Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel terrible I did this?

155 replies

Harlowwolrah · 13/10/2022 19:54

Today a car hit me as they went through a red light and I went through on green.

It was a genuine accident and the wife of the man who hit me was very upset and they were both concerned if I was hurt - I wasn’t. They didn’t speak great English and said they’d only been in the UK a short time.

Their friends showed up and this friend actually tried to say it was both our fault. They later rang me and asked to pay me and avoid insurance. I said no and that I had to go through insurance as who knows what the damage could cost and I wouldn’t have a courtesy car etc

I just feel terrible. They seemed like a nice couple and now I feel I’ve made life hard for them when they’ve just moved countries because their insurance will go up etc

Am I stupid to feel this way?

OP posts:
Spuffcat · 14/10/2022 18:40

I would always go through insurance, I have plenty of stories of family not doing it and it went horribly wrong.

Maryminx · 14/10/2022 18:32

Get an estimate for damage ASAP.
Then get cash from these people straightaway.
Tell them it was not your fault,whereas the other car went through on green.

exaltedwombat · 14/10/2022 18:24

There's no legal requirement to go through insurance.

When you checked the car number online did it show as insured? (That doesn't prove that THAT driver was insured, but it's a start.)

It CAN be cheaper for both sides to keep insurance out of a minor prang. But you need to be sure it IS minor, and a degree of trust is involved. Attitudes can change after a family discussion!

Highover · 14/10/2022 18:22

I think the fact that they are new to the country is very relevant. They may well have been confused by driving on the ‘wrong’ side of the road.
Don’t crumble and accept a 50/50 claim. Your insurance company will probably encourage that option as it is easier for them.

police don’t attend for damage only accidents where there are no other factors eg obstructions/public order etc

ReformedWaywardTeen · 14/10/2022 18:20

They caused an accident. They were negligent. The fact their mate tried to get you to share blame says it all. Why would they call a mate, they should have phoned police to report an accident.
I wonder if they even have insurance and it's more that their petrified if you go to insurances they will be flagged as driving illegally.
You should not feel bad because someone wasn't driving with due care and attention. Go through insurance as planned

jetadore · 14/10/2022 18:16

If you don’t go through your insurers you’ll be setting yourself up for a world of trouble. Well done for having empathy for the couple but ffs don’t screw yourself over in the name of “being nice”.

LovelyLisa2 · 14/10/2022 18:12

Be careful. I had similar and they tried to sue me to 10k. There was a tyre mark on their car and no dents. Stick to the insurance root…

Ofcourseshecan · 14/10/2022 18:11

I voted Yanbu, but I meant what you did was reasonable. Letting them give you some money instead of claiming on insurance would be unreasonable. Wherever they come from, I bet a red light means stop, same as here!

Tessabelle74 · 14/10/2022 17:51

ALWAYS go through the insurance. You have zero guarantee they will pay any private repair bill

WireSkills · 14/10/2022 13:34

If they didn't want to suffer financially they should drive more carefully.

Given their ability to drive through a red light and having friends that then tried to blame it on you, I think you're fortunate that they had insurance at all.

You've done the right thing OP. Even if you'd agreed to go private on it, there's no guarantee they'd have ever come up with the cash and then you'd have been out of pocket.

Glad you had a dashcam though - there's no arguing with that! Without it, the others could have said their light was green and yours was red and the insurance would have said it was 50:50.

Jaxhog · 14/10/2022 13:00

You shouldn't have to pay anything if it wasn't your fault. Either their insurance will pay, or your insurance will cover you for an uninsured driver. In full.

SarahR2022 · 14/10/2022 07:46

YANBU....Ive previously settled without insurance but it was a small dent in a car park so a hundrew quid or so to get it repaired which was less tuan the the insurance excess anyway....definitely wouldnt do it for a proper crash....also did you report to the police??? Its an offence not to report an accident....youre being too nice....which is refreshing but a bit daft....good luck...

IsaidWhot · 14/10/2022 07:38

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 13/10/2022 23:24

You're kinder than me, I wouldn't have an ounce of sympathy for someone who ran a red light and wrecked my car (and nearly wrecked me). Even if I did, it would have evaporated when their friend turned up to gaslight me about whose fault it was.

💯
Also, minus points for choosing to drive when unsure of the rules (red light?) and turning into victims when they cause an accident.
And minus points for using the I'm not from around here card, so what? Sorry, you need to learn how things work generally and certainly before endangering others. I say that as an immigrant btw.

Endlesssummer2022 · 14/10/2022 07:37

Which country did they come from where it’s not customary to stop at a red light? They are trying to play you. They could have hit and killed a pedestrian. Fuck them.

worriedatthistime · 14/10/2022 06:52

I would of considered this years ago and dh was recently involved in an accident. And looked like just a small dent it bumper but then when it went in it was a couple thousands of work as more damage behind the bumper that you couldn't see due to apparentlyi how the car us designed
Tbh the dent was something we even considered ignoring and if we had hit a post or something where no other party wS involved we may nit of even fixed it , so lesson learned that damage can also be unseen so not worth the risk

MrsLargeEmbodied · 14/10/2022 06:29

i have had someone go into me at a roiundabout, offered bank transfer, it is very hard to argue with.

daisychain01 · 14/10/2022 04:41

TastefulRainbowUnicorn · 14/10/2022 00:11

Google fake crash / whiplash and all will be revealed ...

Thank you!

This was my first thought reading the OP:

  • staged accident
  • tends to be a "married couple" to increase authenticity and tug at the heart-strings
  • the "friends" turn up magically on the scene (if they haven't been in UK for long, how come they have friends who are miraculously there at the drop of a hat), to reinforce the victim is at fault
  • very often the staged incident involves traffic lights, jumping a red light, creating the accident then blaming the victim

Definitely don't give them cash, that's not traceable. As pp have stated take it through insurance, they are increasingly aware of these scams. Did they give you an address or just their mobile

Fizzorgin · 14/10/2022 00:56

You've done the right thing OP - and in the long term your insurers will reclaim against theirs given your dashcam footage should given sufficient weight and leverage so you should get your excess back as well.

If your NCD is protected then it shouldn't have too much impact on your premiums either.

As a point of note for other posters on here, the question at renewal is generally not now 'have you had any claims in the last X years' but 'have you had any incidents' - if you fail to declare anything even if settled by cash between parties and insurers find out (for example the other party notify their insurers even if they don't proceed with a claim) then it all gets recorded on the CUE database and may result in a voided policy which is far more problematic than a claim.

Stoptheworld1000 · 14/10/2022 00:53

Harlowwolrah · 13/10/2022 19:59

Thank you. I just hate the thought that because they offered me money that means going through insurance will make then struggle.

I’ve made the claim now and it’s even going to cost me £600 - cheers Direct Line.

Or it means they don't have insurance

CosyDarkNights · 14/10/2022 00:46

MrsLargeEmbodied · 13/10/2022 21:47

an old man went into the back of me, i stopped at a junction he just went into me, he smelled of booze, he gave me his address, and offered to pay cash so not to go through the insurance,
so many people are worried about claiming it seems, i got a quote and he sent me a cheque.

And you didn't ring the police to report a drink driver because? Sorry I fail to see why you accepted cash and didn't report? Did you have no insurance or something fishy going on?

EchoPark · 14/10/2022 00:38

I'm surprised at the voting percentages.

To me it's clear YANBU.

JustFeckIt · 14/10/2022 00:32

Did their friend turn up in a car? Could have been friends car which they were borrowing if they haven’t been in country long which they weren’t insured for especially as friend popped up and tried to say you were equally to blame to try to stop you reporting. Or car had no insurance at all.

If the driver wasn’t aware light had turned red then they are a very dangerous driver (not a ‘accident’.IMO). Thank god it was a car he hit with no injuries rather than a pedestrian on a crossing.

MrsGhandi · 14/10/2022 00:28

MrsLargeEmbodied · 13/10/2022 21:47

an old man went into the back of me, i stopped at a junction he just went into me, he smelled of booze, he gave me his address, and offered to pay cash so not to go through the insurance,
so many people are worried about claiming it seems, i got a quote and he sent me a cheque.

and you let off a drunk driver that might kill someone one day?

Cantthinkofanewnameatm · 14/10/2022 00:27

Insurance.
Their friend was trying to intimidate you, 3 against one.
Driving through a red light is a fault anywhere in the world, being in a different country is no excuse.
You have dash can evidence, present it to your insurance company and hand it over to them. They’re lucky the police weren’t involved.