Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
WillPowerLite · 16/10/2022 08:25

LaForza101 · 14/10/2022 14:23

I thought this was madness at first and then learnt that it was covered in glass so no damage done. It's got us talking and is in the same protest vein as the suffragette that slashed a painting (but again with no actual destruction).

It did make me think about my abhorrence at the thought that it had been destroyed. I literally watched a news report on animal extinction just yesterday with more passivity and that feels wrong now

I also had the animal extinction story in my head when I heard this.

Good on them for doing this. We do need to interrupt our lives and force crisis action on climate change.

user1477391263 · 16/10/2022 08:21

They get criticised for using protest methods that inconvenience people trying to get to work, so they use a method that is attention grabbing but doesn't cause disruption to the public and people are still pissed off.

Are you for real? Of course these things are disruptive to the public.

user1477391263 · 16/10/2022 08:20

All these twats do is make it harder to fight climate change.

We already have an issue of conservative types dismissing environmentalism as "woke nonsense"--and now, lo and behold, a pair of spoiled brats with weirdly dyed hair throwing a tantrum in an art gallery. This kind of stunt is actively slowing progress.

ILeclercreturn · 16/10/2022 08:15

Twillow
(What foolish comments.
You sound unpleasant, and that's something I rarely say on Mumsnet.)
It stems from waking up 4 mornings a week feeling suicidal, which was deliberately caused by Alice Morgan of Chattertons (Lincoln) and Roman Kubiak of Hugh James(Cardiff), (both solicitors) who have taken my life and health away. Their abuse has caused me some brain damage as well as physical problems. As an interesting 'aside' despite the horrors of Auschwitz, very few attempted suicide. She solicitors just named have caused this in me so where does that put them on the spectrum of humanity? Reading this thread in general it suggests that more needed to study stem subjects to understand the physics of 'global issues' then of course politics and capitalist manipulation.

DdraigGoch · 15/10/2022 22:23

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 11:48

It's great that your doing these things. What do you know about the protestors' own footprints?

I agree that there are lots of hypocrites in this area - private jets to attend carbon summits and all that - but I've not seen anything to suggest these protestors are in that category. I think it's more likely they are pretty hardcore in their own lifestyles, but of course we don't know.

I'm sure that a tabloid journalist is at this very moment digging around their Instagram accounts for anything incriminating.

DdraigGoch · 15/10/2022 22:04

Keep you car, yes, the one powered by petroleum fuel, because the manufacture of and the extraction of precious metals for a new electric vehicle uses more energy, and causes way more damage to the planet than keeping your 20 year old petrol vehicle going.

@BigWoollyJumpers I don't believe that's true. I'm sure that it's been calculated that the tailpipe emissions from an older car (not just CO2 but all of the other nasties) are so bad that buying a new car (even a petrol one) will quickly recoup the embodied emissions through tailpipe savings. Unless of course you only do tiny mileages.

Not that I think that most people should be running cars anyway. There are a lot of people who could easily do without their car if they really had to.

neverbeenskiing · 15/10/2022 19:33

fuck the painting.

I agree. They get criticised for using protest methods that inconvenience people trying to get to work, so they use a method that is attention grabbing but doesn't cause disruption to the public and people are still pissed off.

Twillow · 15/10/2022 19:05

BerriesOnTop · 15/10/2022 17:44

We are currently at the mercy of Russia and Saudi Arabia for oil, with our current Prime Minister wanting to cancel green initiatives and restart, pointlessly, fracking

Fracking and offshore drilling will help you in the medium term so should be started now. I recall this very argument deployed ten or so years ago wrt nuclear — well, that would really have been helpful right about now!!!

It's short-term, we're talking 10 years at best. And think of the costs involved.
I'm no conspiracy theorist but in all honesty, do you trust anything the government says anymore?

BerriesOnTop · 15/10/2022 17:44

We are currently at the mercy of Russia and Saudi Arabia for oil, with our current Prime Minister wanting to cancel green initiatives and restart, pointlessly, fracking

Fracking and offshore drilling will help you in the medium term so should be started now. I recall this very argument deployed ten or so years ago wrt nuclear — well, that would really have been helpful right about now!!!

Twillow · 15/10/2022 17:23

ILeclercreturn · 15/10/2022 09:03

Just Stop oil is such a ridiculous concept as literally the whole world 'runs' on oil products. For a start the 'activists' should be detained in a place that has no continued use of oil. so they would be caged up and would both starve and freeze to death (eventually). If they want to protest, they should walk to Russia and stop Mr Putin trashing vast quantities of oil/gas in his war. Similarly the 'Insulate Britain protestors need to protest to the government to INSIST that all UK housing stock (private and council) is adequately insulated. Those that are gluing themselves to roads etc should simply be physically removed and if it takes chunks of their skin off, so be it.

What foolish comments.
You sound unpleasant, and that's something I rarely say on Mumsnet.

Twillow · 15/10/2022 17:19

It was a symbolic act rather than one of pure vandalism. The painting is behind glass and was not damaged.
We are currently at the mercy of Russia and Saudi Arabia for oil, with our current Prime Minister wanting to cancel green initiatives and restart, pointlessly, fracking.
What does it take to get people in charge to do something about the energy and climate crises?
People used to think the Greenpeace anti-whalers were fools too.

alpenguin · 15/10/2022 17:13

My issue isn’t that they targeted a so called masterpiece, it’s that they used food at a time when people are sick and dying of hunger in one of the richest countries in the world. Many have said elsewhere the protest was about the cost of the painting and what that kind of money could do for hunger but wasting food isn’t the way to make that point about hunger. Im guessing this was an arsecovering after the event comment when they realised what a poor decision food was.

Us little people could make all the changes humanly possible to our lives and it would make a minimal impact on the environment because we require corporations and the elite to be making the changes to their practices. They cause the majority of the damage.

I see different generations with different opinions on what these two did but they’re all missing the class reality. At least one of the protestors is from a highly privileged
background who will inherit a lot of wealth and conveniently live a rather comfortable life after all this debacle dies down. Parents will hire an expensive lawyer and they’ll get some community service is they’re unlucky. Had they been black working class kids it may have made more of an impact but then the justice system would crackdown on them in a way these two can never expect. What they have done doesn’t really help anyone. Most of the population are aware of the climate crisis and we’re also aware we’re farting into the wind if we think we can make the necessary changes. As with recycling it’s all smoke and mirrors designed to keep us fighting among ourselves while the big corporations keep
churning out their crap and causing all the damage.

ILeclercreturn · 15/10/2022 16:44

thedancingbear
Due to the deliberate actions of UK solicitors Hugh James (Roman Kubiak) I have regular suicidal thoughts and have been told by the Legal Ombudsman that I may as well kill myself because they don't care (valuing my life at £100). So the idea of some idiots suffering for ill thought out 'causes' hardly bothers me. The police are aware of my 'condition' but can't/won't make a real difference. MN, mods, don't bother reporting me the 'authorities' already know.
The 'stop oil 'protestors are happy to wear Hi vis vests made of oil and carry banners made of oil and will have used oil (car/bus) to get to the protest sites.
Not to mention that everything they do and wear depends on oil.

SkiingIsHeaven · 15/10/2022 16:08

It was an oil painting. They really don't like oil do they?

BerriesOnTop · 15/10/2022 15:31

These are the very standards, and the aspiration toward them, that have put us in this position. We must expect, and plan for, a change in our expectations of what a good standard of living looks like, thinking more in terms of sustainability and collectivism

Good lord. This will cause far more human suffering than climate change.

BigWoollyJumpers · 15/10/2022 12:36

DH is working on a project - The decarbonisation of the NHS. It is further proof that quite a lot is being done behind the scenes, but no-one seems to know about. Big caveat, again it will take a looooonnnng time to achieve. It covers everything from specific running costs, heat light etc, to anetheastics, to drugs, to suppliers of consumables, to staff commuting, to patients attending. A lot relies on digital implementation, which many are resisting.

CatsandFish · 15/10/2022 11:54

Sartre · 15/10/2022 07:43

People called the suffragettes terrorists.

I don’t condone throwing soup on decent artwork although no damage was actually done since they’re covered in protective glass… I equally can’t believe one of the first posters suggested they would be happy if someone ran them over and potentially murdered them? Seriously, you would be happy to see another human being murdered? Pretty sick.

I think people are misrepresenting what was said. That poster said their son was critically ill, every second counted, and if they were blocked from getting to the hospital, it is fair to run them over in an emergency. They didn't say run them over just for the sake of it, they were talking about in an emergency. I'm sure if it was your child or family member who was minutes away from death you'd see it their way too.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 11:48

Alltheprettyseahorses · 15/10/2022 10:21

thedancingbear

I don't drive, I've never flown, I walk almost everywhere and rarely get public transport because of the cost, I've been vegetarian since I was about 11, I haven't bought myself new clothes for a good decade or so, I don't have a tumble dryer etc - and I don't use toxic bright pink hair dye either.

It's great that your doing these things. What do you know about the protestors' own footprints?

I agree that there are lots of hypocrites in this area - private jets to attend carbon summits and all that - but I've not seen anything to suggest these protestors are in that category. I think it's more likely they are pretty hardcore in their own lifestyles, but of course we don't know.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 11:46

BigWoollyJumpers · 15/10/2022 10:34

The complexity of the issue is completely lost to them I fear.

The biggest thing anyone can do, is not have children. No-one, except perhaps I think Attenborough tried, suggests this as a solution. The next is to keep using what you already have. Keep you car, yes, the one powered by petroleum fuel, because the manufacture of and the extraction of precious metals for a new electric vehicle uses more energy, and causes way more damage to the planet than keeping your 20 year old petrol vehicle going. Fix your washing machine. Keep you mobile phone more than 2 years. How about legislating against the process of bitcoin mining. So many issues.

This is a sensible post, and I agree with a lot of it. In particular, electric cars are not the panacea that they are being sold as.

However I don't think we can assume that the complexity of the issue is lost on the protesters. Maybe it is, maybe it isn't - we just don't know, but we shouldn't assume they are idiots simply because they're young.

The thing is, they could write a detailed paper comparing the harm-adjusted costs of various different kinds of power generation, and write erudite letters to their MP - and be completely ignored. And all the while things carry on towards their inexorable conclusion, which plenty of posters on this thread have acknowledged. I think the comparison with the suffragettes is a good one, and we need more non-violent direct action like this.

And, again, this doesn't extend to blocking ambulances and fire engines; people who do that are arseholes.

thedancingbear · 15/10/2022 11:40

ILeclercreturn · 15/10/2022 10:44

I am being misrepresented on several fronts.
I am not calling for torture and execution of climate activists. I said that they should be denied ANY of the modern conveniences that oil provides, so no imported food, no heating beyond lambswool garments so basically reverting to 'hunter gatherers'. OK if they can get a fire going that could be a source of heat for them. No plastics (they are usually derived from oil).
I m not a climate change denier as it is blatantly obvious the worlds climate is shifting with more extreme weather events. As the earth is a big rock in space it will always undergo changes partly defined by the proximity of the moon but also sunspots that affect many things in subtle ways. Look at the vast areas of Russia and America that have been rendered desolate by drilling for oil and exploding nuclear 'bombs' (see also atolls in the caribean and central Australia) that have been sacrificed by Human's 'research and greed. Fertilisers and farm machinery rely on oil to enable food to be produced in sufficient quantities to feed people. Humans must stop trying to live in environments that are either too hot or too cold for survival and life that requires earth's resources to sustain existence. So cut out 'air conditioning' and excessive heating so if you can't survive by putting on arm clothes or sitting in the shade, don't live there.
Rather than stopping oil (gas) the world needs to scale back expectations and use ANY fuels as efficiently as possible. solar (PV) panels use a lot of glass and silicon which is very energy intensive in it's production, likewise cement for concrete uses vast amount of heat energy to produce. This of course is usually derived from coal, oil or gas.
So, The Dancingbear needs to look at the WHOLE issue not just her prejudices.
As for being insulting that should see a doctor maybe she should look to her own errors first. I have 'done by bit' for sustainability by only having one child and living in a property with hardly any heating that used relatively small amounts of natural resources to build.

You posted:

^For a start the 'activists' should be detained in a place that has no continued use of oil. so they would be caged up and would both starve and freeze to death (eventually)...

Those that are gluing themselves to roads etc should simply be physically removed and if it takes chunks of their skin off, so be it.^

Leaving aside the point that the 'activists' could rely on green fuels (which represent getting on for 50%) to sustain themselves, you are literally stating that you want the protesters to physically suffer, even die.

That's fucking deranged.

If what you meant to type was 'I would like to see them prosecuted and fined, even imprisoned' then I look forward to your clarification.

ILeclercreturn · 15/10/2022 10:44

I am being misrepresented on several fronts.
I am not calling for torture and execution of climate activists. I said that they should be denied ANY of the modern conveniences that oil provides, so no imported food, no heating beyond lambswool garments so basically reverting to 'hunter gatherers'. OK if they can get a fire going that could be a source of heat for them. No plastics (they are usually derived from oil).
I m not a climate change denier as it is blatantly obvious the worlds climate is shifting with more extreme weather events. As the earth is a big rock in space it will always undergo changes partly defined by the proximity of the moon but also sunspots that affect many things in subtle ways. Look at the vast areas of Russia and America that have been rendered desolate by drilling for oil and exploding nuclear 'bombs' (see also atolls in the caribean and central Australia) that have been sacrificed by Human's 'research and greed. Fertilisers and farm machinery rely on oil to enable food to be produced in sufficient quantities to feed people. Humans must stop trying to live in environments that are either too hot or too cold for survival and life that requires earth's resources to sustain existence. So cut out 'air conditioning' and excessive heating so if you can't survive by putting on arm clothes or sitting in the shade, don't live there.
Rather than stopping oil (gas) the world needs to scale back expectations and use ANY fuels as efficiently as possible. solar (PV) panels use a lot of glass and silicon which is very energy intensive in it's production, likewise cement for concrete uses vast amount of heat energy to produce. This of course is usually derived from coal, oil or gas.
So, The Dancingbear needs to look at the WHOLE issue not just her prejudices.
As for being insulting that should see a doctor maybe she should look to her own errors first. I have 'done by bit' for sustainability by only having one child and living in a property with hardly any heating that used relatively small amounts of natural resources to build.

BigWoollyJumpers · 15/10/2022 10:34

The complexity of the issue is completely lost to them I fear.

The biggest thing anyone can do, is not have children. No-one, except perhaps I think Attenborough tried, suggests this as a solution. The next is to keep using what you already have. Keep you car, yes, the one powered by petroleum fuel, because the manufacture of and the extraction of precious metals for a new electric vehicle uses more energy, and causes way more damage to the planet than keeping your 20 year old petrol vehicle going. Fix your washing machine. Keep you mobile phone more than 2 years. How about legislating against the process of bitcoin mining. So many issues.

FirewomanSam · 15/10/2022 10:29

Alltheprettyseahorses · 15/10/2022 10:21

thedancingbear

I don't drive, I've never flown, I walk almost everywhere and rarely get public transport because of the cost, I've been vegetarian since I was about 11, I haven't bought myself new clothes for a good decade or so, I don't have a tumble dryer etc - and I don't use toxic bright pink hair dye either.

I am sure her ‘toxic bright pink hair dye’ is probably a vegetable-based temporary dye (most wacky colours like that are).

Alltheprettyseahorses · 15/10/2022 10:21

thedancingbear

I don't drive, I've never flown, I walk almost everywhere and rarely get public transport because of the cost, I've been vegetarian since I was about 11, I haven't bought myself new clothes for a good decade or so, I don't have a tumble dryer etc - and I don't use toxic bright pink hair dye either.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 15/10/2022 10:19

A cursory Google of the efficacy of environmental activism will tell you it is a necessity for accelerating concrete, meaningful action.
Environmental activism in the UK in the last 5 years has served to significantly shift the Overton window, 'mainstream' environmental issues and facilitate a move toward policy change. I am absolutely certain it would not have happened had it not been for the commitment and diligence of Extinction Rebellion activists, and the subsequent efforts of allied or related groups such as Insulate Britain, Stop HS2 and Just Stop Oil. As a society, we owe them a great debt of gratitude.
I find myself bemused when posters consider climate mitigating measures with some sort of caveat for preserving current western standards of living. These are the very standards, and the aspiration toward them, that have put us in this position. We must expect, and plan for, a change in our expectations of what a good standard of living looks like, thinking more in terms of sustainability and collectivism.
We live without many of the things many of my friends take for granted, yet our 'standard of living' would have been the norm in most homes until fairly recently. We don't replace things unless actually necessary (ie not for cosmetic reasons, but only if broken or worn beyond repair) and then source second hand replacements or parts where possible. We consider aquisitions in terms of resource required to manufacture and distribute, and whether the manufacturing process carries additional environmental harm, such as pollution. We're not loaded, and can't necessarily go for pricier eco alternatives (for paint, for instance); we just decide that, on balance, we'd rather not paint, if the environmental impact is deterioration of water courses as a result of the use of heavy chemicals in the manufacturing process. Or, we buy paint second-hand.
As for the van Gogh action, I am glad they did it, because here we are, talking, and normalising the conversations about what the hell can be done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread