Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to worry about a U-turn on the energy price cap?

159 replies

DahliaMacNamara · 14/10/2022 13:27

I have no idea if they can or would do this. If someone can explain why it would never happen, that'll make it a nice short thread. Anyone?

OP posts:
PurpleWisteria1 · 17/10/2022 14:09

Grumpybutfunny · 17/10/2022 11:20

Ffs so once again the tax payer loses out and benefits aren't cut 😡

Same old same old.
Those that work hard for their money are taxed further and further.
Those that have climbed the slippery slope giving up 12 hours of their day Monday- Friday to earn a meager bit more are taxed even further.
Sit around all day on your arse and get a bigger and bigger slice of what others have worked for.
Dont mind helping people in genuine need but that’s the minority IMO

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 14:08

The energy crisis is not down to the government, but external events. What’s actually making it a crisis in the UK is the decisions that have led us to being so exposed to it. A lack of investment and impetus in nuclear and alternative energy sources, the closing of the Rough gas storage facility etc. have all been decisions made by the Tory governments (and to some extent, Labour before that), but which is now having a massive negative impact on our ability to respond.

As with all governments and the decisions they make, when they get it wrong, it’s the people who have to pay the price. But make no mistake, excuses that it’s due to circumstances that they can’t (or more accurately, couldn’t have) controlled or limited, just wont wash.

FatEaredFuck · 17/10/2022 14:07

This is the govt punishing us all for not being grateful enough when they offered it the first time.

They're trying to calm the markets and wait for the next budget to throw average people a bone - once we grovel nicely.

They're creating a very cruel winter.

NewBootsAndRanty · 17/10/2022 14:07

The elderly and disabled already get 'warmer homes' which is money if temperature very low

Do you mean cold weather payments?

You’ll get a payment if the average temperature in your area is recorded as, or forecast to be, zero degrees celsius or below over 7 consecutive days.You'll get £25 for each 7 day period of very cold weather between 1 November and 31 March.

www.gov.uk/cold-weather-payment

Flapjacker48 · 17/10/2022 14:06

@Genevieva Your post toally ignores that the cost of government borrowing has been increasing massivley since the "mini budget" - it is that which is driving where we are. Despite what some people think - investors don't have to loan the UK government money (and if they believe the loan more or a risk, then of course they are going to expect much better return interest rates to give a higher return on their lending)

IndigoC · 17/10/2022 14:02

If energy prices stay high this is going to hurt. The mitigation to mortgage costs of this u-turn will be minimal. The Bank of England base rate is still expected to hit 5% next year and could push higher if inflation is as persistent as it looks in the US. This is no silver bullet for borrowing costs, which were heading higher irrespective of Trussonomics. Maybe it ends up saving 1% on mortgage rates, but if you then double (or worse) people’s power bills…

itwasntmetho · 17/10/2022 14:02

The kind of X number of units discounted to X price has the same effect as giving every household £66 a month off of their bill though doesn't it, without the added calculating step.
Same number of units discounted by the same amount for every single household = same overall discount for every single household. May as well give another gift payment from April and be done with it, a summer relief rate.

FistFullOfRegrets · 17/10/2022 14:01

floataboat · 17/10/2022 11:36

I wasn't expecting this u turn to be honest, although perhaps I should have been. It really didn't occur to me that this would be changed, and now I feel terrified about energy bills again.

I'm sure there will be more targeted support, but I doubt we'll qualify for it, and yet we are having to watch every penny as it is.

@floataboat I'll sit on that bench with you. I didn't expect them to U turn on the price cap. I wasn't sure about £ next winter, but I thought the Price Cap would stay.

I can live with paying more than before the Russian attacks on Ukraine started, to support Ukraine. But the Govts (of all varieties) should have made different decisions about our Energy supplies over the years, so we were more self sufficient with Energy, it makes me very annoyed that they didn't.

are you fixed or variable??

NoSki · 17/10/2022 14:00

FourTeaFallOut · 17/10/2022 11:38

I do wonder what will happen to those people who had signed up for a fixed energy deal only for the government to insist energy companies bump them onto the government limited cap.

The assumption that this was inevitably the cheaper solution for those customers was based
n the (now false) assumption it was in place for two years. What happens they find themselves looking at expensive energy tariffs in April wishing that their original contract hadn't been disbanded?

This! I had worked out o would over pay now as I would be protected come January and April but I was bumped off the tariff I signed up for! Now I’ll be far worse off come April than I would have been on my original tariff.

Thatsnotmycar · 17/10/2022 13:57

The elderly and disabled already get 'warmer homes' which is money if temperature very low.

Not all disabled people are eligible for the warm home scheme. I have disabled DC and use more energy as a result but we aren’t.

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 13:55

I think the burden on people with disabilities, their carers and families should be recognised as a priority but also that we should all unite together to speak up

Two things on this.

One you've got time to do this now.
Two I think you are going to be a very hard group to ignore.

I think the public's sense of what is fair really does allow for protections along these lines.

I think its MUCH MUCH harder to make that argument for the squeezed middle. See posts about middle classes having to cut back on their take out coffees...

Which is why I put forward the squeezed middle as the group who are most exposed to this policy shift not the disabled. Because I'm already assuming from the use of words about 'ending universal support' that the most vulnerable are already in the minds of government here.

I think its worth thinking about voting patterns too. In recent years its been more lower income households, rather than the squeezed middle who have leant support to the Tories - especially in the Red Wall areas. The squeezed professional middle class demographic are pretty solidly red. And they are unlikely to swing... Giving money to the middle won't win them votes.

PuzzledObserver · 17/10/2022 13:54

The benefit of targeting is that money goes to those who most need it. But administering it can be complicated and expensive. Universal schemes are cheap to administer.

How about this as an idea:

Every household gets their first 2,900 kWh electricity and 12,000kWh gas (you know, the typical usage amount) at the price cap rate. Households where anyone is in receipt of any benefit, be that pension credit, UC, PIP, gets all their usage at that rate. Other households pay market rate for usage above the aforementioned amounts. As simple a system as possible for confirming to energy suppliers that the household is elegible for the cheaper rate, e.g. a letter from DWP or whoever confirming the award to anyone in the household.

It’s a fairly crude form of targeting, admittedly, but I would argue better than universal support and not overly complicated.

Oh, and windfall tax on fossil-fuel generators, but not on renewable generators. And sort out the market so the price of renewable electricity is not linked to gas prices.

GasPanic · 17/10/2022 13:52

Doubtmyself · 17/10/2022 13:22

OR

Do what other civilised countries have done, tax the profits of gas companies making billions to fund it.

The problem is that the North Sea is pretty marginal in terms of investment compared to the rest of the world.

The older fields are tapped out. New fields tend to be in remote and difficult to operate places.

So if there was a windfall tax, that would further disincentivise any future North Sea development, which normally planned on a timescale of decades.

If you issue a windfall tax, it's effectively like saying we will tax the crap out of you when you do well, but not help you when things are going badly. Effectively making an investment that is already marginal even more marginal.

Not only that, but it signals to other corporates that their profits could completely vanish at a stroke if its deemed politically acceptable. So it strongly disincentivises future investment in the UK across the whole of business.

So in short, it's not just free, easy money that can be hoovered up without some consequences. Otherwise the government would have already done it.

flapjackfairy · 17/10/2022 13:50

@Wheretheskyisblue
What happens to people like us who have disabled children reliant on medical equipment and a warm home to survive? we use 3 times the average on a good day and BG sent a letter last week advising we need to pay 800 a month with the prices capped as they are. We had relaxed a bit knowing we were not facing any higher bill's for 2 years and now here . this government are an absolute joke . They should not be allowed to go back on their promises whenever they please.

caringcarer · 17/10/2022 13:49

Government should increase minimum wage. They should not have to subsidise employers for having staff. People who work full time should not need to claim benefits.

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 13:49

itwasntmetho · 17/10/2022 13:31

I don't think the squeezed middle are spending their money on coffees out and frequent tourist attraction visits, I don't think they'd be so scared if they had a disposable buffer like that each month.

That buffer had already been somewhat eroded, but I think there was still some left. And there was a little light at the end of the tunnel with the proposed tax cuts, to provide a element of comfort. Whereas now, the implosion point is now definitely on its way and going to be here a lot sooner.

They’re mainly scared, not because of what’s happened so far, but for what about to happen. As you know, fear is often like that- it’s at its peak before the event. The fact that they’re scared now shows to me that the worst is still to come.

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 13:47

What energy companies need to do is lower the standing charge and let those who use lots of energy pay for doing so. Having very high standing charges is a disincentive to reduce usage. Every household should get the first X amount on a lower tariff then pay more over that rate. The elderly and disabled already get 'warmer homes' which is money if temperature very low.

Our tariff is higher standing charge / lower unit cost. This works for us, as we are a low useage household. It costs us less than a low standing charge / high unit cost tariff.

I think this is more of an issue. People are stuck on shitty deals or don't know what would work out a better deal.

Rather than lowering the standing charge as your default to improve things for users, I'd like a simplification of the entire system so there isn't this mess of finding a good deal for your personal circumstances.

Why do we need a standing charge at all? Slightly higher unit prices might be more economical / encourage lower useage. With a minimum unit useage - at which point you get charged daily - for empty/low occupancy properties (like second homes).

The warmer homes tariff could be linked to the winter payment scheme in a better way too, in theory...

FistFullOfRegrets · 17/10/2022 13:41

Grumpybutfunny · 17/10/2022 11:20

Ffs so once again the tax payer loses out and benefits aren't cut 😡

@Grumpybutfunny

I presume you've gone totally off topic and are talking about the 1p on/off income tax?

It makes fuck all difference to take home pay, but is expensive to the Govt, it was a bloody stupid thing to do anyway.

Irrespective, you really want benefits CUT??

Out of work benefits- I don't claim any & never have, thank fuck as I have NO idea how people live on them, I really don't.

people shouldn't NEED to claim 'in work' benefits. An honest days work, no matter what you do, should pay enough to live on, increasingly it isn't.

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 17/10/2022 13:38

@RedToothBrush as always your posts are insightful and useful but I do take issue with "I think the middle are the ones who are right to be most worried by this"

There is going to be a lot of talk about the "squeezed middle" and whilst I agree they will need support due to mortgage/rent/fuel/childcare costs, I think with relation to the energy crisis, people with disabilities are much more at risk and therefore the most worried and in need of support. Equipment like adapted beds, dialysis/oxygen, stairlifts, hoists, charging mobility scooters are essentials and can't be "cut back" on. Plus the cost of being disabled and having to heat your house (or just one room) as you're inactive is essential and not a "luxury". There are so many coats associated with being disabled and the government genuinely don't give a fuck. It hasn't (to my knowledge?) even been confirmed by what measure disability benefits will be increased - and this is next year even though the cost of living has gone up hugely already. It's also hard not to feel less "powerless" as we have limited options for increasing income through employment etc - especially for those with severe disabilities. And their carers of course.

I think the burden on people with disabilities, their carers and families should be recognised as a priority but also that we should all unite together to speak up (and take direct action/protest) The fighting amongst ourselves about who is the most "worthy" and the age old working people v benefits debate, which the government love as it takes the heat off them, needs to stop. We need to start punching up instead of down, and concentrate on holding our government to account, and govern effectively.

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 13:35

So if they'd just done nothing to start with then we'd be better off throughout.

In a word: yes.

And the positive market response to do, will be the reasons that Liz Truss will find it difficult to survive tbh.

GottaGetOutofDairy · 17/10/2022 13:35

Wheretheskyisblue · 17/10/2022 11:54

What they should do it cap the cost of the first x KWs of energy that households use rather than cap all of it. That way the support will be targeted in order that everyone can afford a basic level of heat/power and people will be incentivised to cut their use to come under the limit. Their current policy is hugely costly and inefficient.

I totally agree.

A kwh 'allowance' at a capped rate: balanced according to number and vulnerability of the people in each home.

That should allow everyone a reaonable amount of energy to cover cooking, lighting, heat and power to medical equipment.

Then those of who use more than that (which includes me, btw) should pay market rate for anything over that amount.

caringcarer · 17/10/2022 13:33

What energy companies need to do is lower the standing charge and let those who use lots of energy pay for doing so. Having very high standing charges is a disincentive to reduce usage. Every household should get the first X amount on a lower tariff then pay more over that rate. The elderly and disabled already get 'warmer homes' which is money if temperature very low. Personally I think no one should get more than 5 per cent rise this year. Nurses are asking for 15 percent, don't know what teachers want but usually match up to nurses. If those working got 5 percent then those on benefits could get 5 percent too. Disabled and Pensioners should get about 7.5 percent. We as a country have to reign in our spending. Everybody would like 15 percent but we can't bloody well afford it. It just builds debt for the next generation who will already be retiring later. We also need to cut foreign aid to help our own. 30 funded Nursery hours should be for those that work 30 hours each week. Less funded hours for those that chose to stay home and not work. Once children are 6 years old, parents should be expected to work at least 20 hours per week if claiming benefits. This is still only a little less than 3 days a week or 4 hours per day whilst child at school. Also economic migrants should have a job in place before coming over and not be entitled to claim benefits until paid into our system for 5 years. We have got to tighten the purse strings.

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 13:33

woff45 · 17/10/2022 13:14

@RedToothBrush just want to thank you for your thorough and level headed response, I was ready to reel but am slightly reassured.

I suspect we may fare badly, we have a good household income but high mortgage, the energy cap was a big reassurance to us, so does feel slightly back to square one with uncertainty, but if it helps stop mortgage rates spiralling it'll help us in the end.

My first reaction to DH shouting 'the energy cap has gone' to me in the other room was 'what the fuck' and 'shit thats not good'.

So you aren't alone.

Its only when I've sat down and thought it out, that it seems like the only reasonable step that ANYONE could have taken at this point.

Tbh, I think the whole thing of how mortages work, what interest rates are, how the pound works against other currencies, the effect of commodity and energy price markets are really poorly understood. More people could do with understanding them better.

I don't know how you mitigate that. A lot of it, probably is at the upper end of GSCE level maths understanding. Some of it higher. Its not easy stuff. A lot of it is general knowledge rather than maths based though too.

I have to say, I was slightly relieved (massively bloody relieved) when Martin Lewis came on the TV to say pretty much what I was working out in my own head! I had a moment of panic that maybe I was completely wrong!

I still think there are a load of cavets in here. It DOES look like the gas prices might end up being lower than estimations (which is what I thought would happen - I've said on MN about this previously).

The gas price projections were based on last year's consumption rates and therefore demand. As people decide to look on their usage and be careful that should have driven down demand and therefore prices. Thats potentially a theory that can be carried forward.

If we want to look towards government savings which will help with cost of living then the very top of my list would be getting councils to have a good hard look at where they can save money on energy. Not budget cuts elsewhere. This first. Because it also have a secondary effect in terms of how it drives costs down.

I'd also look at more incentivisation of households and businesses generating their own energy as far as possible. Its doable. Perhaps with difficulties but still doable.

itwasntmetho · 17/10/2022 13:31

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 13:22

The trouble with not providing support to some of those who don’t technically need it (usually the middle), means that they then spend their disposable income on energy bills. Which is a lot of baristas, and tourist attraction guides, and hairdressers etc. who are then out of a job.

I don't think the squeezed middle are spending their money on coffees out and frequent tourist attraction visits, I don't think they'd be so scared if they had a disposable buffer like that each month.

Queenmarie · 17/10/2022 13:30

Hayliebells · 17/10/2022 13:24

I've heard reports that as Hunt mentioned the support would encourage energy efficiency, we're looking at a similar scheme to Germany. There, usage up to a certain limit is capped, but above that limit it would be charged at wholesale prices. That's on the (perhaps incorrect) assumption that those on lower incomes use less energy. They need to address the poor insulation, with no means to improve it by the bill payer, of rental properties if they're going to do that though!

I think that is probably the fairest way to do it. So many inconsistencies doing it by income. And plus it would have the huge benefit of reducing energy useage.