Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
Squeezita · 17/10/2022 17:50

As someone with family caught up in the Pakistan floods, I commend @thedancingbear for caring.

And thanks to everyone who donated.

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 17:46

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:32

So how do you think those protestors' actions are going to DIRECTLY make a difference..that is, aside from getting people to talk? You took me to task about saying you were picking and choosing which illegal activity you condoned.

They're obviously not going to make a DIRECT difference. What a pointless question.

It's about awareness raising, challenging presumptions, placing issues on the agenda, and, to a large degree, expressing horror, outrage and exasperation at the indifference of people like you.

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 17:44

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:36

I'm not the one advocating proactive action. What you are representing is like juggling jelly.

So what are you advocating?

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:36

I'm not the one advocating proactive action. What you are representing is like juggling jelly.

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 17:33

Wrap it up any way you want, criminal activity is not the way to address environmental issues.

what is the way to address it?

30 years of peaceful protests haven’t worked

So you condone these crimes?

im asking what the way to address it is, what is your solution?

but instead of answering the question, you ask whether I condone crime? When you answer the question, I’ll answer yours

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:32

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 17:28

I'm happy to say that I condone some of them, yes.

The UK has a proud history of civil disobedience, and I see some of these activities in the same spirit as that. To be clear, this doesn't extend to blocking ambulances or fire engines.

So how do you think those protestors' actions are going to DIRECTLY make a difference..that is, aside from getting people to talk? You took me to task about saying you were picking and choosing which illegal activity you condoned.

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 17:31

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 17/10/2022 17:27

It has worked! Companies are embracing new technologies but it takes awhile for all the technology to come together to replace fossil fuels. I think people are being unrealistic wanting everything to change right away. It can only be done as fast as it's been done. Peaceful protests have worked. The evidence is there already.

Are you kidding? We're on course to miss the modest targets set by the Paris Agreement by a country mile.

It can only be done as fast as it's been done

Total bollocks.

thedancingbear · 17/10/2022 17:28

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:23

So you condone these crimes?

I'm happy to say that I condone some of them, yes.

The UK has a proud history of civil disobedience, and I see some of these activities in the same spirit as that. To be clear, this doesn't extend to blocking ambulances or fire engines.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 17/10/2022 17:27

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 17:20

Wrap it up any way you want, criminal activity is not the way to address environmental issues.

what is the way to address it?

30 years of peaceful protests haven’t worked

It has worked! Companies are embracing new technologies but it takes awhile for all the technology to come together to replace fossil fuels. I think people are being unrealistic wanting everything to change right away. It can only be done as fast as it's been done. Peaceful protests have worked. The evidence is there already.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:23

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 17:20

Wrap it up any way you want, criminal activity is not the way to address environmental issues.

what is the way to address it?

30 years of peaceful protests haven’t worked

So you condone these crimes?

ILeclercreturn · 17/10/2022 17:21

You need to look at maslows 'Heiratchy of needs' and work your way up it. This is for everyone. STOP buying stuff because you want it Research angd get the best and lowest global impact items for what you NEED. People who buy/obtain stuff they want rather than need are the problem. That means everybody.

ivykaty44 · 17/10/2022 17:20

Wrap it up any way you want, criminal activity is not the way to address environmental issues.

what is the way to address it?

30 years of peaceful protests haven’t worked

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 17:18

VegMam · 17/10/2022 16:37

There’s a huge amount of misinformation on this thread so I would urge anyone reading to do your own research, read the IPCC reports, see what the actual science says (btw just stop oil, extinction rebellion etc. are simply following the science).

50 scientists held a protest at the world health summit yesterday, it’s not made any headlines. A tweet covering it Here.

I can see that they are following the trouble. They are only lucky they aren't protesting/stamping their feet in less liberal countries than the UK. Then again, they dont have the true grit for that. As for the recent rabble, causing a bridge to be shut down. I'd happily leave them up there and let (lawful) business carry on as usual.

GooseberryCinnamonYogurt · 17/10/2022 16:51

VegMam · 17/10/2022 16:37

There’s a huge amount of misinformation on this thread so I would urge anyone reading to do your own research, read the IPCC reports, see what the actual science says (btw just stop oil, extinction rebellion etc. are simply following the science).

50 scientists held a protest at the world health summit yesterday, it’s not made any headlines. A tweet covering it Here.

Yes you're right but the manner in which they are protesting isn't going to change anything. All it does is alienate themselves.

VegMam · 17/10/2022 16:37

There’s a huge amount of misinformation on this thread so I would urge anyone reading to do your own research, read the IPCC reports, see what the actual science says (btw just stop oil, extinction rebellion etc. are simply following the science).

50 scientists held a protest at the world health summit yesterday, it’s not made any headlines. A tweet covering it Here.

Blossomtoes · 17/10/2022 16:00

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 14:27

@Blossomtoes as far as lefties go Blossom., you're OK 👌

Thank you ☺️

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 17/10/2022 15:25

Stars, I hear what you are staying and I must admit that I often flinch when I hear reports of seemingly outrageous actions carried out by environmental activists.

Then I remember how our government is stalling on environmental policy and is actively causing harm both nationally and internationally by not implementing change and being complicit in environmentally damaging activity. And I question why I'm not walking around in perpetual anguish in the face of the damage done to life. How it is that this real, irreversible harm has become so much part of the water in which we swim that it just washes over us, day in, day out.
I think of my mother's life-long environmental activism, tirelessly writing letters to MPs, boards of directors, privately boycotting products and companies who operate in ways which damage the planet, signing petitions, and patronising environmental lobby groups and organisations which work to protect wildlife. Her life is designed around keeping her carbon footprint absolutely tiny. You would probably approve of her kind of activism; dignified, quiet and definitely not disruptive. And I conclude, on balance, that 50 years of her, and people like her, doing this stuff has not been as effective as what has been achieved as a result of direct action and peaceful protest in the UK in the last 5 years.
Because our government doesn't really want to listen.

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 14:27

@Blossomtoes as far as lefties go Blossom., you're OK 👌

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 14:17

Blossomtoes · 17/10/2022 14:08

Oi! I can fathom it! 😂

😅

Blossomtoes · 17/10/2022 14:08

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 14:06

Is Owen Jones on this thread? Feels like it, with all the flouncing going on. For right wing, read standards, morals and free speech (within the confines of the law); something the left wing can't fathom.

Oi! I can fathom it! 😂

Stars71 · 17/10/2022 14:06

Is Owen Jones on this thread? Feels like it, with all the flouncing going on. For right wing, read standards, morals and free speech (within the confines of the law); something the left wing can't fathom.

CatsandFish · 17/10/2022 13:21

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 17/10/2022 13:14

ILeclerc, Berries, Stars and Cats, I appreciate your commitment to defending your opinions. I don't quite 'get' the motivation though - is it really just to discredit some young activists and cast unfounded aspersions on their character? Literally no harm has been done, so it seems it just comes down to a personal feeling of indignation?

Berries, you are quoting the IPCC report in the most selective way, hinting that any other reading of unfolding world events is alarmist, ill-informed and overly dramatic. This is so sneaky! Parts of the world are indeed becoming 'unlivable' as a direct consequence of man-made climate change: in my professional role I often meet families from countries who report how life is increasingly hazardous or impoverished as a direct result of adverse climate conditions. These places may have experienced similar issues historically, but current events are exacerbated by the climate emergency. Examples include Jordan, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, Mali, Afghanistan and Somalia.

Further up the thread you suggest that my suggestion to manage our expectations of our future standard of living and working toward sustainable adaptations will cause more death and misery (I paraphrase) than climate change. Really? What do you think is being advocated? We cannot pursue a global or national growth economy indefinitely on a planet of finite resources. A gradual transition to sustainable alternatives will be necessary. Failure to make timely adaptations to mitigate future damage is what will cause untold harm.

Marsha, I remember when Greta first became 'the face' of the climate movement and London and other cities erupted with the first Rebellion events. People would say "That's all very well, these people all moaning about the climate, but what are the alternatives? What are their policies? What do they suggest we should be doing instead? What does XR actually want!? " thus dismissing the concerns of activists as clueless at best or inflammatory hypocrisy at worst. The early core message was always clear, and directed at the governments of the world as opposed to individuals: "Tell the truth" and "Act as if the truth is real". The point I am making is that it should not be up to the populace to solve the climate emergency. Governments need to act responsibly and with due urgency and transparency; to listen to scientists and hold corporations to account. The points you raise about HS2 and nuclear energy are really good examples of where conflicting interests, expected harm vs potential benefit, integrity and timescales collide. Fracking is another one. There is abundant scientific research and evidence that these will cause harm in the short, medium and long term. The irreparable damage to wildlife predicted by the HS2 project may seem surmountable if one's focus is on economic growth (which is what all the 'benefits' essentially boil down to: prioritising the capacity to rapidly transit a workforce or consumers participating in the growth economy), over the preservation of ancient woodlands (with their inherent capacity to sequester carbon), watercourses and the wildlife therein. Nuclear energy is similarly touted as a green alternative and I have yet to see a single solution to the problem presented by the storage of the huge quantities of radioactive waste generated which will not store up dire problems for future generations and be vulnerable to any number of environmental factors, material deterioration or human error, potentially causing critical damage. I grew up experiencing directly the impact of the Chernobyl disaster, which had lasting and damaging impact on the community of my childhood, albeit in another country hundreds of miles away.

Growth may be necessary to enable us to sustain the status quo for a while longer, until other factors inevitably intercept the trajectory, and what happens then will no doubt be more damaging than a planned and anticipated weaning off our dependency on fossil fuels and transitioning to a more sustainable alternative, which should include adjustments in living standards.

And whoever likened the activists of my acquaintance I referred to in my previous post to Antifa; nope, all acquitted of all charges. Not guilty. Judge and jury on the right side of history.

It's about morals and principles. Those activists discredit themselves by the harm they do to others (such as milk hazard on the floor, blocking the roads, etc - it is not a victimless crime, someone always suffers somehow for their actions). Do you not understand that one can advocate for action on climate change, without acting like an immature 7 year old child? Doesn't maturity and acting with decency and conscientiousness come into it? How can a mature, well-adjusted adult possibly defend their actions?
I never, ever, ever thought I would see anyone on here (at least over the age of 25) defend these horrible nasty brats.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 17/10/2022 13:14

ILeclerc, Berries, Stars and Cats, I appreciate your commitment to defending your opinions. I don't quite 'get' the motivation though - is it really just to discredit some young activists and cast unfounded aspersions on their character? Literally no harm has been done, so it seems it just comes down to a personal feeling of indignation?

Berries, you are quoting the IPCC report in the most selective way, hinting that any other reading of unfolding world events is alarmist, ill-informed and overly dramatic. This is so sneaky! Parts of the world are indeed becoming 'unlivable' as a direct consequence of man-made climate change: in my professional role I often meet families from countries who report how life is increasingly hazardous or impoverished as a direct result of adverse climate conditions. These places may have experienced similar issues historically, but current events are exacerbated by the climate emergency. Examples include Jordan, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, Mali, Afghanistan and Somalia.

Further up the thread you suggest that my suggestion to manage our expectations of our future standard of living and working toward sustainable adaptations will cause more death and misery (I paraphrase) than climate change. Really? What do you think is being advocated? We cannot pursue a global or national growth economy indefinitely on a planet of finite resources. A gradual transition to sustainable alternatives will be necessary. Failure to make timely adaptations to mitigate future damage is what will cause untold harm.

Marsha, I remember when Greta first became 'the face' of the climate movement and London and other cities erupted with the first Rebellion events. People would say "That's all very well, these people all moaning about the climate, but what are the alternatives? What are their policies? What do they suggest we should be doing instead? What does XR actually want!? " thus dismissing the concerns of activists as clueless at best or inflammatory hypocrisy at worst. The early core message was always clear, and directed at the governments of the world as opposed to individuals: "Tell the truth" and "Act as if the truth is real". The point I am making is that it should not be up to the populace to solve the climate emergency. Governments need to act responsibly and with due urgency and transparency; to listen to scientists and hold corporations to account. The points you raise about HS2 and nuclear energy are really good examples of where conflicting interests, expected harm vs potential benefit, integrity and timescales collide. Fracking is another one. There is abundant scientific research and evidence that these will cause harm in the short, medium and long term. The irreparable damage to wildlife predicted by the HS2 project may seem surmountable if one's focus is on economic growth (which is what all the 'benefits' essentially boil down to: prioritising the capacity to rapidly transit a workforce or consumers participating in the growth economy), over the preservation of ancient woodlands (with their inherent capacity to sequester carbon), watercourses and the wildlife therein. Nuclear energy is similarly touted as a green alternative and I have yet to see a single solution to the problem presented by the storage of the huge quantities of radioactive waste generated which will not store up dire problems for future generations and be vulnerable to any number of environmental factors, material deterioration or human error, potentially causing critical damage. I grew up experiencing directly the impact of the Chernobyl disaster, which had lasting and damaging impact on the community of my childhood, albeit in another country hundreds of miles away.

Growth may be necessary to enable us to sustain the status quo for a while longer, until other factors inevitably intercept the trajectory, and what happens then will no doubt be more damaging than a planned and anticipated weaning off our dependency on fossil fuels and transitioning to a more sustainable alternative, which should include adjustments in living standards.

And whoever likened the activists of my acquaintance I referred to in my previous post to Antifa; nope, all acquitted of all charges. Not guilty. Judge and jury on the right side of history.

Maireas · 17/10/2022 12:09

Excellent points, @LimpBiskit and @Blossomtoes, as ever 👍

Blossomtoes · 17/10/2022 12:02

Feelingconfused2020 · 17/10/2022 10:33

This thread is so depressing. I know there's a wide variety of opinion on mumsnet but to see so many right wing, climate denying,judgmental, selfish opinions on a site meant for women is not a good look. I know not all women hold these opinions but if you honestly value the van Gogh painting or some milk (!?) more than the planet and actually think people are extreme for protesting against fossil fuels you are shameful and I am ashamed to be part of a site that's gives a voice to these opinions.
I'm out.

Loving the assumption that anyone who doesn’t agree with you is right wing. I couldn’t be much further to the left. Disapproving of privileged brats wasting food and making minimum wage workers unnecessary work doesn’t look particularly right wing from where I’m sitting.