Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
Plexie · 14/10/2022 18:11

Some Suffragette campaigners damaged paintings in public art galleries in the early 1900s (and also committed arson elsewhere).

There was a display at the National Portrait Gallery in London a few years ago of the steps galleries took to prevent it: liaising with each other and the police, circulating mug-shots, extra guards, bag searches (sound familiar?). And I'm not sure if I'm mis-remembering but I think at one stage only women visitors were allowed if they were accompanied by a man.

Here's an article about similar steps taken in Liverpool:

www.liverpoolmuseums.org.uk/stories/troublesome-ladies-and-vote100

"... as reported in the Liverpool Daily Post on 8 May 1914, visitors had been banned from bringing bags, cameras and packages in to the Walker and four additional commissionaires, or guards, had been employed to patrol the galleries in the hope of averting a suffragette attack."

RoseyPalm · 14/10/2022 18:05

@latetothefisting You cannot expect new technologies to be developed much more quickly than has been achieved. Several attempts to make safe workable batteries for instance. Remember the laptop batteries that caught fire. Airlines threatened to ban them from aircraft. Estimate the greater amounts of heat that a few hundred would develop in a family car.
What did these activists contribute to science to speed up the solution?

sagalooshoe · 14/10/2022 18:04

And what point were they trying to make? That even the oil in oil painting must be forbidden now? 😆

glamourousindierockandroll · 14/10/2022 18:02

I don't think their actions are anything to do with climate change. I think these are individuals who get a kick out of causing trouble, plain and simple. As someone who supports green initiatives, I think it damages the message massively.

colddayinhell · 14/10/2022 17:59

BigWoollyJumpers · 14/10/2022 13:48

We have energy crisis. We have cost of living crisis. We have fuel crisis.

None of which will be solved in the short term by stopping gas and oil exploration/extraction. What do they expect people to do? Burn logs in their living rooms? Twats.

This. They are incredibly naive and misinformed middle-class muppets who have never experienced real hardship. Do they think that world governments can suddenly magic-up a new special form of energy that will be magically cheaper and cleaner than oil and gas and all abundant? They are just causing problems for people trying to get to work and get to hospital. I wish the police would treat them with the same uncompromising urgency as they treat football thugs.

Hawkins001 · 14/10/2022 17:57

Appleandoranges · 14/10/2022 17:54

But these people are being imprisoned. They are throwing themselves in front of cars though not horses. And someone was threatening to run them over in this thread. Suffragettes also took part in what were seen as outrageous publicity stunts. Maybe these protesters will be seen differently in 100 years time. I do think there are some similarities between them and the suffragettes

One key difference, they are not after being able to vote, and their actions are unlikely to alter anything, it could be debated, especially when it's usually big business that with investment and research, it could also be debated that will help the environment.

StillWeRise · 14/10/2022 17:56

I haven't RTFT but they seem to have been unsuccessful in that we are all discussing their tactics rather than the climate disaster.
It is of course possible to care about and want to protect art
and also
care about and want to protect nature, the planet and people
they should direct their attention to the oil companies and the government.
They also need to do the boring hard work of talking to ordinary people and persuading them that we actually face an emergency- this takes time, patience, imagination, compassion and respect.

I despair I really do- I have been talking about climate change since possibly before these 2 were born. I eat a mostly local, vegetarian diet. My leaky house is insulated as well as I can afford and heated very conservatively. I use active transport or public transport wherever possible. I fly very very rarely and only when unavoidable. If these people have alienated me, how do they expect to win over the people who are still thinking 'warmer summers? bring it on!'

Appleandoranges · 14/10/2022 17:54

But these people are being imprisoned. They are throwing themselves in front of cars though not horses. And someone was threatening to run them over in this thread. Suffragettes also took part in what were seen as outrageous publicity stunts. Maybe these protesters will be seen differently in 100 years time. I do think there are some similarities between them and the suffragettes

BerriesOnTop · 14/10/2022 17:48

People don't seem to understand that if we want to halt, let alone even try to reverse climate change it will mean HUGE changes to "ordinary lives" but even then that's better than the alternative which is that there won't be any ordinary lives left to live for billions because huge parts of the planet will be uninhabitable and the knock on effects on even those homes aren't flooded or to hot to live, lives will.be affected or ended by the knock on effects of global famine/mass migration etc

The planet is not going to be uninhabitable. You read the IPCC reports and you’ll read no such thing.

Funny how the countries where people are fleeing from are the very ones without stable access to energy. You don’t see desperate migrants from say, China (well, anymore), because they’ve managed to raise the living standards of the average person by leaps and bounds. Migration from developing countries would drop if they followed the East Asian model of development. We should encourage that to raise global living standards instead of impoverishing ourselves pointlessly

Hawkins001 · 14/10/2022 17:47

VladmirsPoutine · 14/10/2022 17:44

The world is becoming inhabitable. Some kids throwing paint at a painting behind glass will not change that the earth is literally in places flooding and or underwater.

That's where we need big technology companies to develop new technologies to help save the environment.

OilSlick · 14/10/2022 17:46

@Journeybacknorth thanks for the considered reply, however just to take issue with the figures quoted - whilst "true" via the lense applied to them they are manipulated (time/ capex/ projections etc)

I know first hand that for 22-23 the figure for one of those that you quote is more like 40% of profit invested in energy transition linked projects, not traditional exploration and production.

VladmirsPoutine · 14/10/2022 17:44

The world is becoming inhabitable. Some kids throwing paint at a painting behind glass will not change that the earth is literally in places flooding and or underwater.

Hawkins001 · 14/10/2022 17:44

xogossipgirlxo · 14/10/2022 13:26

They are terrorists.

Excatly, one could ask the question if they were detained in a official sanctioned site, weather it would modify their behaviours.

latetothefisting · 14/10/2022 17:42

RoseyPalm · 14/10/2022 17:30

@EscapeRoomToTheSun and other sympathisers.
Why do you all ignore what has been done already? All vehicle manufacturers have used technology and developed systems to make engines more efficient and much less polluting.

Much electricity is now being generated from renewables.
More EVs have been sold to end consumers than was forecast.
There are limits to battery production. Lithium is essential but it is in short supply. The price rise is huge.
How else do we ordinary families' cope with more difficulty to live ordinary lives?

Because "what has done already" still isn't even coming close to what needs to be done. Its barely scratching the surface.

People don't seem to understand that if we want to halt, let alone even try to reverse climate change it will mean HUGE changes to "ordinary lives" but even then that's better than the alternative which is that there won't be any ordinary lives left to live for billions because huge parts of the planet will be uninhabitable and the knock on effects on even those homes aren't flooded or to hot to live, lives will.be affected or ended by the knock on effects of global famine/mass migration etc.

The only outside chance to avoid either of those things is for governments to spend fortunes on researching and implementing alternatives so people can still live similar lifestyles to those we've become accustomed to, including forcing the huge companies that cause most of the issues to make drastic changes - but this will.still require changes in behaviour and lifestyles (much higher tax and things being more expensive as said companies pass on their increased costs to the consumer) to the ordinary person.

Journeybacknorth · 14/10/2022 17:40

OilSlick · 14/10/2022 17:25

But if these technologies aren’t invested in now in favour of new fossil fuel projects I worry the alternative will never materialise and climate breakdown will be irreversible

The amount of investment that is being made in this area now is astonishing, both in the U.K. and globally.

Real, tangible projects that will change the way in which we live in the next decade or so. In a generation, by 2050, the way in which we produce and use energy will have changed immeasurably.

Unfortunately, because it's not yet "visible" most just assume it's not happening.

Just think about how pre covid many were still seeing electric vehicles as a novelty - they won't be the enduring solution I don't think, but the major manufacturers are turning away from the internal combustion engine. It's happening before your eyes.

To give one example (which the U.K. is leading on), the Net Zero Teeside project which is already underway, will when commissioned, remove something like 20% of the U.K. industrial carbon dioxide emissions at the flick of a switch. Once that's up and running, they'll build more and better ones elsewhere as the concept will evolve. this is happening TODAY

We'll still need feedstock in the form of hydrocarbons, but the CO2 will not be produced.

The number of zero or low carbon (wind, solar, biofuel, hydrogen) projects waiting to be signed off in my company alone are so huge in number that it's difficult to keep up, and once they are they'll get turned around and be producing in 5-10 years.

Just Stop Oil are 10-15 years behind the curve at best, they really are.

I work in a related field - not an energy producer - so am aware that strides are being taken.

However - energy producers are investing vastly, vastly more in new oil and gas exploration than renewables. Here is just one investigation done into this - www.channel4.com/news/energy-companies-investing-just-5-of-profits-in-renewables -

“BP invested £300m into renewables and ‘low carbon’ in the first half of 2022 — equivalent to just 2.5% of its £12.2bn profits. By comparison, it invested £3.8bn in new oil and gas projects — more than 10 times its low carbon investments.

Shell invested equivalent to 6.3% of its £17.1bn profits into low carbon energy, investing nearly three times more in oil and gas.

The analysis found all four companies are investing more in fossil fuels than renewables and low carbon energy.”

Now I know people will say there’s no alternative to continuing to expand oil and gas extraction - but continuing the extraction of fossil fuels indefinitely (which, realistically, is what new projects entail) is most certainty not an option either.

I’m going to dip out of this thread now as, honestly, I don’t have the solution to what is such an intensely complex system - and neither does any one person on the internet! But I do know that if we are going to avert climate breakdown we need to start thinking beyond the existing ways of doing things.

And whether you like what they did or not, Just Stop Oil have opened up a conversation on just that through their actions.

sst1234 · 14/10/2022 17:38

Journeybacknorth · 14/10/2022 15:42

Those who say they’re alienating the public/won’t get support through these actions - what do you think will work?

There is no credible argument to suggest that man made climate change isn’t already causing havoc around the world - not to mention the economic and geopolitical ramifications of our reliance on imported fossil fuels.

Over 30 million people were made homeless by flooding in Pakistan and the public don’t support drastic climate action.

Energy bill hikes and high levels of inflation due to curtailed supply of imported fossil fuels is causing economic hardship for millions in the UK and the public don’t support drastic climate action.

Truly - what is left if not direct action?

This kind or regurgitated parroting is totally unhelpful.

Floods happened in Pakistan because of decades of corruption, siphoned funds redirected from infrastructure projects to politicians and finally a culture of backhanders to evade planning rules.

MarshaBradyo · 14/10/2022 17:37

I have just seen the video on IG and they fumbled around with coats and cans for a while. Security must have been in the room

Crosswithlifeatm · 14/10/2022 17:34

It has to come from the top and our problem is our government is more interested in money and quick fixes rather than long term sustainable solutions ,it reacts it doesn't plan.. Insulation is a lowish cost initiative but that has not been followed through on.New builds,still not being built with solar panels,insulation and on flood prone land.
So we need to march and protest,at least that will keep us warm.!
What doesn't help people this winter and probably next is fracking and exploring for more oil wells and will not lower global fuel prices(that needs fixing first).

Hbh17 · 14/10/2022 17:32

A pointless and stupid stunt by idiotic attention-seekers. They are entitled to campaign in support of their views, of course, but I have absolutely no idea why they think this juvenile behaviour furthers their cause.
Thank goodness the painting is OK!

stayathomer · 14/10/2022 17:30

The thing is it’s easy to say people aren’t heeding the environment but it’s not necessarily true. Over the years we’ve had progress- we’ve come on in terms of modern appliances, medicine, heating, hygiene, food keeps longer. All of these things impact the environment but without them we go backwards. But we try. We take as many steps as we can, trying to figure out how to dry clothes in a cold country without using a dryer, drinking borderline disgusting water from a tap to avoid bottled water, buying from charity shops to stay away from fast fashion- the only thing a lot of us can afford.

Look at people saying eg governments need to look at insulating people. Here in Ireland we have grants now for things like solar panels, insulation, different forms of heating. Number one to get the grant you have to be paying a percentage, then they take so long you may have to pay their cut up front and they pay you back. To get solar panels your house has to have a really good energy rating. So basically unless the government can pay for all of it and fix your house what are your options? Oil or gas or burning fossil fuels. People can’t cope with prices rising again- those protestors have no idea

RoseyPalm · 14/10/2022 17:30

@EscapeRoomToTheSun and other sympathisers.
Why do you all ignore what has been done already? All vehicle manufacturers have used technology and developed systems to make engines more efficient and much less polluting.

Much electricity is now being generated from renewables.
More EVs have been sold to end consumers than was forecast.
There are limits to battery production. Lithium is essential but it is in short supply. The price rise is huge.
How else do we ordinary families' cope with more difficulty to live ordinary lives?

jetadore · 14/10/2022 17:26

Worse things happen at sea.

OilSlick · 14/10/2022 17:25

But if these technologies aren’t invested in now in favour of new fossil fuel projects I worry the alternative will never materialise and climate breakdown will be irreversible

The amount of investment that is being made in this area now is astonishing, both in the U.K. and globally.

Real, tangible projects that will change the way in which we live in the next decade or so. In a generation, by 2050, the way in which we produce and use energy will have changed immeasurably.

Unfortunately, because it's not yet "visible" most just assume it's not happening.

Just think about how pre covid many were still seeing electric vehicles as a novelty - they won't be the enduring solution I don't think, but the major manufacturers are turning away from the internal combustion engine. It's happening before your eyes.

To give one example (which the U.K. is leading on), the Net Zero Teeside project which is already underway, will when commissioned, remove something like 20% of the U.K. industrial carbon dioxide emissions at the flick of a switch. Once that's up and running, they'll build more and better ones elsewhere as the concept will evolve. this is happening TODAY

We'll still need feedstock in the form of hydrocarbons, but the CO2 will not be produced.

The number of zero or low carbon (wind, solar, biofuel, hydrogen) projects waiting to be signed off in my company alone are so huge in number that it's difficult to keep up, and once they are they'll get turned around and be producing in 5-10 years.

Just Stop Oil are 10-15 years behind the curve at best, they really are.

Windtunnel · 14/10/2022 17:12

@Asparagoose we could be doing more I'm sure you'd agree though

Blossomtoes · 14/10/2022 17:10

Fucking idiots.