Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
Dave20 · 20/10/2022 18:03

I can only assume the people on here who side with those idiots who climbed a bridge were not affected by them.
Never mind poor innocent people with children , old people, and sick people who were stuck in cars for hours.

Those two men endangered their own lives and used up lots of public services. You know, the public services that are at breaking point

But if you weren’t affected and live in ivory towers, I’m happy for you.

And if you think those two men actually will change the attitude of global , multibillion dolllar oil companies, then you’re even more stupid ( or naive) than I thought.

Dave20 · 20/10/2022 17:54

Vikinga · 19/10/2022 14:51

Yeah well, the few people who will do their bit like that will have us knee deep in floods and food scarcity and deadly heatwaves in the near future.

We need systemic change and to transition extremely quickly from burning fossil fuels. Doing a bit of recycling and a few walks instead of drives will do sweet FA. Even if it makes you feel like you've done your bit. It won't make any difference.

Listen to what the scientists are saying in every way they can. See what is happening around the world. Listen to what the experts, the ones who gain nothing from it say we need to do.

What do you suppose us normal folk can do though? I drive trucks, delivering essential goods. The stuff that people need to eat, to survive.
I drive a petrol car to work and work various shifts at anti social hours.
Please tell me what I can personally do.

And what if other big polluters, such as Russia, China and India?
What do they do ?

ILeclercreturn · 20/10/2022 16:41

{BerriesOnTop · Today 15:34}
Since when are Europeans children?
There are many different needs and opinions across the 27 Countries of the EU and more if you include other non EU members so a blanket dismissal of 450 million people is rather silly. artificially regulated supply, yes of course it is, OPEC for which the UK is largely a tagalong member. When it comes to it you will discover the UK is very reliant on Europe just to survive and Brexit has been an exercise in slapping the people who would help you in the face. Fracking if viable would take 5 years absolute minimum to come onstram and as gas prices are determined globally the price would not be determined by the UK.
As limpbiskit says UK housing is way behind 'best practice' and the sluggish adoption of techniques used elsewhere in Europe is just part of it. House building is controlled by government and mainly in the hands of Tory donors.
Climate change will affect UK homeowners because hotter summers and colder/wetter winters will shift the requirements . Measures to control excess rainwater runoff have only been introduced relatively recently and this affects the whole drainage and sewer systems. Newbuild estates now have to have rainwater capture/dispersal schemes which are relatively easy to implement but retrofitting to old estates is massively intrusive. Building on flood plains never was a good idea as the groundworks necessary to protect them are immense.

LimpBiskit · 20/10/2022 15:56

ivykaty44 · 20/10/2022 15:15

@LimpBiskit new homes are not insulated to the degree that other countries in the northern hemisphere insulated, which vastly improves the heat retention.

Not all old homes can be insulated, but that doesn't stop other homes being insulated and in particular that would be a vast majority of council homes.

Its not bollocks to make improvements, the people living in these homes would certainly benefit both health wise and if they could save 25% on their fuel bill rather than 50% they'll still take the 25%

We are nowhere near passivehaus standards if that's what you're getting at but we are also a much wetter country which means we need more ventilation than some other countries too. High insulation can be achieved but it requires active ventilation systems to work properly and they are very expensive. The U values set out in Building regs 2022 are sufficient for our climate and increasing them means significant structural change. Pre existing housing stock cannot be insulated beyond a certain point and many houses, including many council houses cannot be insulated beyond their build spec. For example, it's just cost my local council nearly a million to remove the insulation from some of their properties due to it causing damp. The insulation acts as a bridging material and draws moisture into the properties. The cavity is there for a reason. I think most people have their houses insulated to the optimum levels and this has been an ongoing process for decades.

BerriesOnTop · 20/10/2022 15:42

ladyofshertonabbas · 20/10/2022 13:10

I think it’s a fairly mild protest, throwing soup at a glass protected oil painting. Try throwing red wine at a medieval tapestry!

someone has to stand up to climate change, not just let it happen.

Apocalyptic beliefs ☝️

This mentality is similar to that behind destroying the Bamiyan Buddhas. Someone has to stand up to idolatry!

They won’t stop at Van Gogh, they may escalate to destroy actual works of art.

BerriesOnTop · 20/10/2022 15:34

*Fuel poverty is related to the huge global oil and gas industries holding immense power over the people of the world because everyone NEEDS fuel for heating transportation manufacturing etc Gas and oil exist under countries that have dodgy governments (Russia and the Gulf as well as the USA) so THEY rule the roost

No, it’s about (artificially) restricted supply. Europe halved domestic oil production since about 2010, so of course you are at the mercy of foreign governments when it comes to pricing.

Wtf did you think would happen when you started relying on others to serve critical needs like energy just so you could chase the green mirage?

That’s why I say Europeans are children.

ivykaty44 · 20/10/2022 15:15

@LimpBiskit new homes are not insulated to the degree that other countries in the northern hemisphere insulated, which vastly improves the heat retention.

Not all old homes can be insulated, but that doesn't stop other homes being insulated and in particular that would be a vast majority of council homes.

Its not bollocks to make improvements, the people living in these homes would certainly benefit both health wise and if they could save 25% on their fuel bill rather than 50% they'll still take the 25%

DdraigGoch · 20/10/2022 15:12

Hawkins001 · 19/10/2022 20:09

Yes, and they should continue to do so. After watching a 6hr banking debate with the head's of the largest banks in USA and UK.

It can be surprising just how large the carbon footprint of your mortgage is.
www.theguardian.com/environment/green-living-blog/2010/sep/16/carbon-footprint-mortgage

ILeclercreturn · 20/10/2022 13:59

Fuel poverty is NOT because the UK doesn't frack. The companies themselves say it is not really viable in the UK because the geology and presence of homes etc make it unviable. Fuel poverty is related to the huge global oil and gas industries holding immense power over the people of the world because everyone NEEDS fuel for heating transportation manufacturing etc. Gas and oil exist under countries that have dodgy governments (Russia and the Gulf as well as the USA) so THEY rule the roost. The other end of the story is that everyone needs to use as few resources as possible, so insulation of all buildings, research (or re learn) techniques for building that use minimal resources. Putting more clothes on to keep warm, don't follow 'fashion' so slavishly which is incredibly wasteful. thousands of tons of 'unsold clothes from UK shops get sent to Asia to go into landfill because they are unwanted because 'fashion' has changed. THAT is an obscenity in itself and is so easily stopped. many UK problems are down to crippling failures in Diplomacy. As awkward as it may feel but the UK HAS to get along with neighbouring countries, and regimes that are abhorrent and simply stamping your feet won't change that. If you want to borrow some money from somebody for example, would you start the discussion by punching them in the face? No, you wouldn't. The UK government has been doing this either quietly or overtly for decades and left British Ambassadors to try and smooth things over as quietly as possible. The Tory government particularly don't seem to have understood that the UK does not have an Empire any more and as such it needs diplomacy more than ever for the UK citizens to retain the quality of life that it had got used to.

LimpBiskit · 20/10/2022 13:18

ivykaty44 · 20/10/2022 13:07

You have fuel poverty because you wouldn’t frack and you didn’t build those nuclear power plants like you should have 10 years ago.

so still selling fuel, not insulating new & old homes and putting solar and airforce heating in to reduce the need for buying so much fuel, rainwater harvesting.

New homes are insulated and many old homes cannot be effectively insulated. Insulate Britain is bollocks for that very reason. Agree with solar to offset carbon based fuels though.

ladyofshertonabbas · 20/10/2022 13:10

I think it’s a fairly mild protest, throwing soup at a glass protected oil painting. Try throwing red wine at a medieval tapestry!

someone has to stand up to climate change, not just let it happen.

ivykaty44 · 20/10/2022 13:07

You have fuel poverty because you wouldn’t frack and you didn’t build those nuclear power plants like you should have 10 years ago.

so still selling fuel, not insulating new & old homes and putting solar and airforce heating in to reduce the need for buying so much fuel, rainwater harvesting.

LimpBiskit · 20/10/2022 12:36

BerriesOnTop · 20/10/2022 12:32

it’s not all about climate change, the fact we have fuel poverty in this country is a direct consequence of the government stance on this for the last 10 years

You have fuel poverty because you wouldn’t frack and you didn’t build those nuclear power plants like you should have 10 years ago.

So yeah, I totally agree with this statement (but in a very different way than you do)

If fuel poverty is real (and it very much is), the last thing you want to do is further restrict supply, like this lot want!

Disagree with fracking as the evidence clearly indicates the risks outweigh the benefits. Agree about nuclear though and that should have been done years ago and in house without outsourcing to EDF!

BerriesOnTop · 20/10/2022 12:32

it’s not all about climate change, the fact we have fuel poverty in this country is a direct consequence of the government stance on this for the last 10 years

You have fuel poverty because you wouldn’t frack and you didn’t build those nuclear power plants like you should have 10 years ago.

So yeah, I totally agree with this statement (but in a very different way than you do)

If fuel poverty is real (and it very much is), the last thing you want to do is further restrict supply, like this lot want!

LimpBiskit · 20/10/2022 12:31

ivykaty44 · 20/10/2022 12:05

I don't think many people deny climate change. The debate is around how much influence humans have over it.

it’s not all about climate change, the fact we have fuel poverty in this country is a direct consequence of the government stance on this for the last 10 years

all the things that would primarily decrease climate change would also reduce people choosing between eating and heating

it would also reduce deaths from pollution of 40000 people each year in the U.K.

There are too many protesters with mixed messages though and targeting different things. The most impactful change would be to move away from gas for domestic heating as it generates large quantities of co2 and is the biggest contributor of PM2.5 but no-one is advocating that and instead focussing on vehicles which contribute very little to greenhouse gasses or indeed PM2.5 particles.
The most impactful thing would be a proliferation of nuclear power but that brings an other host of issues for future generations to manage. Solar isn't the answer in the UK but can offset carbon based fuel use.
It would be helpful if protestors came together with a clear message and a clear way forward instead of being disparate and having different foci.

ivykaty44 · 20/10/2022 12:05

I don't think many people deny climate change. The debate is around how much influence humans have over it.

it’s not all about climate change, the fact we have fuel poverty in this country is a direct consequence of the government stance on this for the last 10 years

all the things that would primarily decrease climate change would also reduce people choosing between eating and heating

it would also reduce deaths from pollution of 40000 people each year in the U.K.

LimpBiskit · 20/10/2022 11:48

thedancingbear · 20/10/2022 07:26

It's quite likely that at least some people defending fossil fuels (not necessarily posters on here) are paid shills for the energy industry. It's a recognised thing. There are entire PR agencies who makes this their business.

As a result, anyone reading the online debates would think the jury was out on the existence, and likely catastrophic consequences, of climate change. The reality is that there is overwhelming scientific consensus that we are heading for an unprecedented shitstorm. The only real debate among serious people is whether, if left unchecked, it will be civilisation-changing or cilvilisation-ending.

I don't think many people deny climate change. The debate is around how much influence humans have over it.

ILeclercreturn · 20/10/2022 11:44

{Solar has ample potential for domestic electricity - how many flat-roof buildings are there in the UK without solar? Why is it not legislated for all distribution centres to have solar roofs?}
Flat roofs are only 'partly good for solar use because they need to be oriented correctly but otherwise you are right that legislation and better inducements to install solar for PV and water heating could and should have been done a decade or more ago. This along with even the more simple insulation schemes would have been massively beneficial to so many. Of course a major issue is corruption where everything is monetised the government, corrupt itself, hands vast sums to lobby groups for schemes that are often bad value. So 'simple' aspects like changing planning laws and house building regulations and properly targetted assistance to get insulation/solar PV/heating installed at a time when buildings may be having other work done (to reduce disruption) is vital. the problem being the government (Tory) don't want citizenst to really benefit. Labour COULD possibly have worked harder on this but are not necessarily as focused on the more practical aspects.

Stars71 · 20/10/2022 11:15

So now spray painting the entrance to Harrods? Total lunacy and well done to the blokes tearing up their banners and physically removing them from the roads. If the police can't do their jobs, the hard working public will.

Twillow · 20/10/2022 11:01

BerriesOnTop · 20/10/2022 07:57

Good grief. Why are you so persistent that it is only fossil fuels that can advance developing nations? There are umpteen technologies in existence and development that can do the vast majority of this without having to go back to medieval labour

If you are referring to nuclear power, that’s fine for electricity generation. (Hydro can be very problematic for those downstream, to be deployed with caution).

But you still need plenty of fossil fuel inputs for construction (ie infrastructure), agriculture and heavy transport. There’s really no way around it.

And you are utterly incorrect that climate deaths drop after an industrial revolution

No, look at natural disasters death tolls and you will find they have dropped precipitously. Monsoons, flooding and famine used to kill tens of thousands and even hundreds of thousands for very bad disasters. Now it’s rare for those numbers to be reached despite much bigger populations.

Other kinds of death may well drop, but industrial revolutions are the mainstay of climate change

Yes, but my argument is that good infrastructure and productive economies can overcome this.

I'm not a big fan of nuclear for electricity - it simply leaves the world with different long-term risks. Solar has ample potential for domestic electricity - how many flat-roof buildings are there in the UK without solar? Why is it not legislated for all distribution centres to have solar roofs?

The pathetic proportion of money invested into greener fuels by the oil companies should have had a far greater impact on the development of biofuels and hydrogen by now, both of which are viable alternatives for heavy machinery and aviation.

I have investigated and interestingly you are correct that deaths from natural disasters have dropped (with a caveat):
"The number of disasters has increased by a factor of five over the 50-year period, driven by climate change, more extreme weather and improved reporting. But, thanks to improved early warnings and disaster management, the number of deaths decreased almost three-fold" (World Meteorological Organisation). The decreased deaths are not, as you imply, due to the infrastructure itself.

ILeclercreturn · 20/10/2022 10:28

{WhoDatDen · 18/10/2022 20:49}
The UK might have been 6th in a ranking of economies but it certainly isn't now and due to the antics of the Tory Government (and the secretive ERG) the UK is going to fall a very long way, because manufacturing (money creation) is knackered and largely uninvestable, and in any case much of it wouldn't help UK citizens as is being proven. Workers in the UK are likely to become the Uighurs of China when the Chinese decide to flex their muscles in the UK. the 'incident' at the Chinese Embassy in Manchester 2 days ago is only a foretaste of things to come. Much of Africa and all countries on the perimeter of the South China sea are indebted to China and even the uS economy would collapse if China called in the debts in the USA.

BerriesOnTop · 20/10/2022 08:18

we (as well as countries in the markets you mention) now 'offshore' much of their manufacturing, and, when challenged on emissions, say 'ours are tiny - you need to look at China and India'. When of course it's us creating the problem

So offshoring is a problem for you? Do you want to bring industry back to Britain and stop importing Chinese goods? (there goes your climate targets lol not that Europe is willing to do what it takes to have a thriving manufacturing sector)

Why flagellate yourselves over a trend that has only improved life in China for the average person. They would’ve remained an incredibly poor, impoverished country (as would Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea before them) without exporting their products to global markets.

Its astonishing you think this was something negative. Export-oriented development was the biggest anti-poverty action in history, basically.

BlueWalnut · 20/10/2022 07:59

Vikinga · 19/10/2022 18:56

It isn't just goods. It is our investments. Our banking etc. They fund fossil fuels.

One of the most impactful actions people can take are to divest from fossil fuel investments. They need to stay in the ground and one way to achieve that is to make sure that my own bank or pension is not investing in the oil and gas industry.

BerriesOnTop · 20/10/2022 07:57

Good grief. Why are you so persistent that it is only fossil fuels that can advance developing nations? There are umpteen technologies in existence and development that can do the vast majority of this without having to go back to medieval labour

If you are referring to nuclear power, that’s fine for electricity generation. (Hydro can be very problematic for those downstream, to be deployed with caution).

But you still need plenty of fossil fuel inputs for construction (ie infrastructure), agriculture and heavy transport. There’s really no way around it.

And you are utterly incorrect that climate deaths drop after an industrial revolution

No, look at natural disasters death tolls and you will find they have dropped precipitously. Monsoons, flooding and famine used to kill tens of thousands and even hundreds of thousands for very bad disasters. Now it’s rare for those numbers to be reached despite much bigger populations.

Other kinds of death may well drop, but industrial revolutions are the mainstay of climate change

Yes, but my argument is that good infrastructure and productive economies can overcome this.

thedancingbear · 20/10/2022 07:35

BerriesOnTop · 19/10/2022 17:43

But the point is often missed that if you factor in goods we consume that are manufactured in other countries, our footprint is much more than 1%. I'm sure you recognise this but many don't

China has been diversifying into Middle Eastern and South American markets and see themselves as part of a more global middle class
than exclusively serving Western markets. This is part of the work I do btw—whether certain posters want to believe that or not, as they just want to believe I’m some sort of oil shill 😆

I don't see where anyone has suggested China is serving exclusively Western markets? The problem, as you well know, is that we (as well as countries in the markets you mention) now 'offshore' much of their manufacturing, and, when challenged on emissions, say 'ours are tiny - you need to look at China and India'. When of course it's us creating the problem.

This is so fundamental. It's depressing that it needs repeating.

Swipe left for the next trending thread