Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Ukrainian families may just have to..

329 replies

FindingMyself1999 · 13/10/2022 22:15

Go back? bbc article

such a sad situation but we barely have enough housing or school places as it is. Unless the hosts can act as guarantors? That’s a possibility ?

the government really hasn’t thought through the aftermath of the hosting scheme.

OP posts:
pnutter · 20/10/2022 17:14

I'm hosting as I previously said
I'm a single parent on a low income
I still haven't had a penny of the hosting payments
My guest I treat just as one of my children , own room , food , laundry , cleaning all done , got him a bicycle fixed up , he has free gym for a year
He is from a rich family however and has moaned today that his sister is in an expensive flat in London with a rich family , and he got me , lol 😂 , and my family
He has a job interview next week and I think I will have to ask him for rent or to move out if he gets the job . He wasn't in Ukraine before he came here and this wasn't revealed to me until he'd been here a while . He certainly looks down on the UK (says we are racist , lazy, poor )
I keep things jolly with him as I don't want trouble but I do feel very frustrated that I'm getting no support. Best not expect that from the govt at the moment!

Scrabble · 16/10/2022 00:32

They face enormous uncertainty. They may get universal credit etc, but they probably fear that they will never get the things they left behind back. May never get their decently paid jobs back. They don't know how long they'll be able to stay in the UK for. When you face so much uncertainty and fear you don't tend to feel like offering to pay for things. And they probably don't think it's expected.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 20:35

@mycatisannoying Schools should be receiving extra funding for students who have arrived on the Homes for Ukraine scheme. That money should be used for resources like an iPads for translation, uniform etc. Your school really shouldn’t be taking resources away from the SEN dept. I wonder if their thinking is that Ukrainian students with no English can’t access the curriculum at all, whereas the student in your example can access the curriculum, but not to their full potential? Doesn’t make it ok though, unless it’s very temporary. The school needs to check they’re receiving the right funding and using it appropriately.

Info here:
www.gov.uk/government/publications/homes-for-ukraine-education-and-childcare-funding/homes-for-ukraine-education-and-childcare-grant-conditions-of-funding

No doubt this will also be used to blame Ukrainian refugees for something they have no control over though!

mycatisannoying · 15/10/2022 20:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

forgodssnake · 15/10/2022 20:13

'42% were employed in the UK, up from 9% in April. Of these 42%, 63% said they had a permanent job, and 25% a temporary job. The most common sectors of work were accommodation or food service (29%), manufacturing (8%), and wholesale and retail trade (8%);
among adults with their highest level of qualification gained outside of the UK, 43% said employers generally did not recognise their qualifications when applying for jobs (25% did generally recognise them, and 29% said they did not know;
other major barriers to employment were reported to be respondents’ English language skills not meeting the job requirements (58%), and not being able to find a job that suited their skills (24%).'
migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/qa-the-uk-and-the-ukraine-refugee-situation/
Mumsnet is a different reality...

Anneofwindypoplars · 15/10/2022 19:38

But @Kendodd , you haven’t been complaining about ‘your guests’ but about Ukrainian refugees as a body, descending upon the UK to take advantage, and it’s really ugly reading.

I am quite disappointed the thread has been allowed to run with no input from MNHQ, although some deletions were finally made.

vera99 · 15/10/2022 19:36

Whitepouringglue · 15/10/2022 19:04

Yes of course kendodd. I didn't mean to suggest you weren't! Was more thinking of those for whom being pissed off morphs into a reason why they should be sent back to where they came from (usually people who haven't actually hosted but heard second hand). You absolutely shouldn't have to be a saint about it. It's already pretty saintly to have got involved, to be fair.

Very true kudos to anybody who had a go - they have a better heart than me.

Whitepouringglue · 15/10/2022 19:04

Yes of course kendodd. I didn't mean to suggest you weren't! Was more thinking of those for whom being pissed off morphs into a reason why they should be sent back to where they came from (usually people who haven't actually hosted but heard second hand). You absolutely shouldn't have to be a saint about it. It's already pretty saintly to have got involved, to be fair.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 18:57

Whitepouringglue · 15/10/2022 18:28

It's interesting to see how many posters have a concept of a good refugee and a not good refugee. It's actually very difficult to be a good refugee and not everyone is going to hit the mark because refugees are just people like the rest of us, often under stress that doesn't place them in their finest hour. We help because we should, not because they deserve it. There will never be a flux of deserving refugees to cancel out those not toeing the line. We don't offer shelter on that basis. It's quite naïve to be disillusioned or to feel there's some lefty gotcha moment when people don't behave the way you'd imagined. That is the reality of providing aid. Foster children experience the same phenomenon.

And equally, hosts are not saints either, we are allowed to be pissed off by our guests.

Anneofwindypoplars · 15/10/2022 18:45

Whitepouringglue · 15/10/2022 18:28

It's interesting to see how many posters have a concept of a good refugee and a not good refugee. It's actually very difficult to be a good refugee and not everyone is going to hit the mark because refugees are just people like the rest of us, often under stress that doesn't place them in their finest hour. We help because we should, not because they deserve it. There will never be a flux of deserving refugees to cancel out those not toeing the line. We don't offer shelter on that basis. It's quite naïve to be disillusioned or to feel there's some lefty gotcha moment when people don't behave the way you'd imagined. That is the reality of providing aid. Foster children experience the same phenomenon.

Excellent post.

Anon778833 · 15/10/2022 18:30

Whitepouringglue · 15/10/2022 18:28

It's interesting to see how many posters have a concept of a good refugee and a not good refugee. It's actually very difficult to be a good refugee and not everyone is going to hit the mark because refugees are just people like the rest of us, often under stress that doesn't place them in their finest hour. We help because we should, not because they deserve it. There will never be a flux of deserving refugees to cancel out those not toeing the line. We don't offer shelter on that basis. It's quite naïve to be disillusioned or to feel there's some lefty gotcha moment when people don't behave the way you'd imagined. That is the reality of providing aid. Foster children experience the same phenomenon.

I very much agree with this.

Whitepouringglue · 15/10/2022 18:28

It's interesting to see how many posters have a concept of a good refugee and a not good refugee. It's actually very difficult to be a good refugee and not everyone is going to hit the mark because refugees are just people like the rest of us, often under stress that doesn't place them in their finest hour. We help because we should, not because they deserve it. There will never be a flux of deserving refugees to cancel out those not toeing the line. We don't offer shelter on that basis. It's quite naïve to be disillusioned or to feel there's some lefty gotcha moment when people don't behave the way you'd imagined. That is the reality of providing aid. Foster children experience the same phenomenon.

Whitepouringglue · 15/10/2022 18:21

People in a helpless situation can be childlike and expect to be helped. It's easy to see how this could happen. Any one of us could react the same way. It must be very disorientating.

My deep respect and gratitude to all the hosts. It cannot be easy.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 17:13

Eslteacher06 · 15/10/2022 15:44

Robust checks definitely do not happen. I've known of a host who had brought a guest over and he did it so that he had a ready made housewife. That man had schizophrenia and severe depression. The family were put in a hotel once that came out.

I'm not really blaming the Ukrainians, but our shit show of a government.

It's well known now predatory men stalk Facebook looking for vulnerable women to host. In most cases I don't think checking would reveal this, women just need good escape routes.

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 17:09

ipredictariot5 · 15/10/2022 15:43

I hosted April to September a family of three, they got jobs and we managed to get them into a private rental with an understanding landlord and the council supported so no guarantor needed. The ending is the hardest bit of all to manage well. Our host experience was positive but I too was struck by the huge advantages out family had compared to other refugees. I was also struck that they didn’t ask if they could contribute at all financially and felt free bus passes/ entrance to zoo etc etc that they got initially was something they came to expect. Our experience was overall positive but it is only now they have gone my own teenagers have said how tough it was. Would I do it again if faced with it again in March 22 yes. Would i do it again now - no! Well done to all fellow hosts x

I've heard the most successful placements are those when the guest gets a job and quickly moves on. My guest shows no intention of doing either.
Would I do it again though? Actually yes. My guests city was bombed while she was there. Its not occupied or even really front line, but still, she had a child, and they were being bombed. So despite her unwillingness to pay her own way, and her racism, I would do it again. None of this is her kids fault. I will be very glad when they do eventually move out though.

Eslteacher06 · 15/10/2022 15:46

I've also heard of them complaining about the cost of transport. Considering they are getting universal credit and no bills, that will be the least of their worries!

Eslteacher06 · 15/10/2022 15:44

Robust checks definitely do not happen. I've known of a host who had brought a guest over and he did it so that he had a ready made housewife. That man had schizophrenia and severe depression. The family were put in a hotel once that came out.

I'm not really blaming the Ukrainians, but our shit show of a government.

ipredictariot5 · 15/10/2022 15:43

I hosted April to September a family of three, they got jobs and we managed to get them into a private rental with an understanding landlord and the council supported so no guarantor needed. The ending is the hardest bit of all to manage well. Our host experience was positive but I too was struck by the huge advantages out family had compared to other refugees. I was also struck that they didn’t ask if they could contribute at all financially and felt free bus passes/ entrance to zoo etc etc that they got initially was something they came to expect. Our experience was overall positive but it is only now they have gone my own teenagers have said how tough it was. Would I do it again if faced with it again in March 22 yes. Would i do it again now - no! Well done to all fellow hosts x

NicolaSixSix · 15/10/2022 15:32

HikingforScenery · 14/10/2022 11:17

At what point do numerous horrible experiences qualify as “generally”. There must be a point, surely.

I’d suggest a course in statistics

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 13:00

Oh and the person living in Asia came here in July, don't know where that puts them in the getting a Visa thing. I don't really know the other person who was living in Asia well.

NicolaSixSix · 15/10/2022 12:57

BewareTheLibrarians · 13/10/2022 23:26

There’s always a poster who knows loads of Ukrainians who “weren’t even living in Ukraine” but have got on the sponsorship scheme, yet the Home Office’s own eligibility criteria states you need proof of living in Ukraine before January 2022. Unless they’re accusing our govt of being hideously incompetent?

“Unless you’re accusing our govt of being hideously incompetent”

I mean………………

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 12:57

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 12:36

@Kendodd very true, I can’t believe that’s not even a possibility anymore. And for it to be suggested to Ukrainian guests feels very wrong as not only is it not available for UK nationals, it’s likely never going to be available for them. I feel like they’ve been sold a lie in terms of what they can expect here.

(And I was a bit angry about having to put free NHS treatment, as I’ve had to pay privately to sort out a pretty debilitating problem as the NHS waiting list was over 2 years. I’m lucky I could, how on earth people who that’s not an option for are supposed to cope is beyond me. Sorry for the sidetrack.)

I was very honest with my Ukrainian guest about what the UK was really like before she came, I don't think she really believed it though. I know dentistry was a joke, I didn't realise quite how bad our health service is in comparison though. Ironically (and unfairly if you ask me, you may disagree) there is a dentist locally taking on Ukrainians (nobody else) as NHS patients. My guest registered with them although is still unhappy because they don't just dish out antibiotics as they do in Ukraine.

The state of healthcare and dentistry (and public housing and every other public service) isn't her fault though, its 100% our fault. We get what we vote for.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 12:36

@Kendodd very true, I can’t believe that’s not even a possibility anymore. And for it to be suggested to Ukrainian guests feels very wrong as not only is it not available for UK nationals, it’s likely never going to be available for them. I feel like they’ve been sold a lie in terms of what they can expect here.

(And I was a bit angry about having to put free NHS treatment, as I’ve had to pay privately to sort out a pretty debilitating problem as the NHS waiting list was over 2 years. I’m lucky I could, how on earth people who that’s not an option for are supposed to cope is beyond me. Sorry for the sidetrack.)

Kendodd · 15/10/2022 12:27

free dentistry

Your having a laugh. The Tories have basically privatised dentistry. When my guest arrived, we had a big long list of jobs to do and things to register for. Included in that, on the government's helpful list, was register with an NHS dentist, as if that's just a thing you can do. Most Ukrainians I know go home for medical and dental treatment which really says something about the state of healthcare here.

BewareTheLibrarians · 15/10/2022 12:19

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen
I can’t really see that you’ve queried “a lot” of my assertions so much as misunderstood one post and kindly corrected me on the situation in France on another so no offense taken 😊

The idea that foreign nationals can claim recourse to public funds seems so alien to some that it helps to point out it’s not a UK only phenomenon. And even on the UK of course, non-EU nationals (dependent on visa type) don’t have recourse to public funds. DH is a non-EU national so couldn’t claim for social housing, free NHS care, free dentistry, unemployment benefit etc etc and that’s absolutely fine with us. Of course all his taxes go into the UK system which means he pays in but doesn’t directly benefit, but again, we knew that before we came here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread