Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to take nephew out for the day?

286 replies

iz92 · 13/10/2022 12:00

Nephew is 15, y11, he hasn't done a full week at school this academic year with having one day off a week or attending one day and having the rest of the week off, he attended 4 days last week, had the Friday off and has so far had the whole of this week off, his parents don't seem to care, in their defence he did skip school Monday and Tuesday but yesterday he said he didn't want to go for no particular reason, and the same today. When he doesn't go he just stays in bed on his devices (which I wouldn't allow but I'm not his parent!).

Today, I'm going to take DD to a trampoline park, as she only attends nursery a few days a week and she's off today, his mum has asked if I can take him along as he'd enjoy it, I've said no as he should be at school and that'd be rewarding him for not attending and its half term soon so he can go then. BIL spoke to DH and DH has said I'm BU as I know nephew struggles with his anxiety which is probably why he isn't going, I disagree as yes I understand he has anxiety but I think he isn't going as he finds staying at home more fun.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Badgirlriri · 13/10/2022 13:57

YANBU and I would have refused too.

Lots of assumptions on this post. Yes he has anxiety but how do we know he’s not just a kid who doesn’t want to go to school. There were plenty of them in my school.

Parents are raising a bunch of snowflakes these days. Allowing them to stay in their bedrooms all day and not pushing them to go out of their comfort zone is going to ruin their lives. Is that what you want for them as adults?! How are they going to work? Oh no theyre too anxious to work so they’ll just sit in their bedroom and claim universal credit. Depressing! Get help for your kids!

Inertia · 13/10/2022 13:54

I fully understand how hard it is to parent teenagers with mental health issues. However, you need to be fully focussed on parenting your own toddler, and it isn’t fair for relatives to expect you to also take on responsibility for a teenager with severe mental health challenges at the same time. He needs a parent on hand too.

Quincythequince · 13/10/2022 13:54

GloriousGlory · 13/10/2022 13:40

@Quincythequince so you r decided from a second handed judgemental poster that you know the best course of action?

Are you involved in MH services for children?

I didn’t say I knew the best course of action, no.

But in light of what sounds like no other intervention and a child just playing on devices all day, he is being failed left, right and centre.

And I have experience with this (personally as well) and yes, I am familiar with children’s MH services (have had to deal with them both directly as a parent and a clinician (albeit a few years ago no professionally)).

I don’t think taking him is a reward, but the comments directed at the OP are far of the mark too!

Spanielsarepainless · 13/10/2022 13:53

I wouldn't take him either. It's time for you and your child, not for some teen boy muscling in rather than go to school.

Mochachocolatte · 13/10/2022 13:51

So many posters here just really don't get it.

Yes anxiety can be bad enough to not go to school but still be ok to go other places. Because its not just anxiety - it is a trauma response. School can be really bloody traumatic for some children especially if that school cannot meet a child's needs. It is no longer a safe space for that child to be. They do not feel safe. School 'refusal' is a survival instinct.

averythinline · 13/10/2022 13:51

I wouldn't take him either ....if his parents think hed like to go trampolining they can sort it..

Same for your dh...whats he doing to entertain/support his nephew?

You are not therapist for your dn...

Iateallthechocolate · 13/10/2022 13:50

I would have refused, for different reasons. I would want to concentrate on a day out with my toddler. Maybe you can all go together another time with his parents? I also wouldn't be offering my opinion on their parenting, it never goes down well.

Georgeskitchen · 13/10/2022 13:46

His anxiety is so crippling he can't leave the house to go to school but he can leave the house to go to the trampoline Park? Why can't his parents take him?

GloriousGlory · 13/10/2022 13:40

@Quincythequince so you r decided from a second handed judgemental poster that you know the best course of action?

Are you involved in MH services for children?

ExtraOnions · 13/10/2022 13:39

Also … just wanted to include the text of this letter from the team of “not fine in school” - for those of you going through similar.

Dear family and friends

I hope that you are all well. I need to explain a few things to you, things that are central to the way we now live our life, things you may never have realised, things we have perhaps unwittingly or even deliberately hidden as we’ve sought to understand.

Our family life is fraught, it’s busy just like yours, we do sports, we go on holiday (sometimes short), have days out and celebrate events but we always ensure we plan, we have a plan A, a plan B and probably the most, a plan to respond to crises when the day just goes upside down.
You see, we are not being rude when we are vague in our replies to invitations, to evenings out or too enquiries about our children’s progress.
Every day for us is progress, little steps, as many backwards as we do forwards.

I thought life was made of milestones. It is.
Nursery, school, followed by uni and jobs and lots of adventures along the way.
Isn’t that how it is?
I’m not sure anymore.
I didn’t bargain for having to hold my child’s hand through some of the roughest terrain I’ve ever encountered.
I had no idea he was heading for a fall.
Sometimes there are clues along the way: struggles with uniform; shoes; homework; friendships and understanding, we brushed them off as part of ‘normal’ development, we’d get there in the end. You cannot tell the future, none of us can.

‘My child does not attend school.’
There, I’ve said it.

‘What?’ I hear you say, ‘I’d make them go.
How do you manage?
What do they do all day?
What do you mean, he can’t?
But, it’s not allowed… What about uni?
What about a job?
Exams?’

What?
All the stuff that ‘normal’ kids do?

My child just can’t go to school, it’s hard to explain.
He cries, over time he’s screamed, he’s confused about it all.
Sometimes he’s poorly, sometimes so desperate he’s violent or hurts himself.
It’s difficult to unpick.
Reading’s hard, spelling’s worse.
Friendships?
Goodness, I don’t know where to start.
What is clear is that somewhere in there ‘school’ has made him ill and not being there has helped him to be better; to be calmer; to be able to think; to be able to talk more; to feel he’s safe.

‘Surely someone can help?’
I hear you say.
Where would you like me to start?
We tried the GP, they referred to CAMHS; the school nurse, I tried her too, along with the MP.
School?
Well, sometimes they care, sometimes they just don’t have a clue, they are geared up for children who just keep on going.
They’ve tried to threaten with fines and punishments, sometimes persuasion and encouragement but I’m not sure they really know what to do.
My child just cannot cope with school.

Other people tell me to shout, to force, to drag out of bed: it so doesn’t work.
We just end up in a double meltdown, that’s him and me.
Counsellors claim to have the answers, therapies for this and for that, to support my child, to support me, to support the family but nothing stands out as succeeding.
I’ve learned to follow my gut, maybe that’s why you’ve never noticed.
It hurts that I can’t help my child, it’s hurting that no one knows how to help.
Maybe it’s just part of growing up.

‘Who else have you tried?’ I hear you ask.
Let’s see, Counsellors, Paediatricians, school staff and oh yes, we started with the SENCo at the school, you see, none of this works very well unless they see it for themselves.
I’ve become an expert at documenting every move; emails, letters they are all vital to our trail of evidence.
I’ve amazing friends online who are drifting in the same stormy seas, the numbers are scary but no one seems to realise.

‘Does he stay at home alone?’
Well, sometimes, sometimes not.
It’s tricky, it depends on age.
I used to work, we fought our way in to school, I juggled it all, until he could manage no more and we had to rely on texts and calls.
He wouldn’t answer the door and it worked for a while, but we had tears at night, we didn’t sleep, we’d try for school every morning.
I’d arrive at work frazzled and stressed, so, I don’t do that anymore.
I dropped the work, let’s face it, I couldn’t let my child fall.

So, what now?
I could be fined, I could be prosecuted, I could even face a prison term (now you know the worst..)
Will it happen?
We’re battling to gain support.
I have no idea, I live day to day and hope that someone might just help but I’ve realised nobody can force this.
What can I do?
Well, I look after my child, I fight their battles, I speak to school, to counsellors, to CAMHS, to doctors, to try to find a way through the maze that we have found ourselves in.
Above all else, I follow my child’s needs and slowly we have improved how he feels.

You asked me what you could do to help?
There are some things that could make such a difference:

Talk to me, come to the house, a cup of tea, a cup of coffee, it will help me to breathe (it’s certainly not catching).

Think about the behaviour you have witnessed from my child, can you help me unpick it?
I need to understand the triggers.
I know it’s not just a tantrum.

Listen to me, especially to my child; he just can’t manage school.
Attending other activities is still, perhaps more important, so yes, a playdate, sports, walks, a picnic, we’ll try to get there.

Remember my child is just a kid, he’s frightened and doesn’t know what to do.

Please avoid making judgments (plenty already are), consider how you would feel if it were you.
You might think of something which hasn’t yet struck me.

Getting back to school might not be the answer, ‘education’ does not always mean ‘school’, help us find the right fit.

If I have to give up on my hopes and dreams or even my job, for a while at least, support me, I’m doing what my child needs.
We’re a ship that’s gone off course and need to find our own route.

If I talk about alternative education; part-time school; flexi-school; Pupil Referral Units; online learning or even de-registration; ‘unschooling’ and elective home education, take an interest, smile and please don’t shake your head.

In finding a way to understand the labyrinth we are caught in, consider if you could be a witness to the way I parent my children; how proud we are of our successes and find some time to attend the myriad of meetings where I act as my child’s advocate, I’d be very grateful.

Being ‘Not Fine at School’ is hard. It’s reassuring to know that someone might take the time to understand.

ExtraOnions · 13/10/2022 13:38

God this is a depressing read.

DD missed the whole of Y10 & Y11 - anxiety, and undiagnosed ASD. The notion that you should be punishing these young people, or even “rewarding” attendance is on one hand ignorant, and on the other hand (if you have lived through this) laughable.

Educate yourselves folks notfineinschool.co.uk

Even the term “school refuser” is unhelpful .. they aren’t “refusing” they are unable to go

CornishTin · 13/10/2022 13:36

It’s different for everyone thought isn’t it @gogohmm ? I “made my DD go in” for quite some time.

Eventually she became so mentally unwell that she started to have episodes that looked like psychosis, she was a danger to herself and others. She didn’t even recognise me at times. She was 8.

When I took her out… the episodes stopped within a week. The nightmares reduced. The nausea stopped. Her appetite came back. Her meltdowns reduced to a couple of a week rather than daily.

She also has ASD. She masks well, can appear confident and sociable and is what used to be described as “high functioning”. If you’d seen me with her today you wouldn’t have known why she wasn’t in school and you wouldn’t have thought that she looked anxious.

OP doesn’t really know what is going on behind the scenes with her nephew (doesn’t mean she should have taken him with her though, she had plans of her own) and is judging through her own lens.

Thank you @Harridan1981

NImumconfused · 13/10/2022 13:34

Justmemyselfandi999 · 13/10/2022 13:00

So many fortunate people here who haven't had the horrendous battles brought on by a school refuser.
The vast majority of school refusers don't attend due to unmet needs, most often a neuro diversity. When my child became unable to attend school I tried everything, being forceful, working with the school, building up from just getting uniform on to tolerating looking through the classroom window. In hindsight, I should have listened to my child. My child became so unwell they never left their bedroom in over 6 months, suffered a mental health breakdown, panic attacks, was unable to sleep and tried to take their own life. Fighting every authority to try and access help was exhausting, while trying to hold down a job, attend appointments and fight for alternative education. Attitudes like the OPs disgust me. Neuro diverse people can mask behaviours to meet expectations. Online gaming is safe, predictable, and offers a distraction from reality that soothes many sufferers. Taking away electronics, insisting on expectations only forces more masking and ultimately burnout.
I would welcome a child expressing they can't tolerate school, verbalising they wanted to spend time with family. Embrace these times, you have no idea what battles the young person is facing.

Absolutely this. We're two years in to dealing with school refusal following a disastrous transition to secondary - help is incredibly difficult to access, and the total lack of joined up thinking makes it worse.

We waited a year for help from CAMHS, they've faffed about a bit with CBT, melatonin and antidepressants, and have now told us they think DD is autistic with a PDA profile so they can't help her and we need to go to the bottom of the 2-3 year waiting list for autism services "but they're so underfunded you probably won't get much out of them"!! She'll be left school by the time she gets any help. If I had a pound for every time I've heard "just make her go" I'd be able to afford the private psychiatrist appointments she needs... 😡

Quincythequince · 13/10/2022 13:30

GloriousGlory · 13/10/2022 13:27

Has it occurred to you that what might be right/wrong for you is different for others?

Surely if the treatment was all the same it would be an easy fix?

Of course it has.
But from the brief amount of information the OP has given, and it is brief, this is not the right course of action.

He isn’t receiving any education at all…that’s far more damaging than not being taken to a trampoline park.

MajorCarolDanvers · 13/10/2022 13:29

@gogohmm

Pretty sure I have not suggested rewarding not going in.

GloriousGlory · 13/10/2022 13:27

Quincythequince · 13/10/2022 13:21

I have a child with severe anxiety.
Allowing them to stay off school and taking them to a trampoline park is not the way to deal with this!

Not taking him doesn’t meant OP isn’t sympathetic.

Has it occurred to you that what might be right/wrong for you is different for others?

Surely if the treatment was all the same it would be an easy fix?

gogohmm · 13/10/2022 13:25

@MajorCarolDanvers

School refusal is complex, but that doesn't mean you should reward not going in.

My dd would have never gone unless we encouraged it, she wanted to be at home, school was a nightmare to her (autistic) but she didn't work at home she played computer games! I made her go to school even if I was collecting her by 11am, I worked with the school on solutions like a private space to work rather than classrooms. Generalised anxiety isn't made better by going trampolining, you need to work with the school and the child for solutions.

We don't know this situation but it sounds like the nephew has anxiety but the parents aren't dealing with it, they have given up - we don't know if they are at the end of their tether or just can't be bothered.

It's hard to parent a teen with anxiety, letting play on devices is the easy way out.

Quincythequince · 13/10/2022 13:21

I have a child with severe anxiety.
Allowing them to stay off school and taking them to a trampoline park is not the way to deal with this!

Not taking him doesn’t meant OP isn’t sympathetic.

Harridan1981 · 13/10/2022 13:15

CornishTin · 13/10/2022 13:13

@tfresh - Anxiety in the school environment doesn’t mean the child is too anxious to leave the house.

My daughter has been so unwell before school that she has been shaking and retching and having diarrhoea. It’s not “fake”. It’s absolute fear. She is child who really wanted to go to school and who beats herself up for not being able to go and to cope and to join in with things. I’ve had her sitting in the car outside before and heard her saying “breathe, just breathe” to herself, and “you can do it” to try and get herself out of the car. She is 9 years old.

As it happens, we went to an outdoor farm park today (and there were trampolines). She was absolutely fine. Why wouldn’t she be?! It wasn’t an environment that overwhelms her and where she feels trapped.

Ah the poor love ❤️

My otherwise confident now 12 year old clung to me screaming “please mummy no, please no don’t leave me” in the reception of her high school while two members of staff (very kindly) tried to close the door between us. It’s like a physical pain isn’t it, seeing them like that. I hope she is doing ok.

CornishTin · 13/10/2022 13:13

@tfresh - Anxiety in the school environment doesn’t mean the child is too anxious to leave the house.

My daughter has been so unwell before school that she has been shaking and retching and having diarrhoea. It’s not “fake”. It’s absolute fear. She is child who really wanted to go to school and who beats herself up for not being able to go and to cope and to join in with things. I’ve had her sitting in the car outside before and heard her saying “breathe, just breathe” to herself, and “you can do it” to try and get herself out of the car. She is 9 years old.

As it happens, we went to an outdoor farm park today (and there were trampolines). She was absolutely fine. Why wouldn’t she be?! It wasn’t an environment that overwhelms her and where she feels trapped.

Sirzy · 13/10/2022 13:12

tfresh · 13/10/2022 12:54

So much anxiety that he can happily go to the trampoline park.

No, you're in the right. Parents aren't helping this kid

Well given the well documented benefits of activity for mental health if he can manage it then it could be the perfect way to give himself a little boost

GloriousGlory · 13/10/2022 13:09

tfresh · 13/10/2022 12:54

So much anxiety that he can happily go to the trampoline park.

No, you're in the right. Parents aren't helping this kid

Absolutely correct, people with anxiety should not set foot outside the door. We should maybe consider maybe locking them up until they're able to do a full week at work or school.

I'm not going to take my massively anxious DSis for coffee every again, yeah she might enjoy it, yeah it might give her a little respite, but no, she'll stay indoors until she cures herself.

You need to enlighten yourself, you're very ignorant of MH issues.

MajorCarolDanvers · 13/10/2022 13:07

@JennyForeigner2

Where is your evidence led position- cause so far your posts are just ignorant and prejudiced.

Harridan1981 · 13/10/2022 13:05

JennyForeigner2 · 13/10/2022 12:51

And I’d suggest that a parent of a persistent truant is unlikely to be able to honestly evaluate why other parents don’t have children with the same issues.

Nah, she rejoined school in year 4 after being home educated for 4 years and is now in year 8. A brief flicker of almost refusing in year 7.

No one can tell nether the child in this instance is an anxious truant or a truly anxious refuser, even the OP.

I wouldn’t be taking him out as he isn’t your responsibility, but equally I wouldn’t be assuming poor parenting or behaviour on his part.

A happy, healthy 15 year old doesn’t want to be in bed alone all day or at a trampoline park with a toddler. They want to be out with their peers, at school or otherwise. A mentally healthy 15 year old does not isolate themselves like this.

TrashyPanda · 13/10/2022 13:05

Perhaps you should have just said you want to spend the time with your DD.

an anxious teen and a pre schooler don’t sound like they would have much in common anyway.