Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Ukrainian families may just have to..

329 replies

FindingMyself1999 · 13/10/2022 22:15

Go back? bbc article

such a sad situation but we barely have enough housing or school places as it is. Unless the hosts can act as guarantors? That’s a possibility ?

the government really hasn’t thought through the aftermath of the hosting scheme.

OP posts:
SaySomethingMan · 14/10/2022 07:32

StoneofDestiny · 13/10/2022 23:35

I've been impressed how many have found jobs, many doing more than one job. These are people prepared to work hard and not to 'live off' people. So many taking English lessons too.

That’s usually the norm for refugees who get the chance to be granted asylum and allowed to work. It is impressive indeed.

FindingMyself1999 · 14/10/2022 07:32

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/10/2022 07:15

What? How the fuck do you know who else applied and was added to the waiting list? Did you personally access the in year applications to see who else has applied and measure the distance from their houses to the school gate?

And how can they have been prioritised if they've been added to a waiting list? They're not in school at all when the vast majority of applicants on a waiting list for in year already have a place.

Because the family moved down are my friends. They moved into the area over a year ago (bought a business very centrally are most definitely in catchment and live above the business) and were told by the council they were second on the list. Since then another friend who is hosting a Ukrainian family, two of their daughters have got into the school ahead of my other friend’s son. Said friend called the council and they said they were prioritising Ukrainian families who come ahead (for whatever criteria) than her son so he’s now dropped to 6th on the waiting list (as other Ukrainian children come before him). That’s how I know.

OP posts:
Sirius3030 · 14/10/2022 07:32

So, just out of interest, if they decide they don’t want to go, what are you going to do? How are you going to force them on to those planes? Perhaps send them to Rwanda first? Obviously the children can be carried on, but that’s a bit trickier with grown-ups, especially if they start fighting back?

ARR14 · 14/10/2022 07:31

Perhaps if the government looked at their spending and decided that social care and infrastructure was actually important, this wouldn’t be such a mess….just a thought

SaySomethingMan · 14/10/2022 07:29

FindingMyself1999 · 13/10/2022 22:48

I am aware of a family where the Ukrainian children were prioritised for a school place as someone else on the waiting list got told they’d gone from 2nd to 6th. So that’s already happened. If we can just support the refugees enough they really will work their socks off to pay their way. They don’t want handouts just ‘stabilising’

From the many posts on here, your last point is contrast to what many seem to want tbh

PinkFrogss · 14/10/2022 07:25

GonnaGonnaGoing · 14/10/2022 00:15

I believe you @pinkfrogs but my answer would be no, because I would feel it was a leapfrogging situation and I had been waiting longer.

Then again, I'm just a woman and not a plaster saint.

I know some posts have said it's the government's fault for not having enough housing and they don't it's true but then again, given that there is such limited stock, I really do feel that it should be given to those who have been on the list for longer.

I ask myself, if the situation were to be reversed and UK nationals fled to Ukraine would we be expecting their nationals to be dumped down the list while we took their place?
I'm not Mystic Me g but taking a wild guess, I think they would tell Alison and her children to fuck away off.

That’s fine, not everyone has to feel the way I do. I’ve been on the waiting list for years. For me personally I can’t get worked up about refugees getting houses above me, because then I’d have to be upset at single mothers, disabled people, and everyone else who has gotten once with less than a wait for me.

I am however very annoyed with the government, not just for the lack of council housing but also for the housing crisis in general. If rent and buying were more affordable then less people would need council housing. If they took the amount I pay in rent, and have paid for years and years without fail, they would see actually yes I can afford to pay a bigger mortgage - I’ve been paying someone else’s mortgage and then some for over a decade after all!

lollipoprainbow · 14/10/2022 07:25

@Parker231 I don't know why would I care, I'm talking about this country.

Parker231 · 14/10/2022 07:22

lollipoprainbow · 14/10/2022 07:16

@ClaudineClare bigots or realists?? Wake up we don't have enough housing, schools, etc ffs.

And other countries do have?

emmathedilemma · 14/10/2022 07:18

There’s 1300 refugees currently on a ship in Edinburgh, of which about a third a children. I’ve no idea what they’re all doing for school places or how long they’re planning to keep them onboard for but surely it can’t be a long term solution!

lollipoprainbow · 14/10/2022 07:16

@ClaudineClare bigots or realists?? Wake up we don't have enough housing, schools, etc ffs.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/10/2022 07:15

FindingMyself1999 · 13/10/2022 22:48

I am aware of a family where the Ukrainian children were prioritised for a school place as someone else on the waiting list got told they’d gone from 2nd to 6th. So that’s already happened. If we can just support the refugees enough they really will work their socks off to pay their way. They don’t want handouts just ‘stabilising’

What? How the fuck do you know who else applied and was added to the waiting list? Did you personally access the in year applications to see who else has applied and measure the distance from their houses to the school gate?

And how can they have been prioritised if they've been added to a waiting list? They're not in school at all when the vast majority of applicants on a waiting list for in year already have a place.

Userno64473836326 · 14/10/2022 07:15

I questioned this from the start. Whilst I feel deeply sympathetic for the people of Ukraine and what's going on, moving here on paper was a fab idea, but I always questioned where they would live perhaps when their hosts couldn't host them anymore, they can't stay in these homes forever and we have a serious shortage of housing. They seem to be very hard working but the lack of housing is very real!

LeChat0 · 14/10/2022 07:14

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 14/10/2022 07:12

Honestly, knowing what a shit show of a Government we have I cannot believe anyone agreed to this half baked scheme in the first place.

I know the majority of hosts have done it as a good thing to do, however I also think they have been incredibly naive and shortsighted.

Did they think the war would be over in 6 months? If not, what then? And that couple in the article from Oxfordshire who are trying to get Social housing for their guests are obviously seriously out of touch with the reality of that situation.

ClaudineClare · 14/10/2022 07:11

BewareTheLibrarians thank you for that post. These threads always bring out the bigots.

Increasing payments to hosts is a good idea.

hadtochangetothisone · 14/10/2022 07:04

Can hosts on here say why they want their arrangement to end. The BBC article doesn't really explain why.

In the first case it is obviously a very small space they are sharing and alludes to a 'bereavement' .. whilst the second, where space is not the issue doesn't really explain why at all.

I am just wondering if it is anything to do with the payment and the daft situation where a host is paid £350 regardless of how many people they are hosting.

I host a Ukrainian woman. She is a delight. We have a very small home and therefore not too expensive to heat, however with the aid of my smart meter I have worked out that having her here wfh, whilst I work in my office, costs almost an additional £200 a month in Electricity and heating oil alone. When the host payment is £350 perhaps it simply isn't enough. It's one thing to open your home up to a guest in need. If the costs are covered (such as my case) However the CoL crisis has meant now it actually COSTS hosts if they are hosting more than one person.

I would suggest increasing host payments to those who have hosted more than one guest for 6 months or more (to avoid opportunists) .

A lot cheaper than temp emergency housing.

Era · 14/10/2022 06:50

It suits the US to have a long bloody war in the Ukraine. There weapons manufacturers will make billions and they are a long way away from the warzone.

well Russia is bloody enormous but America is obviously not a long way away from Russia.. there is a section where you can, at times literally walk across the ice from Russia to America.

ParsleySageRosemary · 14/10/2022 06:50

Aishah231 · 14/10/2022 06:23

We're not protecting ourselves when we send weapons to the Ukraine. We're escalating tensions and prolonging the inevitable - which is peace talks and compromise. It suits the US to have a long bloody war in the Ukraine. There weapons manufacturers will make billions and they are a long way away from the warzone. Unless the West want to send in serious numbers of troops the Ukraine can't win - they can only prolong. It sounds like the kind thing to do to help but it's not. At the start of this conflict the Ukraine was offered peace if it agreed not to join NATO. The helpful West didn't even investigate that offer.

That’s absolute bullshit. You need to look up the Budapest Memorandum and understand that Russia has lied so often that it can no longer be trusted. You could also look up some of the speeches and material from Putin declaring that Ukrainian people do not exist as a separate identity. He wanted to quietly commit genocide and creep Russia’s land borders back to - where exactly? Back down the middle of Germany, or further still? - while the West continued their lulled sleep dreaming of gently murmured reassurances.

MarieG10 · 14/10/2022 06:43

FindingMyself1999 · 13/10/2022 22:48

I am aware of a family where the Ukrainian children were prioritised for a school place as someone else on the waiting list got told they’d gone from 2nd to 6th. So that’s already happened. If we can just support the refugees enough they really will work their socks off to pay their way. They don’t want handouts just ‘stabilising’

This is because many schools, particularly good faith ones have criteria that's gives high precedence to families moving into the area. Hence someone moving from another part of the U.K. or abroad can trump a local living down the road. This was a big issue in our area in the run up to the Brexit vote and was a factor. School appeals were rife that year for us because there had been a large move into the area from some EU citizens who displaced a load of local children from the school intake because children moving to the area came higher in the criteria

I have to say though that many schools determine their criteria

Parker231 · 14/10/2022 06:41

The uK has done very little compared to some other countries - over 1.4 million have applied for temporary settlement in Poland. The UK needs to step up and takes its share.

Softplayhooray · 14/10/2022 06:38

Aishah231 · 14/10/2022 06:23

We're not protecting ourselves when we send weapons to the Ukraine. We're escalating tensions and prolonging the inevitable - which is peace talks and compromise. It suits the US to have a long bloody war in the Ukraine. There weapons manufacturers will make billions and they are a long way away from the warzone. Unless the West want to send in serious numbers of troops the Ukraine can't win - they can only prolong. It sounds like the kind thing to do to help but it's not. At the start of this conflict the Ukraine was offered peace if it agreed not to join NATO. The helpful West didn't even investigate that offer.

Sadly Putin is the next Hitler and there is no such thing as peace talks or compromise with a person that mad. YEARS of research into Putin shows every single time that he takes negotiation and compromise as nothing but weakness and a signal to be more brutal and dominant, which he always does.

Era · 14/10/2022 06:37

I’m hosting a family of five. One mother four children. It’s unsustainable but how do you ask them to leave. The government knows that many hosts will feel unable to and will let the arrangement just carry on.

lollipoprainbow · 14/10/2022 06:27

*FindingMyself1999
I am aware of a family where the Ukrainian children were prioritised for a school place as someone else on the waiting list got told they’d gone from 2nd to 6th. So that’s already happened. If we can just support the refugees enough they really will work their socks off to pay their way. They don’t want handouts just ‘stabilising’*

They can work their socks off all they like they've still taken a school place from someone which is utterly wrong.

Aishah231 · 14/10/2022 06:23

Softplayhooray · 14/10/2022 06:09

The hosting Ukraine scheme was appallingly thought out by the Govt from the start, and was clearly just a short term solution with no long term plans. We need to send millions to fight Russia because if we don't, the escalation of Russia being emboldened to invade other countries and also use nuclear weapons without fear of retribution is too frightening. We're protecting ourselves when we protect Ukraine.

We're not protecting ourselves when we send weapons to the Ukraine. We're escalating tensions and prolonging the inevitable - which is peace talks and compromise. It suits the US to have a long bloody war in the Ukraine. There weapons manufacturers will make billions and they are a long way away from the warzone. Unless the West want to send in serious numbers of troops the Ukraine can't win - they can only prolong. It sounds like the kind thing to do to help but it's not. At the start of this conflict the Ukraine was offered peace if it agreed not to join NATO. The helpful West didn't even investigate that offer.

Softplayhooray · 14/10/2022 06:09

GonnaGonnaGoing · 13/10/2022 22:41

In the BBC article linked, it mentions that Cherwell Council were going to prioritise council accommodation for Ukrainians.

I imagine that will ruffle feathers-if it goes ahead-from home grown people who have also been waiting. If that hope is replicated by other councils, I think there will be a lot of angry and disappointed people, magnified when school places and nhs dentist places are also prioritised in this way.

My unpopular view-and I didn't always have it-is that we just cannot afford to carry on sending billions of pounds worth of weapons and bearing high costs and possible danger ourselves. At first, i supported Boris in his efforts to stand with Ukraine but now I think there may be trouble ahead!

The hosting Ukraine scheme was appallingly thought out by the Govt from the start, and was clearly just a short term solution with no long term plans. We need to send millions to fight Russia because if we don't, the escalation of Russia being emboldened to invade other countries and also use nuclear weapons without fear of retribution is too frightening. We're protecting ourselves when we protect Ukraine.