Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dm said she’s never seen a child as bad before as Dd

284 replies

Allweatewasspaghettihoops · 13/10/2022 21:05

Parents are here to stay, Dd just 4 has always been energetic but not hugely difficult in behaviour. Since around March, we saw some changes and the last few months she’s having fairly bad meltdowns and is speaking not that nicely and being impatient and shouting/crying a lot, plus wanting things her own way.
Shes been over excited because they’re here and has also had less sleep. We’ve been going out everyday and today we got up as usual and went to get ready. As I was doing her hair, she completely lost it, screaming and crying and saying I was doing it wrong, each time I kept trying to do what I thought she was asking, I was getting it more wrong and she was getting more upset.
I tried really hard to keep my patience, but I admit I felt out of control and just could not calm her down at all. I ended up sitting away a little on the bed and crying in frustration.
Dm came up looking really shaky and upset and almost crying and asked if I was ok and all was ok, she put her hand on my shoulder.
I ended up being able to calm her down and we lay cuddled together. I was so emotionally drained and feel like I’m walking on eggshells sometimes with her behaviour.
This afternoon I was talking to dm and she was saying none of us were anything like that and that she’s worked in a nursery and never seen a child get like that…ever 😢
She says I should go to the doctor with her asap.
I agree that this mornings episode was v intense and probably the worst I’ve had as she looked like something was driving her and she literally couldn’t stop. But I’m feeling really shocked and upset by the way Dm has described it all and I’m really worried now.
Does this sound really terrible for a just turned 4 year old?

OP posts:
Allweatewasspaghettihoops · 13/10/2022 22:06

@KangFang What do you think is wrong?

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 13/10/2022 22:05

In the nicest possible way, I wouldn't be taking her for drives etc.

I know what you mean, but I think that removing a child from a room/situation for a bit, getting a change of scene, fresh air, etc, can be really helpful. Not to make a big thing of anything, just to move the whole scenario on a bit rather than dwelling.

mswales · 13/10/2022 22:05

Tigofigo · 13/10/2022 21:20

I have an explosive child, I do know how hard it is. Lots of children aren't like that at all, but quite a few are. So while it might not be the norm, it's not unusual either. Lots of children still have tantrums up to 5 or 6.

LOADS of children will behave beautifully at nursery and school then explode when they are at home so I wouldn't read too much into your mum's comment. I hate to say it but I don't you'll get much help from GP. Maybe look at council parenting courses for strong willed children instead

What I WOULD say is this:

She can want things her own way as much as she likes, but that doesn't mean you have to give it to her. You can empathise AND set boundaries. Look at Big Little Feelings and Dr Siggie on Instagram.

Your mum's reaction tells me a lot. She obviously struggles to cope with big emotions. And lo, so do you. I wonder if you were allowed to have big emotions and fully express yourself as a child? I wonder how she reacted when you demanded something?

Explore this and work out why your daughter having big emotions and setting boundaries is so hard for you.

Then work on your own self regulation so you can stay truly calm in the moment. They're just feelings, and she's allowed to express them. You can still set boundaries. You can still stay unruffled. It's not our job to keep our children calm and happy always. You're the parent and need to be calmly and lovingly in charge to make your child feel safe, and at the moment it sounds like your DD is in charge?

Once you have this down, you can then work on coaching her to express her feelings through words, recognise when she's starting to get wound up, and on what else she can do when she's starting to feel that way, practise calming things to ward off explosions.

Do you have any other concerns about her behaviour?

What are the triggers for meltdowns? Can you spot any patterns?

My child's behaviour is mostly anxiety driven. Something to consider.

This is really excellent advice. As well as Big little feelings I recommend looking at Aha parenting website by Dr Laura Markham, and listening to the Unruffled podcast by Janet Lansbury.
Your daughter doesn't sound like she needs medical attention at all, sounds like a 4 year old with big feelings that she isn't able to regulate yet. Children's brains don't develop regulation or impulse control until quite late on. It feels like the worst thing in the world when you have conflict like that I know - I have a now five year old who has a lot of BIG feelings but only with me.... There are always things triggering the behaviour and the feelings that often aren't even linked to the situation apparently causing them in the moment. So your daughter's reaction to the "wrong" hairstyle wasn't really about the hairstyle. Have a read of the stuff mentioned above. There's so many great resources out there to understand child behaviour, and it really helps. You're doing a great job by caring so much, don't beat yourself up x
Something to start with - www.ahaparenting.com/guide/preschoolers

Allweatewasspaghettihoops · 13/10/2022 22:05

@Flobbertybillop I do think my mum seems too rigid in things with her, she’s a kind person but I’ve noticed things. For example, last time they stayed, I was cooking and Dd was playing with the toilet roll, not ideal no, but she was using it to make a road for her cars to go on, I let things like that go as she enjoys it and can just tidy up afterwards. I heard mum telling her it was naughty etc, I also see Dd looking over at Dm when she does certain things, so I think she’s giving her a *look

OP posts:
Istolethecookies · 13/10/2022 22:03

Honestly, I could have written this about me and my DD4. She has always been very active and energetic. My parents said that I was exactly the same though, so I've never really thought much of it. I do think your DM is being a bit dramatic. 4 is a hard age, they have so many emotions that they're learning to deal with and it sounds like the last few days have probably been over-stimulating for her with your parents around, so maybe you could try and have some time alone with DD? Do some calmer activities, do some painting, baking, go to the cinema?

ArabellaScott · 13/10/2022 22:03

What I'm trying to say is - you're doing okay.

I wasn't there, but from what you describe it sounds like your mum is making you more anxious than you perhaps need to be. You're heaping expectations on yourself and your DD.

Try to just chill out, step back, take a deep breath and let it go. I know that's easier said than done ... your first task is to look after yourself, then you can give consideration to your DD.

Brew
PlinkPlonkFizz · 13/10/2022 22:03

This behaviour sounds more extreme than normal and laying down with DD, hanging around while it's going on and feeling frightened - these are likely to make the situation worse. I'd be a bit more matter of fact and resolute.

Most tantrums require an audience - don't indulge this or try and placate - just leave her at it and get on briskly with your own tasks. If this behaviour continues definitely check with the GP as I saw similar in a friend's DD and they have had years of it but no diagnosis. The friend is an exceptionally kind person but she did a lot of hovering and trying to placate her DDs rages and I suspect it didn't help at all.

awomanofthecuntytype · 13/10/2022 22:02

I asked her what was wrong, we had cuddles etc, she only ever says she doesn’t know…there doesn’t seem to be a reason to her?

OP, that's because she's 4.

In the nicest possible way, I wouldn't be taking her for drives etc. If you had more than one child, you'd be unlikely to be packing them all into the car so you could take one of them for a drive. She's getting too much attention, and you're (again in the nicest possible way) sort of expecting her to be able to give you adult answers to your questions.

She's a young child who can't really make sense of her rushes of feeling. She needs to be allowed to express whatever it is, within reason (i.e. she can't hurt anyone or break things), and you need to accept that sometimes she will behave "badly"/irrationally, because she's a child who's trying to make sense of her world.

You need to make it very clear to your DD that you're calmly in charge. It sounds as if the boundaries are becoming blurred by your fear that your mum is judging you and her.

I do have a child with AS, btw, and it's a bit annoying when any tantrum/spirited behaviour is said to be due to an ASD. I don't think it's helpful to the parent or the child, either.

Allweatewasspaghettihoops · 13/10/2022 22:02

@NewYorkLassie What could it mean? It’s been since around 3.6 to now

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 13/10/2022 22:01

A 4 year old has EPIC tantrums - yes, this happens. It sounds like you know exactly why - excitement, lack of sleep, disruption - she's just recently started nursery, too? So lots and lots on her mind.

Check the simple things - thirst, hunger, tiredness, overstimulation. All of which are fairly straightforward to address.

I found a good book was 'simplicity parenting', which helped for a child that got over-wrought.

Also - dial back expectations. Don't try to force your child to do things when they're struggling. If it's too much for them, just go for a shorter time. Make quiet breaks - taking your DD out for a drive was a great idea. Exercise, fresh air, always helps.

Then check if she's learning how to squash her feelings/behave at nursery, she may well just need a big hard cry to let it all out at the end of the day. If she doesn't get the chance to do this, she may act out in different ways - rage, meltdowns, etc.

Allweatewasspaghettihoops · 13/10/2022 22:00

@Valhalla17 We didn’t all lie together, my mum quickly popped in then out, I was surprised with her coming in and the look on her face etc. I was crying but often can feel like that as it can be draining, but me crying isn’t massively out of sorts, Dd doesn’t generally see that.
Everyone was waiting downstairs and I was just trying to get her ready as quickly as possible but without trying to cause her to get all cranky as she often takes a while to get ready and out of the door now. I’m not generally so indulgent with her hairstyles, I suppose I try to keep things *Nice because my parents are staying

OP posts:
Peashoots · 13/10/2022 21:59

@Valhalla17 100% agree with this

CoveredInCobwebs · 13/10/2022 21:58

@Spicycurry I think the tide is turning. I remember when my oldest was a toddler (so this is 7ish years ago) the general advice was to use punishments like the naughty step. But when my oldest was a toddler (1.5ish years ago) I got a lovely booklet from the HV about empathetic, peaceful parenting. I was so pleased as that was what I’d been doing all along - and it works so well, and I believe it to be so much better for kids.

Notanotherwindow · 13/10/2022 21:57

She sounds like she's testing your boundaries and maybe needs you to be a bit more firm with her. If she never had the terrible 2 phase, perhaps she's just having it now. Make it clear what is and isn't acceptable and pull her up on it every time.

Insist she makes it right. So if she throws something you tell her its not ok and make her pick it up. If she hits she has to say sorry to the person she hit and make it clear that she has hurt them. If she is rude, you tell her firmly not to be and that it upsets people when you are rude to them. Apologise to xyz for being rude or lose a privilege, people don't want to play with you if you will be rude to them. If she can't ask nicely then you won't do her hair as you don't like being screamed at, she'll have to have a ponytail/wear it down and lump it.

All kids do this, she might just be doing it a bit later than the norm.

Yack02 · 13/10/2022 21:56

I think your mum has been overly dramatic tbh - shaking and almost crying? Really?!

It sounds like your daughter was having a bit of an epic tantrum but it's no big deal, it happens. If it makes you feel any better mine was utterly vile from 3-4. It passed, he's 7 now and 99% awesome!

goodnightsugarpop · 13/10/2022 21:56

Allweatewasspaghettihoops · 13/10/2022 21:34

I just don’t know as I know it was really full on this morning, I was just trying to get her ready and out and really should have just left it sooner, it was clear she needed a day at home
My mum came upstairs she says to see if she could help as she says it sounded so awful downstairs, she was really quite upset and shaky
Just feels like such a strange day and week really with me trying to control her behaviour in front of them. So much easier when just us at home

Do you think another reason DD is having these meltdowns is she's picking up on your anxiety and your desire to control her behaviour? It feels like you've got stuck in a vicious cycle where you're anxious about how she'll behave and how your parents will judge you/her, then she can feel that anxiety in you which makes her anxious too, then you try to manage the situation by either trying to control her more than usual or give in to her more than usual, and both those things make her lose it because it feels unfamiliar and like nobody is in charge. The boundaries are blurry and mummy is feeling worried and that's stressful.

Cakeyface123 · 13/10/2022 21:56

I’d go to the GP, as they might want to ‘watch and wait’ for a while, see if things get better/worse. Even if they start the ball rolling looking as ASD assessment- it takes years. It’s a loooooong process. I think get things moving and hopefully ……hopefully things will get better and you might not need it. id maybe read up on autism in girls too - see if you can see any other signs (ie sensory differences). If it’s autism rather than needing firmer boundaries - then it’s a different way of dealing with this. My son (age 6) is autistic and for a long time I tried to be firmer etc …,it didn’t work, his behaviour was because he couldn’t cope,

orbitalcrisis · 13/10/2022 21:56

I do think it's better to walk away for dramatics, if you feed into them and give her extra attention they may only get worse. Just say you are not dealing with her when she's like that and if she carries on, walk away.

I say this as a parent to three autistic children who are very calm and have not had meltdowns since toddlerhood.

Moonlightdust · 13/10/2022 21:55

I have 3 kids and age 4 was the very worse age. I found each of them extremely challenging at that age. They would also be spectacularly awful in-front of grandparents 🙈 You say she’s just started preschool so is adapting to the change in routine and was also under pressure having grandparents stay over. I would see how things go as she settles at preschool.

Allweatewasspaghettihoops · 13/10/2022 21:55

@Dibbydoos After the incident, I lay down on the bed calmly with Dd with a little music in an attempt for us to sleep as she was yawning whilst screaming/crying so much. She couldn’t sleep and kept saying she wanted to go where we originally were going to go (shopping centre, cafes etc) there was no way I’d attempt that so I said we’d take a little drive (just her and I) in hopes of her falling asleep as she sometimes does in the car. I also just wanted to get out of the house on our own and just diffuse things. I said to my parents that we were going for a drive as she was tired etc and dad was saying shouldn’t she stay in if tired. But I knew if she was just in all day with them sat there it would be a nightmare!
I asked her what was wrong, we had cuddles etc, she only ever says she doesn’t know…there doesn’t seem to be a reason to her?

OP posts:
CoveredInCobwebs · 13/10/2022 21:54

Great post from @Tigofigo . I think there is a lot to unpick here in terms of both your and your Mum’s upset over these emotions of your daughter’s.
It’s hard to say whether your daughter’s behaviour is ‘normal’ or not at this age - ironically my NT DD threw some wild tantrums around 3/4 whereas ND DS was a very chilled fellow - but I do think some emotional regulation strategies for both you and DD would be positive. If you like podcasts then Janet Lansbury is very good on holding boundaries calmly.

Flobbertybillop · 13/10/2022 21:54

My mum said horrible things about my kids. My kids are bloody brilliant, I get compliments about how lovely they are regularly, now polite and kind.
I’ve learnt to brush it off now, she was very nice to me either.
is she normally like this, or is it a one off and she’s concerned?

NewYorkLassie · 13/10/2022 21:53

OP I’d be concerned they are getting worse at 4. Most kids are getting better by that age.

Spicycurry · 13/10/2022 21:52

wouldn’t have it

I have had to review my own thoughts on these sorts of comments. I have seen a lot on MN over my time here: mostly in sentences which say things like boundaries, consequences, etc.

My own DS isn’t two yet, but I have found the more I dig my heels in the worse his behaviour is. It’s often the answer on here: be stricter, be sterner, regardless of age.

for some children, it really doesn’t work. And I am not sure it works for any children really - I suppose it does in that you get the behaviour you want, but in terms of actual understanding I do not know.

I have found with my own DS that the more sternly I have responded to things the more likely he is to respond with anger, frustration and distress. It helps no one. I’m not going to put us both through it to tick someone else’s boxes of good parenting.

orbitalcrisis · 13/10/2022 21:52

My mum says things like this about everyone, she's very critical. She used to say horrible thigs about my children's behaviour until I angrily told her that I was fed up with her bitching about them and that she must be the problem because they don't behave badly with me! I think she FINALLY realised she'd gone too far. She praises my parenting now but it's too late to save our relationship.

I think it's down to two things:

  1. She's forgotten what it's like
  2. She's a bitch