Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Underinsurance - insurers trying it on?

41 replies

Aleaiactaest · 14/10/2022 17:10

OK I admit to name changing for this and I might be being unreasonable but here goes…

Just had a classic leak situation in my house. A leaky pipe behind a kitchen cabinet leaking for months causing some damage into a utility room below, some flooring etc. Have quite expensive home insurance, renewed annually etc. - it is like ÂŁ1000 a year.

When I bought the house 10 years ago the building surveyor stated rebuild cost would be max 500,000k. Every year since the building sum insurance has been adjusted upwards slightly. It is now at around 750,000k which seems loads. Especially because a similar house next door was built from scratch 5 years who for about 450k and all shiny new etc.

Anyway, the loss adjuster shows up and states we are massively underinsured because apparently in the last two years according to RICS March 2020 to 2021 build cost went up 8 per cent and March 2021 to March 20212 a whopping 18.3%. He has plucked the March figure although the loss was in August and the claim is only being addressed now.
So they are not going to cover the whole leak and will only cover around 70 per cent and they want us to pay to have the house revalued properly etc etc.

Thankfully we don’t have a big fire etc. and all destroyed. But just a word of warning to others out there that rebuild costs have gone up massively.
Or are they trying this on?
Are they really going to do similar to some poor family who have lost their house in a fire etc?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kirinm · 07/11/2022 07:58

Underinsurance is a big issue for insurers at the moment because rebuild costs are dramatically increasing and showing no signs of slowing down.

It isn't a try on. It is a clear question that is important to ensure insurers have sufficient money available - it directly impacts premiums.

Luckydip1 · 15/10/2022 11:29

Unlimited cover is the way to go to stop these bastards trying to wriggle out of the claims.

Aleaiactaest · 15/10/2022 11:26

Yes, I think that is the safe way to do it! Always get unlimited buildings cover. Especially in this climate.

The thing is my general insurance fact sheet states “unlimited buildings cover as standard unless agreed otherwise”. The broker never highlighted that they went out and got a limited cover “agreed otherwise” and deviated from the norm. And I am paying a big premium. It is all a little strange. Also my new insurer took over my previous insurers book of business because the previous insurance stopped doing it. It is all rather strange and confusing. When I try to call up the new insurer it says it is a commercial insurer.

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 15/10/2022 11:09

I've checked my cover and the buildings element is unlimited.

NoseyNellie · 15/10/2022 10:37

The insurers are being (relatively) reasonable, your brokers have f*cked up by not advising you up your coverage.

Your brokers will have professional indemnity cover to claim against so I would start discussions about them covering the shortfall on the repairs and if a polite conversation with a senior partner doesn’t get you anywhere, it will be time to take legal action against the broker.

2bazookas · 15/10/2022 10:09

Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 20:37

If you overinsure you pay a higher premium than you should.

Nonsense. My rebuild cover is I million (standard) and my annual premium is just over ÂŁ100. Compared to OP''s ÂŁ1000.

It's cheap because my property, security and claims history makes me a golden client to insurers. At every renewal I go to a comparison site and let them fight/beg for my business.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/10/2022 21:24

"I'd keep querying what the relationship is between the value of the building and the value of an (interior) claim. I'd also suggest maybe cross posting in Legal or asking MNHQ to move the thread for you"

This is well meaning but ultimately pointless advice. The condition of average doesnt apply separately to different parts of the policy, you dont pay separate premiums for separate contracts to insure buildings and contents, you have to pay the correct premium for the policy and if you haven't because of under insurance then average applies to any property claim irrespective of what property is under insured.

This is a basic principle of insurance. You can't base the contract on sums insured lower than reinstatement / replacement costs as then you're not paying a fair premium, if this was allowed then people would regularly under insure, premiums would be artificially low, claims would still be paid at the same level, and insurance companies would quickly to bankrupt or stop writing property.

If you were allowed to claim more than the value of your damaged property because you were insuring for more than they were worth, then this would clearly lead to fraudulent claims (already billions per year). People would insure their property for much more than it was worth then damage it.

It's a basic principle of insurance law and claims settlement that policyholders pay a premium that is proportionate to the risk (ie based on the correct sums insured) and put policyholders back in the exact same financial position as they were in before the loss.

Lots of household policies have various inflation protection built in for example my insurance policy has rebuild costs banding, eg up to ÂŁ1m so you dont have to pick a specific rebuild value

Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 20:37

If you overinsure you pay a higher premium than you should.

7catsisnotenough · 14/10/2022 20:24

Hi OP, we're on the downward side of an insurance claim for similar damage at DMIL's house, the insurance company have never queried the house valuation. MIL had a hidden leak behind vanity units in the upstairs bathroom and it caused major damage (rot etc in floorboards ) I'd keep querying what the relationship is between the value of the building and the value of an (interior) claim. I'd also suggest maybe cross posting in Legal or asking MNHQ to move the thread for you

Thiswayorthatway · 14/10/2022 20:16

If you underinsure then you pay less premium than you should.

SunneRising · 14/10/2022 20:07

Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 19:54

So if you over insure they can deny your claim?, is that correct?

Yes if they think you've done it on purpose to defraud them. If you say your house is worth double what it is and claim that your kitchen would cost ÂŁ40k to replace, (when actually it was IKEA and would cost ÂŁ10k to replace).
I don't think they'd worry if you overestimated your rebuild costs by a couple of thousand though. But wise to use the calculator.

Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 20:04

So if I under insure they pay less of the claim and if I over insure they don't may more than the claim, what a scam, how do they get away with this.

prettybird · 14/10/2022 20:00

I actually had an argument with our broker last month about the rebuild value when I was renewing our buildings and contents insurance: it was something silly like ÂŁ300k and I said that was ridiculously low. She asked how much a similar house would sell for and I said the house opposite (like ours: the upper half of a Victorian stone villa but without the converted loft that we have) had sold recently for cÂŁ400k - but that that had zero correlation with rebuild costs.

She then quoted me a renewal cost that was high, with a slightly increased rebuild cost but I still considered the rebuild cost too low.

Anyway, I went and searched and found the RICS calculator. Plugged in the details (stone built three foot thick sandstone walls slate roof, first floor and attic floor and entrance on the ground floor, in a conservation area) and it came out at close to ÂŁ1million Shock - I even had to slightly underestimate as the on-line calculator couldn't cope with I think the combination of size and being over 3 floors. Confused

Plugged it into a comparison website and found buildings and contents insurance with Tesco Bank for half what the broker had quoted Shock Re-build cost is unlimited so I'm confident we're covered. And yes, I've read the fine print of the policy Wink

Plus I know that our downstairs neighbours also have good insurance, so that should the worst happen and our house be raised to the ground for whatever reason, between us we're more than covered to get it rebuilt Grin

drpet49 · 14/10/2022 19:59

2bazookas · 14/10/2022 18:40

"Members of the public can't be expected to know how much it will cost to rebuild their homes,"

Every insurer I've ever had, has always told me in writing, how and where to work out the rebuild cost. Every policy I've ever had, has warned that underinsuring risks only partial compensation in a claim.

This. l’ve always over insured

ScruffGin · 14/10/2022 19:57

I'd complain to your broker, this is what you're paying them for!

Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 19:54

So if you over insure they can deny your claim?, is that correct?

TheCraicDealer · 14/10/2022 19:30

I’m an LA (not property though) and we’ve been getting regular company wide emails about the exponential increase in materials and labour since Spring 2020. The adjuster who came out to you was right. I would be taking this up with your broker. My property colleagues have been doing regular pieces on LinkedIn and also email drops to work contacts, including brokers, publicising this since the first lockdown. The rebuild amount might have been specified by you, but they should have warned all their clients about the increase in costs and given you the chance to factor this in- it’s literally the type of advice you’re paying a broker a premium for. I would go back to your broker and advise them of the adjuster’s position and ask them how they intend to resolve it.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/10/2022 19:29

It's not the small print though it's a legal contract that people agree to - as well as being one if the major conditions in the policy it's usually pointed out as an important condition in the policy summary and brokers should be pointing it out as well. Insurers could do more to make their wordings clear and try and help people understand them but being honest if people dont read the overview documenta are they going to read other additional docs? If someone has insured for x amount, paid a premium based on x amount, then insurers will pay claims based on x amount, not more because someone didn't realise or properly read their documents.

Plexie · 14/10/2022 19:23

Thanks to this thread I've used the rebuild calculator and the calculation for my house is reassuringly well below the ÂŁ1m cover of my policy. (Although now I'm worried I've miscalculated floorspace or something, as it's a lot lower than the OP's house. Maybe she lives in a mansion??) And I've downloaded a pdf of the report.

It's free to use but you need to register, and can make up to 4 calculations (per year?).

calculator.bcis.co.uk/

SunneRising · 14/10/2022 19:22

And if you deliberately over-insure that's also likely to result in a declined claim.

SunneRising · 14/10/2022 19:18

Aleaiactaest - sorry my comment wasn't aimed at you at all and probably came across as harsh. A few others seemed not to know - and I despair that the basics of insurance, finance, credit cards, mortgages, banking, marriage contracts, rental contracts, wills etc are not taught in schools or understood by so many.

I hope your leak gets fixed.

NoSquirrels · 14/10/2022 19:17

Something similar with a relative’s house - apparently now the rebuild cost is £300,000 greater than the property’s maximum market valuation. It’s bonkers.

Luckydip1 · 14/10/2022 19:17

From now on I'm going to overestimate by 50% so they can't try this on. They are taking the p....

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/10/2022 19:11

The condition of Average is in every single property insurance contract. You have to insure for the whole cost of reinstatement / replacement and if you don't, then any claim would be proportionately reduced by the same ratio that you've under insured by.

If insurers didnt do this, then people would knowingly under insure, banking on the fact that they are extremely unlikely to have a total loss. Insurers would still pay out the same claims but be getting less premium and would go under. The onus is on policyholders to get their rebuild costs right and there are online calculators that can help with this. Obviously it's harder if your house isnt as 'standard' as others eg is bigger or has some special design features or in a location that makes it hard to build on.

If you have a broker though, you are literally paying them for their insurance advice - did they advise you about inflation and uplifts and checking rebuild values at renewal? This has been happening for a year so they should have. So you might be able to get them to contribute if they have been negligent in the advice they provided

Plexie · 14/10/2022 19:06

Every insurer I've ever had, has always told me in writing, how and where to work out the rebuild cost.

Ours doesn't. We've been with them for decades and just renew every year.

However I've found this in our small print:

"Index linking: The buildings limit of cover may be increased during the period of this insurance in line with the House Rebuilding Cost Index prepared by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors."

Perhaps OP should check whether her policy contains similar?