate every year to give to their insurance company! Insurers need to factor in the risk of building cost increases into their calculations when setting premiums.

SusannahD · 14/10/2022 17:39

Rebuild costs have increased drastically in the last 2 years, caused by brexit and covid, tradespeople are in short supply as well as building materials, if your house is under insured the insurer will be applying average to your claim which is standard practice.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 14/10/2022 17:31

Who has been adjusting the sum insured upwards each year, you or the insurance company?

Muststopeating · 14/10/2022 17:29

Surely they should pay for the whole lot up to 750k???? Different if the whole house burned down but unless there are % based limits I don't see how they can justify that???

RiderOfTheBlue · 14/10/2022 17:24

Some insurers offer policies with unlimited buildings cover, e.g. eSure. Worth considering that when your next renewal is due.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/10/2022 17:14

You can use this calculator for free
Rebuild calculator

Check what this says then you can challenge the insurers if needed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread