Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to worry about a U-turn on the energy price cap?

159 replies

DahliaMacNamara · 14/10/2022 13:27

I have no idea if they can or would do this. If someone can explain why it would never happen, that'll make it a nice short thread. Anyone?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
woff45 · 17/10/2022 18:42

It will be political suicide for energy cap not be extended if prices continue to rise, do not reduce or stay at current level after April 2023.

I think the Tories are well and truly past political suicide, they are firmly in "nothing left to lose" territory, and who the fuck knows what that'll bring.

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 18:23

DamnUserName21 · 17/10/2022 17:49

I'm not worried.
It will be political suicide for energy cap not be extended if prices continue to rise, do not reduce or stay at current level after April 2023. Ever closer to an election isn't it!

This is what I think too. Although, I’m prepared to accept that’s probably of the biased and wishful type.

DamnUserName21 · 17/10/2022 17:52

The Tories are pretty good at pulling money out of a magic hat (or from a magic money tree) when suits them!

DamnUserName21 · 17/10/2022 17:49

I'm not worried.
It will be political suicide for energy cap not be extended if prices continue to rise, do not reduce or stay at current level after April 2023. Ever closer to an election isn't it!

Boomboom22 · 17/10/2022 17:28

Thing with the benefits though, someone said they want them to be poorer than them, but of course? It is right that people who cannot work are supported but who is actually arguing they should be genuinely richer than say a couple working on minimum wage. Most disabled people can work somewhat, maybe pt maybe ft. So disabled benefits should be about helping raise standards not paying you to live. Ie to help the person make adjustments they need.
Carers allowance should be far far higher as it is based on ft work essentially, maybe close to nmw. But other benefits cannot outpay the lowest work or the whole system starts to fail.
Pp attitudes are partly why voters are scared of labour. Under the last Labour gov tax credits were very generous, to the point most people I know clear a similar amount now they earn double that.

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 17/10/2022 16:35

@Garysmum I agree with all your points. People forget in their rush to condemn people saying they can't make ends meet when they are "privileged" to be earning 50k, that it's not just income it's outgoings. People are being shafted by extortionate rents and mortgages based on extortionate house prices (driven by the governments lack of investment in housing amongst other factors) We aren't anywhere near earning 50k as a family but it doesn't mean I don't have sympathy and empathy for people in that boat. Fuel, housing, childcare, energy, cost of food etc... it affects families like this and also their children. People having zero sympathy for these families (sometimes due to envy and resentment) ignores the impact on their DC. For example they are also affected when they have to move from their two bedroom house that costs £1400 in rent to a one bedroom flat for £950 where their parents sleep in the lounge, or when they face repossession for defaulting on their mortgage, and become unwell from stress.

It's not a race to the bottom and I despise the government for (sadly successfully) encouraging resentment, envy and arguing amongst ourselves instead of looking at the bigger picture.

PS Please claim PIP if you are entitled, I know it's an awful process, stressful and upsetting, but it will give you more protection in the current climate, I feel a lot of the "thresholds" for support will use this as a criteria. For example, we got an additional £150 on top of the COL support (admittedly an absolute drop in the ocean against the bills for a lot of people with extra equipment/energy needs Hmm)

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 17/10/2022 16:19

*"One you've got time to do this now.
Two I think you are going to be a very hard group to ignore.

I think the public's sense of what is fair really does allow for protections along these lines."*

@RedToothBrush the erosion of womens rights over the past couple of years, and the publics lack of interest, doesn't give me much hope for protection here! But I agree we need to be, well not "shouting the loudest", but certainly at the forefront of protest/campaigning. Like you say, it's hard to ignore someone pointing out they need funds to use oxygen/a hoist etc and it doesn't help the government's usual strategy of look over there, people on benefits are getting more than you or should people on 40k be subsidised to run a hot tub - off you go and fight amongst yourselves so you aren't fighting the government...

whatsthestory123 · 17/10/2022 15:58

so a guarantee is not a guarantee

have to agree those running expensive equipment for health reasons need more help

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 15:50

GasPanic · 17/10/2022 15:41

Yes it will impact future E&P.

If you are a corporate and have a choice between investing in a country that has a stable and long term corporation tax policy, or one that has a policy that changes at random depending on a number of political factors then you will invest in the first not the second, especially if you are going to invest for decades in infrastructure.

The North Sea is not looked on as a great place to invest in E&P. There are many more lucrative areas around the world. So a poor tax environment is not going to help that at all.

If you want to cite BP as a particular example, yes it has profited from North Sea operations because of Russia. But it has also had to write down a lot of investments that it had in Russia, so as a business it is swings and roundabouts. It also isn't that big a producer (maybe 4th or 5th largest) in the North Sea.

Most people seem to have forgotten there is already been a windfall tax in place by the UK on North Sea profits.

As for the EU efforts, a significant proportion of the EU energy sector is public owned. So it's probably just a smoke and mirrors exercise.

Generally I'm supportive of taxing companies who wriggle out of paying enough tax - there are several large ones that do this. But taxing energy companies when we actually need more not less investment in energy (oil and gas as well as renewables) seems like madness to me, and probably is going to be long term counterproductive to energy security.

I agree, but be warned, nobody will lend you a pitchfork with that kind of logical attitude.

GasPanic · 17/10/2022 15:41

Doubtmyself · 17/10/2022 14:44

BP reported its biggest quarterly profit for 14 years, making £6.9bn in the three months to June this year.

BP received more money back from the UK government than they paid every year from 2015 to 2020, they do this by offsetting tax payments for the exact things you're talking about- decommissioning North Sea oil platforms and further exploration.

The reason Truss was against windfall tax, because it didn't fit the Britannia Unchained: ideology of Truss, Kwasi and Mogg

The EU have a tax levy, along with mandatory cuts in electricity use, which means their citizens can afford to eat and stay warm.

Taxing excess revenues made from surging electricity costs is not stopping future exploration, it only has an impact on bumper shareholder divi's and bonuses for the C-suite

Yes it will impact future E&P.

If you are a corporate and have a choice between investing in a country that has a stable and long term corporation tax policy, or one that has a policy that changes at random depending on a number of political factors then you will invest in the first not the second, especially if you are going to invest for decades in infrastructure.

The North Sea is not looked on as a great place to invest in E&P. There are many more lucrative areas around the world. So a poor tax environment is not going to help that at all.

If you want to cite BP as a particular example, yes it has profited from North Sea operations because of Russia. But it has also had to write down a lot of investments that it had in Russia, so as a business it is swings and roundabouts. It also isn't that big a producer (maybe 4th or 5th largest) in the North Sea.

Most people seem to have forgotten there is already been a windfall tax in place by the UK on North Sea profits.

As for the EU efforts, a significant proportion of the EU energy sector is public owned. So it's probably just a smoke and mirrors exercise.

Generally I'm supportive of taxing companies who wriggle out of paying enough tax - there are several large ones that do this. But taxing energy companies when we actually need more not less investment in energy (oil and gas as well as renewables) seems like madness to me, and probably is going to be long term counterproductive to energy security.

marsbara · 17/10/2022 15:10

Although it's easy to say, I'm not going to worry about what might or might not happen in April. Lots of things might have changed by then...who knows...we might even have had a snap election and have a new government with different policies, in power!!

FistFullOfRegrets · 17/10/2022 15:04

AnApparitionQuipped · 17/10/2022 12:22

It would be difficult to administer but what they should do is link it to temperature - have lower rates if it drops below a certain temperature in your postcode area, so people will be able to keep warm. Higher rates at temperatures where you shouldn't really need to have heating on.

That really wouldn't work. Things like which way your house faces makes a huge difference. As does the houses around you.

MojoMoon · 17/10/2022 14:57

Hopefully they will replace it after April with something similar to the system Germany has just announced to support household energy bills.

You would get a certain amount of kWh (units of electricity) at a heavily discounted rate and then after that you pay more, and after a certain level above that, you start paying full market rates.

It encourages energy efficiency where as the existing cap just meant little incentive for wealthier households to reduce demand.

Poor households use less energy (live in smaller homes, have fewer things running, are more frugal) so are less likely to consume enough to be in the top category. But people with spare bedrooms they keep hot, running hot tubs and heating look carp ponds can and should be paying full market prices with zero subsidy provided.

Hunt said today that whatever replaces it will promote efficiency so I hope they aren't too proud to just borrow the German plan

Old people living alone in big homes might also be encouraged to sell and downsize which would also have positive effects in areas with housing crisis.

thecatneuterer · 17/10/2022 14:47

Wheretheskyisblue · 17/10/2022 11:54

What they should do it cap the cost of the first x KWs of energy that households use rather than cap all of it. That way the support will be targeted in order that everyone can afford a basic level of heat/power and people will be incentivised to cut their use to come under the limit. Their current policy is hugely costly and inefficient.

I also agree with this, and that's the policy in Albania apparently.

NewBootsAndRanty · 17/10/2022 14:45

NewBootsAndRanty · 17/10/2022 14:07

The elderly and disabled already get 'warmer homes' which is money if temperature very low

Do you mean cold weather payments?

You’ll get a payment if the average temperature in your area is recorded as, or forecast to be, zero degrees celsius or below over 7 consecutive days.You'll get £25 for each 7 day period of very cold weather between 1 November and 31 March.

www.gov.uk/cold-weather-payment

www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/cost-of-living/dwp-excluded-warm-homes-discount-24703316

I also should have said that this year's warm home discount scheme (which has g9ne up from £140 to £150) has changed (unless you're in Scotland)

Those on the Guarantee Credit element of Pension Credit will automatically qualify. For everyone else though...

  • Just being in receipt of PIP or DLA alone isn't a qualifier any more. As well as needing to be in receipt of qualifying benefits/tax credits, it's also going to be based around the size and energy efficiency of the property, based on VOA data.

Just a heads up @caringcarer

Doubtmyself · 17/10/2022 14:44

GasPanic · 17/10/2022 13:52

The problem is that the North Sea is pretty marginal in terms of investment compared to the rest of the world.

The older fields are tapped out. New fields tend to be in remote and difficult to operate places.

So if there was a windfall tax, that would further disincentivise any future North Sea development, which normally planned on a timescale of decades.

If you issue a windfall tax, it's effectively like saying we will tax the crap out of you when you do well, but not help you when things are going badly. Effectively making an investment that is already marginal even more marginal.

Not only that, but it signals to other corporates that their profits could completely vanish at a stroke if its deemed politically acceptable. So it strongly disincentivises future investment in the UK across the whole of business.

So in short, it's not just free, easy money that can be hoovered up without some consequences. Otherwise the government would have already done it.

BP reported its biggest quarterly profit for 14 years, making £6.9bn in the three months to June this year.

BP received more money back from the UK government than they paid every year from 2015 to 2020, they do this by offsetting tax payments for the exact things you're talking about- decommissioning North Sea oil platforms and further exploration.

The reason Truss was against windfall tax, because it didn't fit the Britannia Unchained: ideology of Truss, Kwasi and Mogg

The EU have a tax levy, along with mandatory cuts in electricity use, which means their citizens can afford to eat and stay warm.

Taxing excess revenues made from surging electricity costs is not stopping future exploration, it only has an impact on bumper shareholder divi's and bonuses for the C-suite

notprettybeautiful · 17/10/2022 14:23

People on benefits pay for their energy too. Not sure what your point is.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/10/2022 14:22

DahliaMacNamara · 17/10/2022 11:27

I wonder if they'll just say 'Fuck it', call an election, and let Labour deal with the fallout, whether that's borrowing more money to provide support after April or throwing households and businesses under the bus.

At this point, I think I'd wanna tag the other team in!!

Crimeismymiddlename · 17/10/2022 14:20

It did not surprise me, more because they way they go about everything is so cack handed and costly. They would never just tell the energy providers to go whistle for the cap to rise, no they give tax payers money back to them to pay four months worth of bills, as well as subsidising the providers with millions of tax payers money. It was an expensive gamble.

Genevieva · 17/10/2022 14:18

@Flapjacker48 You can't cover everything in a single social media post. It isn't an academic essay. Just as your point shows limited knowledge of how government borrowing works. There are obviously a lot of factors, but the ones I mentioned are getting drowned out.

CoffeethenCrochet · 17/10/2022 14:17

Grumpybutfunny · 17/10/2022 11:20

Ffs so once again the tax payer loses out and benefits aren't cut 😡

I'm unable to work due to ongoing chemotherapy, you think I should have even less than the already ridiculously low amount of benefits I currently get?!

I paid tax for over 15 years until suddenly i was unable to work. I can hardly afford to eat let alone keep warm at home.

Please re think hating benefit claimants for the dire situation our government has put us all in!

RedToothBrush · 17/10/2022 14:17

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 14:08

The energy crisis is not down to the government, but external events. What’s actually making it a crisis in the UK is the decisions that have led us to being so exposed to it. A lack of investment and impetus in nuclear and alternative energy sources, the closing of the Rough gas storage facility etc. have all been decisions made by the Tory governments (and to some extent, Labour before that), but which is now having a massive negative impact on our ability to respond.

As with all governments and the decisions they make, when they get it wrong, it’s the people who have to pay the price. But make no mistake, excuses that it’s due to circumstances that they can’t (or more accurately, couldn’t have) controlled or limited, just wont wash.

No government in the last 30 years has taken energy or food security seriously enough.

Covid proved that. Climate change is the other elephant in the room.

This isn't restricted to the UK either.

EmmaH2022 · 17/10/2022 14:15

i thought it was help till April, hadn't heard two years.

Elderly mum also worried that help might be withdrawn this winter.

Garysmum · 17/10/2022 14:13

@WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles

I would have quoted you but that's a lot of text.

I think we need to be worried about both the squeezed middle and those with disabilities. I fall into both camps.

The squeezed middle are probably always one or two steps away from needing significant state support. Loss of job, interest rates going a bit higher etc - can push a family quickly into homelessness. Part of the issue is that there is nothing to rent for a reasonable cost. Mortgage costs can often be cheaper than renting the same property.Families can quickly become dependent on state support.

If, due to a mixture of energy prices, interest rates, rising food costs etc a large number of families end up unable to pay their mortgages, this represents a serious crisis - and has the potential to require significant state funding - where is that money coming from? (Currently I would argue these families are likely to have 2 working parents, paying tax and possibly not that reliant on state funding in terms of child care credits etc. Some might have one earner over 50k so no child benefit either. They sound wealthy don't they? But they are heavy net contributers in terms of tax.) The country can't really afford for a large number of these families to switch from net contributers to becoming those that rely on state assitance.

On the other hand, we have the disabled a class of people with expensive and specialist needs. Not every disabled or vulnerable person will need to heat a room to the same level or require the same level of assistance. However, I am aware of a number of families who have been paying privately to support a family member in one form or another - whether that is physio, buying equipment etc. When those families feel the pinch and can no longer afford to support then the burden on the state will be even greater.

I also think that those people who have medically required equipment at home which uses electricity do need extra assistance. I'm lucky as I need a fridge which I would run anyway and also a pump which is not daily. I have been advised that I would meet the threshhold for PIP - I rely on help to cook, dress, clean etc. I have never made a claim as I am middle income earner and feel that I should just suck up the cost. The trouble is I'm not going to be able to suck up the cost much longer so I will look at making a claim. I can't be the only one in this position.
I do think special provision needs to be made for people with specialist equipment and extensive needs. I couldn't even begin to suggest how this would be funded.

IndigoC · 17/10/2022 14:11

DomesticShortHair · 17/10/2022 14:08

The energy crisis is not down to the government, but external events. What’s actually making it a crisis in the UK is the decisions that have led us to being so exposed to it. A lack of investment and impetus in nuclear and alternative energy sources, the closing of the Rough gas storage facility etc. have all been decisions made by the Tory governments (and to some extent, Labour before that), but which is now having a massive negative impact on our ability to respond.

As with all governments and the decisions they make, when they get it wrong, it’s the people who have to pay the price. But make no mistake, excuses that it’s due to circumstances that they can’t (or more accurately, couldn’t have) controlled or limited, just wont wash.

Yes, very well said. I want to hear specific details from the government on how they’re addressing our energy infrastructure to avoid this in the future. It’s not enough to just hope prices come down and stay down.