Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that school budgets are going to fail our children

167 replies

BakeOffDisasters · 14/10/2022 07:08

I'm coming from this as a teacher and parent and I'm so worried about how things are going in some schools due to tightening budgets.

I'm facing a day without an LSA in a year 1 class of 30 today with a lot of challenging needs. Across our ks1, three support staff have now been signed off and there aren't enough LSAs in the school to cover. So that will be one LSA for four classes today. This will mean that children with the highest needs will miss out on the support they so desperately need for behaviour, emotional issues and academic needs. Supply agencies are too expensive for some schools so it turns into a skeleton staff.

My son has SEN and I'm currently in the process of looking for a school for him. From questioning management across schools, the message seems uniform that with the cost of living, budgets are tightening and this has a knock on effect to staffing, specifically support staff. All teaching and support staff are the most valuable resource to children in schools, without them, children will suffer.

I feel so disillusioned with it all right now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
poormanspombears · 15/10/2022 13:17

I was having this conversation about a year 7 student yesterday.
We have basically come to the realisation that the school is setting her up to fail so she can access a specialist unit in order to access some form of education. Mainstream school just doesn't work for her for MANY reasons and it just makes me so sad.

I work in mental health in a secondary school but I also double up covering the isolation side of things which is especially hard for me and the students. One minute I'm helping them with suicidal thoughts or self harm and the next I'm giving out on them because they've sworn at a teacher or truanted! It's a very conflicting role 😞

Morph22010 · 15/10/2022 13:11

conkercollector · 15/10/2022 11:02

When my own son was in ms the head often used to say to me that I was choosing to send my son to a mainstream school and he shouldn’t be in one.

Gosh, we are absolutely not allowed to say that.

I knew he shouldn’t have been saying it too so I confirmed our conversations back in writing by email a few times just in case I ever needed for anything

conkercollector · 15/10/2022 11:02

When my own son was in ms the head often used to say to me that I was choosing to send my son to a mainstream school and he shouldn’t be in one.

Gosh, we are absolutely not allowed to say that.

Rainbowcat99 · 15/10/2022 10:59

I'm a SEND teacher and we're feeling it too despite historically being one of the few schools in our authority with a reasonable budget.
We've been told that this year the books balance and that there will be a very small surplus but that next year we can expect to be several hundred thousand in deficit. We've been told "no redundancies needed...yet"
So watch this space.
I'm top of my salary scale and so likely to be a priority in redundancies and to be honest I've got to the stage where I don't worry about it any more. Teaching is so stressful now and if they start reducing the number of TA's our classes will quickly become unsafe. So I'm probably happy to get out.

Does anybody have experience of teacher redundancy packages and how generous they are?

noblegiraffe · 15/10/2022 10:24

Or we could reduce the number of teachers off sick with stress by improving working conditions?

caringcarer · 15/10/2022 10:03

I worked as a secondary teacher for almost 30 years before retiring four years early due to not great health. There have always been staff shortages in some subjects often Maths and Science because graduates in these subjects can command higher salaries in the private sector in industry. I think it is sensible to offer these graduates 5 percent higher salary than other teachers for first 5 years of their career. Budgets are not good. However I was always amazed at how many staff had such poor sick records. I often went 3 years without a day off but some were constantly off sick. Would come back after 6 months sick with stress work a few months then off sick with stress again. I honestly think these people are not suited to teaching. If budget has to cover paying staff off sick for 6 months on full pay them 6 months on half pay then hard to pay for supply teacher to cover classes. I would change system to 3 month's full pay, then 3 months half pay. Then hold job open but only statutory sick pay for 6 months and if they don't return lose their job. It's not fair on children to take money for 6 months leaving them with no teacher. I think other professions should do the same. I have read about 1/3 of all nurses are off on full sick pay at any given time of year. One of my neighbours, a nurse took 4 months off with bad back on full pay, yet told me she had managed to decorate with wallpaper her bedroom and hall. Then she went back to work on short shifts phasing back in. I feel very sorry with teachers and nurses who have colleagues like that because that is why they are overworked. I know my v of ew won't be popular but I have observed this in teaching first hand over many years and almost always same teachers off sick and same ones having to cover their lessons and break duties.

Morph22010 · 15/10/2022 09:49

conkercollector · 15/10/2022 09:34

Of course there are parents who are desperate for non-existent special school places. However, I know from my own experience that there are many parents who will not consider even looking at special school places. Sometimes it is because they rightly believe their DC will be better off in supported mainstream education. However we have a number of pupils who would do much better in a specialist setting(if available) with staff with much more comprehensive SEND training but whose parents will not even consider it.

I have never come across that in practise amongst Sen parents myself although I accept there may be a few but like I said I don’t think that’s the main issue. When my own son was in ms the head often used to say to me that I was choosing to send my son to a mainstream school and he shouldn’t be in one. He was giving this impression to other people so maybe they thought I was one of those parents who didn’t want specialist like you suggest. The truth was I didn’t want him in that school anymore than the head did but didn’t have a choice unless I homeschooled which I wanted to do even less. I did get him into specialist in the end but it was a massive fight and I had to go to tribunal even to get an ehcp assessment

Whinge · 15/10/2022 09:42

This is not the case in my school. Any surplus we had has gone with paying for supply when staff were off with covid, putting in hand gel dispensers etc and paying for extra cleaning and staff for bubbles. We're starting off in a rubbish place financially and it will only get worse.

It's the same at my school. We've never been in such a precarious position, and for the first time we can't see any way out. There's nothing left to cut back on, and with the current financial situation it's only going to get worse.

Sherrystrull · 15/10/2022 09:37

CentralLondonLife · 15/10/2022 09:06

Part of the issue at the moment is that many schools are sitting on large surpluses post Cv19. They will diminish this year but at the moment they are there. So on paper there is not a current crisis but teacher pay, support staff cost rises and fuel costs will eradicate many surpluses this year.

Primary numbers have fallen off the cliff in many areas due in part to reduced immigration and London boroughs are consulting on closure but other large cities will not be far behind.

This is not the case in my school. Any surplus we had has gone with paying for supply when staff were off with covid, putting in hand gel dispensers etc and paying for extra cleaning and staff for bubbles. We're starting off in a rubbish place financially and it will only get worse.

conkercollector · 15/10/2022 09:34

Morph22010 · 15/10/2022 09:21

Please don’t perpetuate the myth that it’s parents not wanting their kids in Sen schools that is the issue. There are many many more that would love their kids to get an Sen school place but there are not the places,

Of course there are parents who are desperate for non-existent special school places. However, I know from my own experience that there are many parents who will not consider even looking at special school places. Sometimes it is because they rightly believe their DC will be better off in supported mainstream education. However we have a number of pupils who would do much better in a specialist setting(if available) with staff with much more comprehensive SEND training but whose parents will not even consider it.

Morph22010 · 15/10/2022 09:26

I also think that what people sometimes don’t get is that if all Sen children go then their funding will go with them so the school won’t even have the same inadequate funding it has now. A chunk of a schools funding is for low level Sen support but is not ring fenced so in these times it is very likely it is being used to fund other basics. Also children with ehcps and 1-1 TA’s that ta often assists other children in the class. That child goes and the class ta is likely to go completely. I had one particular parent in my sons ms class that used to moan a lot and put in complaints about my son who had asd and full time 1-1. I often couldn’t get near my sons ta in the mornings as they were talking to them about issues with their child. When my son moved to specialist the ta was moved from that class and they had a teacher only

CentralLondonLife · 15/10/2022 09:26

Meklk · 15/10/2022 09:23

Classroom resources - honestly, if not a few donations from parents - our kids at school's nursery wouldn't have even ONE PENCIL. We simply keep buying Poundland stuff (pencils, crayons) that our kids could paint or draw.
They simply need new chairs, new toilet seats, etc - everything is falling apart. Books look like a toilet paper - probably 2 pages out of 10 left.
One of the parents in our group is a maintenance and did great job this week fixing some things from his own pocket. I just can't believe these things happening in 2022. I'm from Eastern Europe and believe me, even in our poor country they are never short of pencils or can't afford to fix the toilet seats....

Is this a school nursery?
Sounds like poor management, schools are not so desperate that they dont have pencils if they are well managed and realistic about costs and structures.

Meklk · 15/10/2022 09:23

Seashor · 15/10/2022 06:01

It’s absolutely dire. Parents need to wake up and smell the coffee. I am often quite vocal in the school moaning threads because parents are still so naive to a typical school day.

I refuse to use my own money on classroom resources, this means that sometimes children are sharing pens to write with. We have no classroom support and no meal time assistants.

Thankfully however there is still plenty of money for Ofsted to come in and do ‘inspections’ and for the ridiculous phonics screening tests and KS1 and 2 Sats to go ahead. Thank the Lord for that!

Luckily for me my own child is now in the private sector.

Classroom resources - honestly, if not a few donations from parents - our kids at school's nursery wouldn't have even ONE PENCIL. We simply keep buying Poundland stuff (pencils, crayons) that our kids could paint or draw.
They simply need new chairs, new toilet seats, etc - everything is falling apart. Books look like a toilet paper - probably 2 pages out of 10 left.
One of the parents in our group is a maintenance and did great job this week fixing some things from his own pocket. I just can't believe these things happening in 2022. I'm from Eastern Europe and believe me, even in our poor country they are never short of pencils or can't afford to fix the toilet seats....

Morph22010 · 15/10/2022 09:21

conkercollector · 15/10/2022 08:17

Even if there were sufficient special school places, you can't place a child in one unless the parents agree. Many parents of children with SEND want their children in mainstream schools, for a wide variety of reasons.

Please don’t perpetuate the myth that it’s parents not wanting their kids in Sen schools that is the issue. There are many many more that would love their kids to get an Sen school place but there are not the places,

CentralLondonLife · 15/10/2022 09:06

Part of the issue at the moment is that many schools are sitting on large surpluses post Cv19. They will diminish this year but at the moment they are there. So on paper there is not a current crisis but teacher pay, support staff cost rises and fuel costs will eradicate many surpluses this year.

Primary numbers have fallen off the cliff in many areas due in part to reduced immigration and London boroughs are consulting on closure but other large cities will not be far behind.

Forestfever · 15/10/2022 08:57

whatsagoodusername · 15/10/2022 08:54

@Forestfever It's messages like this that I really wish Mumsnet would add a thumbs up or heart for. Well done to your son. I'm sure you know this already, but thankfully most people do not think like that other poster!

Thanks, I do know! Usually I can ignore it when people are nasty, but it was epic today!

The funding situation is dire, and it's failing everyone. Blaming it on the SEN kids getting some extra support doesn't help!

I 100% agree! And it's ridiculous to think that taking away the inadequate funding that some SEN kids have will make any difference to the situation overall. It just won't!

MrsG010814 · 15/10/2022 08:54

@mgmnt you really have no idea what you are talking about and the way you talk about children with sen is absolutely despicable. My son has sen and if you think for one second that children with sen get extra support so easily you are very much mistaken. Parents have to fight very hard to get support for their children in order for them to access education. My son has a high level of intelligence but struggles with social, emotional and sensory processing so requires support to manage those needs. A lot of the time children with sen are failed by the system due to underfunding and huge delays in needs being assessed.

DianaBarry5 · 15/10/2022 08:54

Yes there are poor and great parents in all areas, deprived and wealthy. However, my personal experience of working in a school in a poorer catchment is that many of the parents push for diagnosis of ASD/ADHD when it's is simply bad, lazy parenting. I see it every day and it frustrates the hell out of me. Parents standing at the door in the morning complaining their child has not had a good start to the day usually because they can't say no or put boundaries in place not because they have a child with SEND

whatsagoodusername · 15/10/2022 08:54

@Forestfever It's messages like this that I really wish Mumsnet would add a thumbs up or heart for. Well done to your son. I'm sure you know this already, but thankfully most people do not think like that other poster!

Thanks, I do know! Usually I can ignore it when people are nasty, but it was epic today!

The funding situation is dire, and it's failing everyone. Blaming it on the SEN kids getting some extra support doesn't help!

Titsflyingsouth · 15/10/2022 08:52

Am school Governor and a parent of a SEND child and it terrifies me. I think school will middle through for a year or so and the worst impact will be felt in about 12 months time. I'm praying for a general election soon. Much as I hate Labour's TWAW stance, I desperately want someone in charge who will take sorting out schools and the NH seriously....

Takeoutyourhen · 15/10/2022 08:41

It’s really scary. I have additional adults in my class who are spread so thinly amongst many many needy children. My TA is unable to do much bar watch children with behavioural issues like a hawk. I have to do everything and I can see it clear as day that barely any of them get the right amount of attention. I don’t know what will happen next.

listsandbudgets · 15/10/2022 08:40

PS DS is in a private school.... there's no escape for your precious little ones.. unless you get them a governess of course!

Even the most selective private school in our area ( 700 applicants to 80 places) has children with SEN because they select on ability and potential. They even offer adjustments in their entrance exam. They certainly wouldn't kowtow to the hideous view of parents like you.

whatkatydid2013 · 15/10/2022 08:38

Ok @mgmnt I’ve seen your update. So in your world what happens to the abandoned and ignored children with SEN when they become adults? With good support as kids many of them will be more than able to live independently and contribute to society like everyone else. What do you think is likely to be the higher cost over their life (since that’s clearly all you care about at all)

whatkatydid2013 · 15/10/2022 08:29

I must admit I sometimes question if it’s the right thing for some SEN kids to be in mainstream school. My nephew has just started primary recently. He has being diagnosed as Autistic and has most of the markers but hasn’t had a full assessment and it’s unclear how much it will impact him as he gets older and how much support he will need longer term. Currently he needs a lot of 1:1 support because he has only very recently begun to talk and struggles to communicate needs with new people. He can get very distressed about things not working in the way he expects them to and at times can be violent (biting, hitting & head butting). He is definitely far from stupid as he understands and follows complex instructions, builds Lego for adults and can manage maths at/above level of many kids his age.

Honestly he might be better off in a specialist school at the moment that was set up to manage needs of pupils with ASD, ADHD and similar. I suspect such a school would actually be more expensive than having TA support in mainstream but it would mean the set up could be geared entirely around the students with complex needs and wouldn’t have to balance that with a large class. It would also reduce the chances of another child being hurt at some point if he were in an environment with a small class size, genuine 1:1 or 2:1 etc. I want him to get access to tools to help him succeed in life. I’m very hopeful that since getting glue ear fixed that went undiagnosed in the pandemic his language will improve and that will help a lot in his ability to communicate his needs and at that point with a bit of extra support he can thrive in a mainstream setting. In the meantime though it’s hard as it’s stressful for him managing in mainstream. It’s stressful for his parents who worry about him coping and also that if he bites/hits at school he could end up labelled as a “bad” child for the whole time he’s in that cohort of children even if he manages to get better at communicating and at regulating his behaviour over time. It’s doubtless stressful for the overstretched staff who may well be blamed if he does hurt another child because his 1:1 person was doing something else at the time.

Unless you are suggesting just not bothering to educate anyone who has complex needs I’m not sure what you think the answer is. Is that what you are suggesting @mgmnt? To just leave them out of school entirely since it’s too expensive? If so what is your plan when they are adults?

KarenPirie72 · 15/10/2022 08:28

I’ve reported mgmnt for hate speech. Calling SEN children dumb window lickers is without doubt the vilest thing I’ve ever read on MN and that’s saying something. I hope they are banned from the site.

Swipe left for the next trending thread