Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 17:24

Are people dense, obtuse or still missing the point? Climate change will disrupt absolutely everything. It already is. .

CurzonDax · 18/10/2022 16:56

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 16:33

Wow people are going to have a lot more disruption than not being able to get from a to b on time 🙄

True. Except for people who need to get to vital hospital appointments.
I mean, it's only "a to b", unless you have a 9 am chemo appointment, and a 3 hour backlog of traffic. Still, all they need to do is get up around 5.30 am to make sure they get there on time, right? Only a minor inconvenience, and the chemo is going to make them tired anyway, and so having to get up a little earlier won't matter.

Work is only a to b as well. It's the employer's fault anyway, for not allowing all the key workers to work from home.

It's only a little disruption to get from a to b.

(I repeat what I said earlier - not everyone is just popping to Lakeside/Bluewater to go shopping ...)

bebravelikesuperman · 18/10/2022 16:50

If I needed to get my child to hospital (in a life of death situation) trust me when I say this........ one of those save oil humans would be dying, before my child!!
I'd run straight over them, and deal with the consequences of my actions after!!
I MEAN THAT

DdraigGoch · 18/10/2022 16:42

Electric cars are not going to save the planet. The future cannot involve mass car ownership full stop.

Public transport combined with self-propelled methods (walking/cycling/Chucklemobiles...) will have to suffice for most of the population, with those who need a vehicle at work (I don't merely mean the commute, I mean those who have to go from location to location - tradesmen, home helps, farmers etc.) will need to be provided with one by their employer, or if self-employed will just have to consider it a cost of business as their diesel van is now.

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 16:33

Wow people are going to have a lot more disruption than not being able to get from a to b on time 🙄

thedancingbear · 18/10/2022 14:19

Even if the whole of the UK brought electric cars tomorrow, the national grid couldn’t cope with the electricity usage! It would literally collapse with everyone charging them.

This is absolute nonsense.

SarahBelles86 · 18/10/2022 14:03

People have a right to PEACEFUL protest.

What these lot get up to is stupid.

I totally agree with you OP, their message, which most people probably agree with, gets lost in their ridiculous behavour!
If they are stupid enough to glue themselves to a busy road then they should be left there to rot, muppets!!
Also those going in to shops and pouring milk everywhere should be charged with criminal damage.

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 13:48

But even using electric vehicles relies on fossil fuels to charge them up. Electricity.

You can’t just expect trucks and vehicles to stop using oil overnight. Most lorries use diesel. Yes we all want a greener planet but we must have realistic expectations.

Even if the whole of the UK brought electric cars tomorrow, the national grid couldn’t cope with the electricity usage! It would literally collapse with everyone charging them.

As I said previously, many food deliveries have been stopped as a direct result. This means less stock in supermarkets.

Doesn’t the French own the Dartford bridge? Will they take legal action against the protesters on this? Or will they fine the UK government for loss of earnings?

DdraigGoch · 18/10/2022 12:39

StarmanBobby · 18/10/2022 00:01

Got everyone’s attention though, didn’t it?

So did Erica Roe streaking across Twickenham. Doesn't mean that anything will come of it, any more than anything came of that (yes, I know that she wasn't actually protesting, just drunk).

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 11:21

Jesus, if we’ve reached the point of hypothesising about what Van Gogh might have thought about it, we’ve really jumped the shark.

Strawberrypicnic · 18/10/2022 11:18

The people getting irate about the "waste of food" (come on) or the fact that the glue was made with fossil fuels, as if that's some
big "gotcha!" moment, just prove what huge cognitive dissonance there is around this topic and why the actions needed are actually even more radical than this one.

Another person said that they are hypocrites for doing this because they were "probably driven to school in Range Rovers". It's so intellectually dishonest.

I can see that this particular stunt has really divided people and I might question its value on that basis. But there is no point having art on a dead planet. Van Gogh was a thoughtful person and disliked the degree to which art was commodified. I think he'd have supported this.

Stars71 · 18/10/2022 11:04

Justkidding55 · 18/10/2022 10:49

@Stars71 what would you do if you were a corrupt government who wanted protests banned? You’d encourage or even set up fake protests and plant protesters to encourage this along. I wouldn’t put it past them to have done this. Many groups have.
the Sarah everard protests were peaceful and it made no difference.
They could sit nicely by the side of the road and people could still claim they are being a nuisance.
you all sound like far right nutters tbh who coincidentally also don’t want rights for anyone either.

I would rather be a law abiding, right wing thinker, than a hypocritical left wing do gooder, who gets offended about everything and anything and searches for band wagons to jump on. Insecure people with nothing better to do than cause misery to others. You're never happy unless you've got a crusade to chase. Never wanting unity, only division.

Lesserspottedmama · 18/10/2022 11:03

I admire them.

BigWoollyJumpers · 18/10/2022 10:55

Justkidding55 · 18/10/2022 10:49

@Stars71 what would you do if you were a corrupt government who wanted protests banned? You’d encourage or even set up fake protests and plant protesters to encourage this along. I wouldn’t put it past them to have done this. Many groups have.
the Sarah everard protests were peaceful and it made no difference.
They could sit nicely by the side of the road and people could still claim they are being a nuisance.
you all sound like far right nutters tbh who coincidentally also don’t want rights for anyone either.

Or we could do like France, rip their hands off the road, baton charge protesters, tear gas them.

Or we could have a happy medium. Protest peacefully, quietly, and don't disrupt the lives of others, who many not agree with your protest. Would you feel differently, if for example, a load of anti-abortionists were blocking entrances to hospitals..... they are allowed to protest after all.

Justkidding55 · 18/10/2022 10:49

Stars71 · 18/10/2022 10:30

Well with the way things are going, protests WILL be banned. These people don't know how to protest peacefully, without causing destruction.The only good they are doing is making people realise even more how our police is a service, not a force. Namby pamby tactics are used rather than forcing the buggers to move out of the way of ambulances etc.

@Stars71 what would you do if you were a corrupt government who wanted protests banned? You’d encourage or even set up fake protests and plant protesters to encourage this along. I wouldn’t put it past them to have done this. Many groups have.
the Sarah everard protests were peaceful and it made no difference.
They could sit nicely by the side of the road and people could still claim they are being a nuisance.
you all sound like far right nutters tbh who coincidentally also don’t want rights for anyone either.

Stars71 · 18/10/2022 10:30

Justkidding55 · 18/10/2022 09:43

The venom people have towards protests is bizarre. Be careful what you wish for because rights to protest are being continually eroded and that is the real thing we should be worried about. If this government has its way we won’t be allowed to protest at all and we already have a PM with no actual power, doing things that weren’t in their manifesto and by people we didn’t vote for. Imagine when protest is banned? They are doing it by the backdoor. Who decides what’s peaceful? Who decides where is a good place or time to protest? Anyone can say a protest is inconvenient.

Well with the way things are going, protests WILL be banned. These people don't know how to protest peacefully, without causing destruction.The only good they are doing is making people realise even more how our police is a service, not a force. Namby pamby tactics are used rather than forcing the buggers to move out of the way of ambulances etc.

CurzonDax · 18/10/2022 10:22

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 06:53

I fully support and endorse just stop oil. They very briefly got soup on some glass. Meanwhile the entire fate of the planet is going to shit because we have corrupt and incompetent leaders. Direct your anger at the right place maybe?

They very briefly got soup on some glass.

Erm - try telling that to the local residents of Kent and Essex right now, due to those idiots on the QE2 bridge.
The second day in a row of massive traffic delays - those people stuck in traffic for over two hours, missing hospital appointments at Darent Valley Hospital. Or those just trying to get to work, so they can afford to pay their bills and feed themselves/their families, during a cost of living crisis.

We're not just talking about people being annoyed as they're missing a day of shopping at Lakeside/Bluewater - we're talking about normal people just trying to live. For those people, this is not just some soup on some glass.

The bridge idiots are causing massive disruptions, and targeting the wrong people - after the show in government yesterday, I doubt anyone in government is bothered by the disruption caused to Joe Bloggs in Thurrock.

Stars71 · 18/10/2022 10:22

Vikinga · 18/10/2022 00:35

Oh do piss off. Brave activists risk their lives and their freedom all over the world. So get off your pathetic soap box and do something useful. When people are trying to save your lives and your future at least be grateful or stfu

Another aggressive post. You don't see, do you, how your attitude just does you zero favours. It is why childish antics of the 'protestors' get them nowhere. You go about it entirely the wrong way. No, I won't STFU.

BerriesOnTop · 18/10/2022 10:02

CherryGenoa · 18/10/2022 09:34

Fossil fuel companies have long known about man made climate change and as you see from my previous post, had the resources to transition citizens smoothly to a low carbon, sustainable lifestyle that would not reduce living standards. But they didn’t.

And what, pray tell, would these companies be transitioning to?

Because solar and wind cannot sustain a modern economy.

Hydroelectric power has limits, and can be too contentious in developing countries (build a dam and then you are denying people water downstream).

Only nuclear power can replace fossil fuels in electricity generation. But even that cannot touch the needs of the agricultural industry nor the shipping/transport section, nor pharmaceuticals and medical devices, among other needs.

You just aren’t being very realistic.

Mardyface · 18/10/2022 09:53

Honestly I'm starting to think most of these 'issue of the day' threads are started by journalists or government and industry schills to guage opinion or spread the party/industry line. I'm never eloquent enough to refute things eloquently so thank goodness for people like @CherryGenoa and others.

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 09:51

I have no issue with protests. I went on plenty of marches in my time and I was at Greenham. My issue is with wanton waste and destruction to no good end. Wave as many placards as you want, shout as much as you want, it’s fine with me. Slinging tins of soup at paintings and pouring milk on a supermarket floor - just fuck off and stop behaving like a brat.

BerriesOnTop · 18/10/2022 09:51

The fossil fuel industry receives $11 million per MINUTE in subsidies according to the IMF, so industry PR minions are deployed to spread misinformation in order to protect those interests. This is what this poster represents

So anyone who has an opposing POV is some industry shill? That’s some logic you have. Very sad this is the only way you can handle an opposing opinion in your mind.

Why did the oil and gas industry not put the 3 billion $ per day profits earned every day for the past 50 years to make this happen then?

Their wheelhouse is fossil fuel extraction. They probably wouldn’t be any good at development work, now would they? It’s not just a matter of money but a commitment to providing a good environment for businesses to thrive. Money is easy to give (and into the wrong hands), the hard work of creating infrastructure is not (Europeans should know this lol what with the HS2 and inability to get nuclear power plants up and running 🤦‍♀️).

In China, this was first done in places like Shezhen, where migrants flocked to pick up a poorly paid (but good for China) job in one of the many export-oriented factories. After making some money, they would often open their own small businesses back home as a knock-on effect. South Korea, Taiwan and Japan has similar experiences (although iirc took a more direct route in picking winners in key industries). Luckily there was a big market in the US to sell their products, but pre-Covid they were making good headway selling their cheap goods in the MENA and South America.

Justkidding55 · 18/10/2022 09:43

The venom people have towards protests is bizarre. Be careful what you wish for because rights to protest are being continually eroded and that is the real thing we should be worried about. If this government has its way we won’t be allowed to protest at all and we already have a PM with no actual power, doing things that weren’t in their manifesto and by people we didn’t vote for. Imagine when protest is banned? They are doing it by the backdoor. Who decides what’s peaceful? Who decides where is a good place or time to protest? Anyone can say a protest is inconvenient.

CherryGenoa · 18/10/2022 09:34

Fossil fuel companies have long known about man made climate change and as you see from my previous post, had the resources to transition citizens smoothly to a low carbon, sustainable lifestyle that would not reduce living standards. But they didn’t.

CherryGenoa · 18/10/2022 09:25

BerriesOnTop · 18/10/2022 08:25

Millions of people worldwide are dying and being displaced and all people can do is moan about people trying to get it into the bloody news

Fossil fuels are lifesaving. They create lifesaving infrastructure, heat and cool homes, give a massive boost to agriculture through chemical fertilisers, byproducts are used for medication and medical devices.

You want to save people in the developing world? Give them coal plants, roads, decent housing, larger-scale agriculture.

China has lifted more people out of poverty than any other government — through industrialisation. Would that other developing countries follow their model (and I have no particular love for the current Chinese government either)

The fossil fuel industry receives $11 million per MINUTE in subsidies according to the IMF, so industry PR minions are deployed to spread misinformation in order to protect those interests. This is what this poster represents.

The latest IPCC report warns that the world is set to reach the 1.5ºC level within the next two decades and only the most drastic cuts in carbon emissions will help avert environmental disaster, resource wars and mass human suffering, all over the world.

Fossil fuel reserves need to stay in the ground now. No further expansion, no opening of coal plants, no new licences.

Oh and by the way

You want to save people in the developing world? Give them coal plants, roads, decent housing, larger-scale agriculture.

Why did the oil and gas industry not put the 3 billion $ per day profits earned every day for the past 50 years to make this happen then? They have had ample time and resources to make a difference to the developing world in the ways described. Didn’t happen. And now this approach would be very unwise. Follow the science.