Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to look after her too!

64 replies

abstractplantpot · 14/10/2022 15:46

I'm a Sahm married with 3 children aged 20 down to 7. 20 yr old is away in another country at Uni. Two dc left at home. My mother has Denmetia and i'm her main carer.

I have one sister (3 yrs older) who helps care for mum but she works full time her mental health is fragile and she is tired a lot. She is quite immature for her age. Her friends tend to be much younger until they settle down then she is left on her own.

People tend to love her when they first meet her because she is giggling and happy and full of life but after a way they fall away because she talks constantly about her pets and doesn't really seem to live in the real world. I love her to bits and i'm worried what will happen when we get older.

She is 52. She has had a few boyfriends but generally the men who are interested in her aren't what she wants. She doesn't want to compromise in a relationship so i guess she is going to be single for a while yet.

I have always said I'd like to move away to the country for my retirement. DH and I have been looking out at houses which we could invest in as a holiday home and then retire too. DS has made it clear she expects us to include her in all our old age plans as she has no one else.

AIBU to not want this! I can only tolerate the silliness and nonsense for short bursts. How do I tell her it's not happening?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
7eleven · 15/10/2022 09:42

🤦‍♀️ It’s like everyone has learnt a new word - narcissist.

Fimofriend · 15/10/2022 09:36

How is it "slagging someone off on social media" when it is anonymous? OP is probably deliberately venting on MN instead of to her IRL friends in order to avoid hurting her sister's feelings.

As to the posters who are offended because OP doesn't feel close to her sister even though her sister thinks they ste close: Narcissists usually think that everyone loves them. It is NOT mean to not love a narcissist. OP is obviously neither rude nor mean to her sister. It actually seems as if she ought to be less polite to her. She helps the sister all the time and the sister doesn't reciprocate but is quite selfish.

Daleksatemyshed · 15/10/2022 09:31

@abstractplantpot unless someone's cared for a parent with dementia they have no idea how tricky it can be. Every time I thought I had evrrything sorted my DM managed to surprise me! Feel free to PM me if it will help

notputtingtheheatingon · 15/10/2022 09:23

I don't think you're being unreasonable but I think this really needs to be addressed. Sometimes families place their expectations on us by 'casually mentioning' a thing and if we don't push back, in their minds it can become a 'done deal'.

If your sister had no one else in her life then I think it's reasonable that she might want to move when you do and if you're comfortable with that, just make it clear that she wouldn't be moving in with you and that she'd need to live independently. Rural living has its challenges so you could ask her if she's considered all that. E.g how she would see her friends regularly etc. In other words, you've no issue with her living close by but you're not going to be looking after her.

Set out your boundaries now. They'll be a lot tougher to enforce the longer this conversation doesn't take place.

caringcarer · 15/10/2022 09:16

When you talk about moving to the country and she mentions coming with you, just say sorry sis but this is DH and my romantic adventure together once children grown up and moved out. You will have to sort out your own adventure.

billy1966 · 15/10/2022 09:13

OP,
Hard boundaries are required.

Your sister doesn't get to decide to move into your home and retire.

You do not owe her that.

You need to start telling her that it is not happening.

You have enough caring responsibilities.

Your sister might be suited to an assisted living space with a warden etc.

abstractplantpot · 15/10/2022 09:06

@Daleksatemyshed This is exactly it! caring for mum is exhausting. I have no headspace for anything extra.

OP posts:
Daleksatemyshed · 15/10/2022 09:01

@abstractplantpot I'm afraid you seem to have hit a sore spot with some people here judging by their posts. You've spent years looking after your DC, DH and now your DM and I know how hard it is to care for someone with Dementia. Your youngest DC is still a child and you're caught between childcare and caring. I know by the time my DM passed I could not have taken on anyone else, I was stressed out and ill.
Your DS reminds me of someone I knew , she claimed everyone as a friend but she soon wore her friends out, she was too intense, you had to keep strong boundsries with her or she took your life over.
You can love your DS but still find them too much .

GoldenGorilla · 15/10/2022 05:59

fuckinghorgel · 14/10/2022 20:02

Why don't your parents or the other siblings take them in?

@fuckinghorgel - sibling currently lives with our parents but they’re ageing and finding it harder and harder to cope - I’m one of 4 but the others don’t have big enough houses. I hesitated for ages about buying this house (large spare room) because I knew we’d get this pressure!

giggly · 15/10/2022 00:34

7eleven · 14/10/2022 17:13

You really don’t like your sister, do you. She sounds vulnerable and with poor mental health. Annoying, but she’s your sister! Stop talking crap about her and help her get some professional help.

This in bucketfuls. I’m curious as to what your retiring from to move to the country?

7eleven · 15/10/2022 00:23

Cameleongirl · 15/10/2022 00:11

No, @7eleven , but people do come on MN to vent because it’s anonymous.

I get that. I think it’s just the way the OP criticises her sister in every line, whilst the sister thinks they’re close, that I find off. If the OP has such a low opinion of her sister she could go low contact. She just sounds like a mean girl.

Reading between the lines I’d say the sister is lonely. The OP is sat in her family home rolling her eyes because the sister talks about her pets….

SarahDippity · 15/10/2022 00:13

You mention your husband is elderly. Does she see some future where you are two single sisters in an empty next pottering around together?

I have to say I feel for both of you. You each have your own lives, and yours is already filled with responsibilities. It sounds like she is creating responsibilities (pets, illness which as you describe it sound exaggerated, though I could be wrong there), and this comes across as attention-seeking … but has she anyone in her life who truly pays attention to her? I’m not saying that’s your responsibility at all, but she doesn’t have a plus-one to lean on. Many single people are self-sufficient, but many people aren’t, and I do feel a bit sorry for her claiming a closeness with you when you are already full to bursting with responsibilities, so I can see how the dynamic she creates is an added burden on you.

Cameleongirl · 15/10/2022 00:11

No, @7eleven , but people do come on MN to vent because it’s anonymous.

7eleven · 14/10/2022 23:59

@Cameleongirl does your aunt, as far as you know, write messages slagging your dad off on social media? Would you mind if she did?

7eleven · 14/10/2022 23:57

Cameleongirl · 14/10/2022 23:53

Well, siblings don’t have to like each other, @7eleven . I know my Auntie doesn’t really like my Dad-she still helps him out sometimes, but she needs to keep her distance.

Of course they don’t, but the sister thinks they’re close. I think the OP perhaps needs to be more honest with her sister.

Cameleongirl · 14/10/2022 23:53

Well, siblings don’t have to like each other, @7eleven . I know my Auntie doesn’t really like my Dad-she still helps him out sometimes, but she needs to keep her distance.

7eleven · 14/10/2022 23:48

Cameleongirl · 14/10/2022 23:19

But she does manage independently, @MightyOaks . She works, has her own house, and her own friends. She sounds fine overall. For some reason though, she thinks she should move in with the OP and her DH in ten years. I can’t understand why she’d need to.

The OP can still be a supportive sister, but they don’t need to live in the same house. Perhaps moving to the same area would be logical if her sister would like to be close by?

My posts have more been about the general way the OP writes about her sister. I completely agree the OP should not be expected to have her live with her.

I don’t think the OP has had one nice thing to say about her sister, yet clearly she feels the superior one.

Cameleongirl · 14/10/2022 23:19

MightyOaks · 14/10/2022 22:40

THIS 👏🏻

The poor girl sounds like she has Autism or similar (I have a DC with Autism before anyone starts so I do know the traits) and unfortunately as far as the authorities will be concerned (if they're brought into it), like it or not, once your mother passes you will be fully expected to be the one to care for your DSis. I understand that's not what you want but if she cannot feasibly manage 100 % independently then who else will be there for her?

Either way please stop slagging her off and speaking about her like something you stepped in, she is your SISTER.

But she does manage independently, @MightyOaks . She works, has her own house, and her own friends. She sounds fine overall. For some reason though, she thinks she should move in with the OP and her DH in ten years. I can’t understand why she’d need to.

The OP can still be a supportive sister, but they don’t need to live in the same house. Perhaps moving to the same area would be logical if her sister would like to be close by?

MightyOaks · 14/10/2022 22:40

7eleven · 14/10/2022 17:13

You really don’t like your sister, do you. She sounds vulnerable and with poor mental health. Annoying, but she’s your sister! Stop talking crap about her and help her get some professional help.

THIS 👏🏻

The poor girl sounds like she has Autism or similar (I have a DC with Autism before anyone starts so I do know the traits) and unfortunately as far as the authorities will be concerned (if they're brought into it), like it or not, once your mother passes you will be fully expected to be the one to care for your DSis. I understand that's not what you want but if she cannot feasibly manage 100 % independently then who else will be there for her?

Either way please stop slagging her off and speaking about her like something you stepped in, she is your SISTER.

TirisfalPumpkin · 14/10/2022 21:08

YANBU at all.

I think she should try for a reassessment. GPs dismissing women who suspect they have autism or other developmental issues is very common. That would be reasonable sisterly support, advocate for her, get her referred and fill out the family part of the form. It could be that, could be something else, but I’d be amazed if there isnt something. You don’t have to give up your entire life to take care of her.

suzyscat · 14/10/2022 21:01

YANBU to not want to care for your sister but YABVU to be so judgey about her debilitating IBS. It's an invisible disability and yes, sometimes going to the gym does help with it.

NotJustAnybody · 14/10/2022 21:00

So, she owns her own house, works full time but has a couple of health issues. She's not doing too badly really and sounds very capable.
Next time she jokes about it, be blunt and tell her to think again and that you want a peaceful retirement, just you and DH and any spare rooms will be for your own DC visits. Knock it on the head.

Lollypop701 · 14/10/2022 20:07

Set your stall out now, you are not your sisters keeper

fuckinghorgel · 14/10/2022 20:02

GoldenGorilla · 14/10/2022 17:01

i have a sibling with serious mental health problems and have dealt with masses of pressure from them, parents and other siblings to invite her to live with us.
all you can do is be crystal clear about your boundaries: so whenever there’s any reference to the idea of her living with us, I repeat that “she can’t live with us, but I’m happy to help her find somewhere”. No excuses, no explanations or justifications. If I start giving people reasons she can’t live with us they try to debate it or tell me I’m wrong. So just a brisk matter of fact “she can’t live with us, but this is what I can do.”

Why don't your parents or the other siblings take them in?

7eleven · 14/10/2022 19:27

Sikaris · 14/10/2022 19:23

She doesn't have to like her and she isn't her responsibility.

The sister could get help herself, or her parents can arrange it.

I agree. The thing is though the sister thinks she does like her. I just find that a bit sad.