Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to look after her too!

64 replies

abstractplantpot · 14/10/2022 15:46

I'm a Sahm married with 3 children aged 20 down to 7. 20 yr old is away in another country at Uni. Two dc left at home. My mother has Denmetia and i'm her main carer.

I have one sister (3 yrs older) who helps care for mum but she works full time her mental health is fragile and she is tired a lot. She is quite immature for her age. Her friends tend to be much younger until they settle down then she is left on her own.

People tend to love her when they first meet her because she is giggling and happy and full of life but after a way they fall away because she talks constantly about her pets and doesn't really seem to live in the real world. I love her to bits and i'm worried what will happen when we get older.

She is 52. She has had a few boyfriends but generally the men who are interested in her aren't what she wants. She doesn't want to compromise in a relationship so i guess she is going to be single for a while yet.

I have always said I'd like to move away to the country for my retirement. DH and I have been looking out at houses which we could invest in as a holiday home and then retire too. DS has made it clear she expects us to include her in all our old age plans as she has no one else.

AIBU to not want this! I can only tolerate the silliness and nonsense for short bursts. How do I tell her it's not happening?

OP posts:
Sikaris · 14/10/2022 19:23

7eleven · 14/10/2022 17:13

You really don’t like your sister, do you. She sounds vulnerable and with poor mental health. Annoying, but she’s your sister! Stop talking crap about her and help her get some professional help.

She doesn't have to like her and she isn't her responsibility.

The sister could get help herself, or her parents can arrange it.

Daleksatemyshed · 14/10/2022 19:07

@OriginalUsername2 makes a very good point her Op, some people can feel that family means you'll always look after them but they don't feel the need to return the favour. It's difficult with your DM but please don't let her make you feel you HAVE to look after your DS, she isn't your responsibilty, she has her own home, work and friends so it's not like your planning to abandon someone who can't fend for themselves.
I do wonder if she's not had any serious relationships she doesn't understand that a married couple really don't want someone else living with them?
For now, take care of your DM but don't be so available for your DS, you can't go from seeing her at the drop of a hat to nothing overnight

1FootInTheRave · 14/10/2022 19:07

She sounds similar to my sister tbh. My sister is a lovely, kind human and I adore her. But, she is lackadaisical and doesn't really take responsibility for herself.

She is still living with my parents and there is no way on gods green earth will I ever be taking over facilitating her poor life choices.

Before I'm jumped on she is nt. Some minor mh issues but probably less than my own tbh.

7eleven · 14/10/2022 19:05

I wouldn’t want to live with either of my sisters either. I don’t talk shit about them on social media though. I think it’s in the sister’s interest to stay away from the OP. How sad that the sister thinks they’re close and doesn’t realise how she’s thought of. Really disrespectful.

I could be biased though as I’ve just bought my cats advent calendars 😂

JudgeJ · 14/10/2022 19:00

7eleven · 14/10/2022 17:13

You really don’t like your sister, do you. She sounds vulnerable and with poor mental health. Annoying, but she’s your sister! Stop talking crap about her and help her get some professional help.

Sounds to me like she's never bothered to look after herself and is used to having others runs around after her. The OP has no responsibility to take her into her home, she has her own house and needs to learn to be less pseudo-needy.

OriginalUsername2 · 14/10/2022 18:53

Socially challenged people can sometimes be completely unaware of the need to reciprocate and put effort into relationships.. maybe it wouldn’t hurt to point these things out to her.

OriginalUsername2 · 14/10/2022 18:51

I’m usually a suit myself person but I don’t know about this one. Your sister sounds quite vulnerable and like she has trouble with managing money, plus a bit socially challenged.

But she’s working and helping you care for your mum, so she’s maintaining her relationships with the family. She sounds like a good person who needs a bit of support in life. sounds like your mum is aware of this.

Reading your post I do feel bad for her.

That said, I wouldn’t want her to move in with me either! Maybe you can help her come up with a plan for her future and be a distant support with occasional visits.

abstractplantpot · 14/10/2022 18:40

I should add, sister is independent and is quite capable of running her own life and keeping herself happy when everything is rosie. When life throws a curve ball and all her friends are too busy or not available I get a call to help - which I invariably do. I have done as long as I can remember. I will also say this isn't reciprocated. DS will prioritise her friends and their needs over me and mum.

Mums health is deteriorating quickly so I would say she will have passed on before I move. i will be moving about 4 hours away. As I said initiallly it will be as a holiday home then if we find schools etc for the younger kids we will move permanently. She says she imagines she will live here for about 10 yrs or so then "retire" with us.

Sometimes I feel i'm being unfair and she's my only sister and I should suck it up and accept i need to look after her in later life. Then she will ring specifically to tell me her rabbit kissed her to waken her this morning and I just know i can't live with it!

OP posts:
hardtochangename · 14/10/2022 18:32

I suppose one complication is your mother's health and how her dementia progresses. Is your sister worried about being left with the main responsibility of caring for your mum if you move? How far away might you be moving? If it's a few hours drive is Sis coming to stay or visit? She can't seriously think she can move in with you but it would be difficult to stop her buying a house in the same area.

Crucible · 14/10/2022 18:30

Here's a good one for most folks on this thread;
'Boundaries are the distance at which I am able to love you and me.'

Coatdegroan · 14/10/2022 18:26

@Choccolocko it sounds like you are very supportive to your brother. I agree if he was fine you should move abroad if you got an opportunity you wanted to follow.

For me, I know my sister would probably not be OK as she needs human contact, and wiuld become very lonely and isolated. I have probably compromised my life in some ways. Nothing major..but I don't have as many friends as many people.because I don't have time or energy left for many other people. The alternative would be to do more of what I want and cut down the time I spend with my sister. This would lead to a build up of problems for her which ultimately I would end up dealing with so it isn't worth it.

As I have become more patient I fo find I enjoy spending time with her as we find mutual things we enjoy.

At the end of the day, life isn't always easy or fair. I abandoned my sister a little bit when I had young children as I was too busy and stressed... it didn't make me feel good. Ultimately, I guess it is about finding the right balance for you.

You can look at it in that you only have 1 life, you.mist do x y and z which you always dreamed of doing...or you only have 1 life, you need to try to give what you are able to help as you wouldn't want to look back and regret not helping.

I do agree that homing someone needy who can actually manage to live independently is beyond the call of duty.

Choccolocko · 14/10/2022 17:55

@Coatdegroan But that’s not what the sister is looking for. My DB has mental health issues. We speak twice a day and I see him twice a week. That will likely continue until I/he dies.

But if I wanted to move abroad and I knew my brother could cope without me I would hate to think that I couldn’t do it. I mean, where does caring for others end and thinking about yourself become a possibility

Coatdegroan · 14/10/2022 17:52

Could she have ADHD?
Whilst its important to have a life and not just give it over to supoorting others, I'm a little bit erring on the side of what @7eleven said.

I have a sister with special needs. I've had to give support in various ways since I was born. She can be really hard work and really full on and annoying. But she's also got some really good sides and I'd hate to think what wiukd happen to her if I wasn't able amd willing to spend some time with her.

It doesn't sound like your DS needs to move in, and you could kindly let her know that. However I don't agree with these people saying you only have one life, you need to do what you.want etc. It seems quite uncaring. Life is also paetly about helping those who need it, even if they are sometimes annoying.

RealBecca · 14/10/2022 17:52

Annoying your mum had 2 kids and expects you to look after your sister. I understand why she worries but it's a really unfair expectation to place on you.

Choccolocko · 14/10/2022 17:51

7eleven · 14/10/2022 17:13

You really don’t like your sister, do you. She sounds vulnerable and with poor mental health. Annoying, but she’s your sister! Stop talking crap about her and help her get some professional help.

You have obviously never had the weight of looking after several family members, on your shoulders.

OP you are not responsible for anyones mental health or future.

Tell your sister now that you are planning a quiet retirement with your husband. Say it’s not going to be up to you as to whether or not she moves close to you but you will not be responsible for her and she will not be living with you. You are entitled to retire from caring duties when children are reared and parents have passed away. Siblings who don’t need care (and you sister doesn’t need it, she just wants it) need to make their own lives

AcrossthePond55 · 14/10/2022 17:44

willingtolearn · 14/10/2022 16:36

You need to change 'other people's expectations'.

Start with your sister and your mother.

When they jokingly or seriously say she's living with you say 'No, that's not something I'm prepared to do, you/she will have to make her own arrangements'.

You get one life, do not give it to other people.

@abstractplantpot

I agree with PP, but I think you'll have to take it one step further. Replying to their 'joking' won't get them to take you seriously. They'll just assume you don't mean it.

You need to have a serious sit-down with your sister NOW and have a no holds barred conversation. Say baldly that she will NOT be moving in with you, discussion over. Tell her what (if anything) you would be willing to do should you or a medical source determine she needs help. But do it NOW when she's still young enough to make other plans. If she chooses not to or not to believe you, that's on her. And I'd tell her that, too.

Leave your mother out of your discussion with your sister, but don't be blackmailed by her when DS inevitably runs to her to tattle. In cases such as these I think it's perfectly acceptable to dodge the issue and refuse to discuss it.

A totally different scenario, but my DBro was a bad alcoholic (sober now 7 years). We made it clear to him that he would never be allowed to live with us nor would we ever enable take care of him. If our mum (who never knew how bad he was) had asked us to, frankly I would have lied to her. DBro would have known the truth.

BMW6 · 14/10/2022 17:43

7eleven · 14/10/2022 17:13

You really don’t like your sister, do you. She sounds vulnerable and with poor mental health. Annoying, but she’s your sister! Stop talking crap about her and help her get some professional help.

Bollocks to that.
She doesn't have to like a sibling. No-one does. Nor is she obligated to take care of her.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 14/10/2022 17:36

Next time she says something about it, be clear "I realise you're probably joking but just to be clear, we aren't going to ask you to live with us"

And she can't force you to let her live with you so don't worry about it too much, at the end of the day it won't happen unless you choose to.

2bazookas · 14/10/2022 17:30

You can just use the situation with your mum. You, and DH, just keep telling Sis

"Poor old Mum, it is really heavy going for years being responsible for her. But it's shown us one thing for certain; when mum is gone Plantpot /DH and I are going to be FREE to live our own lives, and will never ever share it with anyone else again. "

2bazookas · 14/10/2022 17:22

Just lie.

Whenever she refers to it, you just say " With all the economic uncertainty we're making no plans at all. Decided to stay put. "

Never, ever discuss your intentions or future move with her or in her hearing.

abstractplantpot · 14/10/2022 17:16

@BigglyBee oh no! That sounds horrible for you.

My father did support ds before he died but I don't think we ever thought she had learning difficulties.

She doesn't have Autism, I know this because she went to the GP with a long list of "reasons why she thought she had Autism" He told her there wasn't enough evidence to refer her.

I think I'm just going to have to start managing the expectations from now on!

OP posts:
7eleven · 14/10/2022 17:13

You really don’t like your sister, do you. She sounds vulnerable and with poor mental health. Annoying, but she’s your sister! Stop talking crap about her and help her get some professional help.

BigglyBee · 14/10/2022 17:10

I have a sister who sounds very like yours, OP. Unfortunately, her obvious learning and MH difficulties have never been addressed because my father forbade it. (Before someone asks, because he is a twat). He allowed/encouraged her to become very dependent on our parents, despite having her own house. Then they retired and fecked off to Shetland. Since then, she has tried to make me responsible for her in the same way that our parents were. I have four kids, a farm, a business and an elderly husband to take care of, I don't have the time, patience or will to do that. I shudder to think what her retirement plans are, but she does know that she has a sister with a farm...

In the end, I had to cut her off entirely. She isn't the sort of person who can take no for an answer, and is sometimes violent, so I just stayed away and blocked her in every way I could. I did try explaining to her that I can't help her in the way that she wants, but she genuinely seems to believe that she is doing me a favour by letting me become her personal slave (because we're famly, don't you know).

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 14/10/2022 17:06

You just tell her it isn't going to happen.

MeowMeowPowerRangers · 14/10/2022 17:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.