Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Ukrainian families may just have to..

329 replies

FindingMyself1999 · 13/10/2022 22:15

Go back? bbc article

such a sad situation but we barely have enough housing or school places as it is. Unless the hosts can act as guarantors? That’s a possibility ?

the government really hasn’t thought through the aftermath of the hosting scheme.

OP posts:
BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 12:12

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen Far from placing absolute trust in the government, it’s a perfect example of how to organise a shitshow. However, is it too much to ask a basic level of competency? Clearly it is.

And re your first paragraph, yes, they had that at the start, with Ukrainians having to apply at Visa Application Centres which included passport and biometric checks. While that method was fortunately scrapped in March, biometric tests are still required - just after arriving in the UK instead of prior to arrival. Here’s the explanation:

“Biometric checks are an essential part of our visa application process. There are those who seek to take advantage of the UK, and we will not let them use the Government’s humanitarian schemes for Ukrainians fleeing the Russian invasion to do so.
We are aware of cases where individuals that could pose a national security threat have attempted to enter the UK during crisis situations, and biometric checks have enabled us to identify these individuals as potential threats.
However, in order to make our Schemes as straightforward to use as possible, and based on the latest security advice, on 15 March we made changes to allow Ukrainians with valid passports who are eligible for this route to do their application online. They will no longer need to go to a Visa Application Centre to give their biometrics before they come to the UK, instead giving them after they have entered the UK.”

So, to steal an example from above, if the biometric check and passport check isn’t showing residency in Asia for 9 years, what is it doing? Either the checks have failed, or the person being referred to has come in via another type of visa/legal migration route.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/10/2022 12:05

Oh dear, I seem to be querying your assertions rather a lot today. Nothing personal.

Uk nationals had recourse ….. in a very much more limited way than vice versa. I lived in France for fifteen years. Other Uk citizens were often surprised at the restricted access to public funds compared to the UK legislation for access to things such as child benefit or unemployment benefit. ( I was aware of this as I spoke decent French and was sometimes used as an unofficial ie unpaid interpreter). It was one of the reasons that there are relatively few EU citizens of other nationalities living and working in France, at least outside the cities. ( also of course the very few vacancies in France, and the deep dislike of the French for employing anyone not French).

vera99 · 15/10/2022 12:05

I have known a British builder/labourer - who always works in cash, reckoned he had a bad back, is now on pension credit having barely paid any NI in his life and has a nice 1-bed council flat in Twickenham. He boasted about spending 3 months in Thailand every year doing what you could imagine he would do there. Voted for Brexit and doesn't like immigrants. Should we say all Brits are like that?

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 12:00

People taking the piss isn't a matter of nationality, it's a relatively common human trait.
I agree. I don't know why some posters seem to think refugees are all suffering saints. They are not. People are complex, even the very best people have their failings and the very worst have their positives, most of us are a mixture of everything.

And to this -
A previous poster tells us that Ukrainians who haven’t even lived in Ukraine for 10 years have been able to come over.
Yes true, nine years living in Asia, her friend moved here under the scheme and that's why she came, friend fixed her up with a host. Believe it, don't believe it, up to you. As I said earlier, higher hurdles preventing this sort of thing would just slow down the escape of others though and the UK Visa scheme was far to slow already. They should have binned the whole idea of a visa when this first kicked off and just sorted paperwork when people got here like most of Europe did.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 11:57

@Galaktoboureko Wouldn’t she get child benefit though regardless of whether she’s working or not working (or working cash in hand)? It’s a non-means tested benefit. I’m not sure I understand the point you’re trying to make here. EU nationals with settled status have recourse to public funds. UK nationals also had recourse to public funds in EU countries, before Brexit of course. This isn’t new or shocking information.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/10/2022 11:57

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 11:36

@LikeTearsInRain Rather than falling for a random’s account on Mumsnet and propagating anti-Ukrainian nonsense, actually go and meet some Ukrainians, hear their stories and make you own mind up?

A previous poster tells us that Ukrainians who haven’t even lived in Ukraine for 10 years have been able to come over. Yet the government criteria is that you must have been living in Ukraine immediately prior to the outbreak of the war. Did you bother to check, or did you just leap on to the post that confirms your beliefs?

I’m interested to know how the ‘government’ ( presumably the Home Office or Foreign Office) can carry out robust checks in this sort of situation. Presumably there are not cooperative English speaking counterpart officials sitting in offices with international communication equipment waiting to validate residency. I expect it comes down to self certification, which is not exactly watertight.

Please correct me if I am mistaken. It just seems slightly amusing that people who normally do not have a good word to say for ‘Government’ policy , efficiency or even probity, are perfectly prepared to place absolute trust in them when it suits their argument.

Galaktoboureko · 15/10/2022 11:47

People taking the piss isn't a matter of nationality, it's a relatively common human trait. My Lithuanian mate has a friend who claims child benefit yet works cash in hand as a cleaner (which I know is true as she quickly shushed me when I asked in company whether she was still cleaning, without realising she was claiming too).

My friend takes a pretty dim view of it herself though, as she's lived here almost 20 years, works full time, and is annoyed her friend has more disposable income than her.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 11:36

@LikeTearsInRain Rather than falling for a random’s account on Mumsnet and propagating anti-Ukrainian nonsense, actually go and meet some Ukrainians, hear their stories and make you own mind up?

A previous poster tells us that Ukrainians who haven’t even lived in Ukraine for 10 years have been able to come over. Yet the government criteria is that you must have been living in Ukraine immediately prior to the outbreak of the war. Did you bother to check, or did you just leap on to the post that confirms your beliefs?

vera99 · 15/10/2022 11:33

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 15/10/2022 11:01

There are quite a few Ukrainian refugee families here (small city) and it's beginning to cause bad feeling in some respects.

Just the other day, a host posted on the local FB page that the family she'd been hosting had just been offered a house by the council & did anyone have any furniture etc they could donate? Fair enough request. This was then followed by multiple posters asking if the family could give advice on how to jump the housing list....

Similarly, a Ukrainian lady living here posted asking if anyone local would host her friend who was living with a host elsewhere in the UK but liked our town better so wanted to move.... Comments were pretty much she can move here when she can afford to live here just like everyone else (we are on the top 10 places to live in the UK list) as her current location is fine & safe.

I'm on a few local FB groups as I am thinking of moving to the general area and a lot of these posts seem to have proliferated very similar wording to what you mention. One does wonder if these are far-right planted or Putin bots stirring up resentment to Ukrainians. The comments are sort of 50/50 between having some heart thorough to taking the piss.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 11:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

See? Like this shit. 🤡

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 11:31

Thanks @Kendodd
Equally frustrating for me is hearing all your stories, but also knowing the Ukrainian refugees I know, who are families living in one bedroom of a sponsor house,
or a relative’s house. I don’t know any in social housing now (but of course I could just not know them!) Families with parents working 12 hour days so they don’t have to rely on their hosts. Children who’ve had panic attacks needing medical intervention because their “safe” city was bombed on Monday and their grandparents are still there. Teenagers with PTSD from the start of the war.

So a casual “lots are taking the piss” is a kick in the teeth, and actually makes me worry for the safety of them, when we can see from this thread how easily people will pick up and run with a “Ukrainians all take the piss” narrative.

PigletJohn · 15/10/2022 11:25

It would be interesting to know where this mythical borough is, that has a stock of empty council houses.

LikeTearsInRain · 15/10/2022 11:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Anneofwindypoplars · 15/10/2022 11:23

Well yes, you clearly know all Ukrainians.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 11:20

@Kendodd Is it too much to ask that you be careful with your language here? I completely understand your frustrations but comments like “a lot of them are taking the piss” as well as not being statistically accurate are just going to stoke anti-Ukrainian xenophobia as already seen on this thread. Which will affect the “good” Ukrainians that approve of.

Yes taken on board.
It is very frustrating though seeing stuff first hand.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 11:14

PigletJohn · 15/10/2022 11:08

What makes you think they get council housing? Are you living in the 1950's?

Because of hosting, I've got to know a lot of Ukrainian people and some have gotten council housing in my council area. Not temporary hotel or something, but a council house.

Anneofwindypoplars · 15/10/2022 11:12

I’m calling out some of these posts are xenophobic and completely inappropriate.

WahineToa · 15/10/2022 11:11

@Kendodd Is it too much to ask that you be careful with your language here? I completely understand your frustrations but comments like “a lot of them are taking the piss” as well as not being statistically accurate are just going to stoke anti-Ukrainian xenophobia as already seen on this thread. Which will affect the “good” Ukrainians that approve of.

Agreed.

PigletJohn · 15/10/2022 11:11

@Kendodd

Oh, I understand now.

You are just spouting made-up stories to stoke anti-foreigner sentiment.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 11:10

I've posted this option on another thread, but theres a housing emergency in the UK, with or without immigration. The private sector has completely and utterly failed to provide adequate and affordable housing, the government needs to step in with an emergency response and build prefabricated homes for people just like it did after WW2.

PigletJohn · 15/10/2022 11:08

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 11:04

One thing that doesn't really make a lot of sense to me is why they actually get council housing. They're all here on temporary visas.

What makes you think they get council housing? Are you living in the 1950's?

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 11:07

@Kendodd Is it too much to ask that you be careful with your language here? I completely understand your frustrations but comments like “a lot of them are taking the piss” as well as not being statistically accurate are just going to stoke anti-Ukrainian xenophobia as already seen on this thread. Which will affect the “good” Ukrainians that approve of.

Sadly there are people (on this thread) who don’t bother to learn about the criteria for the schemes and have no understanding of how the schemes work or what people have to do to get here, who just see comments like yours and go “omg they’re all taking the piss!”

Like you’ve clarified about the Holland example, some people would not have be able to find family/child friendly accommodation or jobs in other counties (the waiting list for social housing in Amsterdam is apparently 13 years) so the Homes scheme would have seemed a godsend. They wouldn’t know that the housing situation in the UK was equally awful, or the government support would be delayed, or nonexistent in some cases. How could they know that? Yet given out of context, it’s more fuel for those who don’t trouble themselves with any critical thinking and go “omg they’re taking the piss.”

And the example about the family not moving out because they’re sending money home - are their relatives from an unsafe area so have had to move across country/stay in hotels without a job? Would you abandon your family in the same situation? Speculation of course, but a potentially real situation that some on here won’t trouble themselves to think of.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 11:04

One thing that doesn't really make a lot of sense to me is why they actually get council housing. They're all here on temporary visas.

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 15/10/2022 11:01

There are quite a few Ukrainian refugee families here (small city) and it's beginning to cause bad feeling in some respects.

Just the other day, a host posted on the local FB page that the family she'd been hosting had just been offered a house by the council & did anyone have any furniture etc they could donate? Fair enough request. This was then followed by multiple posters asking if the family could give advice on how to jump the housing list....

Similarly, a Ukrainian lady living here posted asking if anyone local would host her friend who was living with a host elsewhere in the UK but liked our town better so wanted to move.... Comments were pretty much she can move here when she can afford to live here just like everyone else (we are on the top 10 places to live in the UK list) as her current location is fine & safe.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 10:50

LetsPlayShadowlands · 14/10/2022 22:23

I know someone who got their Ukrainian family visas and brought them over. Few weeks later they chose to go back. Now they have visas for 3 years and can come and go as they please. Oh and one is on the NHS waiting list for a procedure. But voluntarily still living in Ukraine. Convenient.

In my experience, people actually go back to Ukraine for medical and dental treatment because services are so piss poor here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread