Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
BloodAndFire · 18/10/2022 09:05

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 08:20

I only have so much energy, like we all do, so yes. Pick your battles

Thinking these protestors are wankers achieving less than nothing doesn't take any energy. Nor is it a battle. Trying to convince myself otherwise would be q lot more difficult.

BerriesOnTop · 18/10/2022 08:58

Berries, you are quoting the IPCC report in the most selective way, hinting that any other reading of unfolding world events is alarmist, ill-informed and overly dramatic. This is so sneaky! Parts of the world are indeed becoming 'unlivable' as a direct consequence of man-made climate change: in my professional role I often meet families from countries who report how life is increasingly hazardous or impoverished as a direct result of adverse climate conditions

Adverse climate conditions have always been with us. How we deal with it is good infrastructure. Even you know this. Why would we want people to live like this when they could live as comfortably as you or I?

Europe stopping using fossil fuels will only hurt yourselves and the people you mention will not be helped one bit.

Jordan, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, Mali, Afghanistan and Somalia

People have been quite comfortable now in the Arabian peninsula thanks to copious use of fossil fuels. No one could really live there without them except for nomadic groups living on the literal margins, their lifestyle is not an easy one as you also must know.

Further up the thread you suggest that my suggestion to manage our expectations of our future standard of living and working toward sustainable adaptations will cause more death and misery (I paraphrase) than climate change. Really? What do you think is being advocated? We cannot pursue a global or national growth economy indefinitely on a planet of finite resources

People are already having to choose between energy and food due to artificial scarcity. The drop in living standards is now at your door and you have no solution other than further cutbacks. You say resources are scarce, but then it’s all artificial, since you don’t support further exploration efforts. Peak oil is not even talked about anymore, it was a total myth.

Do you even know how important fossil fuels are to something as basic as agriculture? Inputs from the fertilisers all the way to harvest. You cannot get away from it.

Additionally, if you want birth rates to drop in the developing world, the best thing you could do is … develop it. Look at East Asia’s huge drops in birth rates after each individual countries’ development. We need to other countries to follow the East Asian model.

A gradual transition to sustainable alternatives will be necessary. Failure to make timely adaptations to mitigate future damage is what will cause untold harm

You could advocate for nuclear power in energy generation. But green advocates rarely do.

I have lived in China for much of my life (though not anymore). I have seen how industrialisation has improved the living standards of the average person tremendously and people like you act as if that’s a bad thing. Flooding and earthquakes used to kill tens of thousands when they happened—and even though the population is bigger, deaths have dropped precipitously thanks to better building standards (fossil fuels), better roads in and out (fossil fuels), better emergency equipment (fossil fuels), better hospitals (again powered by fossil fuels).

You have nothing to offer a developing country whilst asking your fellow European to take a pointless hit to their living standards.

It honestly makes me angry how myopic Europeans can be.

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 08:54

At least everyone on this thread understands at least in general terms what their goals are,

Newsflash - this thread’s not the world. And I have no idea what their goals are. Nor, I suspect, do they.

ivykaty44 · 18/10/2022 08:38

At least everyone on this thread understands at least in general terms what their goals are

sadly I don't think that people do understand the goals and the MSM have spun their own spin on this as they are owned by the people that are deniers

I obviously from my posts don't think these people are brats, I am amazed by the diversity of people that are staging these protests, lawyers, doctors, accountants who have retired are very predominant in these groups - calling them brats seems peculiar when so many are well passed middled age and have had a decent standing throughout their working lives.

BerriesOnTop · 18/10/2022 08:36

thedancingbear · 18/10/2022 08:29

Bought to you straight from the BP public relations team.

You can believe that if you want. But it doesn’t change the reality that our way of life is based on cheap access to fossil fuels—and Europe in particular hasn’t done enough work to secure that access and they will suffer for it. But blame Putin or America or anything but themselves who have caused this very problem

thedancingbear · 18/10/2022 08:30

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 08:29

Millions of people worldwide are dying and being displaced and all people can do is moan about people trying to get it into the bloody news

They haven’t got it into the bloody news though. Most people have absolute no idea what they were trying to accomplish, attention is firmly focused on the vandalism. For which there’s little sympathy.

You're completely wrong. At least everyone on this thread understands at least in general terms what their goals are, even those calling the protesters brats etc.

thedancingbear · 18/10/2022 08:29

BerriesOnTop · 18/10/2022 08:25

Millions of people worldwide are dying and being displaced and all people can do is moan about people trying to get it into the bloody news

Fossil fuels are lifesaving. They create lifesaving infrastructure, heat and cool homes, give a massive boost to agriculture through chemical fertilisers, byproducts are used for medication and medical devices.

You want to save people in the developing world? Give them coal plants, roads, decent housing, larger-scale agriculture.

China has lifted more people out of poverty than any other government — through industrialisation. Would that other developing countries follow their model (and I have no particular love for the current Chinese government either)

Bought to you straight from the BP public relations team.

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 08:29

Millions of people worldwide are dying and being displaced and all people can do is moan about people trying to get it into the bloody news

They haven’t got it into the bloody news though. Most people have absolute no idea what they were trying to accomplish, attention is firmly focused on the vandalism. For which there’s little sympathy.

BerriesOnTop · 18/10/2022 08:25

Millions of people worldwide are dying and being displaced and all people can do is moan about people trying to get it into the bloody news

Fossil fuels are lifesaving. They create lifesaving infrastructure, heat and cool homes, give a massive boost to agriculture through chemical fertilisers, byproducts are used for medication and medical devices.

You want to save people in the developing world? Give them coal plants, roads, decent housing, larger-scale agriculture.

China has lifted more people out of poverty than any other government — through industrialisation. Would that other developing countries follow their model (and I have no particular love for the current Chinese government either)

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 08:20

I only have so much energy, like we all do, so yes. Pick your battles

BloodAndFire · 18/10/2022 08:09

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 06:53

I fully support and endorse just stop oil. They very briefly got soup on some glass. Meanwhile the entire fate of the planet is going to shit because we have corrupt and incompetent leaders. Direct your anger at the right place maybe?

Do you have a finite supply of anger that has to be carefully rationed?

I don't. I'm able to hate the government and big businesses AND think these people are twats as well.

BloodAndFire · 18/10/2022 08:07

StarmanBobby · 18/10/2022 00:01

Got everyone’s attention though, didn’t it?

So did Jeffrey Dahmer.

Most people over the age of 8 realise that 'getting attention' isn't an achievement in itself.

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 06:53

I fully support and endorse just stop oil. They very briefly got soup on some glass. Meanwhile the entire fate of the planet is going to shit because we have corrupt and incompetent leaders. Direct your anger at the right place maybe?

thedancingbear · 18/10/2022 06:46

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 22:47

Why are you always so aggressive?

How would you describe your position re climate change other than 'I don't give a fuck?'

Genuinely interested.

Vikinga · 18/10/2022 00:39

YankeeCat · 17/10/2022 22:59

Instead of attempting to destroy a historical artifact and potentially blocking emergency vehicles, maybe doing something like this would be better instead

worldnewsdailyreport.com/lottery-winner-arrested-for-dumping-200000-of-manure-on-ex-boss-lawn/

www.wdtn.com/news/man-dumps-chicken-manure-to-protest-neighbors-wedding-venue/

www.mediaite.com/weird/watch-florida-man-dresses-as-grim-reaper-to-protest-reopening-of-florida-beaches/

I don't endorse doing dumping manure of course but doing something crazy like this would still generate headlines while being less destructive. I don't think it is illegal in the UK to dress up as the grim reaper so maybe mass of people protesting in Grim reaper outfits would grab headlines and be appropriate for the season. Let's be a little more creative and less destructive.

If you could be arsed to look through the movements social media accounts you will see that everything you or anyone has thought of has been done. Most of it doesn't make the news.

The painting wasnt harmed either.

Millions of people worldwide are dying and being displaced and all people can do is moan about people trying to get it into the bloody news???

When you have teachers and scientists and doctors and nurses and uni professors spending their precious free time trying to bring this ti attention. When you've got activists from the global south risking their lives and their freedom to bring attention to what is happening right now, you bloody listen. Or you're a fool. But at least don't admit it in public.

Vikinga · 18/10/2022 00:35

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:18

I can see that they are following the trouble. They are only lucky they aren't protesting/stamping their feet in less liberal countries than the UK. Then again, they dont have the true grit for that. As for the recent rabble, causing a bridge to be shut down. I'd happily leave them up there and let (lawful) business carry on as usual.

Oh do piss off. Brave activists risk their lives and their freedom all over the world. So get off your pathetic soap box and do something useful. When people are trying to save your lives and your future at least be grateful or stfu

StarmanBobby · 18/10/2022 00:01

Got everyone’s attention though, didn’t it?

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 23:59

Catlady2021

it was symbolic as he fought for the country and what was the point if this generation keeps doing what it’s doing, it’ll all have been for nothing

YankeeCat · 17/10/2022 22:59

Instead of attempting to destroy a historical artifact and potentially blocking emergency vehicles, maybe doing something like this would be better instead

worldnewsdailyreport.com/lottery-winner-arrested-for-dumping-200000-of-manure-on-ex-boss-lawn/

www.wdtn.com/news/man-dumps-chicken-manure-to-protest-neighbors-wedding-venue/

www.mediaite.com/weird/watch-florida-man-dresses-as-grim-reaper-to-protest-reopening-of-florida-beaches/

I don't endorse doing dumping manure of course but doing something crazy like this would still generate headlines while being less destructive. I don't think it is illegal in the UK to dress up as the grim reaper so maybe mass of people protesting in Grim reaper outfits would grab headlines and be appropriate for the season. Let's be a little more creative and less destructive.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 22:47

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 19:02

You’re asking the wrong question. She doesn’t give a fuck.

There’s lots of it around, you know

Why are you always so aggressive?

Annoyingkidsmusic · 17/10/2022 22:44

Utterly disgraceful and they just look entitled, batshit and unhinged. I hope they’re made to pay for the damage, or serve community service/ a jail sentence to compensate.

Gillume · 17/10/2022 22:38

Personally don’t agree with this sort of protest, a video is circulating with milk being poured over a supermarket floor, who do they think has to clean this up? They are making work for overworked underpaid individuals in most cases!

DdraigGoch · 17/10/2022 22:21

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 21:20

I’d agree to an extent, though I don’t think the HS2 protestors are, by and large, climate activists. I get the sense it’s a mix of woodland conservationists, and nimbys. And it goes without saying that some protesters are just in it for shits and giggles

It's very difficult to tell with the various People's Front of Judea/Judean People's Front splinter groups.
Earlier, @ILeclercreturn said:
HS2 is largely a 'white elephant' unless there is a clearly defined plan to make things that need transporting from 'the north' to London. Has anyone seen detailed plans (or even vague ideas) for development of industry that COULD use a high speed train? NO, it is an attempt to pull workers from the North to work in London

Which basically illustrates that that poster doesn't have a clue about the project. I can't be bothered to go into full details yet again about how capacity is freed up for freight etc. so instead I'll go into the effect on aviation.

Approximately five million people fly between the Scottish Central Belt and London every year. Only two and a half million fly between London and Paris. What's the difference? Well thanks to high speed rail, it now only takes two and a quarter hours to get to Paris, compared with four and a half hours to Scotland. That has decimated the Cross-Channel aviation market, a phenomenon which will be replicated when London-Scotland journey times fall below the key four hour mark.

People use trains (particularly long-distance ones) for many reasons other than for work, which is why they're often full and standing off-peak. Liverpool Lime Street for example is 15% up on passenger numbers compared with 2019.

Catlady2021 · 17/10/2022 22:19

Also can businesses take legal action against them for loss of earnings? Lots of poor truck drivers bringing in vital supplies suffered today. Food, medicine, etc etc.
Sainsbury’s and Tesco both have depots near Dartford. Both of which won’t have been able to deliver food today.
Lets remember people are genuinely going hungry at the moment so food banks would lose out too.

Catlady2021 · 17/10/2022 22:16

Surely the best thing to do with these idiots is ignore them ? They want to climb the Dartford Bridge? Let them . But allow the traffic to continue as normal. They weren’t blocking the road , traffic could pass.
It’s October. It’s getting colder, wetter and darker.
Surely there’s only so long a protester can hang around a bridge before they need a piss, a shit, need a drink or eat food?
Closing major roads and giving attention is exactly their aim.
Let then crack in whilst everyone else goes about their business.