Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to forgive MIL for this?

161 replies

forgiveormakehimpay · 13/10/2022 21:27

It was her birthday Sunday.

All 3 of her DC and their wives came to her house for a 'get together'

She was reminiscing about family and old times. Her dad came up in conversation

She said 'Ahh, I love the name Andrew. I so wish one of my grandchild got to have that name'

It was a bit of an awkward silence and then she looked at me and said 'Sorry but it's true :) I know that might be hard to hear' and she came over and patted me on the hand, before walking into the kitchen to ask if anyone wanted a top up

My son was called Andrew. He was born early and passed away shortly afterwards. Nobody has ever mentioned him since, and refuse to. But mention my SIL's stillborn daughter.

AIBU to never forgive her? Split with my H a few weeks ago because he wasn't helping with DS1. I came to her birthday because I thought I'd be wanted there

OP posts:
PurpleWisteria1 · 14/10/2022 08:41

so sorry for your loss. I would have been so upset by this comment.
Sounds like she wanted a grandchild called Andrew, and the one grandchild that was called that sadly passed away and now because of that no others who came afterwards (if there were any) would ever be called Andrew. So she hasn’t a living grandchild called Andrew. That’s what she was meaning.
She should have kept that to herself 100%. Absolutely no need to verbalise it to you. It goes without saying that everyone would wish your Andrew was still here.

Squirrelvillage · 14/10/2022 08:40

Absolutely awful, I would never go again. Sorry you had to go through that.

diddl · 14/10/2022 08:39

I do think it's odd that you went as your ex could have looked after your son.

Well you know what as nasty bitch she is & to keep well away.

No. My Andrew was the pregnancy nobody wanted except me Sadly

Bloody hell that's awful.

I think you've had a namechange fail?

lampturnedoff · 14/10/2022 08:29

dammit88 · 14/10/2022 07:18

Sorry for your loss. it was an awful thing to say. Was your ex Andrews dad? I imagine he must have been devastated too at his own mother saying such a thing?

No. My Andrew was the pregnancy nobody wanted except me Sadly

sandytooth · 14/10/2022 08:28

Musti · 14/10/2022 08:20

What an evil cow. And I’m surprised no one said anything.

I can imagine everyone else stunned into silence and not really knowing how to react tbh

Musti · 14/10/2022 08:20

What an evil cow. And I’m surprised no one said anything.

Cantthinkofanewnameatm · 14/10/2022 08:16

Did she mean she’s sorry she doesn’t still have a grandson with that name? I.e, she’s sad for the loss of your ds? By patting your hand it’s possible she meant that.
As you and stbxh have split you’re unlikely to see much of her in the future.
I’m very sorry for your loss.

WeepingSomnambulist · 14/10/2022 08:16

She knew exactly what she was saying. That's why she singled you out for the pat on the hand and "hard to hear" comment.

She basically said, "well, I know you called your son Andrew, but he died so it doesn't count and I dont actually have a grandchild called Andrew, do I?"

That's what she meant. That's why she said its hard to hear but it's true, because that's how she feels. She feels like that doesn't count. She is a total bitch. I wouldn't forgive her either.

Your son counts. She should never have said such an awful thing.

BlackSwan · 14/10/2022 08:14

You really don't have to allow people like this to feature in your life, just cut her off.

SeasonFinale · 14/10/2022 07:48

Now you know. Avoid her. Any contact she has with your DS should now solely be during DH's contact time with his son and you shouldn't be drawn in to making the effort with her during your contact time at all.

MyEasterEggs · 14/10/2022 07:43

Oh OP my heart goes out to you 😔

I lost my son in the second trimester and my OHs family rarely talk about him. PIL have never been all that supportive or understanding. My family aren’t much better, to be honest, but a cousin, SIL and a few friends have gone some way to keeping the memory of my boy alive.

Given the added information you’ve shared, I’d take this opportunity to step back and leave it up to your exH to maintain communication and ensure she sees her grandkids. Her behaviour sounds toxic and I think she’s shown her true colours. It demonstrates a complete lack of respect and perhaps some judgement around your experience of loss vs that of your SIL. This is something I’ve felt myself, from family and even from someone at a baby loss charity.

Ultimately, there’s no comparison. The loss of a baby is the loss of a baby, regardless of your personal experience 😢

BitOutOfPractice · 14/10/2022 07:41

One of the best things about getting divorced was that I no longer had to pretend to care what my exMiL thought of me. It’s very liberating.

im so sorry for your loss OP.

Blueblell · 14/10/2022 07:40

Do you think perhaps she was clumsy with her wording? She patted you on the hand so I would take that as acknowledgement of your loss.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 14/10/2022 07:34

I would just never speak to her or your dh siblings again just on this basis.
Some people do have a good relationship with inlaws post separation but that depends on them not being cunts.

keeprunning55 · 14/10/2022 07:31

That’s appalling. I assume she knew your sons name was Andrew?
Im so sorry.

dammit88 · 14/10/2022 07:18

Sorry for your loss. it was an awful thing to say. Was your ex Andrews dad? I imagine he must have been devastated too at his own mother saying such a thing?

SMrs · 14/10/2022 07:08

forgiveormakehimpay · 13/10/2022 21:27

It was her birthday Sunday.

All 3 of her DC and their wives came to her house for a 'get together'

She was reminiscing about family and old times. Her dad came up in conversation

She said 'Ahh, I love the name Andrew. I so wish one of my grandchild got to have that name'

It was a bit of an awkward silence and then she looked at me and said 'Sorry but it's true :) I know that might be hard to hear' and she came over and patted me on the hand, before walking into the kitchen to ask if anyone wanted a top up

My son was called Andrew. He was born early and passed away shortly afterwards. Nobody has ever mentioned him since, and refuse to. But mention my SIL's stillborn daughter.

AIBU to never forgive her? Split with my H a few weeks ago because he wasn't helping with DS1. I came to her birthday because I thought I'd be wanted there

I'm sorry for your loss and that your little boy isn't mentioned.

As you have other grandchildren I would keep a relationship for their sake but I would back off personally.

My MIL is a real b*ch and super malicious with me and my husband but she is wondering with my children.

We've had some big ding dongs over the years and now we only have a relationship for my children and we only talk about the kids. Don't see her often and the boys mostly go to her. Suits us all fine

Oceans12 · 14/10/2022 07:05

@Wishihadanalgorithm

Have nothing to do with the her now. You’ve split with her son, he can facilitate her relationship with the children from now on.

^^ This.
And thank your lucky stars that you had the good sense to split with her son - as others have said "the fruit doesn't fall very far from the tree".

Upwards and onwards OP.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 14/10/2022 06:59

That’s a vile thing for her to have said. The fact she patted your hand shows she understood it would upset you. She is a c?nt of the highest order.

Have nothing to do with the her now. You’ve split with her son, he can facilitate her relationship with the children from now on.

sandytooth · 14/10/2022 06:57

forgiveormakehimpay · 14/10/2022 05:39

But what was everyone elses response including your ex?

Silence.

Tbh I think I'd be stunned into silence too.

Never go back there

Oceans12 · 14/10/2022 06:50

It was a bit of an awkward silence and then she looked at me and said 'Sorry but it's true :) I know that might be hard to hear' and she came over and patted me on the hand, before walking into the kitchen to ask if anyone wanted a top up

Nasty, just plain nasty.

At that point OP, I would have excused myself and walked out.

You can forgive her or not forgive her as you please, but I would now have minimum contact with this poisonous woman.

Was your estranged husband there when she said this?

emanresuymevas · 14/10/2022 06:46

2bazookas · 14/10/2022 00:52

Is it possible she spoke clumsily/you misunderstood, and what she was actually referring to was the loss of grandbaby Andrew. Then she felt terrible for reminding you, and bolted.

That has to be the most generous interpretation of this situation ever possible.

OP she's just rewritten the dictionary definition of bitch.

On the upside everybody else in the room was shocked - speechless - at what she said. So you were not alone in that moment in your understanding.

Never go back. And she can see her grandkids when her DS has them. You're under no obligation to facilitate anything for her.

worriedatthistime · 14/10/2022 06:46

Sorry for your loss , you should feel able to speak about your son whenever he is part of you

worriedatthistime · 14/10/2022 06:43

You don't need to have a relationship with her now your ex dh ) or maybe soon to be) can facilitate the relationship with your child and her when he has his visitation etc

GloriousGlory · 14/10/2022 06:43

She's awful, what a dreadful thing to say!

I'm sorry you lost Andrew OP, totally heartbreaking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread