Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a quiet Christmas?

85 replies

littlebird13 · 13/10/2022 13:07

My husband and I are massively disagreeing on what we should do for Christmas this year.
We have two little girls who will be 6 & 20 months by Christmas.

I'd love to stay home and have Christmas just the four of us (And the dog)So I can actually sit and play with my children and their new toys and just enjoy them being excited for the day. We have never done this since we have been together.

For a bit context, my husband has a very big family they have big, busy Christmas's. But my children are the only children on his side so I feel like it's very full on for them. They're very lucky to have lots of grandparents and great grandparents but this means lots of presents opening and the kids don't actually get to sit and enjoy their things.

My family is quite small and also very dysfunctional in comparison. I lost my mum in November 2020 and since have had very little to do with my siblings for lots of reasons.
Although I have a relationship with my dad we aren't very close and I only hear from him once every couple of months when it suits him.
We usually alternate between my family and my husbands. When it was my family we would have it at our house as my parents separated when I was very young so it would've been awkward for anyone else to host, but it was just chaos every single year. My husband spent all day cooking and one year I found my then 3 year old in her bedroom playing by herself to escape the madness downstairs because my nephews are ferral and my brothers just allow it. It made me so sad!

My husband thinks the kids will be "missing out" if we don't go and have a big Christmas with his family this year. Which is what we did last year but I refuse to host my family as it's just carnage and they never seem grateful for everything we do.

I have said we will happily see his family on Boxing Day if we can enjoy Christmas Day just us and actually relax for a change.

Aibu to let my children stay in their pyjamas if they want and play with their toys all day?
Or should I suck it up and go to my in-laws so the kids don't "miss out"?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kpo58 · 09/12/2022 14:43

I've always hated quiet Christmases. Nothing happening at home. Nothing open outside to go to. It was just so boring. I'd much rather be able to see extended family on that day. Yes, you could go on boxing day, but by then they may have all dispersed and there is a good chance that you won't be able to see them all til next year and you will have missed out.

Wheredoallthepensgo · 29/10/2022 23:24

FetchezLaVache · 13/10/2022 13:32

I think if you went to the ILs' last year and particularly if you are going to go there next year, then YADNBAAU. Alternating between the two is an absolutely fair compromise.

Why should DH and your ILs get the Christmas they want at the expense of the Christmas you want, every single year?

Yes.

Why should your DH and his family over rule what you want every single year.

I'd insist on taking turns. One year his, one year at home as you want.

pinkksugarmouse · 29/10/2022 23:06

Your girls won’t be missing out because they aren’t seeing their extended family on one specific day which your baby is oblivious to and your toddler will forget in a very short space of time.
I think this is about what you want and you are perfectly reasonable to want to spend a year when you are mothering two very needy children to want to be in the space where you feel the most relaxed.
My feeling is that for a woman who is pregnant or has a baby for whom it’s their first Christmas she should get the last word on where Christmas is spent.
You have made a perfectly good compromise.
As for your family that’s your call and if they are hard work, Christmas Day is a far too intense day to make it even harder.

CoveredInCobwebs · 14/10/2022 13:00

I think deep down Christmas is a tough time without my mum now.

Deep down it will never be my favourite holiday, but I've learned to make the most of it and not for anything would I have my DC know how I feel.

I really relate to both of these comments… I think being with the ILs at Christmas just amplifies for me that my parents aren’t here. But when it’s just me and DH and the kids, it feels whole - there’s nothing missing.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/10/2022 12:38

I think deep down Christmas is a tough time without my mum now. I would just like to embrace a slower more relaxed day than a busy and chaotic one 🙂

I hear you, OP. If I'm honest, Christmas for me has never been the same since my lovely mum died. Unfortunately, as Christmas carries more social/conventional obligations than all others in the year, it also provided a lovely opportunity for a particularly spiteful in-law to twist the knife.

I no longer see that particular in-law, and life/Christmas is far happier for it. Deep down it will never be my favourite holiday, but I've learned to make the most of it and not for anything would I have my DC know how I feel.

Hope you are also eventually able to find some joy in the occasion Flowers

littlebird13 · 14/10/2022 07:28

ImAvingOops · 13/10/2022 23:00

It doesn't matter what everyone here would like for their own personal Christmas - it's your turn to choose and do it's only fair that you should have the Christmas you want!
Your wishes are just as important as your husband's. Too many women, especially at Christmas, think that they have to please everyone else at the expense of their own happiness. Your children will be fine having a special day just Roth their own parents and seeing everyone else on Boxing Day or whenever. Don't allow your husband to railroad you into doing what his family want every Christmas - he married you and what you would like should be given equal weight to his own preference.

Thank you. He has certainly come round to the idea.
I think mainly he also didn't want to disappoint his family by saying we were having it alone. He does understand where I'm coming from and he agrees it would be fair for me to choose as technically we would be with my family this year if my mum was still here.
Thanks everyone!
I appreciate small Christmas's aren't for everyone and I doubt we would do it every year.

I think deep down Christmas is a tough time without my mum now. I would just like to embrace a slower more relaxed day than a busy and chaotic one 🙂

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 13/10/2022 23:00

It doesn't matter what everyone here would like for their own personal Christmas - it's your turn to choose and do it's only fair that you should have the Christmas you want!
Your wishes are just as important as your husband's. Too many women, especially at Christmas, think that they have to please everyone else at the expense of their own happiness. Your children will be fine having a special day just Roth their own parents and seeing everyone else on Boxing Day or whenever. Don't allow your husband to railroad you into doing what his family want every Christmas - he married you and what you would like should be given equal weight to his own preference.

littlebird13 · 13/10/2022 22:19

LookingAtYou · 13/10/2022 22:04

'making small talk with all the grown ups which most we don't see the rest of the year is not how I want to spend my Christmas'

Being with family shouldn't be about 'making small talk', you just all eat together and relax. Do you actually like his family, are you socially anxious?

Fine to alternate every year most do but please don't have your family Christmas that the 4 of you stay at home every year because that is how you like it.

I never said I wanted to do it every year? In fact I said the opposite. We do the big Christmas every year. I wanted one Christmas just the four of us 🙂

Where yes, I don't have to make small talk with my dh's extended family all day. As much as they are lovely people :)

OP posts:
LookingAtYou · 13/10/2022 22:04

'making small talk with all the grown ups which most we don't see the rest of the year is not how I want to spend my Christmas'

Being with family shouldn't be about 'making small talk', you just all eat together and relax. Do you actually like his family, are you socially anxious?

Fine to alternate every year most do but please don't have your family Christmas that the 4 of you stay at home every year because that is how you like it.

littlebird13 · 13/10/2022 21:43

EndlessMagpies · 13/10/2022 21:30

I cannot think of anything worse than a huge chaotic Christmas Day with having to travel miles to visit people, or spend all day in the kitchen because you are hosting, hordes of relatives, umpteen over-excited kids, and all the ensuing enforced jollity.

I wouldn't even mind loads of children!! I'd really enjoy that. But my kids are the only two and making small talk with all the grown ups which most we don't see the rest of the year is not how I want to spend my Christmas

OP posts:
EndlessMagpies · 13/10/2022 21:30

I cannot think of anything worse than a huge chaotic Christmas Day with having to travel miles to visit people, or spend all day in the kitchen because you are hosting, hordes of relatives, umpteen over-excited kids, and all the ensuing enforced jollity.

littlebird13 · 13/10/2022 21:12

VestaTilley · 13/10/2022 20:37

YANBU. Stay at home, then invite DH’s family to yours on Boxing Day. See you own family for a walk a few days later.

I actually think DC need some peace and quiet on Christmas Day unless you have a huge house, otherwise they just get overwhelmed.

We spent 6 years travelling and seeing both families- flying on Boxing Day, switching each year who got us on Christmas Day, staying away from home for 11 days then returning to work completely exhausted. The last year I said never again - and that was before we had a child! Since then we’ve stayed at home, invited family to us, and seen family on the other days. Once DS was born we decided definitely not to be away again as it’s nice for him to play with his toys and not to have to drive hours etc. I recommend it.

Thank you.
We don't have a huge house by any means and would struggle to accommodate my DH's family.

I have spoken more with DH about it this evening and he seems more on board with it. I just know we will get a scolding from certain members of his family.
Funny thing is, DH's brother and his wife spend EVERY Christmas with her family and nobody has ever questioned it but we will be the bad ones for sure

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 13/10/2022 20:37

YANBU. Stay at home, then invite DH’s family to yours on Boxing Day. See you own family for a walk a few days later.

I actually think DC need some peace and quiet on Christmas Day unless you have a huge house, otherwise they just get overwhelmed.

We spent 6 years travelling and seeing both families- flying on Boxing Day, switching each year who got us on Christmas Day, staying away from home for 11 days then returning to work completely exhausted. The last year I said never again - and that was before we had a child! Since then we’ve stayed at home, invited family to us, and seen family on the other days. Once DS was born we decided definitely not to be away again as it’s nice for him to play with his toys and not to have to drive hours etc. I recommend it.

littlebird13 · 13/10/2022 20:35

My DH and I aren't going to argue about this, it has just been a discussion.

I grew up with just immediate family whereas he has a lot of extended family that literally live within a mile radius so it's just what we are used to.
However, ever since we have been together we have done big Christmas's.
I'm not or would never say I don't plan to see anyone at Christmas ever again but we've never had a quiet day as a family.
My husband is definitely entitled to an opinion and I respect what he thinks as he does with me.
I also want whatever my children will enjoy most. But going to my inlaws at Christmas means they are like the focal point for everyone for the whole day.
My 6 year old is a fairly quiet child, as was I at her age. If there was other children going to be there it would be a no brainer.

I'm very grateful for my DH's family and they do adore my children as they are lovely people but they are very OTT when it comes to my kids. Especially the grandparents. I'm just not used to it in my family so it seems very full on.

I do feel guilty suggesting we don't see them and I hate letting anybody down but I would, very selfishly for a change, like to enjoy the day just me and my family!

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 13/10/2022 19:57

LookingAtYou · 13/10/2022 18:18

Just go for lunch and come home or go for tea? Surely doesn't have to be an intense 24/7 visit.

They are family! many would love a Christmas with lots of extended family rather than cooped up all day with Mum and Dad watching telly

Yes - many would love a big, chaotic Christmas, @LookingAtYou, but equally there are plenty of people who love a quieter Christmas, without lots of extended family. @littlebird13 sounds like she falls in the latter category, so it seems only fair that she gets the Christmas she wants sometimes.

As previous posters have suggested, I think it would be fair for both the OP and her dh to choose how they do Christmas - and as they did the big Christmas with his family last year, she gets to choose this year.

sandytooth · 13/10/2022 19:42

orbitalcrisis · 13/10/2022 18:32

@sandytooth Is 6 too young to know what you want to do?

My fault misread it as 6 months and 20 months.

AngelinaFibres · 13/10/2022 19:07

CookPassBabtridge · 13/10/2022 13:19

I think a lot if people loved the covid enforced Christmas and I don't blame them when they usually have manic Christmasses.

This. We had just me and my husband and my mum. Everyone else had someone to spend the day with. We have a family watts app so there were lots of present opening,food pics ,chatting.We eat at 1pm and mum went home at 4. It was peaceful, easy and brilliant. I would love it like that every year

DSGR · 13/10/2022 19:04

You want to stay home - please don’t say it’s what your children want though! You don’t know what they want?
when I was a child we had big family Christmases and they were the best thing on earth. I loved them so much and have great memories of them.
it’s your choice but be clear it’s your choice

TulipsTwoLips · 13/10/2022 19:00

Definitely a home Christmas for me with immediate family. It doesn't have to be quiet and boring. My parents always managed to make sure we had fun as the four of us.

ChocolateCakeYum · 13/10/2022 18:58

Christmas is just me, oh and ds. Can’t be bothered with seeing people or hosting. We can do that on Boxing Day and beyond. Nobody misses out.

Last year we didn’t even have a Christmas meal, we did a pizza night and it was bliss. Ds loved it and when asked what he wants to do this year he says movie night and pizza so that is what we shall do again.

TwoWrightFeet · 13/10/2022 18:52

Hadjab · 13/10/2022 18:39

By your logic, neither does OP.

Nonsense. The OP isn’t speaking for her children and claiming they are ‘missing out’ on anything. She is doing what’s right for her. That’s why I told
her to crack on with her plans.

Igo · 13/10/2022 18:51

I’d stay home 🏡 you did your in laws last year! Honestly your kids won’t be missing out on anything…

I used to do the one year here, one year there, one year everyone came to us malarky now I just stay home with just us four, it’s so much easier, kids wake up open presents I cook lunch when we want and just spend the day chilling out, playing with new toys, and it’s so much less stressful. We have the most amazing days.

Plenty if time before and after Christmas to see people in my opinion

Happyher · 13/10/2022 18:50

Why don’t you save some of your DC’s presents to open on Boxing Day if you decide to have that as your homely day. I’m with you on wanting a quiet Christmas. I think people get carried away wanting the perfect Christmas and the best ones are the ones where no-one tries too hard and you just enjoy good fayre and company

OceanbreezeSun · 13/10/2022 18:45

I’m from a big family, like your dh & our Christmases together have always been brilliant. I feel very lucky to have all these core memories of Christmas as a child/teen fun, chaotic, lively & exciting, but as I’ve gotten older, they have become more tiring, especially since we had our dd.

We also don’t live local (90 mins away) so it has always meant that we have had to do alot of driving around on Christmas Eve/day as we’d visit dhs family too (4 different houses, as his mum/dad divorced etc) Dh especially was getting tired of doing it tbh. He has never had a Christmas where he wasn’t driving around to see people.

We had dds first Christmas at my parents 3 years ago , which was lovely and I’m glad we did it, but after that, we wanted to make our own family traditions and enjoy the day in our own home.

Last year we decided to have a quiet Christmas Eve & day as a family of 3. It was so relaxing and honestly, just lovely. We saw dhs family a few days before Christmas and saw mine on Boxing Day, where we had a fab big family buffet. It was actually nicer going on the Boxing Day, as the atmosphere was more relaxed. We really enjoyed it, all my nieces and nephews & dds cousins playing with their new toys together, they weren’t as hyper and everyone seemed chilled.

I think some people forget that Christmas isn’t just Christmas Day - there’s all this pressure for one day, but you can see family anytime before & after, it is what you make of it.

NCAutumn · 13/10/2022 18:44

"And on 26th you loll about in pj’s and eat leftovers and the enormous tin of celebrations"

They won't have leftovers and enormous tins of celebrations don't exist. Bloody tiny they are 😅

Swipe left for the next trending thread