Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to take nephew out for the day?

286 replies

iz92 · 13/10/2022 12:00

Nephew is 15, y11, he hasn't done a full week at school this academic year with having one day off a week or attending one day and having the rest of the week off, he attended 4 days last week, had the Friday off and has so far had the whole of this week off, his parents don't seem to care, in their defence he did skip school Monday and Tuesday but yesterday he said he didn't want to go for no particular reason, and the same today. When he doesn't go he just stays in bed on his devices (which I wouldn't allow but I'm not his parent!).

Today, I'm going to take DD to a trampoline park, as she only attends nursery a few days a week and she's off today, his mum has asked if I can take him along as he'd enjoy it, I've said no as he should be at school and that'd be rewarding him for not attending and its half term soon so he can go then. BIL spoke to DH and DH has said I'm BU as I know nephew struggles with his anxiety which is probably why he isn't going, I disagree as yes I understand he has anxiety but I think he isn't going as he finds staying at home more fun.

AIBU?

OP posts:
VioletInsolence · 13/10/2022 14:33

JennyForeigner2 · 13/10/2022 12:40

I doubt that the OP will bring up her children to truant though, so it’s something if a moot point.

Let’s be honest here, it’s generally not the children of people who value education who end up refusing to go.

Rubbish. I’ve got one son who’s been in his bedroom for about two years and one who’s got four predicted A*s at A level.

TheColorIndigo · 13/10/2022 14:30

Spanielsarepainless · 13/10/2022 13:53

I wouldn't take him either. It's time for you and your child, not for some teen boy muscling in rather than go to school.

He's not "some teen boy" though, he's op's nephew. And presumably DDs cousin.

I think it's fair enough to say no as other posters have suggested. It's time you want to spend with your own DD.

I have teens and I have friends with school-refusing teens. There's not a day that goes by without me being grateful they have gone into school, as I know it's pure luck, not my great parenting, that has them there.

Quincythequince · 13/10/2022 14:30

GloriousGlory · 13/10/2022 14:25

An armchair phycologist?

And what are you then? You keep criticising people who either have experience with this, or who know this child, but they’re wrong or to be questioned because you say so?!

Ok then - armchair psychologist yourself!

Naunet · 13/10/2022 14:29

BIL spoke to DH and DH has said I'm BU as I know nephew struggles with his anxiety

Wow! Who the hell do these men think they are? The bosses of the inferior female staff? Fucking cheek of it. Not your kid, not your problem.

IsItThough · 13/10/2022 14:28

What @Soapboxqueen said

Your nephew and family sound like they need support, and perhaps this request was them asking for it. Poor kid, having struggles with mental health and then his auntie heaping on the judgement.

Fundays12 · 13/10/2022 14:26

My eldest has asd and ADHD. He suffers anxiety but no I wouldn't reward him for not attending school by taking him to the trampoline park or giving him his devices if he stays home. I certainly wouldn't be taking nieces or nephews either in that situation. If there parents chose to do be it. I would however be supporting him to find out why he is refusing to attend school and what I can do to help.

GloriousGlory · 13/10/2022 14:25

iz92 · 13/10/2022 14:20

No, he hasn't been diagnosed with anxiety by a professional but as I've said I understand he is anxious but taking him somewhere fun would be encouraging him to stay at home, he does leave the house so it wouldn't be for that benefit. It'll also make him more anxious in the long run because he'll be used to staying at home and will be very behind on work, and this year is his gcse year.

An armchair phycologist?

BirdsOfFeathers · 13/10/2022 14:25

Oops, didn't mean that bit to be crossed out. I was trying to put arrows in

BirdsOfFeathers · 13/10/2022 14:24

iz92 · 13/10/2022 14:20

No, he hasn't been diagnosed with anxiety by a professional but as I've said I understand he is anxious but taking him somewhere fun would be encouraging him to stay at home, he does leave the house so it wouldn't be for that benefit. It'll also make him more anxious in the long run because he'll be used to staying at home and will be very behind on work, and this year is his gcse year.

...or it could help him to break the cycle of anxiety, avoidance, low mood and staying at home that he's got himself into. Mood improves > anxiety lessens, motivation and self worth increases > more likely to feel up to going to school

dailyfup · 13/10/2022 14:20

I agree with you, I would refuse aswell, he can't attent school because of his anxiety but can go to a trampoline park full of people with his anxiety, I know someone with anxiety could not attend school, but now old enough for bars and he out in packed bars every weekend

The anxiety might not be caused by large numbers of people. It could be something else entirely.
I went through a phase of this as an adult and it had absolutely nothing to do with how many people were in a particular space but to do with feeling trapped. ie. if it was a situation where I was able to get up and leave at any point that was fine but situations where I'd need to remain in a place for a particular length of time without being free to leave would trigger the anxiety.

iz92 · 13/10/2022 14:20

No, he hasn't been diagnosed with anxiety by a professional but as I've said I understand he is anxious but taking him somewhere fun would be encouraging him to stay at home, he does leave the house so it wouldn't be for that benefit. It'll also make him more anxious in the long run because he'll be used to staying at home and will be very behind on work, and this year is his gcse year.

OP posts:
BirdsOfFeathers · 13/10/2022 14:20

iz92 · 13/10/2022 12:33

Yes, I know he is struggling with anxiety, but I do think some if it is due to him wanting to stay in bed on his devices as whenever BIL has taken his things in the past and has told him he needs to go to get them back, he goes the next day. I also don't think taking him somewhere fun will help him, as it is rewarding him for not going. I also wanted to have a nice afternoon spending time with just DD. DH is working so he cant take him, as is BIL.

I think there are lots of ways to look at this, and it's impossible to know what's most "correct" without being close to the boy in question.

Without any additional info, I'd be inclined to say take him. His parents know him best.

If he's suffering from anxiety, and potentially avoiding things which make him anxious (including school) by hiding away in bed on his devices, he's likely to also be feeling low in mood/generally rubbish. Staying in bed on his devices will make this worse in the long run. Physical activity and company could help him break out of it.

Having said that, if you'd be taking him reluctantly and wouldn't feel able to be positive and sociable with him, it's probably best not to.

HowzAboutIt · 13/10/2022 14:18

Cw112 · 13/10/2022 12:11

You're being unreasonable. You had the opportunity to spend time, give him value, boost his confidence and resilience and instead you took it upon yourself to punish him because you decided he should be able to manage his anxiety and not managing it is something to be punished. His parents are obviously aware why he struggles and are doing their best to support him, might not be how you'd handle it but he's not your kid.

*spend time, give him value, boost his confidence and resilience"

Which strangely enough can all be done at the weekend if his parents (or he himself) are that bothered.

If at the weekend he choses to spend time with his aunt and pre-school cousin I'll eat my hat that would show that he really is struggling and needs help.

@iz92 You were right to decline - let your DH spend time with him if he cares so much

RFPO77 · 13/10/2022 14:18

You have to wonder how bad his anxiety is if he's fine to go out on treat days but it's too bad to go to school 🤔

Babyghirl · 13/10/2022 14:16

@iz92
I agree with you, I would refuse aswell, he can't attent school because of his anxiety but can go to a trampoline park full of people with his anxiety, I know someone with anxiety could not attend school, but now old enough for bars and he out in packed bars every weekend.

WillPowerLite · 13/10/2022 14:14

It's for his parents to worry if a day out trampolining is going to make his absenteeism better or worse. They clearly think it would be good for him; that's why they asked you.

YANBU to say no if nephew is a pain to deal with, or you just want time with dd and can't be asked.

YABU to refuse because you have your judgy pants yanked up so high that you can't see what's your business and what isn't.

dailyfup · 13/10/2022 14:12

You have no idea how bad his anxiety might be and what he feels like when faced with going to school. Some days are probably better than others which is why he can manage to go in sometimes but not all the time.
Hopefully he and his parents are getting support for this from the school and GP.
It's not as simple as just take his devices off him and send him in if he's really struggling with mental health.

However, YANBU not to take him to the trampoline park. His parents can do that if they think he would enjoy it. But I do think you should have held your tongue a bit there instead of what you did say, which sounds judgemental and I'm not surprised they were offended. Would have been better to say you wanted to spend the day with your toddler on your own and that you'd be in the toddler appropriate section of the trampoline park rather than the sections the 15 year old would be interested in, so he'd be pretty much left to his own devices unsupervised.

Pythonesque · 13/10/2022 14:11

I think the problem here is that this boy's aunt is being asked to take him on an outing without any coherent sense of how this interacts with "what they are doing to help him back towards education". For something like this to make sense to a relative, the conversation needs to start several steps back.

eg anxiety about going to school is escalating into anxiety about leaving the house, it would be great if you could take him with you that day to remind him that going outside is ok"
or "the worst bit of school for him at the moment is PE - it would be so good for him to try trampolining instead"
or "he's really clammed up with us at home, won't talk to anyone. I wonder if you were to take him out with you and your DD, whether he might be more willing to open up with you"
[and my answer to that last one would be, well not the trampolining outing but maybe something else]

If the only conversation has been, you're going somewhere, great can you take DS with you (to give us a day without being responsible for him) ... well you definitely ANBU

StressedToTheMaxxx · 13/10/2022 14:10

I wouldn't have taken him either.

mrsfeatherbottom · 13/10/2022 14:10

I'll just leave this here

To have refused to take nephew out for the day?
Realowlette · 13/10/2022 14:06

*Let’s be honest here, it’s generally not the children of people who value education who end up refusing to go.
*
This has to be the most smug and patronising post of today. You clearly have no idea about mental health, school refusal and the absolute anguish that many parents and children are going through on a daily basis.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/10/2022 14:04

You’re still right at the beginning of the parenting journey op and blissfully clueless of what is to come. If you’re lucky, your dc won’t have an issue attending school. I know plenty of children, mostly teens, who have. Some have entered into the private sector. Others are now home Ed. More still are limping along like your dn, desperately needing support and a learning environment they can cope with, neither of which isn’t there.

We are lucky that we were able to pay for help for my dd when she was at the start of primary as she was seriously struggling to go to school and I had a great many ways of dealing with this, which would not work with an older child. As soon as dd was showing serious signs of being unhappy in state secondary, we had the funds to put into the private sector. She chose the new school and is very happy.

Goingonab33hunt · 13/10/2022 14:00

Yabu. I have a son struggling with anxiety based school avoidance. It is SO hard to see him distressed and begging to be home educated because he feels unable to attend. It's not that he doesn't want to go, he can't cope in that environment due to his ASD. Outside of school he is happy and outgoing and loves spending time with family and friends. However I do have a couple of relatives with your kind of attitude. We just avoid them now.

Minimalme · 13/10/2022 13:59

I'm surprised they asked you, given your views on their son and parenting.

It would be beyond awful for a teenager who is so anxious he would rather spend time alone than in school with friends, to be palmed off on someone who thinks he's lazy.

It's a good job you've made your views on anxiety really clear op.

whumpthereitis · 13/10/2022 13:57

Do 15 year old boys generally want to hang out with their aunt and toddler cousin?

I wonder if it’s more a case of them volun-telling him to go rather than him actually wanting to go.