Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unqualified NHS staff

184 replies

Jammydodgerr · 14/10/2022 09:39

How would you feel about the NHS using unqualified members of staff in a nursing role?

This is being floated at our local hospital, North West region, and it makes me feel really uncomfortable.

What are your opinions?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bottleofbeer · 15/11/2022 10:26

My band 4 is a very, very niche role within the NHS. I'd say what it is but it would he very putting! The same job in other trusts is band 5. I genuinely don't know why!

CaronPoivre · 15/11/2022 08:18

There are many, many unqualified staff in NHS. Also many roles filled by staff with a lower level qualification than those they are covering. A creeping reduction in qualifications for certain tasks - is arguably increased specialising on one very small aspect of a role. Nurse endoscopists, for example. Endoscopy used to be exclusively a doctors role but many are now carried out by nurses.
Nurse practitioners can now prescribe when previously it was a doctors only role in primary care. Ambulance support assistants rather than paramedics on emergency ambulances.

Generally it’s fine but not without some risks. More complex or unusual conditions may not be understood or managed as well without the underpinning theory. Some people will have a lesser service - people with a fractured leg may not get pain relief from the ambulance crews if there is no paramedic. A rare fibrotic lung condition may be dismissed as asthma and progress.

The advantages are more staff providing some access (usually reasonable) to services and treating more people. More enthused and motivated staff retained in jobs they prefer. The big benefit is cheaper healthcare, albeit with less qualified or unqualified staff.

x2boys · 15/11/2022 08:04

Burgoo · 15/10/2022 20:36

I've had mixed feelings about this. They have eroded what it means by having a nursing PIN by allowing band 4 level associate nurses to enter the register. From my experience they are glorified health care assistants and yet they are being used to do all sorts of clinical tasks (injections etc). Way to degrade the profession. That is not a knock-on health care assistant, they are wonderful AND at the same time they simply haven't the knowledge base or experience to make decisions that are rather important. I say that as a former care assistant!

At the same time, the NHS is screwed. They have 100,000 vacancies and no end in sight. They need to get bodies into jobs, and this is the one thing that has actually been helpful in filling roles.

The main problem is that it is the RNs that have overall accountability if they delegate tasks, and it goes wrong. This puts MORE pressure on RNs who are already massively burnt out.

Im not a nurse anymore but my understanding is that a nursing associate is similr to what an enrolled nurse was ,enrolled nurses were being phased out when i sarted my nurse training in the early 90,s ,they had two years training and could do many nursing tasks ,medication ,injections ,care plans etc ,but they didnt have overall responsiblity unl8ke the registered nurses .

EmmaAgain22 · 15/11/2022 07:58

Do you mean like the auxiliary nurses we used to have? They were excellent. I think someone from school went straight into that but obvs he had training.

Missdiva · 15/11/2022 07:49

bottleofbeer · 14/11/2022 23:40

In every other trust, my role is band 5. But my trust don't want to pay band 5 wages.

I'm called a nursing associate. It's a very niche role. When I know a person is Ill and above my skill set, I escalate to a band 6 as that is the next band up in my job. I'm not expected to do anything above my paygrade or knowledge. Band 4s aren't entirely useless 😆

In every trust I’ve worked in nursing associates are band 4. Becuase that’s what they are not yet a nurse they can top up and become a nurse if they like, they can do a lot of what a nurse does just not usually all of it. The last year of a degree to be a nurse is pretty important.

that being said band 4 whether you’re an AP or NA on a ward are very useful as are HCAs wards wouldn’t run without them all together.
this post is about untrained doing trained jobs and as a NA you are a trained individual as you are on the NMC register.

as far as I understand your level of qualification is essentially a foundation degree (completed the first 2 years of a degree essentially) and a top up would then be a degree allowing you to register as a nurse rather than a NA.

HollaHolla · 15/11/2022 00:50

theres not a chance that universities (and in Scotland, NHS Education) would approve nursing students losing supernumerary status. Also, given we can’t get about 1/2 of the first years to pass their numeracy/drug calculations, I wouldn’t trust them to practice alone. Do you want to be on the receiving end of the treatment of an under-confident 17 year old?

Booklover3 · 15/11/2022 00:42

^^ Jesus I’ve just realised I’m still quite bitter about it.

The NHS just needs more band 2,3,4,5 and 6’s full stop. There’s never enough staff. I left several years ago now but I know it’s got worse :(

Booklover3 · 15/11/2022 00:36

This is in part why I left the NHS. More and more responsibility with no recognition or extra training. It felt very unsafe at points and when the shit hit the fan you could never get hold of senior staff. They were too burned out themselves. This was in community projects by the way so no other staff nearby.

With extra training, support and some recognition yes. Just lobbing them in at the deep end, no.

bottleofbeer · 14/11/2022 23:42

Although some band 4's in my role are better and more knowledgeable than the 6's.

I'm not one of them, heh.

bottleofbeer · 14/11/2022 23:40

In every other trust, my role is band 5. But my trust don't want to pay band 5 wages.

I'm called a nursing associate. It's a very niche role. When I know a person is Ill and above my skill set, I escalate to a band 6 as that is the next band up in my job. I'm not expected to do anything above my paygrade or knowledge. Band 4s aren't entirely useless 😆

butterfly990 · 16/10/2022 23:29

I am a band 2 in an unrelated role. I am in my 50's and want to progress my career.

I can't afford to train as a nurse so I am looking at an "associate nurse apprenticeship" roles. Even within my own trust there are variations on what they will pay you. One is offering £9,400 another is offering band 3.

I perceive the "associate nursing role" as a way for the NHS to get cheaper "nurses".

Badgirlriri · 16/10/2022 23:00

BadNomad · 15/10/2022 21:24

Yes, most of the time. But there are some lazy nurses. Too posh to wash nurses. I-didn't-spend-3-years-at-university-just-to-wash-arses nurses. We all know at least one.

I know plenty of these!

CrushingAndClueless · 16/10/2022 22:24

They have reduced staffing ratios, they discharge anyone they can so the wards are full of sicker, more dependent patients and they replaced nurses with HCA's so all the stuff the HCA's aren't allowed to do falls on the RN's shoulders. Often there are only 2 per ward. They literally do not have the time to spend 15 to 30 mins per patient on basic care, because they now do a lot of jobs the Junior Dr's used to do,

My friend is a nurse who works on a stroke patient where there are 30 patients. She said the maximum number of nurses there will be on shift is three, and then they have about six HCA’s per shift to do call the care.

My nurse said that all she and the other nurses do is medications and documentation and she hates it.

bottleofbeer · 16/10/2022 22:21

Not read the whole thread. I'm band four doing what is generally accepted as a band five role at the coal face of mental health.

I'm master's educated. I'm exploited

reesewithoutaspoon · 16/10/2022 20:50

BadNomad · 15/10/2022 21:22

They should be doing it. It's their PIN on the line. "I didn't have time to do it" or "no one told me" won't wash when they're asked why their patient has an undocumented grade 4 pressure sore. Patient care comes first. Notes can wait. It's shit, it's unfair, but it's the truth.

It doesn't matter whether they should. they don't have the time. If you have 15 patients you have 4 minutes per patient per hour.

They have reduced staffing ratios, they discharge anyone they can so the wards are full of sicker, more dependent patients and they replaced nurses with HCA's so all the stuff the HCA's aren't allowed to do falls on the RN's shoulders. Often there are only 2 per ward. They literally do not have the time to spend 15 to 30 mins per patient on basic care, because they now do a lot of jobs the Junior Dr's used to do,

Lex345 · 16/10/2022 08:30

Oh, also, I did the degree. The best part of the job was always and will always be hands on care. I loved doing the things that really mattered to people, helping them wash/dress/use the loo/spending time listening to them/making sure they have enough to eat and drink etc.

Not all degree educated nurses shun this part of the job, but if you make people legally responsible for too much they literally do not have time. If I could go back to nursing knowing I would have the time to give proper, full and comprehensive care to every person I was assigned to look after I would.

It causes a lot of personal turmoil and professional dissatisfaction when you only feel like you are a medication administrating/note writing robot.

Lex345 · 16/10/2022 08:23

What worries me more about the delegation of tasks isn't the competence of HCAs/NAs, it is a way to "cover" the chronic lack of nurses. Safe nurse to patient ratios are key in safety.

I've left nursing now, but when I first qualified, I took a job on an acute medical ward. We were meant to have 8 patients per nurse. I was regularly assigned 12 during my preceptorship!

We had a fantastic Band 4, but at the time she wasn't allowed to administer meds. The solution was to assign her a cohort of patients and we had to do her meds. So sometimes 16 sets of meds in the morning for 1 nurse (with IVs and PRN pain relief, that is a lot!)

So it was bad then. I am told my friends still at the same trust that it is worse now.

We weren't allowed emergency/complex placements until year 3 of training-we all did a rotation on A and E/Surgical Triage/ICU/HDU.

lljkk · 16/10/2022 07:43

I don't scrutinise the qualifications of who does my health care.
A lot of the activity listed here (like taking bloods) sounds like it's not super challenging to learn to do it to a high standard, someone doesn't need a 3+ year degree to do it competently.

Realityloom · 15/10/2022 22:16

@BadNomad they should yes. I've met and heard nurses mainly band 4s say they haven't gone to uni to wash arses.

My old manger at band 6 said to us we are all health care workers and that is the truth but for some reason there's hierarchy to high heavens.

Absolutely it's their pin on the line and it's the RN who would have to stand before the NMC

Topgub · 15/10/2022 21:45

@BadNomad

I hear folk saying it but I've never really met one.

Or if I have they're no longer ward nurses anyway.

BadNomad · 15/10/2022 21:24

Topgub · 15/10/2022 21:10

@BadNomad

I agree.

Except I would swap out lazy with short staffed and overwhelmed

Yes, most of the time. But there are some lazy nurses. Too posh to wash nurses. I-didn't-spend-3-years-at-university-just-to-wash-arses nurses. We all know at least one.

BadNomad · 15/10/2022 21:22

Realityloom · 15/10/2022 20:48

@BadNomad no the nurses don't do it @reesewithoutaspoon is correct. The RN simply do not have time to check 14 patients skin. There's that much paper work taking priority and ticking boxes it's to hell with the rest.

They should be doing it. It's their PIN on the line. "I didn't have time to do it" or "no one told me" won't wash when they're asked why their patient has an undocumented grade 4 pressure sore. Patient care comes first. Notes can wait. It's shit, it's unfair, but it's the truth.

ELL2478 · 15/10/2022 21:19

funtycucker · 14/10/2022 10:12

This has been my experience as a patient in several trusts.

What do you mean 'thankfully'. Those who carry out these skills are trained and assessed. You expect a registered nursesto take your blood all the time instead of HCA's/phlebotomists?

Topgub · 15/10/2022 21:10

@BadNomad

I agree.

Except I would swap out lazy with short staffed and overwhelmed

Realityloom · 15/10/2022 20:48

@BadNomad no the nurses don't do it @reesewithoutaspoon is correct. The RN simply do not have time to check 14 patients skin. There's that much paper work taking priority and ticking boxes it's to hell with the rest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread