Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
Stars71 · 17/10/2022 08:44

Feelingconfused2020 · 17/10/2022 00:22

Thanks for talking some sense on page 1 of this thread @EscapeRoomToTheSun because I'm so fed up of all this bollocks.

In the not so distant future unless we make huge changes the Van Gogh painting won't exist anymore. Nor will any art, or any historic buildings or any beautiful landscapes. They didn't damage the painting it was symbolic.

If extinction rebellion, animal rebellion etc do finally succeed we will look back on the idiots who opposed them (and actually wished they'd get run over by lorries) with absolute contempt. Sadly it's quite possible they will fail and no-one will be looking back at anything.

More aggression from lefties.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:37

Anyone criticising the methods of climate protestors cannot genuinely understand what the climate scientists are trying to tell us

Indeed. It baffles me when people talk about their "methods" having the opposite affect that they want. I disagree, I actually don't know what they will achieve but peacefully protesting and spreading awareness definitely doesn't work so they may as well give it a try. Ultimately at least they can sleep at night knowing they tried. I think at this point it's the most we can hope for.

Climate change is to horrific for us to get out head around. People saying that science isn't predicting scenarios as apocalyptic as some are implying are missing the very important fact that science is only predicting the environmental impact and not the human reaction. What do you think happens when resources run low? When land becomes unlivable? How do you think nuclear powers will react to an increasingly desperate battle for resources? All that keeps the fingers off the nuclear buttons is that life is better without it, what happens when that is not true for everybody?

CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 08:25

Pakistan has been prone to flash floods in the past, usually due to monsoons. You are not very well informed if you think this is anything new.

Man made climate change caused by fossil fuel use has made the monsoons much less predictable, and sometimes it causes the amount of water to be orders of magnitude more than was typical in the past. The latest flooding happened because it did not stop raining for 2 MONTHS!

I don’t expect you care about evidence based on your posting history, and I suspect you might be a (not very successful) industry shill trying to drum up public support for fossil fuel investment, but anyway, here is some reading for others that might be interested:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/unicefusa/2022/09/21/deadly-floods-in-pakistan-linked-to-climate-change/

Also reported in that loony lefty rag the Economist

And if you have a conscience at all you might want to make a donation to The Red Cross to help care for people impacted by the floods, around 33 million people. Equivalent to around half the population of the UK.

BerriesOnTop · 17/10/2022 08:11

For anyone interested in the mentality of the activists behind these crass stunts, Roger Pielke Jr (someone I also have disagreement with, but can’t fault his logic with this one either)

twitter.com/RogerPielkeJr/status/1581617225735163905?s=20&t=j3cQ2vHk5ZQaP5U2xBONrg

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2022 08:04

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 07:44

Isn’t HS2 an electric rail that will take traffic off the road when built?

itll take freight from being on the road as the population increases & more freight is needing to be moved. It’s millions of journeys that will be done by train rather than HGV

Thanks for this

I know people protest to conserve but it’s a bit of an issue because to get the returns from electric rail and nuclear it needs to be built

BerriesOnTop · 17/10/2022 08:04

But why do people in Pakistan need protection from flooding in the first place? Man made climate change primarily driven by fossil fuel use

Pakistan has been prone to flash floods in the past, usually due to monsoons. You are not very well informed if you think this is anything new.

In fact, only fossil fuel-based infrastructural development can save lives in the future.

ForkoTrader · 17/10/2022 08:03

Never underestimate Optimism Bias. Vast majority of humans cannot really take on board hugely negative information about the future.

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 07:51

Throwing milk around a shop floor won't change a thing. It's a needless waste.

its already got people talking about it, and change starts that way

DdraigGoch · 17/10/2022 07:49

Twillow · 16/10/2022 23:54

Is this thread full of climate deniers? Seems the majority are 'incensed' at things like the 'waste of a tin of soup that could go to the homeless', but not in the slightest incensed about the actual causes they are protesting about. Bizarre.

We can have opinions on many subjects and are not obliged to list all of them on any given thread.

I am no climate denier. I have made efforts live a lifestyle which is substantially cleaner than the average Brit, and am looking to invest in technology to improve this further - PV panels, rainwater harvesting etc. I also spend time lobbying my MP and MS on subjects including decarbonising our transport and energy generation.

Throwing milk around a shop floor won't change a thing. It's a needless waste.

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 07:48

Interesting that a vocal minority on this thread see the protection of a piece of art depicting nature as more important than protecting nature that supports life on earth.

i think it’s due to how it’s reported, constantly negative rather than impartial

ForkoTrader · 17/10/2022 07:48

CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 07:44

Interesting that a vocal minority on this thread see the protection of a piece of art depicting nature as more important than protecting nature that supports life on earth.

Exactly the point of the protest and sadly predictable.

Schulte · 17/10/2022 07:46

ForkoTrader · 17/10/2022 07:35

Anyone criticising the methods of climate protestors cannot genuinely understand what the climate scientists are trying to tell us.

What utter nonsense.

CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 07:44

Interesting that a vocal minority on this thread see the protection of a piece of art depicting nature as more important than protecting nature that supports life on earth.

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 07:44

Isn’t HS2 an electric rail that will take traffic off the road when built?

itll take freight from being on the road as the population increases & more freight is needing to be moved. It’s millions of journeys that will be done by train rather than HGV

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 07:41

@EscapeRoomToTheSun Is it better for mass death or one or two people to die?

40000 people will die in U.K. due to pollution alone

of course it would be better if there are no deaths 🙄

ForkoTrader · 17/10/2022 07:35

Anyone criticising the methods of climate protestors cannot genuinely understand what the climate scientists are trying to tell us.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2022 07:33

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 17/10/2022 02:37

Thanks, DancingBear, for fielding some wilfully ignorant posts this afternoon.

The hypocrisy idea always crops up and it's insidious in its disingenuity. It is definitely a kind of playground 'gotcha', a silencing technique.

It also conveniently absolves just about anyone from making any kind of ethical stand: "I couldn't possibly put my head above the parapet -I use a mobile / drive / went on holiday, that would be so hypocritical of me!"

I am acquainted with a handful of people who have participated in well publicised actions on behalf of XR and Stop HS2. They live lives very conscientiously and closely aligned with their activism, and most notably wouldn't judge individual members of the public who disagree with them for their choices. Because that's not the point.

Isn’t HS2 an electric rail that will take traffic off the road when built? Also with nuclear protests the end result is lower reliance on oil

I understand it is disruptive but is there an easy way to transition to lower oil with large scale infrastructure projects?

CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 07:32

BerriesOnTop · 17/10/2022 04:42

you're 'incandescent' about some kids spilling some milk (which I've said, upthread, I think was a dick move), but pretty relaxed about thousands of people drowning in Pakistan

If you really cared about people in Pakistan (instead of using them as a prop for your political beliefs) you’d support fossil-fuel led infrastructure developments that will truly protect them from flooding. Proper drainage and retaining walls will help them (and these can only
be built by fossil fuels btw), climate-related deaths drop massively when you build proper infrastructure. Flooding used to kill many, many more people in the past, despite a smaller global population.

But why do people in Pakistan need protection from flooding in the first place? Man made climate change primarily driven by fossil fuel use.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 17/10/2022 07:08

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 06:36

Someone is going to die because of their antics

the irony of this comment is vast

The cognitive dissonance is truly admirable

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 06:36

Someone is going to die because of their antics

the irony of this comment is vast

GooseberryCinnamonYogurt · 17/10/2022 06:05

Floydthebarber · 14/10/2022 13:51

I am actually leaning towards admiring their balls. They aren't the ones blocking roads which I agree annoys people and endangers lives. But the painting is probably worth a few million, of course it is behind glass. Last week I think they poured excrement over a statue of Tom Moore stating that private jets are shitting on what he stood for. Again, no one was hurt and nothing a bit of Dettol and a hose couldn't fix.

People have always protested and it isn't a crime here.

Protesting may not be a crime. But criminal damage, obstructing the road, are.

They're the great unwashed, we need to get tough like the French, rip their glued hands off the roads, turn the water cannons on them!

Rosehugger · 17/10/2022 05:01

I'm glad the painting was not actually damaged, but generally agree with the point they were making.

BerriesOnTop · 17/10/2022 04:42

you're 'incandescent' about some kids spilling some milk (which I've said, upthread, I think was a dick move), but pretty relaxed about thousands of people drowning in Pakistan

If you really cared about people in Pakistan (instead of using them as a prop for your political beliefs) you’d support fossil-fuel led infrastructure developments that will truly protect them from flooding. Proper drainage and retaining walls will help them (and these can only
be built by fossil fuels btw), climate-related deaths drop massively when you build proper infrastructure. Flooding used to kill many, many more people in the past, despite a smaller global population.

BerriesOnTop · 17/10/2022 04:31

In the not so distant future unless we make huge changes the Van Gogh painting won't exist anymore. Nor will any art, or any historic buildings or any beautiful landscapes. They didn't damage the painting it was symbolic

This is not going to happen, nothing in the official IPCC reports is this apocalyptic.

If extinction rebellion, animal rebellion etc do finally succeed we will look back on the idiots who opposed them (and actually wished they'd get run over by lorries) with absolute contempt. Sadly it's quite possible they will fail and no-one will be looking back at anything

If these groups somehow succeed, they will lead to mass human misery and death, worse than climate change ever could muster. Sri Lanka was just a taster to the kind of damage they can do to a functioning country.

Zeke Haufather, an IPCC author (and fwiw someone who I fundamentally disagree with), has criticised the apocalyptic obsessions of eco-zealots. Read a more balanced take here: www.climateforesight.eu/interview/zeke-hausfather-every-tenth-of-a-degree-counts/

Again, these are not my thoughts on the matter, but this is someone who can be worked with, not like eco-zealots who believe our world is literally ending 🤦‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread