Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect some sort of financial contribution

168 replies

carkerpatridge · 13/10/2022 19:24

DS 22 is living at home since finishing uni this year. He is working 40+ hours a week and doesn't have any expenses or financial commitments apart from some money for travel etc. I help him with quite a large portion of his travel to make the journey to work easier, often late at night due to a lack of buses close to where we live.

I have said that he needs to contribute towards his board and lodgings, and this has been met with complete disbelief. Apparently, this does not happen in other families - which I think is a nice try on his part. So I am wondering what does happen in other families in a similar situation. I left home and fended for myself after uni so can't make any comparisons with my own experience at this age.

OP posts:
19lottie82 · 13/10/2022 22:32

Paying rent is a good life skill. Less of a shock when they have to enter the real world and pay their own bills.
Even if you don’t need the cash, take it and put it aside for when they need it, house deposit ect

Brigante9 · 13/10/2022 22:27

Are you buying his toiletries/doing chores for him? Because that needs to stop. Do you cook for him? I’d be telling him he cooks 3 times a week minimum or he can buy his own ingredients-‘Here’s your shelf, don’t take my stuff’. He needs to sit and look at the bills and understand that you cannot simply pay for him to go out smoking/vaping/buying drugs. Tell him to look at how much house shares are! He’ll have a shock. Not all of us can afford to support someone and why should you when he’s working f/t?

saraclara · 13/10/2022 22:18

TO all those... even.

saraclara · 13/10/2022 22:17

You all those saying that they wouldn't dream of taking a penny from their own children, maybe consider the fact that letting them see their entire income as disposable for several years, is a really bad idea.

We spend their entire childhood teaching our how to be independent and manage their lives, so letting them get used to spending their entire income on themselves goes against all that work. It makes no sense to me.

When they get their first job they need to be aware of their responsibilities and budgeting. What you do with their 'rent' at a later point is up to you, but teaching them to meet their responsibilities, both financial and domestic, is as much part of being a parent as teaching them to dress themselves and clean their teeth was when they were small.

RewildingAmbridge · 13/10/2022 22:05

I did pay for my own phone, car, insurance, petrol, clothes, toiletries and did the lion's share of the family cooking

RewildingAmbridge · 13/10/2022 22:04

I did this after uni, I offered to pay, but DF was adamant that I save up and buy somewhere to live. In the end after much arguing, I would give him £25 a week and he'd put it in a pot. When I moved out he tried to give it back to me! My parents didn't have the financial capability to buy me a car, driving lessons or help with a deposit so he said this was the least they could do so long as I was sensible and saved. I put a deposit on my first flat at 25 which on the outskirts of London in 2010 , on my own, was an achievement. DF left school at 14 without any qualifications, the fact he and my mum were able to buy a house was huge for him. He always said to DB and me, get an education and pay your own mortgage not someone else's.
If you need the money fair enough, of he's not being sensible and saving again intervention is needed, you don't want him living at home forever. If you can afford it and he's saving hard, I wouldn't be charging DS.

LoveJK · 13/10/2022 22:00

carkerpatridge · 13/10/2022 21:48

MissMarple82 I would settle for that! It might be an idea to get him to pay for one thing such as council tax that is an undisputable set amount.
LoveJK Sounds a bit like my experience, coming from a rural town. I moved to a larger place, got crappy temping jobs to afford my rent, then got better work and my own house, one step at a time...but it was always me paying my way and living within my means to achieve what I wanted

Yes, to me that just feels normal. For DH too. We each felt that our family had done “their bit” in delivering us to university as semi-functional adults, and that they expected from then on that we’d be standing in our own feet.

I’m aware that this might sound judgemental, and understand that things were different twenty years ago, but it would have seemed to be a real retrograde step to go “home” rather than to move onwards.

echt · 13/10/2022 21:56

YABU.

With you paying his travel expenses, why wouldn't he be surprised at being asked for a contribution? You've already signalled you 're underwriting his life style.

Stop paying his travel for starters.

Bonbon21 · 13/10/2022 21:54

Well he may have finished uni but he obviously still has a lot to learn.
You need to stop financing his life when he is earning.
If he wants to be a grownup he needs to start behaving like one...pays rent, and a share offood and other bills.
You are not helping him by prolonging his childhood.
If he doesnt like it, suggest he finds a better deal someplace else.
A quarter of his takehome pay.
And he pays for his own driving lessons.
At 22, this man/child needs to grow up.

Boomboom22 · 13/10/2022 21:54

I wouldn't charge rent but I wouldn't be paying for his phone or driving lessons at 22, or doing any of his washing and cleaning. And he would be cleaning too! I'd expect thanks for the lifts and if he wants snacks etc can buy them.

carkerpatridge · 13/10/2022 21:53

MakingNBaking Your method makes a lot of sense and sounds like a way to communicate the information that's going to get the point across.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 13/10/2022 21:48

I wouldn't charge rent but I'd expect him to be paying for all his personal stuff - phone, personal items (clothing, hygiene products etc). Also to do his own laundry and cleaning.

carkerpatridge · 13/10/2022 21:48

MissMarple82 I would settle for that! It might be an idea to get him to pay for one thing such as council tax that is an undisputable set amount.
LoveJK Sounds a bit like my experience, coming from a rural town. I moved to a larger place, got crappy temping jobs to afford my rent, then got better work and my own house, one step at a time...but it was always me paying my way and living within my means to achieve what I wanted

OP posts:
MakingNBaking · 13/10/2022 21:44

It certainly happens in this house.
I told them to look up on spareroom what was the going rate for a large room with en suite in this area. They said £600.
Then I asked them to consider what they got with me that they wouldn't get with a flat share. Things like - medical help when they were unwell, their parcels taken in, free parking, cheese they could nick, access to all sorts of kitchen gadgets, company when wanted, the benefit of my financial advice, all bills and household admin done.
Then I said I'd charge them £300 as long as they saved the difference.
It's working very well.

Caroffee · 13/10/2022 21:31

He should deinitely contribute.

I know adults in their 30s who still freeload off their parents despite working and it isn't good for them. They're up to their eyes in debt, can't budget, think the world owes them a living and expect everybody else to do things for them. Basically, they aren't nice people.

Andypandy799 · 13/10/2022 21:29

carkerpatridge · 13/10/2022 21:08

Talkwhilstyouwalk At this stage I could do with a contribution that covered his share of the bills, council tax (for which I no longer get the single person discount) and petrol. If he paid more, I would probably save it for him as I want to help my DCs get on the property ladder. I fully expect him to move out at some point, but if it was going to be a long term permanent arrangement, I would expect all shared costs to be fairly split.

This is what I would do with my school.

They can stay rent free whilst in ft education. After that they pay bids depending on what they earn and I would keep 80% of this to one side to give them when they moved into there own place which would put them on a great start

Mummyto2rugrats · 13/10/2022 21:29

I paid 10% of my wage in board and would probably do 20% for ours but put 10% away unknown to them to help with a house deposit. I personally think it teaches the value of money whilst giving you the luxury to ssvd to buy your own.

Pixiedust1234 · 13/10/2022 21:29

op when I was younger my mother told all four of her children. I either take 3/4 of your benefits or 1/2 your wages. If you want to keep more of your money then move out.

We all moved out, I actually left just before my 18th. She meant it as a valuable lesson on paying your own way in life, nothing should be expected now we were grown ups. Her view was that parenting successfully is raising/teaching your children so they can fly the nest successfully. And i think she was right. Sometimes you have to be cruel to be kind (as being kind could be crueller)

JRHartly · 13/10/2022 21:27

TwitTw00 · 13/10/2022 21:10

He's 22 not 16; a third of his take-home pay could potentially be many times the market rate for the room he's in, if he's earning well. You can't just demand a third of his salary arbitrarily.

He's on £10.50 an hour. At 40 hours a week he earns £1550 pw, so a third is around £500 pm.

I wouldn't charge him that much yet (I'd charge £300pm for a couple of years), but £500 is not 'many times the market rate for the room he's in'.

MissMaple82 · 13/10/2022 21:26

My 19 year old pays my council tax

LoveJK · 13/10/2022 21:17

I suppose it’s a sign of the times, and so understandable given how things now are, but it still feels strange to me that children will return home after university.

In my case that would have meant returning to a sleepy provincial town where my career options would have been very limited, but even if you live in the middle of London, do the youngsters not want to find a flat-share and start making their own way in life?

I couch-surfed for a fair while after my degree, mainly with friends from my course who’d graduated one or two years ahead of me, and although there were clearly big downsides, I really look back on it as having been a special time, a sort of half-way house between the student days and a proper adult lifestyle.

carkerpatridge · 13/10/2022 21:15

I'm not looking at taking a third of his pay...as things stand a tenth would be a bonus 😂

OP posts:
TwitTw00 · 13/10/2022 21:10

HirplesWithHaggis · 13/10/2022 19:27

Of course he should be contributing! Ask him to find somewhere else to live where he won't have to pay rent, bills, or food. And then take a third of his takehome pay.

He's 22 not 16; a third of his take-home pay could potentially be many times the market rate for the room he's in, if he's earning well. You can't just demand a third of his salary arbitrarily.

PinkSyCo · 13/10/2022 21:10

Of course adult children should contribute. Imagine the shock that awaits the one’s who get everything for free at home, once they eventually fly the nest…… if they ever do.

carkerpatridge · 13/10/2022 21:08

Talkwhilstyouwalk At this stage I could do with a contribution that covered his share of the bills, council tax (for which I no longer get the single person discount) and petrol. If he paid more, I would probably save it for him as I want to help my DCs get on the property ladder. I fully expect him to move out at some point, but if it was going to be a long term permanent arrangement, I would expect all shared costs to be fairly split.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread