Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL is being a bit selfish

292 replies

cherrytreelanecherries · 14/10/2022 10:02

My father in law died suddenly a year ago. He was only mid sixties so it was quite a shock.

My mother in law has struggled, understandably. She had only recently retired, has no other family apart from my DH, only has three close friends. She also lives rurally and doesn’t drive (FIL did all the driving). She is very lonely and quite depressed I think, we’ve started to have tentative conversations about her trying volunteering, going to a bereavement group etc but she just says it’s too soon.

We used to host Christmas for both sides of the family every year. We live several hours drive from both families (in opposite directions - helpful!) But my grandma is 96 and she’s too unwell to make the journey to our house this year. So that nobody has to be on their own, we came up with a plan that my grandma would spend Christmas Day at my parent’s house and we would go to MIL with our two young kids.

However, MIL doesn’t want to do this. She says she will find it too painful to decorate the house or have Christmas dinner (we’ve offered to cook) and she just wants to be on her own all day if she can’t come to ours. My parents have said she can stay at theirs and they will host but she’s refused that too.

I’ve offered that we rent a holiday cottage instead so Christmas Day doesn’t actually have to be in her house with all the memories but she won’t do that either.

My grandma feels so bad that she’s causing my MIL to spend Christmas alone that she is now saying we should go back to plan A and have Christmas at our house, even though she’s really not well enough to make the journey and I’m worried about her.

Basically, I’ve tried to be patient with MIL and I know she is devastated but I think on this she’s being a bit selfish. AIBU.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Babyboynamehmm · 15/10/2022 06:53

cherrytreelanecherries · 14/10/2022 11:22

Hugely, they were soulmates and completely dependant on each other. As I said above she only has three close friends. FIL actually had no friends at all. Both nice people just very introverted and only needed each other.

And yes, not getting the train is a huge issue and I thought perhaps she’d be feeling more confident about it by now but as with everything else it is getting worse not better.

Id be happy for her to move closer but she’s said categorically she won’t move (without anyone suggesting it) as where she lives is all she’s ever known.

My mother was a little bit like this. She was very dependent on my father. Scared to drive on the motorway, scared to be alone, he paid the bills etc. She earned money and was financially literate, but my father did those things.

I used to worry for her if my father died first. I figured she’d move in with my sibling (her preferred child) as she wouldn’t cope alone. As it turned out, she died first. My father was (is) terribly sad, but was (is) much more self sufficient so has been able to build his life back up again.

I do feel for people like this, who depend on another and then that spouse dies. I don’t know how you’d help her in this situation. My mother would - like I said - have just moved in with my sibling, it would have been the only way.

I think if you want to ensure she’s not alone at Christmas, you should host it and be completely honest with your parents - you’re very worried about granny travelling, you don’t want them to feel obliged to come, but if you don’t host Christmas then MIL will be on her own. Then go and see them on Boxing Day.

But this emotional labour shouldn’t be yours. She is your husband’s mother. Let him do the worrying and pandering.

(Or, really, you could just run away from it OP! Book a trip to somewhere warm and fun for you and your kids! I think I’d be tempted 😁)

MsRosley · 14/10/2022 23:23

cherrytreelanecherries · 14/10/2022 11:32

my MIL was in a similar situation with FIL dying young and I never would’ve treated her like you are treating your MIL - let’s be honest you want her driving and volunteering and joining groups so you can wash your hands of having to make an extra effort with her during this difficult time for her. Nasty.

Well, not really. She says she’s bored and has nothing to do and can’t get anywhere, so we have (gently) suggested options to overcome this.

As above, she’s been on holiday with us twice and been to stay with us multiple times, which involves one of us driving to pick her up (6 hour round trip) because she’s too scared to get the train.

I think we can want her to have some form of local support network and independence without washing our hands of her completely.

OP, you have the patience of a saint. You are most definitely not the nasty one here.

limitedperiodonly · 14/10/2022 18:58

Littlewasp · 14/10/2022 16:55

Bitter experience I'm afraid.

That's your MIL not mine. And also not my mum to my sister-in-law and brother. Lots of widowed people want to come round to visit their children and grandchildren but in my experience they are more than happy to return to their own houses when it's over.

Your experience is not usual. It's just particular to your family. Why does Mumsnet have a downer on old women and think they are trying to feed your children crap or take over your life?

My mum had a life of her own. My MIL could never live up to her but she is a very nice woman too. Neither of them wanted to live with me and I wouldn't want to do that either even I am approaching 60 which is decrepit in Mumsnet years.

Though if they had to I would make up the spare room and we would make it work. We might even enjoy it. I loved my mum and though my MIL has her moments she's not bad either.

Littlewasp · 14/10/2022 16:55

limitedperiodonly · 14/10/2022 16:25

Why would you think that? Are you into any popular conspiracy theories by any chance?

Bitter experience I'm afraid.

lovenotwar149 · 14/10/2022 16:51

Mmmm my xmas plans this yr....on my own in my house with my husband and my own kids if they want to come...noo pressure. May not have xmas dinner...might have steak 'n chips. Simple :)

limitedperiodonly · 14/10/2022 16:44
  • your MIL - that is
Notanotherwindow · 14/10/2022 16:44

Just have her over to yours and don't say anything. If your parents and grandma ask, you're spending Christmas with MIL so she isnt alone. Just neglect to mention which house.

This really is taking up too much brain space and it doesn't need to.

limitedperiodonly · 14/10/2022 16:43

@cherrytreelanecherries the PP is right. What she wants cannot happen and that is profoundly sad. I suppose she is miserable sometimes. Her husband died a year ago. It's a bit upsetting. My mum was shockingly short-tempered with us after our dad died. She did this mad thing of signing up for thousands of pounds of replacement UPVC windows because "you don't care about me any more." My brother told the firm to back off. Totally out of character for my mum but understandable under the circumstances. She was very ashamed of nearly being conned like that so we agreed never to mention it again.

For perfectly reasonable reasons you cannot see your on Christmas Day. Lots of us have been. Just see her another day and stop saying you desperately want to please everyone.

cherrytreelanecherries · 14/10/2022 16:36

I’m going to step away from this thread now as I think it’s reached the point where the same arguments are being made on both sides (and also because my work shift starts in 90 minutes and I need to get off my phone and sort the kids out 😂)

Thanks so much to everyone who has contributed on both sides, it has honestly given me so much food for thought and helped me to see several issues from a different perspective. So I really appreciate everyone’s time and wisdom.

I am not able to offload about this to DH for obvious reasons so it’s been nice to have a safe space to talk things through! Thank you.

OP posts:
woodhill · 14/10/2022 16:34

Ii think she is being selfish

You have tried to find compromises

See your dgm

Mischance · 14/10/2022 16:31

If MIL comes to ours then my family and grandma will feel they have to come too, even though I don’t think my grandma is well enough. - There is your problem; not MIL's "selfishness". Sort them out to stay put and then have MIL with you.

cherrytreelanecherries · 14/10/2022 16:30

limitedperiodonly · 14/10/2022 15:48

@cherrytreelanecherries When someone says they want to be left alone, leave them alone. Obviously if someone doesn't wash for days or has rotting food in their fridge you might try to stage an intervention. But it doesn't sound like MIL is like that.

It's profoundly selfish for someone to say they want someone to do what they want because otherwise it is upsetting their plans or making their granny or husband feel bad, or their MIL has been a moany old cow who should just do things she doesn't particularly want to do because she's been given a list and should really buck her ideas up.

It is mid October. A lot of things can happen to change family circumstances between now and Christmas. It's happened to me more than once. Old people die at this time of year - my parents and various older family members and in-laws did. That's not being horrible it's just a fact of life and I thought you were a fan of giving it to people straight. So go on with your plans and leave MIL to a chicken crown for one on Christmas day and phone her if you want to.

She says she wants to be left alone if the only options are for us to come to her or for her to go to my parents house. Not that she wants to be alone full stop.

She actually talks a lot about how miserable and lonely she is and says that she doesn’t want to spend Christmas on her own.

Ultimately a PP nailed it and all she really wants is FIL back again and that can’t happen 😞

OP posts:
limitedperiodonly · 14/10/2022 16:25

Littlewasp · 14/10/2022 16:19

I do hope MIL's long term plan isn't to emotionally blackmail your DH into asking her to move in with you. She is clearly and understandably comfortable in your home, is this what is behind her reluctance to carry on and make a life for herself?

Why would you think that? Are you into any popular conspiracy theories by any chance?

Littlewasp · 14/10/2022 16:19

I do hope MIL's long term plan isn't to emotionally blackmail your DH into asking her to move in with you. She is clearly and understandably comfortable in your home, is this what is behind her reluctance to carry on and make a life for herself?

Ihatecocomelon · 14/10/2022 16:18

People are also missing the part where op says that if they leave her alone, she then moans that she's lonely.
How long until op and family can get on with their lives if op is soooo selfish 🙄

AryaStarkWolf · 14/10/2022 16:09

Ihatecocomelon · 14/10/2022 12:24

@limitedperiodonly I see you missed the part where I said sometimes you need to be cruel to be kind.

She's an adult not a child, they can't force her to go and speak to anyone, jesus christ

SpongeBob2022 · 14/10/2022 16:00

OP you can't please everyone all of the time! So go easy on yourself.

I think there are two separate things.

I don't know why you would feel like you have to travel to your MILs, something that she doesn't want you to do, just so you can justify it to your parents. It's actually their issue not hers! Why does your grandma feel bad..surely the answer to that is to have it at yours but she just doesn't come!

If it's really that you just want to go to your parents, with your grandma, then as long as MIL has the option to come with then that's fine. I do think she shouldn't just be left alone (I know you're not suggesting that).

Having said that I don't think you are unreasonable in the general principle. You've given perfectly reasonable options. If your MIL doesn't want to do any of your suggestions, all of which are fine, then that is up to her. I wouldn't be doing anything to accommodate it further.

I guess I'm being a bit contradictory but in essence Yanbu.

limitedperiodonly · 14/10/2022 15:48

@cherrytreelanecherries When someone says they want to be left alone, leave them alone. Obviously if someone doesn't wash for days or has rotting food in their fridge you might try to stage an intervention. But it doesn't sound like MIL is like that.

It's profoundly selfish for someone to say they want someone to do what they want because otherwise it is upsetting their plans or making their granny or husband feel bad, or their MIL has been a moany old cow who should just do things she doesn't particularly want to do because she's been given a list and should really buck her ideas up.

It is mid October. A lot of things can happen to change family circumstances between now and Christmas. It's happened to me more than once. Old people die at this time of year - my parents and various older family members and in-laws did. That's not being horrible it's just a fact of life and I thought you were a fan of giving it to people straight. So go on with your plans and leave MIL to a chicken crown for one on Christmas day and phone her if you want to.

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/10/2022 15:31

cherrytreelanecherries · 14/10/2022 13:40

This is such an interesting post and has really made me reflect!

I guess there are a couple of things here which make me think “yes, but…” I’m not trying to make excuses, just seeing things from different angles I guess.

The first is that MIL has no family apart from DH. He is an only child and so is she, her parents died a long time ago and she is not in touch with any of her cousins. So there will never be any other family members who can invite her for Xmas, DH is the only option. So she can spend time with us on her own (which is definitely her preferred option) but this can’t become the norm for every Xmas and birthday. I guess I’d worry about setting an expectation we can’t meet in future, and nobody else can step in to fill the gap. But maybe I’m worrying unnecessarily.

The second is that on the the odd occasion she has come to family events, she has actually enjoyed it! A few years back she and FIL came to a party hosted by my side of the family. DH and I were completely in shock when they accepted the invitation and a bit worried about how it would go but it was great. They spent ages chatting to people and said how much they enjoyed it afterwards. Everyone loved them and I said to my friend afterwards that they’re actually really shy and don’t have many friends and she actually laughed as she thought I was joking!

There is no doubt she is a natural introvert and lacks confidence with big groups but she does seem to benefit from social contact from what I’ve seen. But I guess it’s her choice and not my decision what’s best for her, plus it’s obviously different at the moment in the context of the bereavement.

Anyway, just musings really and not completely relevant to the thread but just interesting as it sounds like a similar personality type / dynamic.

I am glad my somewhat challenging life experiences are helping you op. My fil was actually a similar age to your mil when his wife died. He’s always been what I would call old for his age and now in his 80s, he’s finally caught up I think. He isn’t confident in situations out of his comfort zone, which is similar to your mil.

I think the difference between your mil and my fil is that he is content to be alone and not bored. He found his little routine and certain things to do. His garden and he took up cycling. After a few years, he decided he’d like a dog, which has now died and been replaced by the cat across the road, who the neighbours were happy for him to adopt when they moved away. Dh also used to go over when we lived closer and help out to keep him going and we visited very regularly. I think this may be a way forward for your mil to encourage her out of this rut, such as going out in the car and her driving for a little distance or going together to one of these meetings you suggested.

I do think you should let the GP know. My fil is good at looking after his physical and mental health. But he already had practice at this and took himself to the doctor when needed. There are other areas he is less well at, such as keeping his house in repair. I pushed him hard to look after his physical comfort as he was highly resistant and as things wore out, I organised things like a functioning kitchen, a shower as he had none, furnishing eg sofas, a mattress, bedlinen and so forth. He wanted to keep the broken, patched up kitchen tap broke and keep filling a bucket to flush his only loo!

I think it’s easier as part of a couple to compliment one another and plug the gaps. If my fil were depressed, unhappy or refusing to look after his health, I would be stepping in. I get your mil is highly resistant and things need to be chipped away at. Believe me, you don’t get more resistant than my fil!

Pollyputthekettleonha · 14/10/2022 15:13

This is a tough one. It's only one year since she lost her husband. She was clearly exceptionally reliant on him i.e. won't drive or go on the train, few friends. It's not surprising she's struggling so much as she is lacking the skills to do pretty basic things without him, plus the obvious impact of the grief itself. A stark reminder to retain some independence from your OH when the worst happens! I think given the timescale I would go with what she wants this year but make sure you see Grandma and your parents on boxing Day, without MIL and DH if necessary, that should be a non negotiable given your Grandma's age.
I understand your concerns about not setting an expectation that she will get this her way every year, and if she won't compromise next year she has to stay at home alone , but for now it's still pretty raw. She needs to work on some independence skills in time , but obviously this will not be a quick fix after a lifetime of relying on FIL.

latetothefisting · 14/10/2022 14:59

Hmm I can kind of see where you're coming from actually.

If your parents can't come to you because of elderly gran then you hosting mil at your place will mean you won't see your parents at Christmas for the next few years, basically until elderly gran dies (sorry to be blunt but that seems to be the gist of it) - in which case at some point I probably would take mil up on her offer to be alone - not this year but if you are in the same circumstances next year (which will be her third christmas without her husband rather than being newly bereaved) and she's been offered the option to come to your parents with you and refused - otherwise to insist you and dh have to choose her over your parents every single year because she won't accept any suggestion than coming to yours is a bit selfish.

paisley256 · 14/10/2022 14:51

It's a shame really because I think mil might enjoy herself if you were all to have a family Christmas together at your parents, where she'll be with the children and grandma. Whether she agrees to it ofcourse is another issue.

huffyhufferson · 14/10/2022 14:45

You don't have to tell me what is involved with complicated grief.

Gymnopedie · 14/10/2022 14:42

I’m a similar age to your MIL (it’s not that old!), and it’s about time she grew up and learnt to live independently forging her own life and friendships and stop playing the ‘poor old me’ card. She sounds just like my annoying Aunty who lived to a ripe old age and drove everyone potty trying to accommodate her wishes.

I hope you're never in the position of losing your life partner. In my case (I've posted on this thread earlier, he died suddenly just before Christmas last year) DP and I had been together for a few weeks shy of 45 years. If I haven't given myself a whole new life and become the life and soul of the party in a year (or 'grew up' in your words) I'm annoying??

I do things. I travel on trains, I've been on holiday. Doesn't mean I wouldn't rather be at home with DP and I do sometimes just hide myself at home. Because no amount of company, activities and friends/family can ever compensate for him not being here, nice as they are. I don't demand things of others because I know their lives don't revolve around mine. But no two people ever grieve in exactly the same way.

PS The bit about going to the doctor if you haven't moved on in a year refers to not being able to get out of bed, treating the person's room and/or belongings as shrines, crying almost non-stop. It doesn't mean you go if you're still missing the person and haven't completely come to terms with your new life.

Jenpeg · 14/10/2022 14:40

Mardyface · 14/10/2022 14:30

@Jenpeg has it. I feel sorry for your mil but ultimately she's going to continue to feel shit or she isn't. I actually don't think where she spends Xmas is going to change that. You and your family are allowed a nice Xmas and you are not actually excluding her, which would be mean.

Cannot possibly know how bad things are for MIL and what might help, the OP is trying, we can't say if she's enabling or making it worse. I'd want to try to help her too and I wouldn't easily do something I know wouldn't suit her but I also wouldn't want to do something that I don't feel comfortable with for myself and my family. It's not an easy situation and I feel like the OP is considering the feelings of everyone around her and might just have to refocus on herself and what she wants as there is no easy answer

Swipe left for the next trending thread