Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is awful? (Just Stop Oil protesters throwing soup over Van Gogh painting)

613 replies

TheCatsPyjamas1 · 14/10/2022 12:44

Just read that some Just Stop Oil protesters have thrown soup over a Van Gogh painting in the National Gallery in London. AIBU to think this is unacceptable?

I fully support the message of the group (investing in environmentally responsible energy rather than fossil fuels, and helping to make society more equal for everyone), but I find their protest methods are awful and risk alienating people who would otherwise support them.

They keep on doing crazy things, and seem to be escalating their action each time they protest. I don’t really know when or how it’ll end.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kalasbyxor · 23/10/2022 05:30

LimpBiskit: "It would be helpful if protestors came together with a clear message and a clear way forward instead of being disparate and having different foci."

Meh. Not really. That's not a general expectation for other protests; "You can only protest against the closure of local libraries in Leicester if you also bring along a budget proposal for how the council can generate funds to keep said libraries open."

The public should definitely direct their concerns about the changing climate at those who have the capacity to make substantive changes, ie the government. It is up to the government to respond, to tell the truth, and to act as if the truth is real -that is, to implement climate policy congruent with what is actually, demonstrably occurring. It should be up to the government, our elected leaders, to WANT to find the best science and facilitate the most effective solutions for rapid change as a matter of absolute priority. That is what they are there for.

We are right to be concerned about the impact of global heating.

We are right to hold our elected leaders to account and expect them to be acting in our best interests and the best interests of generations to come.

We are right to be protesting and raising awareness of these alarming issues until the government acts responsibly and uses its considerable resource and influence to act on our behalf.

Dave, you are asking what you, an ordinary person, is expected to do. The protesters mentioned on this thread are not directing their protests at the individual decisions made by members of the public; they're all to aware that people live within the confines of society, and operate along it's restrictive frameworks which often precludes the making of positive environmental decisions. Extinction Rebellion, although not synonymous with Just Stop Oil, but ideologically sympathetic, have it written into its core values and principles that blaming and shaming (including members of the public for personal choices) is unproductive and acknowledges the toxicity of a system which damages all who operate therein. The focus is on holding government to account, not ordinary people.
They are using disruption as a strategy to communicate with policymakers at a time when it is alarmingly clear that, when left to their own devices, elected leaders are not taking robust enough action.

VegMam · 22/10/2022 16:54

ButIamBatman · 22/10/2022 13:23

I've just read that paper and the list of contributors and they are not experts in their fields at all. And the disclaimer at the bottom of the list about them acting in individual capacities and not as their institutions speaks volumes too as the universities wouldn't support this as the research is weak.

How are they not experts…!? And what about the others I listed in another post, NASA, met office, Stephen Hawking etc.

The fact that you say them signing in an individual capacity means anything at all shows how little you understand about the professional world. It’s standard wording and of course they’re signing in an individual capacity, do you know what it would take for eg Cambridge university as an organisation to sign off on a paper?

Hawkins001 · 22/10/2022 14:42

Dave20 · 22/10/2022 13:22

But what realistically can the average person do? People have died because of an avoidable bridge closure..
Normal people can only do so much.

Most people need cars. Most can’t afford an electric car, even they are not totally good for the environment.

Not everyone lives close to their work or can work from home. Some people work doing shifts , including bank holidays , 24 hours around the clock.

Do these eco warriors really think that the likes of Shell and BP give a shit about a few members of the great unwashed climbing a Bridge in little England? Or even the millionaires in Westminster who don’t have to travel on these roads?

The big banks ?

None of them really give a shit. Yet innocent members of the public suffer and in this case died. The public will turn against them the more ruthless they become.

The oil giants don’t care a jot about a couple of idiots who climb a bridge.

A point on the banks, this was brought up in the banking debate with the heads of some of the largest banks, jp Morgan, Fargo wells, bank of America ect.

The conclusion was that due to The current client relationships they have with the fossils companies and industry, it's seen as better to continue to do business with them, while transitioning the investments and also helping those companies to progress into using renewable and environmental friendly, technology.

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 13:41

{What particular advice? Most of it has, in retrospect, been disastrous whichever "science" one is following. The only science which prevailed was vaccination.}

Preventing the transfer of an airborne and to a lesser extent contact borne virus is actually quite simple as the poeople in the Village of Eyam discovered a fe hundred years ago. Also in the Spanish Flu pandemic. sending people into care homes etc was obviously going to be a death sentence for many. Discovering what Covid was and how to deal with it took time but even basic preventative measures were not taken for months.

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 13:33

{That's all very well, but the UK is acknowledged as being way ahead of the game. The EU has a long way to go to catch up with UK reductions on CO2. Eastern Europe and Germany in particular.}
UK acknowledged by whom?
You do realise that the EU is 27 sovereign countries agreeing to act together.
The UK meanwhile is at the start of a serious recession so CO2 produced by UK industry will fall drastically while many thousands will be made jobless.
The war in Ukraine is causing massive waste of world resources and pollution. Send the ECO protestors to Russia so they can tell Putin to stop destroying Ukraine.

BigWoollyJumpers · 22/10/2022 13:26

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 13:02

{ivykaty44 · Today 09:01}
And what do you say about the 150,000 or more who have died as a direct result of the Tory Government ignoring scientific based health rules (some from way back Spanish Flu epidemic) when the procedures to limit airborne and contact borne pathogens has been established?

What particular advice? Most of it has, in retrospect, been disastrous whichever "science" one is following. The only science which prevailed was vaccination.

BigWoollyJumpers · 22/10/2022 13:24

The EU is in the process of COLLABORATION to find ways to reduce the effects of climate change but of course with Brexit the UK will now be the dirty man of Europe as well as poor

That's all very well, but the UK is acknowledged as being way ahead of the game. The EU has a long way to go to catch up with UK reductions on CO2. Eastern Europe and Germany in particular.

ButIamBatman · 22/10/2022 13:23

VegMam · 22/10/2022 08:43

Isn’t it wonderful that we have a number of geniuses here on MN who know more about the complex issue of climate change than scientists who’ve studied the subject for years 🙄

Here’s what the science says. That paper is written by experts from leading universities and organisations, a far more reliable source of information than randoms on MN spouting nonsense.

I've just read that paper and the list of contributors and they are not experts in their fields at all. And the disclaimer at the bottom of the list about them acting in individual capacities and not as their institutions speaks volumes too as the universities wouldn't support this as the research is weak.

Dave20 · 22/10/2022 13:22

But what realistically can the average person do? People have died because of an avoidable bridge closure..
Normal people can only do so much.

Most people need cars. Most can’t afford an electric car, even they are not totally good for the environment.

Not everyone lives close to their work or can work from home. Some people work doing shifts , including bank holidays , 24 hours around the clock.

Do these eco warriors really think that the likes of Shell and BP give a shit about a few members of the great unwashed climbing a Bridge in little England? Or even the millionaires in Westminster who don’t have to travel on these roads?

The big banks ?

None of them really give a shit. Yet innocent members of the public suffer and in this case died. The public will turn against them the more ruthless they become.

The oil giants don’t care a jot about a couple of idiots who climb a bridge.

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 13:19

{Ivykaty44
governments need to ban fossil fuel not keep subsiding it and that is what the protests are also about}.

So please explain how banning fossil fuels will NOT cause mass starvation and death when there is no transportation for foodstuffs, Chemicals for fertilisers, Heating, medicines.

What are your thoughts on this?
{Quitting the ECT, which protects fossil fuel investors from policy changes that might threaten their profits, was ‘coherent’ with Paris climate deal, Macron said

France has become the latest country to pull out of the controversial energy charter treaty (ECT), which protects fossil fuel investors from policy changes that might threaten their profits.}

Several EU countries have already withdrawn from the treaty but what about the UK? The UK government are so in league with the oil industry that they have not sorted out a windfall tax. The EU is in the process of COLLABORATION to find ways to reduce the effects of climate change but of course with Brexit the UK will now be the dirty man of Europe as well as poor.

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 13:02

{ivykaty44 · Today 09:01}
And what do you say about the 150,000 or more who have died as a direct result of the Tory Government ignoring scientific based health rules (some from way back Spanish Flu epidemic) when the procedures to limit airborne and contact borne pathogens has been established?

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 12:56

For those interested there is a report about a proposal in America to build a '15 minute city', meaning that almost all the ameneties for life (housing/work/recreation/shopping/schools ) are all within a 15 minute walk or cycle ride and I think electric buses/tranms to travel further afield. The proposal is to use state owned land in Utah (a prison site that is unnecessarily large for it's current needs). Should be interesting but will have many challenges as Utah is pretty hot in summer. If done properly it may be a useful test bed to research sustainable living.

BerriesOnTop · 22/10/2022 12:34

burning fossil fuels in cars isn’t a health issue

Ive been very clear on this. It’s a health issue because of the particulate matter (pm 2.5) from car exhaust along with other harmful toxins like benzene and nitrogen oxides. Biofuels also have these problems btw

Carbon dioxide from car exhaust is harmless to human health but people are hyper focussed on it because of global warming.

CO2 did not kill that girl you linked to! It was all the other nasty stuff coming out of the exhaust pipe. So burning fossil fuels elsewhere to charge urban EVs is totally fine by me and more ideal than ICEs, even though there is an efficiency loss.

BerriesOnTop · 22/10/2022 12:21

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 11:57

Electric vehicles are simply (expensively) shifting the problems with burning fossil fuels to a different place. Burning something (expending energy) is a 'Primary' activity. Storing energy (in a rechargeable battery) is a secondary source of power. The old xinc/Carbon batteries (the ones you can't recharge that you usually throw away) are Primary sources. Nickel cadmium (now banned), Lead acid (car batteries) Lithium Ion and other technologies are secondary sources and are 'simply' a method of transporting electrical power from one place to another. rechargeables (secondary) ALWAYS waste some electrical energy (as heat) and of course most are heavy and large thus representing even lower efficiency. This is basic physics/chemistry that scientists have been battling with for a couple of hundred years. Politicians like 'simple' slogans so saying 'carbon dioxide is bad' and by carefully omitting a lot of downsides with rechargeable batteries they pronounce 'Electric Vehicles to be 'good'.
Generating electricity and getting it to your house wastes around 40% of the primary 'fuel' as heat (mostly) because of various basic physics 'issues'. This is why everyone needs to have at least a minimal understanding of physics before running off to be an 'Eco Warrior'. Burning oil or gas in a 'power station' is less efficient than using it directly in an internal combustion engine when you look at how much 'work' 1 litre of oil can do in both scenarios.

This is all true about EVs but it is a bit of a trade off when it comes to urban air quality. Of course the best is convenient public transport and bike infrastructure, including bike shares. ICEs will probably always take the primary role outside of population dense areas, no reason to push it for all the reasons you list here.

EVs for heavy transport, construction, freight, etc have always been a pipe dream and not worthwhile.

I don’t look at EVs as minimising the carbon footprint (I personally don’t care about that) but as a way to control urban air quality.

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 11:57

Electric vehicles are simply (expensively) shifting the problems with burning fossil fuels to a different place. Burning something (expending energy) is a 'Primary' activity. Storing energy (in a rechargeable battery) is a secondary source of power. The old xinc/Carbon batteries (the ones you can't recharge that you usually throw away) are Primary sources. Nickel cadmium (now banned), Lead acid (car batteries) Lithium Ion and other technologies are secondary sources and are 'simply' a method of transporting electrical power from one place to another. rechargeables (secondary) ALWAYS waste some electrical energy (as heat) and of course most are heavy and large thus representing even lower efficiency. This is basic physics/chemistry that scientists have been battling with for a couple of hundred years. Politicians like 'simple' slogans so saying 'carbon dioxide is bad' and by carefully omitting a lot of downsides with rechargeable batteries they pronounce 'Electric Vehicles to be 'good'.
Generating electricity and getting it to your house wastes around 40% of the primary 'fuel' as heat (mostly) because of various basic physics 'issues'. This is why everyone needs to have at least a minimal understanding of physics before running off to be an 'Eco Warrior'. Burning oil or gas in a 'power station' is less efficient than using it directly in an internal combustion engine when you look at how much 'work' 1 litre of oil can do in both scenarios.

ivykaty44 · 22/10/2022 11:16

So encouraging EVs within urban areas is a good start—and they will be charged of course with fossil fuels! It’s fine.

Carbon dioxide from car exhaust is harmless to human health, but for some strange reason is all campaigners ever focus upon

so if burning fossil fuels in cars isn’t a health issue, why would encouraging EV be needed - keep using cars that run on fossil fuels

Stars71 · 22/10/2022 11:01

Amazing how some deaths seem more poignant than others, on this thread.

ILeclercreturn · 22/10/2022 10:57

While the scientific evidence may be irrefutable the 'conclusions' need proper evaluation and constructive solutions need to be found. Being an arsehole and gluing yourself to something is NOT a constructive solution. Reducing the use of fossil fuels and being more efficient is the only practical route. This means do not buy new things because you WANT them but use older but functional things until they fail. How much of the earths resources are used providing new 'trinkets' for women? Shampoos, conditioners, false nails 'facepaints', all of these use huge amounts of oils either in manufacture or transportation. 'Convenient' packaging of things rather than paring back to what is NEEDED. Supermarkets are gradually moving away from plastics in packaging which is to be commended, as well as other ideas to reduce waste.

The 'science' probably is correct but it is the 'eco zealots with their selective reading and understanding of the science who refuse to consider the global implications (inertia from consumers and cost) and are essentially shouting at the wrong people. So, this winter, turn your heating off completely for 1 day a week and open windows to clear the damp air out and simply wear an extra jumper or coat as necessary. if you are not prepared to do that then you cannot be considered 'Eco' at all. One day a week would be something like a 10% saving in fuels used for heating AND save you money. I have no heating in my house (North France) so from September to March it is a case of wearing sufficient clothes to stay warm. I assure you a trip to the bathroom when it is 4 Centigrade is a pretty swift procedure.

Stars71 · 22/10/2022 10:14

JudgeJ · 22/10/2022 10:13

The police need the power to deal with these terrorists, however they like to wrap up their actions in some sience, and the terrorists should have no comeback if their stupid stunts get them iunjured, their choice. If anyone wants to nudge an idiot off the road I'll be their alibi.

👏

JudgeJ · 22/10/2022 10:13

Stars71 · 22/10/2022 10:10

Disgusting. Police allowed that to happen as well.

The police need the power to deal with these terrorists, however they like to wrap up their actions in some sience, and the terrorists should have no comeback if their stupid stunts get them iunjured, their choice. If anyone wants to nudge an idiot off the road I'll be their alibi.

Stars71 · 22/10/2022 10:10

Dave20 · 21/10/2022 22:19

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11341163/Pictured-NHS-Hero-died-M20-crash-ambulance-delayed-Dartford-Crossing-activists.html

Above article regarding a fatal road crash , the ambulance was delayed due to the protest.

Disgusting. Police allowed that to happen as well.

VegMam · 22/10/2022 10:04

BerriesOnTop · 22/10/2022 09:31

You do understand Attenborough is a television personality, don’t you? Maybe you don’t 😆

Honestly anything to do with Extinction Rebellion is suspect. You shouldn’t have linked to those jokers.

The scientific evidence is irrefutable:

NASA

Oxford university

MET office

Stephen Hawking

The oil industry’s spin

Fyi David Attenborough studied natural sciences.

BerriesOnTop · 22/10/2022 09:31

VegMam · 22/10/2022 09:06

You’re very much the joke here thinking you’re smarter than the experts 🤣

The IPCC report has already been linked to earlier in the thread.

Did you even read who wrote and supported the report I linked?

How about David Attenborough “If we continue on our current path we will face the collapse of everything that gives us our security”

You do understand Attenborough is a television personality, don’t you? Maybe you don’t 😆

Honestly anything to do with Extinction Rebellion is suspect. You shouldn’t have linked to those jokers.

BerriesOnTop · 22/10/2022 09:18

ivykaty44 · 22/10/2022 09:01

without banning fossil fuels either.

what do you think causes these 40000 deaths each year? The girl was one case, but thousands are dying prematurely

You have to separate poor air quality from carbon emissions. They are not the same thing.

We can actually do something about urban air pollution.

The problem is with ICEs which pumps out noxious fumes and particulate matter (pm 2.5) which has negative health effects. Using wood burners and biofuel can also spew out particulate matter, btw. Oh and carbon monoxide, which kills many people as well but as it is not the greenhouse gas warming the world, no one cares particularly.

So encouraging EVs within urban areas is a good start—and they will be charged of course with fossil fuels! It’s fine.

Carbon dioxide from car exhaust is harmless to human health, but for some strange reason is all campaigners ever focus upon 🤦‍♀️