Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 15/10/2022 10:10

It’s the incongruity that gets me

They started with Just Stop Oil then segued into Cost of Living crisis

The latter is caused by the shortage of the former

So if we did just stop oil as they want how many of us could afford to heat our homes?

If they want transition so the price doesn’t spiral further than isn’t that what many want and we are doing already. As pp said above you probably can’t get rid of all of it but bringing in nuclear etc will take time. In the interim what does Just Stop Oil want to happen

7eleven · 15/10/2022 10:09

🤦‍♀️ Oh dear.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 10:06

Alltheprettyseahorses · 15/10/2022 09:58

This is what the climate deniers are like, guys. This is what we are up against.

There is no evidence whatsoever to say the poster is a climate change denier. So we are looking at an irrational movement full of conspiracy theories and manufacturing enemies out of paranoid delusions, which means it will fail because there's no way whatsoever you'll get normal people on your side.

(I guarantee my carbon footprint is a tiny fraction of that of most if not all of those so-called protesters against climate change)

Well, she's calling for the torture and execution of climate activists, so I think it's a reasonable presumption that she is on the other side of the argument. You're free to infer otherwise, of course.

This thread alone shows that there are plenty of people who think the activists have behaved, here, within reasonable parameters.

I guarantee my carbon footprint is a tiny fraction of that of most if not all of those so-called protesters against climate change

Don't be stupid. You have no way of knowing this.

7eleven · 15/10/2022 10:05

Alltheprettyseahorses · 15/10/2022 09:58

This is what the climate deniers are like, guys. This is what we are up against.

There is no evidence whatsoever to say the poster is a climate change denier. So we are looking at an irrational movement full of conspiracy theories and manufacturing enemies out of paranoid delusions, which means it will fail because there's no way whatsoever you'll get normal people on your side.

(I guarantee my carbon footprint is a tiny fraction of that of most if not all of those so-called protesters against climate change)

Great post. It’s a HUGE, irrational leap to assume people who think stunts like this are wrong must be a ‘denier’.

Distinct lack of critical thinking.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 15/10/2022 09:58

This is what the climate deniers are like, guys. This is what we are up against.

There is no evidence whatsoever to say the poster is a climate change denier. So we are looking at an irrational movement full of conspiracy theories and manufacturing enemies out of paranoid delusions, which means it will fail because there's no way whatsoever you'll get normal people on your side.

(I guarantee my carbon footprint is a tiny fraction of that of most if not all of those so-called protesters against climate change)

BerriesOnTop · 15/10/2022 09:57

A very quick Google will tell you you’re wrong on all counts. Just wrong

lol is that all you’ve got? You absolutely must know that our safe, comfortable lives are underpinned by fossil fuels, in nearly all matters.

We cannot transition, no matter how much you may want this.

You could switch to nuclear for electricity generation, but this would still leave us in need of fossil fuels for plastics production/medical devices/agriculture/construction/heavy transport, etc.

all you want to do is deny reality.

MyCatTibby · 15/10/2022 09:46

edenhills · 14/10/2022 15:21

Most people here are completely missing the point. They are holding up a mirror to your cognitive dissonance. Seeing this destruction is making you angry - as it should. But where is your rage at the destruction of the natural world? Amazing beauty that will never be able to be got back. Personally I think the act was misguided to real harm done as the painting was covered in glass and unharmed, as the protestors well knew.

“But where is your rage at the destruction of the natural world”

The destruction of the natural world is due to mankind. We are already overpopulated and it is humans who are destroying the planet. It is humans that need energy and food and the more the population grows the more energy and food will be needed.

The earth’s population in 1900 was circa 2 billion. It took 300,000 years to get to 2 billion.

It is forecast that next month November 2022 we will hit a world population of 8 billion. So we have taken just 122 years to increase the population by 6 billion.

According to some scientists the earth can reasonably sustain a population of 10-14 billion. We are nearly there!! It’s us who are destroying the climate, it’s us destroying the earth with our need for fuel/ heat/food. The more of us, the more the need.

Gruffling · 15/10/2022 09:21

I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

Extinction. It will end the extinction of humanity via climate change, following terrible suffering for billions.

I love that painting, but surprisingly am not annoyed at all. It's just a painting.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 09:14

Just Stop oil is such a ridiculous concept as literally the whole world 'runs' on oil products.

And this is bollocks too, @ILeclercreturn . Around half of the world's energy consumption is currently 'dirty' fossil fuels - coal and oil (Source: ourworldindata.org/energy-mix; OWID is connected with Oxford Uni). Of the remainder, there is some gas and biomass but these are much cleaner.

A transition to a cleaner, safer world for our young people is possible; the scalable technology exists. But you're more interested in seeing those young people freeze to death, or having their skin ripped off.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 09:06

For a start the 'activists' should be detained in a place that has no continued use of oil. so they would be caged up and would both starve and freeze to death (eventually).

Those that are gluing themselves to roads etc should simply be physically removed and if it takes chunks of their skin off, so be it.

You fucking nutcase.

if this is really what you think, you need to go and see your GP. I'm being serious.

This is what the climate deniers are like, guys. This is what we are up against.

ILeclercreturn · 15/10/2022 09:03

Just Stop oil is such a ridiculous concept as literally the whole world 'runs' on oil products. For a start the 'activists' should be detained in a place that has no continued use of oil. so they would be caged up and would both starve and freeze to death (eventually). If they want to protest, they should walk to Russia and stop Mr Putin trashing vast quantities of oil/gas in his war. Similarly the 'Insulate Britain protestors need to protest to the government to INSIST that all UK housing stock (private and council) is adequately insulated. Those that are gluing themselves to roads etc should simply be physically removed and if it takes chunks of their skin off, so be it.

Foxgluv · 15/10/2022 09:02

GloriousGlory · 15/10/2022 08:32

So you'd run them over and kill then?

Yes or no?

Or you'd stand back and clap someone who did do it, but not have the balls yourself?

You've deliberately missed what I'm saying.
If you're sitting on a road and get killed by a vehicle it is your own fault. They're putting their life and others in danger.

They're not preventing some oil tycoon from getting to his daily dose of caviar. They're preventing people getting emergency treatment, encouraging possible collisions, preventing a single mother getting her kids to school on time and reaching a much relied on job, bus loads of people unable to get to where they need, family members not having the opportunity to say goodbye to a relative before they pass away. Fuels expensive too. There's a cost if living crisis. Stop dalaying traffic and endangering the public. This act is doing nothing for their cause.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 15/10/2022 08:56

@windtunnel(?)

My point was that historically governmental change is often persuaded by what % of the populace wants and starts to do. Charities and individuals have started all of the conservation concerns here in the UK. From animals, birds, historic buildings to the more recent solar panels, heat pumps etc.

A government is not an imaginative thing, as Truss is finding out. Their job is to represent us, not have us represent them. And that is how things get changed.

Larger corporations do have to be imaginative. They have to see the beginnings of trends even make those trends. Most of the big utility/fuel companies started their changes decades ago and have pumped millions into research and development of new products. Products the government destroy sometimes, like the manufacturer of wind turbines who was put out of business by Cameron's (?) taxation.

Stop Oil should know where the new solutions are, should be pushing for specifics, could harness the very companies they vilify. But they seem far to evangelical, to set on being Angry Young Things, to be logical. Their pettiness will, like XR, make them ineffective.

It really is down to us, Joe Public. And teeny temper tantrums won't gain traction. They will irritate and the message will be lost. They need far better PR.

GloriousGlory · 15/10/2022 08:32

Foxgluv · 15/10/2022 08:27

I equally can’t believe one of the first posters suggested they would be happy if someone ran them over and potentially murdered them? Seriously, you would be happy to see another human being murdered
They are willfully sitting in front of traffic on busy roads. It's stupidity. If they don't want killed by a car, don't sit on a road. If someone runs them over it's their own fault.
They don't care that emergency vehicles can't get through. Certainly where I am, there's an ambulance shortage. Just because there are no blue lights on a vehicle doesn't mean there isn't an emergency. I had a severe head injury and was taken by car. Women and children could be driving to a safe place. Elderly people or anyone in fact returning home for essential medication. The list goes on. These people don't think beyond themselves. Sitting on roads (also encouraging idle engines) should not be condoned.

So you'd run them over and kill then?

Yes or no?

Or you'd stand back and clap someone who did do it, but not have the balls yourself?

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 08:29

Foxgluv · 15/10/2022 08:27

I equally can’t believe one of the first posters suggested they would be happy if someone ran them over and potentially murdered them? Seriously, you would be happy to see another human being murdered
They are willfully sitting in front of traffic on busy roads. It's stupidity. If they don't want killed by a car, don't sit on a road. If someone runs them over it's their own fault.
They don't care that emergency vehicles can't get through. Certainly where I am, there's an ambulance shortage. Just because there are no blue lights on a vehicle doesn't mean there isn't an emergency. I had a severe head injury and was taken by car. Women and children could be driving to a safe place. Elderly people or anyone in fact returning home for essential medication. The list goes on. These people don't think beyond themselves. Sitting on roads (also encouraging idle engines) should not be condoned.

Again, these people are arseholes. Even if their cause is just, they are causing serious harm by their actions, and just alienating decent people.

Chucking a bit of soup over some glass covering a painting is in a completely different category.

Foxgluv · 15/10/2022 08:27

I equally can’t believe one of the first posters suggested they would be happy if someone ran them over and potentially murdered them? Seriously, you would be happy to see another human being murdered
They are willfully sitting in front of traffic on busy roads. It's stupidity. If they don't want killed by a car, don't sit on a road. If someone runs them over it's their own fault.
They don't care that emergency vehicles can't get through. Certainly where I am, there's an ambulance shortage. Just because there are no blue lights on a vehicle doesn't mean there isn't an emergency. I had a severe head injury and was taken by car. Women and children could be driving to a safe place. Elderly people or anyone in fact returning home for essential medication. The list goes on. These people don't think beyond themselves. Sitting on roads (also encouraging idle engines) should not be condoned.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 08:15

silverclock222 · 15/10/2022 08:10

Just makes me run in the opposite direction when they do things like this. Highlighting the cost of living crisis by throwing away perfectly good food is surely a butut back to front nitvto mention what looks like brand new clothes. I bet they go home to wealthy families too.

A couple of tins of wasted soup >>> thousands or millions of deaths by drowning, starvation etc.

Please don't pretend you give a fuck about poor people, it's offensive.

silverclock222 · 15/10/2022 08:10

Just makes me run in the opposite direction when they do things like this. Highlighting the cost of living crisis by throwing away perfectly good food is surely a butut back to front nitvto mention what looks like brand new clothes. I bet they go home to wealthy families too.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 08:05

Sartre · 15/10/2022 07:43

People called the suffragettes terrorists.

I don’t condone throwing soup on decent artwork although no damage was actually done since they’re covered in protective glass… I equally can’t believe one of the first posters suggested they would be happy if someone ran them over and potentially murdered them? Seriously, you would be happy to see another human being murdered? Pretty sick.

It's the same kind of people who would be happy for thousands of people to drown in Pakistan, or starve to death in Bangladesh.

I'm a million miles from being a greeny sandal-wearing type. but it's becoming increasingly clear we're headed towards a global shitshow that will lead, over time, to millions of deaths.

I don't know whether what these kids have done is a good idea or not, but i can understand their frustration at the fact that fucking nothing is changing. And the fact that many posters on this thread are more concerned about a bit of soup on some glass is just underlining their point.

And, again, this protest is very different from blocking an ambulance or a fire engine, which has potential to cause great harm. Ultimately no damage was done (or intended) that can't be fixed using kitchen towel.

Sartre · 15/10/2022 07:43

People called the suffragettes terrorists.

I don’t condone throwing soup on decent artwork although no damage was actually done since they’re covered in protective glass… I equally can’t believe one of the first posters suggested they would be happy if someone ran them over and potentially murdered them? Seriously, you would be happy to see another human being murdered? Pretty sick.

VegMam · 15/10/2022 07:39

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 21:41

@VegMam genuine question - I’m not trying to be facetious here. You’re clearly very interested in climate change and protecting the planet from it - what are you personally doing about it? Is there anything you’d recommend we do?

I agree it’s something we all need to play a part in, but I don’t think activism is the answer - it doesn’t actually achieve anything directly other than pissing people off.

This has also just got me thinking about the energy price increases. Obviously that is a horrible situation for all of us, and it will be really difficult, but I’m just wondering how much of a difference that’ll make to the environment. Most of us will be forced to use much less energy than usual for an indefinite period - it will be interesting to see what impact that has on the environment.

This article has some god suggestions. My view (based on reading up on studies) is that activism and protests do work. Therefore, the biggest thing I think I can do is be active in my local environmental groups, rallying more activists to the cause.

VegMam · 15/10/2022 07:36

BerriesOnTop · 15/10/2022 06:13

Isn’t it amazing the vitriol aimed at climate protesters who are willing to risk their freedom to fight for a better future for all of us. Where’s the same vitriol for the people who are literally destroying the planet and our children and grandchildren’s futures?

The people in the oil & gas industry are actually supporting the comfortable standard of living you and many around the world enjoy. The only way out of societal poverty is harnessing fossil fuels for development, as was done in East Asia. There’s no way around it.

People such as yourself seem to want to tear down current living standards which will literally destroy the life prospects of your children and grandchildren, more than climate change ever could.

What happened recently in Sri Lanka should have been a wake-up call to people about the dangers of listening to the Green movement …

A very quick Google will tell you you’re wrong on all counts. Just wrong.

VegMam · 15/10/2022 07:35

MrsPerfect12 · 14/10/2022 21:32

I wish they'd spend their energy creating the alternative instead of stupid protests! We're nowhere near ready to do without oil.

Leading scientists say that we are absolutely ready, we have the solutions but not the will. In fact I was speaking to a climate scientist a few years ago about doing a masters in climate related issues, he said if I really want to make a difference I should become an activist; we know what needs to be done and how to do it but governments aren’t willing to.

BerriesOnTop · 15/10/2022 06:13

Isn’t it amazing the vitriol aimed at climate protesters who are willing to risk their freedom to fight for a better future for all of us. Where’s the same vitriol for the people who are literally destroying the planet and our children and grandchildren’s futures?

The people in the oil & gas industry are actually supporting the comfortable standard of living you and many around the world enjoy. The only way out of societal poverty is harnessing fossil fuels for development, as was done in East Asia. There’s no way around it.

People such as yourself seem to want to tear down current living standards which will literally destroy the life prospects of your children and grandchildren, more than climate change ever could.

What happened recently in Sri Lanka should have been a wake-up call to people about the dangers of listening to the Green movement …

clumsygirl · 15/10/2022 00:06

no it’s not my dad works there and they are
embarrassing humans

Swipe left for the next trending thread