Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
LimpBiskit · 17/10/2022 11:42

Feelingconfused2020 · 17/10/2022 10:33

This thread is so depressing. I know there's a wide variety of opinion on mumsnet but to see so many right wing, climate denying,judgmental, selfish opinions on a site meant for women is not a good look. I know not all women hold these opinions but if you honestly value the van Gogh painting or some milk (!?) more than the planet and actually think people are extreme for protesting against fossil fuels you are shameful and I am ashamed to be part of a site that's gives a voice to these opinions.
I'm out.

Nothing wrong with protesting but some of the methods are totally unacceptable and damaging. No-one has said they value a painting more than the planet but how does attacking a painting save the planet? There's a nuance in protesting that involves being noticed but also bringing people with you and some of the more recent protests have just alienated people. Take tyre extinguishers. Someone let the tyres down of a land rover on my road. It knackered the tyres and they are £250 each. That vehicle also acts as a back up mountain rescue vehicle so it was out of commission for a couple of days. Totally mindless acts of vandalism do not support a cause.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2022 11:00

DancingBear always good to get the other perspective. Can I ask how you see the parts I found incongruous re the protest.

The protestors ended by talking about CoL and then the link to soup - if oil were to stop now what do you see the cost of energy doing? Or is it more a transition you are looking for so the price doesn’t spiral out of most people’s reach

Ditto the protests re HS2 and nuclear - do you agree with those and if so how do we transition to electric train travel and nuclear energy?

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 10:52

{Feelingconfused2020 · Today 10:33

This thread is so depressing.}
While considering climate change and fossil fuels etc you have to consider basic physics. If your goal is to move say 20 litres of water from a well to your house, it requires energy. This could be achieved with a small 'vehicle' with a motor of some sort, or your mother/large child could carry it on their head.
Either method requires energy to be expended so 'fuel' for a motor or food for the person carrying. Learning some basics in STEM subjects would enable you to understand this and make a decision about the 'best' way to accomplish this task. People need to understand the world and not jump to conclusions that are unsound.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 10:50

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 10:42

{Stars71 · Today 10:29

CherryGenoa · Today 09:23

There’s a good letter in the Guardian this morning

Full of political bias, of course.}
Discrediting anything that easily is the act of a totalitarian regime. there is a massive failure of critical thinking where to get an accurate view you HAVE to read multiple sources and sift out the common bits of 'truth'. Simply dismissing the Economist or the Guardian is the clear indication you have a very small mind and are incapable of critical assesment. Everyone has some bias but unless you are simply a 'nodding dog' follower you must seek out truth by comparing with other sources. For example the Chinese protestor dragged into the Ambassador's compound in Manchester. Reported in the Daily Mail (strong pro Brexit Brexit mouthpiece) and the Independent (has some bias but less obvious) but the stories essentially match so likely to be as accurate as necessary. The fact the incident happened at all should be a massive wake up call to many in the UK as it represents an awkward shift in UK/Chinese relations.

I'm not a nodding dog. I leave that to the vulgar protestors and their followers.

CatsandFish · 17/10/2022 10:45

Feelingconfused2020 · 17/10/2022 10:33

This thread is so depressing. I know there's a wide variety of opinion on mumsnet but to see so many right wing, climate denying,judgmental, selfish opinions on a site meant for women is not a good look. I know not all women hold these opinions but if you honestly value the van Gogh painting or some milk (!?) more than the planet and actually think people are extreme for protesting against fossil fuels you are shameful and I am ashamed to be part of a site that's gives a voice to these opinions.
I'm out.

I think what is depressing is that there are supposed adults on this site that are defending the subhuman scum who do these stunts because they think you can't take climate change seriously unless you are pouring excrement over a statue or tipping milk all over the floor.

What happened to the arrested development of those defending such disgusting , evil, subhuman selfish behaviours? I thought this was a site for adults. Not ill-bred children. I thought adults on Mumsnet would 100% condemn these stunts. I guess I misjudged the morals and maturity of people on here.

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 10:43

ReunitedThorns · 17/10/2022 09:43

These protesters don't believe in the cause, they just want to cause a bit of trouble. Most lead incredibly climate damaging lives and these protests are rather white middle class art school type of protests.

Evidence please.

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 10:42

{Stars71 · Today 10:29

CherryGenoa · Today 09:23

There’s a good letter in the Guardian this morning

Full of political bias, of course.}
Discrediting anything that easily is the act of a totalitarian regime. there is a massive failure of critical thinking where to get an accurate view you HAVE to read multiple sources and sift out the common bits of 'truth'. Simply dismissing the Economist or the Guardian is the clear indication you have a very small mind and are incapable of critical assesment. Everyone has some bias but unless you are simply a 'nodding dog' follower you must seek out truth by comparing with other sources. For example the Chinese protestor dragged into the Ambassador's compound in Manchester. Reported in the Daily Mail (strong pro Brexit Brexit mouthpiece) and the Independent (has some bias but less obvious) but the stories essentially match so likely to be as accurate as necessary. The fact the incident happened at all should be a massive wake up call to many in the UK as it represents an awkward shift in UK/Chinese relations.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 10:37

Feelingconfused2020 · 17/10/2022 10:33

This thread is so depressing. I know there's a wide variety of opinion on mumsnet but to see so many right wing, climate denying,judgmental, selfish opinions on a site meant for women is not a good look. I know not all women hold these opinions but if you honestly value the van Gogh painting or some milk (!?) more than the planet and actually think people are extreme for protesting against fossil fuels you are shameful and I am ashamed to be part of a site that's gives a voice to these opinions.
I'm out.

Selfish? Pouring human excrement over a monument to a man who fought for his country is VERY selfish, not to mention insular. You lot don't even see your own hypocrisy. Wrap it up any way you want, criminal activity is not the way to address environmental issues. You condone it. I don't. Cheerio.

Feelingconfused2020 · 17/10/2022 10:33

This thread is so depressing. I know there's a wide variety of opinion on mumsnet but to see so many right wing, climate denying,judgmental, selfish opinions on a site meant for women is not a good look. I know not all women hold these opinions but if you honestly value the van Gogh painting or some milk (!?) more than the planet and actually think people are extreme for protesting against fossil fuels you are shameful and I am ashamed to be part of a site that's gives a voice to these opinions.
I'm out.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 10:29

CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 09:23

There’s a good letter in the Guardian this morning

Full of political bias, of course.

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 10:28

So, the floods in Pakistan were deemed very serious. NOW you have to consider what the Pakistani government gas done or not done since 1973 to mitigate against such damage. The UK and other governments have allowed building on flood plains, or in areas known to have potential problems but they go ahead (in the UK) because the housing market is badly skewed by greed. The Somerset levels that were flooded a year or two back and other areas were impacted by failing to consider unusually high rainfall, despite a gradual change in weather patterns over the decades.

BerriesOnTop · 17/10/2022 10:26

People saying that science isn't predicting scenarios as apocalyptic as some are implying are missing the very important fact that science is only predicting the environmental impact and not the human reaction. What do you think happens when resources run low?

We are nowhere near peak oil. Of course,
if you politically bar oil & gas exploration, then you will be causing a manmade shortage, as is happening in Europe now.

When land becomes unlivable?

The IPCC reports do not mention ‘unlivable’ and ‘uninhabitable’ land. You should read the reports—it’s a bit drier than whatever apocalyptic literature you are reading.

How do you think nuclear powers will react to an increasingly desperate battle for resources?

If you mean damming rivers for hydro, well I do disagree with that and it is very impactful on developing economies, obvious effect on those downstream. Better to use cheaper fossil fuels in these cases for sure.

One of the worst economic disasters in the past year has been Sri Lanka, which tried to ban chemical fertilisers and use organic methods.

Well you can guess yields went down precipitously — leading to economic ruin. This was an entirely manmade disaster and you can expect more of it if green parties succeed.

BerriesOnTop · 17/10/2022 10:12

@CherryGenoa

oh, the Economist said it, so it must be true then? 🤦‍♀️

All you have to do is look at the history of flooding in Pakistan. Here’s an article from the NYT about the 1973 floods: www.nytimes.com/1973/08/23/archives/flood-situation-in-pakistan-is-called-extremely-serious.html

What they need is literally more fossil fuels to construct better infrastructure. They haven’t done this, and the locals deserve better than that.

What they don’t need is you using the situation for your own political cause.

And lol I wish I was an industry shill. In fact, it makes me angry these companies don’t push back against the green delusion—they make a product we use literally every moment of every day, and most are entirely unaware of it.

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 09:54

So how much oil has the two 'activists' that climbed up the bridge over the Thames in Esex/Kent wasted.. As I am already 'suicidally inclined' I would reasonably expect to be shot down by a decent marksman. I don't expect others to do what I wouldn't do myself.

ReunitedThorns · 17/10/2022 09:43

These protesters don't believe in the cause, they just want to cause a bit of trouble. Most lead incredibly climate damaging lives and these protests are rather white middle class art school type of protests.

Clymene · 17/10/2022 09:43

This guy for example, can fuck right off

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)
CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 09:23

There’s a good letter in the Guardian this morning

CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 09:21

If anything, it entrenches the government's policies and determination (not to do anything) even more.

We know that Tory policies are built on the shallow foundations of their neoliberal and far right masters rather than scientific evidence, but it would be a new low for this kind of stunt to directly influence government policy! If their policy making is so weak, roll on the general election when we can vote them out.

CatsandFish · 17/10/2022 09:10

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 07:51

Throwing milk around a shop floor won't change a thing. It's a needless waste.

its already got people talking about it, and change starts that way

People aren't talking about the climate, they are talking about the vile brats who did it. It's not the same thing.

Having been on both sides of politics, I know the pollies roll their eyes at antics like this and it confirms their biases that these people are worthless brats and they take less of a notice of them than if they presented a petition. From a political standpoint, it is completely counterproductive. If anything, it entrenches the government's policies and determination (not to do anything) even more.

ForkoTrader · 17/10/2022 09:01

The bitching about the protestors on this thread reminds me of the replies to posters trying to warn that covid was coming to the UK. No logic or evidence made it's way through.

Again, optimism bias.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 08:54

CherryGenoa · 17/10/2022 07:44

Interesting that a vocal minority on this thread see the protection of a piece of art depicting nature as more important than protecting nature that supports life on earth.

Interesting that a vocal minority on this thread, excuse criminal damage. I wonder if said vocal minority would be so understanding if their own property was trashed. I'm sure some bollocks would be spouted as to why they didn't care. Man made destruction v environmental destruction. Fortunately, the law sees the difference.

LimpBiskit · 17/10/2022 08:49

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 14/10/2022 13:49

Climate change is literally happening right now. If we don't do something our children may not survive. Certainly our grandchildren will not inherit a livable planet. But because it will not be profitable, be good for buisness our government, the people in power, do NOTHING.

fuck the painting.

But this just pisses people off and not in a good way. I support the fact that something needs to be done on climate change but I don't support these complete fools. Vandalism is just pointless.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 08:48

*Antifa

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 08:46

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 17/10/2022 02:37

Thanks, DancingBear, for fielding some wilfully ignorant posts this afternoon.

The hypocrisy idea always crops up and it's insidious in its disingenuity. It is definitely a kind of playground 'gotcha', a silencing technique.

It also conveniently absolves just about anyone from making any kind of ethical stand: "I couldn't possibly put my head above the parapet -I use a mobile / drive / went on holiday, that would be so hypocritical of me!"

I am acquainted with a handful of people who have participated in well publicised actions on behalf of XR and Stop HS2. They live lives very conscientiously and closely aligned with their activism, and most notably wouldn't judge individual members of the public who disagree with them for their choices. Because that's not the point.

I guess being called a hypocrite is nothing compared to what your heroes, such as Anifa, call people. That's before they physically assault them. You remain a hypocrite.

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 08:45

Flooding due to monsoons that are or were predictable and loss of life and property is down to the governments of those countries failing to legislate and act to work around the environment. Housing huge numbers of poor people on a flood plain was always going to be a bad idea (in humanitarian terms). Buildings in Switzerland have, by law, to be able to withstand avalanches and maybe even earthquakes in some regions plus bomb shelters against possible nuclear attack as a 'village/town' joint responsibility. Thus building regulations and costs are massive. HS2 is largely a 'white elephant' unless there is a clearly defined plan to make things that need transporting from 'the north' to London. Has anyone seen detailed plans (or even vague ideas) for development of industry that COULD use a high speed train? NO, it is an attempt to pull workers from the North to work in London (for activities that due to Brexit are declining). There is no strategic planning in the UK, and there hasn't been for a long time, possibly since WW2 as the UK needs to reinvent itself but the Thatcher years concentrated everything into 'money markets' banking and insurance. This has been detrimental to so many parts of the UK where pandering to 'city types' who can't be inconvenienced by having to catch a slower train or bus.