Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
BerriesOnTop · 19/10/2022 06:02

The WHO estimate we are already seeing 250k excess deaths globally because of climate change

No we aren’t. Where are you getting such ridiculous figures?

user1477391263 · 19/10/2022 01:45

Have you heard of the suffragettes and the lengths that they went to in their quest to women the vote?

Yes, and they almost certainly delayed women getting the vote by several years. Women probably would have got the vote before WWI if it hadn't been for the suffragettes (who were run by a bunch of upper class dillitantes).

The real hard slog of getting the vote were the suffragISTs (led by Millicent Fawcett), who spent decades doing boring sensible things that worked, like building alliances with lawmakers, writers and the clergy, talking to people and winning them over, and involving women in all walks of life including poor women and rural women.

katmeouws · 19/10/2022 00:37

Have you heard of the suffragettes and the lengths that they went to in their quest to women the vote?

Twillow · 19/10/2022 00:31

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 17:51

There is a simple fact that petrol/diesel contains so much usable energy in a relatively portable format that it cannot be replaced as a mans of powering practical vehicles. Electrical vehicles are basically a way of hiding the emissions that are needed to produce electricity so are placing the 'pollution out of obvious sight. This is basic physics and guess what, physics is well understood and is impossible to escape. Yes you can have 'breakthroughs' but for various reasons such as cost and inconvenience all alternatives will fail.While battery technology will improve, it will never be able to replace petrol/diesel as a universal practical solution without radical changes for everybody. Meaning redesigning of towns and cities to facilitate 'battery powered transportation. How much do you think it would cost to rip up all the streets of the UK (world) to lay new electric cables to allow battery vehicles to be recharged in a time that would be 'convenient' for average travellers? This is the practical requirement that would have to be met to fulfill the fantasies of those with electric vehicles. The electricity generating capability of the UK would have to be tripled (or more) to supply enough power to charge electric vehicles Bear in mind that on average the UK already has to 'import' around 10% of it's electricity from Europe.

Wrong on so many levels.
You are still looking on electricity as carbon based. You should be asking why Liz Truss is against solar. If this government hadn't systematically ripped out almost all support for green initiatives , don't you think more of us would have domestic solar panels and be less vulnerable to the current crisis, let alone reducing emissions? It really makes me question what price this relentless 'growth' plan comes at and how much influence and power the oil industry have over policy.
Electric vehicles have been allowed to develop in entirely the wrong direction -very likely because there is more money and jobs in it by cultivating domestic plug ins.
There are already several very succesful and long-lived kinetic based electric vehicles such as the Prius - these generate energy in movement and do not require plugging in.
With plug ins, it would make much more sense to transform existing petrol stations into battery exchanges - no need to install wiiring domestically and in supermarket car parks etc. Would be as quick as filling up with fuel is at present.
Hydrogen also has the potential to be a viable car power within 10 years.
Sadly though, every new technology is being looked on by industry/governments as an opportunity rather than a solution.

catflycat · 18/10/2022 23:23

We and all other industrialised nations need to reduce our emissions so much such that non-industrialised countries can catch up. It's not enough to aim to be carbon neutral in 2050, we need to do it now and we should be aiming to be carbon negative.

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 23:20

catflycat · 18/10/2022 23:13

It may be in the past but is hasn't gone anywhere, that's kind of the point 🙄 We need to do more, also we're not on track to hit the 2050 target.

But I don’t understand your point about the industrial revolution, it was over a century ago! I understand those emissions are still up in the atmosphere, but what can we do about that now?
Its about looking to the future.

We can’t educate the people that were around then on climate change because they’re all dead!

catflycat · 18/10/2022 23:13

It may be in the past but is hasn't gone anywhere, that's kind of the point 🙄 We need to do more, also we're not on track to hit the 2050 target.

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 23:03

catflycat · 18/10/2022 22:55

Have a look at 'our world in data' and you can see the actual numbers for yourself - there's a good write up here:

eciu.net/insights/2021/why-the-uks-1-of-global-emissions-is-a-big-deal

"the UK is the fifth biggest historic emitter in the world. That’s because we started the burning of fossil fuels – we were the birthplace of the Industrial Revolution. That’s far from water under the bridge – all those carbon emissions are still up there in the atmosphere, and form part of the climate crisis we face today. "

We can’t change the past because of the industrial revolution. That generation is long dead. The UK is committed to net zero by 2050.
The UK is looking forward and doing what it can to be greener. You can’t just make everyone ditch fossil fuels overnight. You have to have realistic expectations.
Im not asking for ‘heroes’ to risk their lives by climbing the Dartford crossing. As for them risking prison, yes I hope they do get sentenced.

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 22:56

Well engines idling is worse for the planet than when they’re moving. So they actually caused more harm to the environment causing traffic jams.

I feel sorry for the man who missed a funeral. The lorry drivers stuck on the M25 with little food and drink.
People going to hospital for cancer treatment.
Ambulances stuck around Kent and Essex and the surrounding areas because of grid locked traffic.
People may have died today because two idiots decided to climb a bridge.

Also if the government backed down to these groups, surely that would set a precedent? Serious question, just wondering.

catflycat · 18/10/2022 22:55

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 22:47

Sorry I don’t believe what you’ve stated there.

Have a look at 'our world in data' and you can see the actual numbers for yourself - there's a good write up here:

eciu.net/insights/2021/why-the-uks-1-of-global-emissions-is-a-big-deal

"the UK is the fifth biggest historic emitter in the world. That’s because we started the burning of fossil fuels – we were the birthplace of the Industrial Revolution. That’s far from water under the bridge – all those carbon emissions are still up there in the atmosphere, and form part of the climate crisis we face today. "

catflycat · 18/10/2022 22:48

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 17:54

No, they’re not any of those things. If you need chemo and you’re prevented from attending your appointment, you’re obviously going to pissed off and upset because some numpty is lashed to a bridge which will have zero impact on anything.

The WHO estimate we are already seeing 250k excess deaths globally because of climate change. It's all happening now - what are you doing about it? There isn't anything that's more important then changing our and other governments' approach to fossil fuels and climate change. We've had gardens spontaneously combust in the UK this summer after record temps, crops are failing, 80% the Maldives will be lost by 2050 because of rising sea levels. 3500 species are currently critically endangered - meaning there's a 50% chance they'll be extinct in ten years. Everyone should be doing everything they can to bring about change, and supporting those who are risking prison (because the gov are making peaceful protest illegal because it's inconvenient).

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 22:47

catflycat · 18/10/2022 22:38

Our total emissions are higher then India, and we have produced 1/3 the emissions of China despite China being 39 time larger. We had our industrial revolution earlier and we outsource much of our damaging production of things we dont really need to China. Guessing you have nothing in your house made in China?

Sorry I don’t believe what you’ve stated there.

catflycat · 18/10/2022 22:38

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 21:10

If the UK didn’t exist from tomorrow morning, it would make barely no impact on the worlds carbon footprint.

We are little Britain.

There are massive countries that churn out emissions far bigger than we’ll ever be able to control no matter what token gestures we make.

Four words- China, Russia, USA, India.

I’d have more respect if these terrorist groups went over to these places to ‘protest’.

Our total emissions are higher then India, and we have produced 1/3 the emissions of China despite China being 39 time larger. We had our industrial revolution earlier and we outsource much of our damaging production of things we dont really need to China. Guessing you have nothing in your house made in China?

Hawkins001 · 18/10/2022 22:13

Would the behaviour of the protesters, be classed as domestic terrorism ?
then if it would, would gitmo be an option ?

just asking as a question

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 21:27

My question stands, what should one do when observing a catastrophe of untold magnitude unfold in front of you? Does anyone actually have an answer or only critisism for those who try.

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 21:12

Do the people who glue themselves to roads realise that the very glue they use contain oils? The very product they are protesting against.

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 21:10

If the UK didn’t exist from tomorrow morning, it would make barely no impact on the worlds carbon footprint.

We are little Britain.

There are massive countries that churn out emissions far bigger than we’ll ever be able to control no matter what token gestures we make.

Four words- China, Russia, USA, India.

I’d have more respect if these terrorist groups went over to these places to ‘protest’.

Catlady2021 · 18/10/2022 21:04

Here’s a quote from another website;

The World's population is 7.75 billion. The population of Western Europe is less than 2 billion. Let's cascade that further: that of the UK is less than 70 million.

I'll put that another way: the UK's population is less than 0.9% of the world's total.

Less than 1%... less than 1%, in a country which already is actively looking to decarbonise.

So here's a question for you:

How is vandalising works of art, attacking retail outlets, slashing tyres and glueing oneself to road infrastructure in a country with less than 1% of the World's population, but one which is already actively decarbonising, going to significantly influence opinion across the other >99% of the World's population?

I'll save you the bother of answering: it isn't.

WhoDatDen · 18/10/2022 20:49

ILeclercreturn · 16/10/2022 10:49

Most of these 'protests' in the UK are a TOTAL waste of time and space and are simply entitled idiots because climate change and extinction are GLOBAL effects and the UK is only a little island. If the whole population of the UK died (or stayed in bed for months) it would make next to NO difference on the global issues. The UK needs to rapidly learn how insignificant it is in global terms.
The gas 'liberated' by the sabotage of Nord stream pipeline would run UK industry for decades. Because of Brexit the UK is dropping out of the worlds list of serious economies but you have to stand outside the UK to actually see this.

UK is the 6th largest economy in the world - hardly piddling.

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 19:34

It ignites conversation. I'm interested though, in what way do you suggest would be an effective protest?

CurzonDax · 18/10/2022 19:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ivykaty44 · 18/10/2022 18:48

It is why childish antics of the 'protestors' get them nowhere. You go about it entirely the wrong way

yet you can't tell anyone what the correct way to go about this, you are just out to moan about anything without actually adding anything constructive as a counter.

By now everyone on this thread knows what you think of the protestors you write the same thing on every other post you disagree with.

DdraigGoch · 18/10/2022 18:46

CherryGenoa · 18/10/2022 09:25

The fossil fuel industry receives $11 million per MINUTE in subsidies according to the IMF, so industry PR minions are deployed to spread misinformation in order to protect those interests. This is what this poster represents.

The latest IPCC report warns that the world is set to reach the 1.5ºC level within the next two decades and only the most drastic cuts in carbon emissions will help avert environmental disaster, resource wars and mass human suffering, all over the world.

Fossil fuel reserves need to stay in the ground now. No further expansion, no opening of coal plants, no new licences.

Oh and by the way

You want to save people in the developing world? Give them coal plants, roads, decent housing, larger-scale agriculture.

Why did the oil and gas industry not put the 3 billion $ per day profits earned every day for the past 50 years to make this happen then? They have had ample time and resources to make a difference to the developing world in the ways described. Didn’t happen. And now this approach would be very unwise. Follow the science.

I've just had a look through that and the headline is very misleading. You can't just chuck in every single negative impact of oil and call it a "subsidy". The actual figure is a sixth of that.

I'd like to think that a case can be made against oil without the need for sensational headlines.

DdraigGoch · 18/10/2022 18:39

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 17:24

Are people dense, obtuse or still missing the point? Climate change will disrupt absolutely everything. It already is. .

Climate change is not disrupting the Dartford Bridge. A bunch of morons are doing that.

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 17:54

Perfect28 · 18/10/2022 17:24

Are people dense, obtuse or still missing the point? Climate change will disrupt absolutely everything. It already is. .

No, they’re not any of those things. If you need chemo and you’re prevented from attending your appointment, you’re obviously going to pissed off and upset because some numpty is lashed to a bridge which will have zero impact on anything.