Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trip to Pakistan with dad or grandmother - identity card or visa on British passport?

81 replies

FeelingGuilty151 · 13/10/2022 22:48

So I was wondering about what would be the most sensible thing to do as my nana and dad have suggested that I go to Pakistan with either of them next year at some point when they go

They suggested I apply for a Pakistani identity card (NIPOC or Pakistani origin card) for overseas Pakistanis and their relatives and offspring as it would give me indefinite visa free access to the country with no restrictions, allowing possible employment, bank account creations and buying land. Or the alternative is a time restricted visa

I am more swayed towards applying for a visa on my British passport as perhaps the identity card could cause issues with the British Home office from helping me if I ever needed to be brought back to the UK

what would you suggest I do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UriahIrwi · 06/09/2023 05:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

botanicalart · 14/10/2022 19:05

It is not easy for consular staff to pull people out of these situations. There is considerable risk to life.
The OP sounds incredibly naive and has drip fed her story.
It all sounds rather odd. Certainly as she is part of that culture she should be aware of what can go wrong.

WifeMotherWorker · 14/10/2022 18:42

Do. Not. Go.

alexdgr8 · 14/10/2022 18:27

sorry, but i don't understand.
are you british or pakistani ?
you live in britain have british citizenship.
why are you accepting to have your life controlled in this way, as if you are not a grown-up ?
why don't you move out and live independently, or flat-share, or with a female friend/partner, if that's what you want.
did you post before, maybe last year ? some of this sounds familiar.
live your own life.
you don't have to fall out with your parents, but just take charge of your own life.
you need to take responsibility.

Pixiedust1234 · 14/10/2022 17:41

FeelingGuilty151 · 14/10/2022 01:39

Apparently they wouldn’t do anything to hurt us and wouldn’t force us to marry anyone as it would be our own choice. But for one of my parents to be so against me going to Pakistan as she “cared about her daughters protection and self respect” to all of a sudden being okay with it is a bit strange

But for one of my parents to be so against me going to Pakistan as she “cared about her daughters protection and self respect” to all of a sudden being okay with it is a bit strange

Have been thinking more about this. I'm going to take a leap here and say she changed when she found out you were gay. She wants you married and respectable before you shame the family. I'm sorry op, your mother might be wishing she could go against the tide but family honour and religion and outside pressure are too intertwined . If you werent gay she would have supported you more in finding someone over here but maybe her own prejudices are too deep .

I repeat from earlier, please don't go.

magma32 · 14/10/2022 17:08

RealHousewifeOfPakistan · 14/10/2022 16:51

I have the reading comprehension problem? Let’s take a look at your own comments:

‘The fact that you say (all) British people will hate it there makes me question whether you actually live there yourself as there is a huge ex pat community living in ex pat communities, even people from villages know this and they’re nothing like the environments you describe.’

No, I never said that “(all) British people will hate it there’. You invented those words yourself: that is 100% your own sweeping generalisation. I did say that I hate living here and I gave reasons why.

And I am very active int eh expat community you describe because I am a dual passport holder: ALL of the expats I know spend considerable time grumbling about the issues I mentioned. Literally all of them. And I go to UK and US consulate sponsored social events on a weekly basis.

I can’t understand what part of my post you think is untrue. I stated that at least half of marriages are arranged in Pakistan and this is true: you can find the statistics online yourself.

I mentioned the filth and pollution, and that’s true and verifiable via many reputable sources as well. It is not a ‘sweeping generalisation’ to mention that the filthy air and water are ‘a thing’ in major Pakistani cities: do your research, it is hardly a secret. You mentioned Lahore yourself: it is one of the most polluted, filthy cities on the planet, and don’t take my word for it: do some research yourself, because there are many published reports with facts and comparison you can read yourself. Karachi and Islamabad are also badly polluted, and I do think these things are relevant because the air and water pollution is something expats notice right away. OP should be aware of these things if she is in a position where she may be forced to stay in a place like this. I don’t want her to be coaxed into accepting a situation, which I have seen happen to other women who are then appalled when they find what their new reality entails.

There are some good things about life in Pakistan, but the negatives vastly outweigh them for me, and I still contend that the OP is at high risk of being forced into a marriage by her family. I know parents like hers, and the signs are all there.

Yes Lahore is unpleasant as are other inner city areas but that’s the not the locale of the ex pat communities I’m referring to there, but there is a lot going on in Lahore which is eye opening for someone who actually thought nightlife is only for men over there. ofcourse people who live there grumble we all grumble but many I know personally there are living in much better environments unless they are lying! These people researched the areas before moving and obviously have done for work reasons but they can choose to come back if they wanted but on the whole they prefer the lifestyle despite the cons. Pakistan is not a country I would choose to live in but it’s definitely not all the same everywhere. Oh yes I completely agree with that ‘sewage’ smell many people are used to it there but like I said all areas are not like that where the affluent choose to live. When you make sweeping statements you don’t need to say all the implication is there as you have said as a “British person you would hate it there” so every single British person? Vast majority potentially but every single one? That is how sweeping generalisations work. It’s the implication.

Now back to my posts, can you please tell me where I have disagreed about OP being in any danger? Or played down in anyway? Unless you are reading someone else’s posts, I have made it clear where I stand with OP’s situation. I highly doubt her family are part of the communities I’m familiar with which is why I didn’t apply a blanket “oh not all people in Pakistan force/coerce their kids their kids to marry so you’ll be okay” I referred to your generalisations separately.

if anything I generally agree with your advice to OP, not your blanket statements about Pakistan. If you are saying the vast majority perhaps have coerced/arranged marriage then I could easily agree with you but not with the general Pakistan is shit for everyone rhetoric. Yes I would much rather be a woman in the U.K. any day but there are whole bunch of Pakistani students and family connections I studied with at a prestigious university who thought the U.K. Pakistani lifestyle was shit compared to theirs, on the whole they seemed much more cultured and liberal than the British Pakistanis I know and those people do exist and have parents who are more liberal than many British Pakistanis I know. But like I said doesn’t mean that is what the op will experience when she’s goes over reading what we have about her family. That’s where the reference to your lack of comprehension lies, as I felt you were implying I was somehow playing down what could happen to OP which is why I asked you to read my posts again, separately to my posts directed towards you.

BiscuitLover3678 · 14/10/2022 17:02

There is no racism here.

I have a good friend who goes back to Pakistani all the time and what she tells me has caused me to think your situation is scary op.

BiscuitLover3678 · 14/10/2022 16:59

Also she might not think she’s forced you but do everything in her power to convince you. If you say you don’t want to go then how do they react?

RealHousewifeOfPakistan · 14/10/2022 16:51

magma32 · 14/10/2022 16:06

I honestly think you have trouble with comprehension regarding my posts. Read them carefully. Yes yours are definitely sweeping generalisations and in today’s very well connected world I do not need to live in Pakistan long term to know the different societies operating there. It really isn’t a secret so I’m not sure what your goal is here by trying to prove all marriages there are forced and all women who have them are treated like chattel. The fact that you say (all) British people will hate it there makes me question whether you actually live there yourself as there is a huge ex pat community living in ex pat communities, even people from villages know this and they’re nothing like the environments you describe. So yes absolutely these are sweeping generalisations and no cultured person would actually make them if they are genuinely ‘well travelled’ the way you imply you are. You are using references from your own bubble to say this applies to the entire population not accounting for those that don’t lead your lifestyle or your maids and what not. And I never contested how many marriages are arranged or whether they actually occur. Please reference your research as it seems you got 50% out of the sky. I would actually expect it to much more than that as Pakistan is a conservative country in general and the communities I talk about are not the majority but they definitely exist in large enough number. I would have no idea how many of those are forced and how many are not as I would need to see the research done and the evidence. But you seem to equate all arranged marriages as forced in Pakistan anyway…

I have the reading comprehension problem? Let’s take a look at your own comments:

‘The fact that you say (all) British people will hate it there makes me question whether you actually live there yourself as there is a huge ex pat community living in ex pat communities, even people from villages know this and they’re nothing like the environments you describe.’

No, I never said that “(all) British people will hate it there’. You invented those words yourself: that is 100% your own sweeping generalisation. I did say that I hate living here and I gave reasons why.

And I am very active int eh expat community you describe because I am a dual passport holder: ALL of the expats I know spend considerable time grumbling about the issues I mentioned. Literally all of them. And I go to UK and US consulate sponsored social events on a weekly basis.

I can’t understand what part of my post you think is untrue. I stated that at least half of marriages are arranged in Pakistan and this is true: you can find the statistics online yourself.

I mentioned the filth and pollution, and that’s true and verifiable via many reputable sources as well. It is not a ‘sweeping generalisation’ to mention that the filthy air and water are ‘a thing’ in major Pakistani cities: do your research, it is hardly a secret. You mentioned Lahore yourself: it is one of the most polluted, filthy cities on the planet, and don’t take my word for it: do some research yourself, because there are many published reports with facts and comparison you can read yourself. Karachi and Islamabad are also badly polluted, and I do think these things are relevant because the air and water pollution is something expats notice right away. OP should be aware of these things if she is in a position where she may be forced to stay in a place like this. I don’t want her to be coaxed into accepting a situation, which I have seen happen to other women who are then appalled when they find what their new reality entails.

There are some good things about life in Pakistan, but the negatives vastly outweigh them for me, and I still contend that the OP is at high risk of being forced into a marriage by her family. I know parents like hers, and the signs are all there.

CirclesandStars · 14/10/2022 16:48

Pakistani origin here. Don't go. What they say here and what happens there may be two different things.

BiscuitLover3678 · 14/10/2022 16:42

I’m sorry op but this is sounding dodgy. You say she is changed but it’s hard to know for sure and once she is there and surrounded by everyone she knows it could all go pear shaped.

Pakistan is a very different country and women have very little say so if something goes wrong, you are basically trapped. I wouldn’t personally go atm.

Igmum · 14/10/2022 16:39

Another one saying please don't go OP. As others have said you probably wouldn't have to face physical force/being drugged etc but this sudden offer after you split with your GF and your family's controlling behaviour are massive red flags. You are very likely to get emotional blackmail, lots of pressure and tears at a point when you are very alone and many miles from home. Good luck Flowers

magma32 · 14/10/2022 16:06

RealHousewifeOfPakistan · 14/10/2022 15:50

Do you live in Pakistan? I do. These are hardly ‘sweeping generalisations’ to anyone who knows the culture from living in Pakistan itself, not just going on random holidays or making judgements based on ‘people I have known and studied with’.

And no, I haven’t had an arranged marriage myself. About half of my friends here have, and so have 100% of our domestic workers. The risk is very high for OP, and you must see that if you read how her parents treat her and the circumstances of their proposal to go.

It is irresponsible NOT to encourage OP to stay away.

I have no idea what the last sentence in your post means about what I ‘conveniently skipped’.

Do your research: about 50% of marriages in Pakistan are arranged. And the majority of parents who want this for their children behave exactly as OP’s parents have done with the control of adult daughters, the constant checking and tracking.

I honestly think you have trouble with comprehension regarding my posts. Read them carefully. Yes yours are definitely sweeping generalisations and in today’s very well connected world I do not need to live in Pakistan long term to know the different societies operating there. It really isn’t a secret so I’m not sure what your goal is here by trying to prove all marriages there are forced and all women who have them are treated like chattel. The fact that you say (all) British people will hate it there makes me question whether you actually live there yourself as there is a huge ex pat community living in ex pat communities, even people from villages know this and they’re nothing like the environments you describe. So yes absolutely these are sweeping generalisations and no cultured person would actually make them if they are genuinely ‘well travelled’ the way you imply you are. You are using references from your own bubble to say this applies to the entire population not accounting for those that don’t lead your lifestyle or your maids and what not. And I never contested how many marriages are arranged or whether they actually occur. Please reference your research as it seems you got 50% out of the sky. I would actually expect it to much more than that as Pakistan is a conservative country in general and the communities I talk about are not the majority but they definitely exist in large enough number. I would have no idea how many of those are forced and how many are not as I would need to see the research done and the evidence. But you seem to equate all arranged marriages as forced in Pakistan anyway…

RealHousewifeOfPakistan · 14/10/2022 15:50

magma32 · 14/10/2022 10:57

Read my posts. I see red flags all over what OP has said but your sweeping generalisations I obviously don’t agree with. I’m glad you are well travelled so I’m finding it odd you have this idea that is the case for everyone that they have a forced marriage. Certainly not in my experience with the people I known and have studied with so clearly there is a different culture there amongst families and from everything else. I wrote clearly in my post it doesn’t mean people like you don’t have forced marriage. You conveniently skipped that bit too.

Do you live in Pakistan? I do. These are hardly ‘sweeping generalisations’ to anyone who knows the culture from living in Pakistan itself, not just going on random holidays or making judgements based on ‘people I have known and studied with’.

And no, I haven’t had an arranged marriage myself. About half of my friends here have, and so have 100% of our domestic workers. The risk is very high for OP, and you must see that if you read how her parents treat her and the circumstances of their proposal to go.

It is irresponsible NOT to encourage OP to stay away.

I have no idea what the last sentence in your post means about what I ‘conveniently skipped’.

Do your research: about 50% of marriages in Pakistan are arranged. And the majority of parents who want this for their children behave exactly as OP’s parents have done with the control of adult daughters, the constant checking and tracking.

magma32 · 14/10/2022 14:42

Yes it's very common and not at all making racist assumptions as some posters are suggesting. We wouldn't minimise other forms of domestic abuse on here so i'm not sure why we need to be careful not to make assumptions when there is enough in what OP has written to have serious concerns. In my line of work I would be in serious trouble if I didn't make some assumptions on these posts and refer to safeguarding to be on the safe side. Of course OP is not a minor but given the type of control her parents have had over her and all the other information she has provided us and her own concerns, she sounds to me quite vulnerable. I find it common in my community for some 'well meaning' people to advise potential victims to not seek advice from people outside the community due to racism etc and whilst in some cases there is racism and stereotyping at play, no community members are offering help for victims themselves but only seem to bash the 'outsider' agencies or in this case, outsider views but there are a few of a us asian women on here telling the OP to not go so I hope that's sending the message to OP that all does not sound okay and no racism at play. and I have a feeling OP posted on this forum as opposed to asking her own community as she wanted neutral advice so let's give her good advice to be on the safe side rather than telling her to make her own judgement etc when she probably has no idea what the potential outcomes could be in a scenario like this.

CMZ2018 · 14/10/2022 13:05

Neither. Don’t go

BeanStew22 · 14/10/2022 12:25

@Ispini : this is good advice. I don’t think people realise how many girls even get taken to the airport thinking they are just heading off on a family day out, hence my advice to OP to get rid of her passport

WatchoRulo · 14/10/2022 12:22

OK, no idea why MN is mangling the links but please google Karma Nirvana

WatchoRulo · 14/10/2022 12:21

Sorry no idea what happened there

karmanirvana.org.uk/get-help/what-is-forced-marriage/

WatchoRulo · 14/10/2022 12:19

karmanirvana.org.uk/

Quveas · 14/10/2022 12:12

The vast majority of Muslim parents would never force a marriage. But I do know of such cases, and this situation has lots of red flags that would worry me. I agree with the majority here - I wouldn't go, full stop. There is too much risk here, and why would they even begin to think you'd be ok with a visa "in case you want to stay".

You shouldn't do this. But if you are going to ignore all the red flags here, then please ensure that you have plenty of friends who know where you are, and store their numbers plus the police and the consulate numbers on a new phone that you keep hidden on your person AT ALL TIMES. Use your normal phone for everything so that nobody suspects you have another one. Keep the second phone muted so that nobody accidentally rings it. At the first hint of anything, start telling EVERYONE that you believe you are in danger and get the hell out.

Ispini · 14/10/2022 12:11

OP please don’t go, I used to teach Pakistani girls who were seriously caught out with arranged marriages after going on ‘holiday’. One piece of great advice is to put something small and metal in your knickers to set off the X-ray machines at the airport if you are being

Devpatelslaughingeyes · 14/10/2022 12:09

OP, if you do nothing else please contact Karma Nirvana (karmanirvana.org.uk ) and tell them what you have told us, even tell them the responses that you have had, and listen to their advice. They are a brilliant organisation who deal with situations like this all the time and will be able to advise and support you. If nothing else they should be able to give advice on how to safeguard your situation here.

if you go to their website there is a contact page where you can email them your details. If you would like a more immediate response there is a free helpline 0800 5999 247. It’s just a phone call that could either give you reassurance or it could save you a world of pain and heartache.

good luck with whatever you choose.

Bedtimeforever · 14/10/2022 11:34

When I first read your post, I thought well there’s absolutely nothing wrong with the identity card. I am Indian and have the Indian version. It is just standard, my dad usually mentions it whenever anybody goes, to get the overseas identity card out and its saved us a lot in visa costs over the years.
However, I don’t have a family who don’t let me go out of town etc etc. After reading your posts, I think you are better off not going given the proposals you’ve gotten etc I would just avoid it for now.