Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to worry about a U-turn on the energy price cap?

159 replies

DahliaMacNamara · 14/10/2022 13:27

I have no idea if they can or would do this. If someone can explain why it would never happen, that'll make it a nice short thread. Anyone?

OP posts:
Genevieva · 17/10/2022 13:28

I don't trust this government at all. Not that I am particularly trusting of any government. But something is seriously wrong. I get the impressions that any government we have at the moment, regardless of political party, will serve the demands of the IMF before considering the needs of the electorate.

The abolition of the 45p tax rate was a political error but so few people pay it that it was not going to have a significant impact on HMRC's tax take. The main tax cut that would benefit most people was the 1p cut in the lower tax rate from 20p to 19p. I think a lot of people could do with that money right now.

The daily fluctuations in the value of sterling are being orchestrated. It is not rational for the markets to be unfussed by billions in unfunded taxes being sent to Ukraine, but then to go into melt down over a 1p unfunded tax cut. The tax brackets have not risen with inflation, with the result that the higher tax rate hits at a relatively low level relative to the cost of living. On the whole, when you take little less of people in terms of tax they spend that money and it ends up back with HMRC another way. The money circulates in the economy for a bit longer and that makes everyone feel slightly better off. Right now, I am not sure it would do more than contribute a little towards utility bills.

Also, most jobs (not MPs mind) have had below inflation pay rises since before the 2008 crash. We were already getting poorer before the government blew £1 trillion on covid relief over 2 years. A significant portion of this went to government cronies for importing defective PPE that couldn't be used or to pay out to fraudulent furlough applications because there were no quality controls, no audit and no scientific analysis of the impact of shutting down virtually the entire economy for the best part of two years. Quite where they think they can get the money for Ukraine, tax cuts or even essential services is I don't know, but I do think that there are members of Boris Johnson's cabinet who should be standing trial for fraud and other related crimes in public office.

antelopevalley · 17/10/2022 13:27

I think that is right. We should not be subsidising people to use hot tubs or heat swimming pools.

Hayliebells · 17/10/2022 13:24

I've heard reports that as Hunt mentioned the support would encourage energy efficiency, we're looking at a similar scheme to Germany. There, usage up to a certain limit is capped, but above that limit it would be charged at wholesale prices. That's on the (perhaps incorrect) assumption that those on lower incomes use less energy. They need to address the poor insulation, with no means to improve it by the bill payer, of rental properties if they're going to do that though!

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 13:22

MrKlaw · 17/10/2022 13:16

how would they meaningfully target support? Energy companies don’t have access to income tax/HMRC records to know who to apply a cap to.

Would the government do a payment scheme like £500 for all those on universal credit? That may target the right people but give too much to some and not enough to others, depending on their circumstances.

I don’t see how you can target without huge inefficiencies

The trouble with not providing support to some of those who don’t technically need it (usually the middle), means that they then spend their disposable income on energy bills. Which is a lot of baristas, and tourist attraction guides, and hairdressers etc. who are then out of a job.

itwasntmetho · 17/10/2022 13:22

You can appeal your council tax band using local similar properties with lower bands as comparables for evidence.

www.gov.uk/challenge-council-tax-band

Doubtmyself · 17/10/2022 13:22

DahliaMacNamara · 17/10/2022 11:27

I wonder if they'll just say 'Fuck it', call an election, and let Labour deal with the fallout, whether that's borrowing more money to provide support after April or throwing households and businesses under the bus.

OR

Do what other civilised countries have done, tax the profits of gas companies making billions to fund it.

Stripyhoglets1 · 17/10/2022 13:18

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 12:39

Right I explained this a little on the Liz Truss thread in several different parts. I will try and explain as best I can, but its NOT as bad as it might sound...

First of all, the major beneficiaries were people who were the wealthiest and can afford not to reduce their useage - many of whom NEED to be reducing their useage due to energy security / global warming.

Second of all, the exact wording is the energy price guarantee will only remain universal. Key word. Universal. That means it could be means tested and still available to those on lower income.

Thirdly this needs a bit of context.
About 45mins before his statement this was tweeted:

Pound Sterling Live AT thepoundlive
Some really good news for Chancellor Hunt. Big fall in gas prices today. NatWest estimates that if the Dec '22 contract hits 300p/therm the Energy Price Guarantee becomes cost neutral. i.e. the new government's biggest spending outlay is shrinking rapidly $GBP
See graph

The gas price is currently at 403p.

Now we could see more spikes in price, however the markets seem to think there is going to be less issues with gas - indeed if demand is lower, that will keep prices lower - again it comes back to getting rich high energy users to reduce how much they consume.

So, whilst I think this announcement is extremely frightening, I also think its NOT as bad as it might sound and it is recognising that the wealthiest were benefiting most from the policy.

The people who are most vulnerable are middle earners with mortgages with high LTV.

However this response should also help to stop interest rates spiraling quite as much as the government don't have the financial black hole that the markets were terrified of.

FURTHER to this...

Faisal Islam is saying Hunt wants to incentive energy efficiency use and thats the key to look for.

Faisal was saying something about scheme in Germany where people are encouraged to use less and get financial reward for doing so.

Thats what I would like to see tbh. Regardless of the fiscal aspect. Its what we need. PLUS it will help to reduce demand which helps to drive gas prices down. Also good for all of us.

FURTHER to this...

Ben Chu AT BenChu_
Initial reaction to Jeremy Hunt moves this morning - some quick calculations.

Briefing suggests OBR was projecting medium term fiscal hole of £70bn.

HMT estimates all tax reversal now raise £32bn...

...so still leaves £38bn hole to get debt falling as share of GDP in three years.

Assume that favourable market reaction to U-turns lowers Gilt yields and interest rates by 1% - takes around £10bn off fiscal hole...

...still implies £28bn fiscal hole & £28bn of spending cuts.

So the question for markets: are those cuts politically deliverable by Hunt/Truss?

Worth noting that the NI hike reversal and the stamp duty cuts in the #miniBudget were costed by HMT at around £17bn a year by 2026-27 - surely a reversal of those (in the end) can't be ruled out too if spending cuts deemed politically impossible

Early indications are the market is reacting well. If you reverse the NI hike reversal and stamp duty cuts, that leaves a hole of £11 billion.

Thats bad. But '£11 billion bad' is not '£70 billion bad', though.

So however you spin this budget, it is better for us all. But still shit. And didn't need to happen.

FURTHER to this...

The pound is now rallying. Thats a good thing for imports. That SHOULD help particularly with food imports which the recent market instability was helping to drive inflation, and therefore the cost of living crisis. To put simply, it should mean that prices at Tesco and Aldi shouldn't rise as much as they would have done without the budget reversal.

In SUMMARY...

A lot of it is completely arse about face and not without risk. But I think people need to stop, and work out what the knock on effects of this are and what it actually means.

You take away with one hand but you should get benefits in other economic aspects which aren't as bad for us.

Also its just been pointed out on the BBC's Politics Live Show (by the presenter who is theorectically neutral) that Labour's energy intervention plan was only due to last until April anyway - which is exactly where the Conservatives have just rolled back to.

Hope that makes SOME sense...

So if they'd just done nothing to start with then we'd be better off throughout.

But LT was elected by members on a tax cutting promise - so they cut taxes and it stuffed the economy and the economy of many households!

MrKlaw · 17/10/2022 13:16

how would they meaningfully target support? Energy companies don’t have access to income tax/HMRC records to know who to apply a cap to.

Would the government do a payment scheme like £500 for all those on universal credit? That may target the right people but give too much to some and not enough to others, depending on their circumstances.

I don’t see how you can target without huge inefficiencies

Queenmarie · 17/10/2022 13:16

Queenmarie · 17/10/2022 13:16

Yes, we do have a (20-year) mortgage, though we are fortunate to have been able to fix it a few months ago before the biggest interest rises so okay on that front.

Thanks, I guess it is a case of wait and see.. But I don't like the uncertainty 😬

And yes, thank you for the sensible posts!

Choccolocko · 17/10/2022 13:16

The energy cap without a windfall tax was never tenable

Queenmarie · 17/10/2022 13:16

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 13:10

You don't say if you have a mortgage.

I think the middle are the ones who are right to be most worried by this. However by April we are into Spring, so in theory its a can kicked to next winter. Targeted support is an argument for another day.

A lot can happen before then. A year is a long time to start working on addressing energy insecurity. Hopefully prices will stabilise somewhat, though probably will stay at higher rates than they have previously been - the era of cheap energy is arguably over.

In the meantime this SHOULD calm inflation and cost of living pressures elsewhere (including interest rates).

I think its very much a wait and see scenario for the squeezed middle. There isn't a medium term answer to your question just yet.

Yes, we do have a (20-year) mortgage, though we are fortunate to have been able to fix it a few months ago before the biggest interest rises so okay on that front.

Thanks, I guess it is a case of wait and see.. But I don't like the uncertainty 😬

acrimoniousone · 17/10/2022 13:15

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 17/10/2022 13:04

Unpaid carer and lone parent to disabled adult son who can't work here - just how poor would you like us to be?

Probably be the same sort of person who puts inverted commas around the word disabled and thinks neurodiversity is overdiagnosed.

To answer the question, they want you to be far, far poorer than them as they consider you (and me) a lower form of life.

woff45 · 17/10/2022 13:14

@RedToothBrush just want to thank you for your thorough and level headed response, I was ready to reel but am slightly reassured.

I suspect we may fare badly, we have a good household income but high mortgage, the energy cap was a big reassurance to us, so does feel slightly back to square one with uncertainty, but if it helps stop mortgage rates spiralling it'll help us in the end.

balalake · 17/10/2022 13:13

I think there will be some support, but I get that the uncertainty as to how much or if you get it will worry and concern many people. Energy charges are almost unique amongst utility bills in that you don't see the bill before you consume/buy.

Queenmarie · 17/10/2022 13:10

ReunitedThorns · 17/10/2022 13:08

The universal cap was a measure that would bring down inflation. The obsession over insulation etc is a distraction, how does roof insulation make it cheaper to use my oven?

Targeted help typically means a cliff-edge in support and there will be many who will be thousands of pounds better off than someone who earns £1 more than them.

We've been done over with the council tax banding, so missed out on the help yet houses that are in the same area (down different streets) are benefiting.

Yep, totally agree and same.

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 13:10

Queenmarie · 17/10/2022 13:00

I'm worried that the 'targeted support' will be done on Council tax band again. We're band E so just missed out on the previous rebate. Our house is only 20 years old so not entirely sure how it was banded and although it does have four beds, it's a terraced townhouse so smaller and a lot cheaper than eg a semi or detached four-bed.

And our household income is £65k (in the SE) so although not low-income, very much middling.

You don't say if you have a mortgage.

I think the middle are the ones who are right to be most worried by this. However by April we are into Spring, so in theory its a can kicked to next winter. Targeted support is an argument for another day.

A lot can happen before then. A year is a long time to start working on addressing energy insecurity. Hopefully prices will stabilise somewhat, though probably will stay at higher rates than they have previously been - the era of cheap energy is arguably over.

In the meantime this SHOULD calm inflation and cost of living pressures elsewhere (including interest rates).

I think its very much a wait and see scenario for the squeezed middle. There isn't a medium term answer to your question just yet.

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 13:08

Bacibaci · 17/10/2022 12:58

People can take out private pensions and income protection insurance. We could fund private health, education, pension education and contribute toward emergency services if tax's were cut to a sustainable level.

Studies show that countries that do this it works out costing more for citizens.

Cost is only one metric. Value and quality also count.

ReunitedThorns · 17/10/2022 13:08

The universal cap was a measure that would bring down inflation. The obsession over insulation etc is a distraction, how does roof insulation make it cheaper to use my oven?

Targeted help typically means a cliff-edge in support and there will be many who will be thousands of pounds better off than someone who earns £1 more than them.

We've been done over with the council tax banding, so missed out on the help yet houses that are in the same area (down different streets) are benefiting.

CherryRipe1 · 17/10/2022 13:05

antelopevalley · 17/10/2022 11:55

@Wheretheskyisblue I agree

I agree too, very practical sensible idea.

Thisismynamenow · 17/10/2022 13:05

hattie43 · 17/10/2022 11:43

It'll be a targeted approach to help the poorest and that is correct . The country is broke and we can't afford to help everyone .

@hattie43 probably says the person who can afford significant coat increases. They put that in place to stop 80% of households going into fuel poverty. 80%, of which a significant chunk may now go into it just as the damage on mortgages has already been done.

Queenmarie · 17/10/2022 13:04

antelopevalley · 17/10/2022 13:03

Band E is over £88k house, so anything targeted below this is aimed at those in a pretty low income.

It's houses priced at £88k in 1991 I think... And our house wasn't built then. It's a very archaic system...

Mumtofourandnomore · 17/10/2022 13:04

Part of the problem is that it’s not always generators who make money - often to get funding they have to hedge their production sales contracts to guarantee a fixed return. If trades are physical (selling forward at fixed prices) it’s the buyer that’s making money and if trades are financial (selling forward at spot prices and hedging with banks) it’s banks making the money.

So totally depends on a generators hedging strategy making windfall taxes a pretty blunt tool themselves. The profit can be in lots of places.

The fact that the government u-turned just shows the essential nature of backing up budgets with concrete funding. Clearly, the OBR couldn’t support Truss’ policies so it wasn’t a timing thing, it was a viability thing. Hence, I think she’ll have to go. It’s one thing having a vision and delaying the funding side to work through the complexity. It’s another thing have a vision and not having even thought about the funding side.

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 17/10/2022 13:04

Grumpybutfunny · 17/10/2022 11:20

Ffs so once again the tax payer loses out and benefits aren't cut 😡

Unpaid carer and lone parent to disabled adult son who can't work here - just how poor would you like us to be?

Thatusernamewastaken · 17/10/2022 13:03

General Election, NOW! Every step is a misstep with this rabble.
Interest rates will still be sky high, the damage has been done, and now people don't even have the reassurance of capped energy for 2 years, which was the only saving grace and the only thing useless Liz could bleat on about in every interview.

antelopevalley · 17/10/2022 13:03

Band E is over £88k house, so anything targeted below this is aimed at those in a pretty low income.