Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you like dogs more than people and treat them better than people ?

331 replies

tvluv · 14/10/2022 07:49

It seems to me there are a lot of people who value dogs higher than they do people and treat them better ?

Do you agree ? Do you do this ?

OP posts:
GlassOuijan · 14/10/2022 08:42

It's like you all like some massive power and someone who can't answer back to you. With a dog, you're in charge. They're there, for you basically. It's weird to me if you like that more than a more complex relationship with a human. You're all a doggie really has. They rely on you completely. And that's the relationship you love the most in your life ? That's weird to me

That's a huge assumption about how and why people love their dogs. A lot of people rely on their dogs, too.
My children relied on me too, but that didn't make me rub my hands together with glee at the power I wielded.

Fuwari · 14/10/2022 08:41

I grew up in a home where my mother loved the dogs more than us. She absolutely would have saved a dog over her own DC, let alone anyone else. It really damaged us. I can’t even be friends with someone who is that devoted to their animals, it’s too triggering, for want of a better word. I do have cats myself now, I love them, but they are pets not people.

Quveas · 14/10/2022 08:41

FirewomanSam · 14/10/2022 08:12

I hate the goady ‘would you save your dog or a stranger’ question. It’s designed purely to stir up upset over a hypothetical situation that nobody is likely to ever find themselves in. And even if they did, nobody knows what they would actually do any such circumstances. Stupid question.

Totally agree - the the MN goady I hate dogs so lets all pile in on people who don't by creating ridiculous arguments.

But turning it on its head, I find it saddening that I am allowed to make humane decisions for my dogs that I am not allowed to make for people. How many people are left in pain and with no quality of life for weeks/months/years because the law says it values human lives more?

WinneyWasherWoman · 14/10/2022 08:41

Oh and I’d save any human over any dog 100%. No question.

Rooster67 · 14/10/2022 08:40

Peter Singer would love this thread 😂

WinneyWasherWoman · 14/10/2022 08:39

Don’t particularly like dogs. Nothing against well behaved well trained ones, but can take them or leave them. Can’t abide badly trained ones which is really more common post-lockdowns.

unfortunately family members on DH’s side seem to prefer the family dogs to my young DD. One of the dogs has shown signs of aggression so I’ve said for Christmas & other family occasions it’s DD or the dog who can be present, or the dog has to be locked away securely in another part of the house. They seem to prefer the dog. Bonkers.

Toomanybooks22 · 14/10/2022 08:39

FirewomanSam · 14/10/2022 08:12

I hate the goady ‘would you save your dog or a stranger’ question. It’s designed purely to stir up upset over a hypothetical situation that nobody is likely to ever find themselves in. And even if they did, nobody knows what they would actually do any such circumstances. Stupid question.

Completely agree.

picklemewalnuts · 14/10/2022 08:38

I treat my dog well because I can't explain to him that he can't sit in his usual seat because a non family member has arrived and wants to sit there.
I can't explain his dinner is late because of roadworks.

I generally expect the most intelligent person to be adaptable to the needs of the less intelligent- adults to be considerate of toddlers and pets.

I consider people who put their preferences above the needs of the non verbal to be dicks.

saraclara · 14/10/2022 08:38

thecatsthecats · 14/10/2022 08:24

What makes a human life more valuable than a cat's?

I want specific answers here, not just "obviously they are".

The lives that matter most to me are the ones that enrich my life. That show me affection, give me joy, provide employment, etc. The same is true of you, if you're honest with yourself.

And I have never, never, never been significantly hurt by a cat. Whereas I know an awful lot of people who have been hurt by a human. I wake up with palpitations daily because I was harrassed by a human. My mum was beaten and abused by the human she married, and that same human poured scalding water on my infant sister.

There are no cat Hitlers, or Putins.

(and that's before you get to the humans who are simply mediocre, boring, or just slightly mean)

I'm sorry that you had a traumatic upbringing, but really, it can't have escaped you that cats are killers? And they don't kill only to survive, they kill even if their fed to bursting by their human. They do it for fun.

I love cats, I've always had them, but seeing then add the 'do no harm' option compared to a human, is just so mistaken that it's laughable. They might not harm you, but that's a different matter.

tvluv · 14/10/2022 08:38

girlmom21 · 14/10/2022 08:35

It's weird to me if you like that more than a more complex relationship with a human. You're all a doggie really has. They rely on you completely. And that's the relationship you love the most in your life ? That's weird to me.

That's the same as your relationship with a baby and I'd save my baby before my best friend.

That is an absolutely ridiculous comparison to make.

OP posts:
CrunchyCarrot · 14/10/2022 08:37

No. I am a cat person and worship at their furry paws.

OoooohMatron · 14/10/2022 08:36

thecatsthecats · 14/10/2022 08:24

What makes a human life more valuable than a cat's?

I want specific answers here, not just "obviously they are".

The lives that matter most to me are the ones that enrich my life. That show me affection, give me joy, provide employment, etc. The same is true of you, if you're honest with yourself.

And I have never, never, never been significantly hurt by a cat. Whereas I know an awful lot of people who have been hurt by a human. I wake up with palpitations daily because I was harrassed by a human. My mum was beaten and abused by the human she married, and that same human poured scalding water on my infant sister.

There are no cat Hitlers, or Putins.

(and that's before you get to the humans who are simply mediocre, boring, or just slightly mean)

I'm sorry that you have experienced some terrible human beings but my experience is different which is probably why I value humans more over animals. An animal doesn't contribute to society in a way that humans do, by working, solving problems, sharing jokes, sharing grief etc. Pets are indeed lovely and I have cats myself and will be gutted when they die but I know I can get another cat who would be pretty similar to the current ones. If my DH or kids were gone it would ruin my life completely. I don't know any truly awful human beings, a few dickheads but nobody abhorrent but I can appreciate if somebody has had a lot of bad experiences they would see things differently.

girlmom21 · 14/10/2022 08:35

It's weird to me if you like that more than a more complex relationship with a human. You're all a doggie really has. They rely on you completely. And that's the relationship you love the most in your life ? That's weird to me.

That's the same as your relationship with a baby and I'd save my baby before my best friend.

Heilalala · 14/10/2022 08:35

So if you had the choice to save the life of a stranger or your dog, which would you save ?

I would save my dog over a stranger every single time. I adore my dogs and they are important family members. I feel completely the opposite about cats though. I detest them.

KangarooKenny · 14/10/2022 08:34

I love my dog more than anyone else.

saraclara · 14/10/2022 08:33

The OP wasn't about who you'd save, but how dogs are treated.
I'm pretty sickened by the whole 'treating dogs like children' think that's become pervasive. Dogs having whole wardrobes of clothes (my friends yorkshire terrier has a dozen outfits at least) etc. Shops are ridiculously expensive accessories and food, and dogs are generally being mollycoddled rather than being allowed to be dogs.
I have one acquaintance who definitely treated her dogs better than her children.

tvluv · 14/10/2022 08:29

I feel uncomfortable with the concept of loving dogs more than people.

It's like you all like some massive power and someone who can't answer back to you. With a dog, you're in charge. They're there, for you basically. It's weird to me if you like that more than a more complex relationship with a human. You're all a doggie really has. They rely on you completely. And that's the relationship you love the most in your life ? That's weird to me.

I have a dog by the way and adore her. But I wouldn't put it on parr with human relationships. It's different. And not above human relationships.

Me / her family are her entire world. Whereas in human relationships that's obviously not the case.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 14/10/2022 08:26

There are no cat Hitlers

I've known a few Hitler cats in my time Grin

Chesneyhawkes1 · 14/10/2022 08:26

@TimeForMeToF1y that's your way of looking at things, which is fine. My way is different.

thecatsthecats · 14/10/2022 08:24

OoooohMatron · 14/10/2022 07:58

Seriously, how ridiculous 🙄

What makes a human life more valuable than a cat's?

I want specific answers here, not just "obviously they are".

The lives that matter most to me are the ones that enrich my life. That show me affection, give me joy, provide employment, etc. The same is true of you, if you're honest with yourself.

And I have never, never, never been significantly hurt by a cat. Whereas I know an awful lot of people who have been hurt by a human. I wake up with palpitations daily because I was harrassed by a human. My mum was beaten and abused by the human she married, and that same human poured scalding water on my infant sister.

There are no cat Hitlers, or Putins.

(and that's before you get to the humans who are simply mediocre, boring, or just slightly mean)

girlmom21 · 14/10/2022 08:23

If your cat/dog dies the only person that is sad is you. Yes it's upsetting but honestly a pet can be replaced in time and you would love the new pet just as much. If a person dies they leave children, parents, lifelong friends etc who's lives are affected by grief that never fully goes away.

All of this is untrue.

Does a dog of a large family then take precedent over an elderly person who has no family left?

If my dog died my whole family would be gutted.

GlassOuijan · 14/10/2022 08:22

I love my dog more than anyone except my DH and DC, and I'm a bit of a misanthrope.

However in the unlikely event that I had a choice of who to save, I'd save the human, albeit very very grudgingly.

countrygirl99 · 14/10/2022 08:19

Dogs don't put goady posts on Mumsnet which makes them much nicer than quite a few people.

Notsa · 14/10/2022 08:18

My dog is cool as are all my pets but they are animals and not on a par with humans. I would save a stranger before one of my animals.

OoooohMatron · 14/10/2022 08:17

LickThis · 14/10/2022 08:02

Why ? They are being honest
Pets have a huge influence on our lives

If your cat/dog dies the only person that is sad is you. Yes it's upsetting but honestly a pet can be replaced in time and you would love the new pet just as much. If a person dies they leave children, parents, lifelong friends etc who's lives are affected by grief that never fully goes away.